Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20171002223259/@comment-31680260-20171007045024

SpacedefenderX wrote: So basically me own conclusion is:

The point of the Mafia is to trick people, in the right hands the roles o the mafia can make the town confused and unsure about themselves

The Coven is more like rolling a dice, every night you role a dice to determine the kills(Not the actually situation, just referencing), you can either kill most of the town, or when the dice betray you, lose some of your own members I disagree with your Coven analogy. The Coven are just as likely to "have the dice betray them", as you said, as the Mafia do. A smart Potion Master wouldn't heal a Medusa that's Stone Gazing, for example. While I will concede that the Mafia are better at deception (minus Framer vs Hex Master), deception isn't as much of an issue when you can end the game quickly. The Coven play like that, and while deception is important, there's no point deceiving the townies if you can't kill them in time.