Board Thread:Role Ideas/@comment-30047735-20160923190358/@comment-30047735-20160924072910

yes, that's true, I feel like the witch should be able to visit locked houses as she controls the person inside to leave the house rather than making anyone go inside. However, in my opinion, the witch's controlled target should not be able to visit a locked house unless they are one of the exceptions listed above. Furthermore, the more exceptions that are added to this role, the less effective it becomes and so I believe that it should apply to everyone except: members of the mafia, the jailor, werewolves, lookouts, arsonists, vigilantes and witches. Since there are so many exceptions to this role's ability, I feel like three uses is a good amount as there is still the possibility that someone else kills the target, the owner of the house is immune at night and a lookout may see two or possibly three members of the mafia visit a house; especially if it's an important town role such as the mayor, jail or or investigator. Finally, I feel like this role is a hard counter to the mayor which is often very overpowered as he is almost always protected by a bodyguard or Doctor, but can still be easily found out as mafia. This is because a lookout will most likely decide to watch the mayor if they know there is a locksmith in the game and may see multiple mafia members visit the target's house. Furthermore, if an investigator investigates the target and the locksmith claims to be a jailor, they will surely be executed.