Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-31126981-20180121025306/@comment-32852564-20180122014023

Didthisformakingroles wrote: LunarBlackSun wrote: Didthisformakingroles wrote: LunarBlackSun wrote: So the role list instead of rt tp etc, has the exact roles but with one uncertainty. What stops you from just saying the rolelist in discussion phase? Evils would know what to claim That would actually hurt Evils more than help them.

What would happen iff there was a Janitor, Retri, RT Investigator, RT Mayor and RT Veteran in a game. And Retributionist was already proven. And Investigator had already investigated the Janitor. Boom. Janitor is insta confirmed as evil. This role cannot be claimed by evils as one little "HEY! NOBODY IS (ROLE) YOU'RE A FAKER" will get them killed. Also.

Another Situation.

NE is Jester. No Framer in Mafia. A Sheriff claim says that PersonT is mafia. Communicator confirms Sheriff and Mafia gets screwed over.

This role is extremely powerful. It's night ability is pretty much useless as you can claim the role list in your Will/Discussion phase. 3 rumors to start then.

If you give specific examples of all roles that are in the game, will be in the game, or have been created by fans (unless they're extremely up), there will be overpowered examples Even with 3 rumors, That's still 12/15 roles confirmed in the game. That literally leaves evils with only 3 random roles to claim. It's just way too OP. The only way this role could possibly work is that it just can't keep a Will at all and be BM'd the entire game.