Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20171025060017/@comment-32384995-20171025100052

I prefer bodyguard. Reasoning:

Bodyguard plus situation:

There are 3 players left: bodyguard, serial killer, mayor. The bodyguard decides to protect mayor. If sk attacks mayor, bg and sk will die, town Wins. If sk attacks bg mayor outvotes sk next day. Now imagine the same situation with doc instead of bg. Doc can't heal the revealed mayor, so sk can kill the mayor and then the doc, sk Wins.