Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32994909-20180604181712

Player X is jailed on the first night

On Day 2, Player Y claims

Whispers on that day:

Player X > Player Y 'If you're really, can you side with me?'

Player Y > Player X 'Sure. What are you and do you know anyone elses' role?'

Player X whispered something back to Player Y

On Night 2, Player Y is jailed

The is killed by the. His will had been forged.

The forged will shows the two people who he jailed on N1 and N2 are correct, which is correct, but their claims were made up.

How did the both who the  was, and who the  jailed on both nights?

Consider:

> The never revealed his name in the day chat nor to any of his detainees. He did not say anything suspicious which would make people think he's a.

> Player X did not claimed jailed on second day, nobody visited him so nobody knew he was jailed except him and the.

> The has no

> Only the three shown whispers occured on Day 2. Nothing was whispered on Day 1. ​​​ 