Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-43403494-20190809150442/@comment-39067078-20190809180626

Interesting concept, but a few things have to be changed. I'll list them from Must be changed to May be changed to Small Tweak

I'll also list some of the good of this role

Must Be Changed: The name really doesn't fit in. It's not an occupation and it's kind of odd.

I think this role should be Neutral Chaos as it really can hurt Mafia and Evils more than Town, as it can attack defenses.

The main thing that gets me is the "Survive till the end" part. It makes it seem benign when it really isn't, and it should be out killing things.

May Be Changed: The Sheriff's results are very specific and a dead give off to a role who doesn't need it. Sheriffs will feel a need to post information that is odd or out of place (Sus, Juggernaut) and they would tell people just to let people know.

Since you can still harm town in a search to win then they're going to lynch you.

The defense is questionable because it makes it a lot easier for you to win, but if you keep the bad invest results then I guess it could work in a "Find out by searching, not by killing" type of way.

Tweaks: You shouldn't be able to kill yourself. If this feature was suggested to any role in ToS I would have to look thoroughly to see if it's fair because being out of the game is not fun or fair. The exception would (might) be the Mafioso incase BMG decides to go to the route of Throne of Lies and allow suicide in case of Roleblock.

The Invest results also do not exist, but that's really not a hard thing to fix. If you put it in with Mayor, Jester, or Godfather then it will be under suspicion.

Good things about this role:

If this role was a zombie or something similar, I would congradulate you on making a searching panic class that feels like an unsatiable hunger. Although it would need some sort of deadline (like dying after a few days of not sucking), this role instigates panic while trying to find the right people.

Although you can win with town, I think that you would still be considered an enemy based on the fact that you kill while searching for sucks.