Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-32651233-20180706000250/@comment-32651233-20181027020201

BendBones wrote: Orecreeper wrote:

TheRoyalOwl wrote: My problem with this role is that it counters so many others roles its dumb.

Counters any known TP + lookout this role is intended to nerf too many protectives going on confirmed Townies. Counters anyother killing roles as you will know they killed the psrson they visited. you know them but so what? Counters the escort from rbing mafia. Yes, that is the whole point, escort/jailor blocking a single MK is almost a guaranteed mafia loss. Kinda counters the tracker as it gets about the same results on who your target visits. '''So Consort counters Escort? Consigliere counters Investigator?''' Like come on. The ambusher is trash because mafia dont need 2 kills a night. sometimes they do, since this role is intended to be in Coven, it legit only shows up in Mafia Returns/All Any.

This thread might be basically dead but i really just want to get off my mind. I have to agree whit Orecreeper here. This role is what I would call done right. This role is a that may get kills but only if its used strategicly. This role will give info to while being able to get kills(but i would guess it would be rare).

But when I think about it, I have to ask: Orecreeper, you said in OP: "You may select the same player for both options, which will kill them if they are a visiting role that decides to stay home/target themself." If you have a or any roleblocked on this player, and the Stalker choosing them for both options, will the Stalker kill them? Or if they visit themselfs thanks to a or ?

​​​​​​​thats a no for RB but yes for Witch/Trans since they technically did visit themselves, but the RB thing they still technically visit its just that their visit doesnt go thru

And btw, cool new pichure

thx