Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-31680260-20170408041528/@comment-31680260-20170427075103

Jallybwan wrote: Jallybwan wrote: Yes I&#039;m single wrote: I posted my review for the newest version, and it still stands. TLDR, it could break some rules, including a conversion role (not really converting, but nk's are supposed to work by themselves) and a Vampire rehash )chatting and voting on who to kill.For your possible changes, I need lots of clarifications.If you control a new corpse every night, what happens on full moon? is it the whole dead working and chatting with you? That would be pretty op if you ask me. and does it work for roles like neutral killing or neutral evil?  Actually, if this role DOES get accepted, they would be voting on ONE of the corpses to go out the NEXT night (Full Moon). TK roles can't be selected (that would give the Necromancer an extra kill) but other roles can do their thing (like Invest can still check someone for clues to their role, Escort can RB someone). Mafia roles and Witches cannot become corpses (Mafia would know who the other mafs are, and Witch is kinda obvious).

Also, the Corpses are DEAD. They cannot directly influence the living players unless they are voted to go out, and that's one Corpse every two nights. So the Necromancer is still mostly working by themselves, and they have to deal with the same stuff all the other Neutral Killers have to deal with (Lynching, Jailor, Vet, etc...)

1. We can make it so that there can be a limit to how many corpses there can be (3 or 4)

OR

2. Once selected to go out, when they complete their ability, the corpse burns up. They cannot be selected to go out again. (They are still a Corpse, but pretty much useless)

On a full moon, if you control a body, it becomes a Corpse (who can only win if Necromancer wins). Mafia and Witches cannot be turned into a Corpse.

No, the whole dead isn't chatting and working with you. You can only control someone who died the previous night/day, so if you aren't controlled immediately after you die you can never become a Corpse. Also, only people who were controlled on a Full Moon turn to Corpses, so you only get one every two nights. The Corpses can only chat to the Necromancer on odd-numbered nights (when they are voting for someone to go out).

As I said, it's a great idea but it's not needed, so if that's the main reason it gets rejected then we can scrap it.

And in regard to the "which category would it be in" NK is the best choice. It kills people and can't win with Town or Mafia. What else would I put it under?