Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-37648484-20181216122704/@comment-36558623-20181218020450

CrownedTraitor wrote: Faraday242 wrote: CrownedTraitor wrote: Attack: None

Defense: None

Abilty: You are a versatile mafia member who may choose at''' day time a limited set of roles. '''

Attributes:

- You cannot be a Mayor, Transporter, Retributionist, Bodyguard but jailor and vigilante?

- You cannot be any killing role.

this means you can be a Sheriff - completely useless Investigator - worse then consig Lookout - trash compared to other RM's Spy - useless Escort - Consort exists for a reason Medium - uesless '''Doctor - The only useful role. and the only one that would be slightly interesting because of it's reaction with spy. although RM's typically can't target other mafia, meaning this role is trash.''' if you break the rules for just this role, fine, this role is a Mafia Protective which are almost always rejected on Forum, but make my day and go ahead and suggest it anyway,

- You chosen role lasts only one night, after it is used it can never be chosen again. so if you try to claim a role, you can't even be consistent with findings.

- You visits do not show up to the spy. '''why nerf the spy. there's no reason. why make this specific RM more special compared to others.'''

- Potion Master can be chosen but the attack potion will be removed, only heal and investigation potion can be chosen. '''you can choose coven? they can all kill, what's the point. besides, this shouldn't be accounted for because it will only come into play in All Any. This is like saying you could become NE, absolutely worthless. Witch would be fine, but it would just be a rehash of an NE that could be on your team.'''

- You can be any random mafia role as well. '''then why TF would you ever be a town role. Mafia will always be useful.''' this role is now broken, all you do is pick Janitor and clean, and then if it ever needs to be useful, forge or roleblock x2, the only abilities this otherwise worthless role knows.

Killing Roles are as follows: Serial Killer, Mafioso, Godfather, Vigilante, Veteran, Jailor, Werewolf, Arsonist, Hex Master, Poisoner, Coven Leader, Pestillence, Pirate, Juggernaut, Bodyguard, Crusader, etc,

Sheriff: Your target is suspicous.

Investigator: Framer, Vampire, Jester, Hex Master or Impersonator. doesn't matter, your result will change so this essentially isn't a result.

Consigliere/ Witch: Your target impersonates others. They must be an Impersonator. so this role just mimics a town role during the night? how could this help mafia? Clearly, you are a terrible critic and didn't thoroughly read everything, '''seriously. want me to be honest?''' a.) i am destroyed between maintaining my social life and an unreal load of homework, so reviewing roles is not my top priority b.) i had a host of role ideas to review, so i only reviewed a few. c.) this idea is trash. it's been suggest hundreds of times, and it never works because of the fundamental concept, not to mention the presentation and execution is not even close to the best it has ever been. you can also be random mafia member, a limited set of townies, and any neutral evil, the most useful one which is Witch already covered. thanks man

fine. i'll decimate your role.

stfu.