Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32994909-20180305211953/@comment-33380803-20180308082652

JamJamalWiki wrote: There is no Transporter or Witch in this game.

It is a non-Coven Ranked game.

On the first night, the Mafia hits the Arsonist.

On the second day, the Jailor whispers to Player X who claimed Bodyguard, to guard him.

On the second night, the Jailor jails Player Y but does not execute. That night he is abruptly killed by the Mafia, and Player X was set on fire by the Arsonist. Player X was an actual Bodyguard, apparantly.

The Jailor asks why he did not protect him, Player X says he was role blocked.

On the third night, the Mafia hits a healed player.

The Jailor tried to talk to a Medium but there was none.

On the fourth day, Player Z claims Investigator, and that he investigated Player Y who came up as Medium, Janitor or Retributionist.

The Jailor is 100% sure that Player Z is actually the Jester.

Give all the reasons the Jailor came to this conclusion, and give all the reasons of why the Jailor may be wrong. A) Player Y claimed a easily-confirmable role in jail, possibly something like mayor that revealed d3. B) Since there was no med, and ret probably would’ve revived jailor and janitor would’ve cleaned before, player y is probably not those roles. C) Now he could be wrong because of course med/jan/ret could’ve been afk, and ret and jan could’ve been rb’d. D) now he’s also could be 100% sure because theoretically there could’ve been 4 confirmed TS’s, and then vig might’ve shot a TI N3 and maf killed other TI, meaning there’s no claimspace for another TI. So basically due to claimspace the claim is impossible. E) Jailor could be wrong because player z could be any other evil role. F) he could be wrong because player Z could be a gamethrower. G) player Y might’ve come up as a different inv result to a dead inv, who couldn’t be disg because RM’s were confirmed/dead. Or he could be disg if RM’s and jailor would therefore could be possibly wrong H) Lo saw player Y visit someone. Jailor would assume if Y was jan he would visit maf’s Killing target, of course jan could be dumb and not do that so jailor could be wrong. But he’d be 100% right if RM’s were dead/confirmed. I) sherrif could’ve got a red on player Y, and since there appears to be no janitor he would think Z was jest, but if RM’s dead/confirmed to be not jan/framer then he is 100% correct.

I’m not done yet but gtg.