Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-34969116-20190412195133/@comment-33307613-20190412204405

If I'm reading this correctly, what happens is the following:

- Abigail Hobbs is the Infiltrator. Giles Corey is the Sheriff.

- N2: Abigail Hobbs attacks Giles Corey.

- D3: Abigail Hobbs is found dead and is revealed to be the Infiltrator.

If the above is true, it poses the same problems of the old Disguiser. Pre-rework Disguiser was able to switch skins, houses, roles, etc of the person they killed. The switching made reports extremely confusing if the Disguiser or the disguised was doing something reportable.

Additionally, the killing of Mafia/Coven/Vampire is extremely useless. Every time an Infiltrator kills, the faction just needs to have everybody say the names of each other. Here is an example:

- Mary Warren is the Infiltrator. Edward Bishop is the Mafioso. Cotton Mather is the Blackmailer. Samuel Sewall is the Framer.

- N2: Mary Warren attacks Cotton Mather.

- D3: (Nothing happens).

- N3: Edward Bishop tells everybody to say the name of the person below them in the list of names. Everybody successfully does so except for Mary Warren. This brings up my next two questions...

- If a Mafia/Coven/Vampire successfully figures out who the Inflitrator is, can they choose to attack them?

- If the solo Godfather/Mafioso is killed by the Infiltrator, how does the Mafia attack?