Board Thread:Role Ideas/@comment-30154040-20161013003833/@comment-26111094-20161013215308

DuckGamer123 wrote: I think I'll post the list of whos been bad and whos been good.

Sheriff - Nice

Investigator - Nice

Spy - So your listening to peoples private stuff? Well, its for the good of the town. - Nice

Lookout - Nice

Jailor (if has killed a town member)Naughty (if hasnt killed town) Nice

Veteran - Nice

Vigilante - Nice

Vampire Hunter - Nice

Bodyguard - Nice

Doctor - Nice

Escort - Naughty (they sleep with people. what do you expect?)

Mayor - Nice

Transporter - Nice

Medium - Nice

Retributionist - Nice

Amnesiac - No deeds

Arsonist - (before incinerate of anyone hes doused) No deeds (after) Naughty

Executioner - No deeds

Jester - Naughty

Serial Killer - Naughty

Survivor - No deeds

Vampire (if youve been youngest before) naughty (if you are still youngest, depends on your previous role)

Werewolf - 1st night - no deeds. afterwards, they have done naughty deeds.

Witch - Naughty (note: anyone witch controls will appear that night as naughty)

Blackmailer - Naughty

Consigliere - Naughty

Consort - Naughty

Disguiser - (before disguise) Naughty (after) No deeds

Forger - Naughty

Framer - Naughty(will make anyone they frame appear naughty)

Godfather - A legitimate businessman? Nice

Janitor - Naughty

Mafioso - Naughty

Grinch - Naughty

Examiner - Nice

Santa - Nice

Replace all naughtys with "evil", all nices with "good", and the name with "examiner".

Look at the list and post what to do to nerf it. However, the problem is with this... is that we need to allow more cover for the evil roles in the game. You need to put down more "Evil" for some town members. Maybe the messages could be "Your target has a dark past." or "Your target is innocent." However, there can be a third message I would recommend for more cover "Your target seems innocent." This will throw your character off and giving cover to some evil roles. For example: For Consig and Invest, "Your target seems innocent." This will throw your character for a loop and may put more doubt on you or the Invest/Consig. Also, maybe instead of an "Examiner" what if this character was instead was an ex-journalist who did Investigative Journalism in his old town. And now, he takes interviews with people and takes photos of them and their actions. Thus, leading to his conclusion of Evil or Good or Seems Good. Any thoughts on that?