Board Thread:Role Ideas (Coven)/@comment-32994909-20171104212147/@comment-32994909-20171108171514

ZedKiller13 wrote: JamJamalWiki wrote: ''' So honestly the actual useful KPN would probably be less than a Poisoner. '''

Well then it has the worst KPN of all the roles in the game, if you put it that way. Poisoner can only be successful if a Doctor doesn't exist or has the Necronomicon. Usually they just shout "I'M POISONED DOC ON ME" and off goes the Doctor to save a life, canceling out a kill.

If you say it has a worse chance than the poisoner, than it isn't needed.

It's mainly the fact that you counter all visiting roles and force them to technically get info they never get to use, since they just kill their target. You balance it with the Escort/Consort thing, but my point is still there.

Taking the point out of visiting roles and forcing them to kill their target, even worse with a Bodyguard/Trapper, doesn't make the game fun. It makes their role pointless.

Thanks for your feedback.

Can you please tell me whether you accept/reject or withhold your judgement on this role please?

I'll admit it has some cons, like nerfing certain visiting roles such as Bodyguard and Trapper, but it buffs them at the same time. For example, an enraged townie could visit a member of the Coven and kill them.

I'd say this has a risky, but rewarding KPN. It's more than a Poisoner (sorry about my earlier post, I actually thought Poisoner had a very high KPN, I didn't think about Doctors and stuff), Potion Master and (possibly) Hex Master. But of course, it has risks.