Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-32892260-20170820224937/@comment-32892260-20170820232842

Its MaiZey wrote: DessertDog wrote: Anything here can be changed to make it more reasonable, but please don't just say "REJECTED" if it's something that can be easily removed/changed (for example: the number of times this role can use a bulletproof vest)

Summary: You are a skilled investigator in pursuit of the Mafia.

Attack: Unstoppable (could be changed? whatever attack seems most reasonable)

Probably Basic here, shouldn't be able to kill a framed NK

Defense: None (Basic with bulletproof vest)

Alignment: Town (Killing)

Abilities: Search the town for the Mafia, shoot someone suspicious, use a bulletproof vest.

Attributes: You can only search the town for the Mafia 5 times. Nerfed Sheriff. You can only shoot someone suspicious once. You can only shoot someone you've investigated. You can only use a bulletproof vest 3 times. '''Nerfed Vig, but I like the concept. '''When you find someone who is the Mafia, a message will show up saying "Your target is a likely Mafia member!". If you didn't find someone who's the Mafia, a message will show up saying "Your target is most likely not part of the Mafia." '''I'd leave out the "likely." Doesn't really make sense to have it in there as there's always the threat of a Framer. '''"You can talk with the Jailor at night (if there is one. this can be removed if it's too OP).

Definitely too OP, and far too confusing for the Jailor to talk to two different people at night (Officer and Jailed suspect).

Sheriff results: Your target is not suspicious.

Witch/Consigliere results: Your target is in pursuit of the Mafia. They must be a Police Officer.

Investigator results: Your target is waiting for the perfect moment to strike. They could be a Sheriff, Werewolf, Executioner, Poisoner, or Police Officer.

Priority: 2

Wins with: Town, Survivor, Guardian Angel, Pirate

Must kill: Mafia, Coven, Serial Killer, Arsonist, Vampire, Plaguebearer, Pestilence, Juggernaut

'''Seems like this is just a nerfed Sheriff with the traits of a Vig (other than the guilt) and the vest of a Bodyguard. Really like the concept and stipulations for killing, but as a Town Killing role, it should hold a little bit more importance. In other words, it really doesn't scale with the Vig's three shots or the Vet's powerful defensive alerts.'''

REJECTED for now, but I'd love to see this develop into something really cool!

Also, I'd just leave it as "Officer." The name sounds better in my opinion. Good luck! That's the nicest and most useful rejection I've ever gotten. Thanks :)