Board Thread:Role Ideas/@comment-29034115-20160930174935/@comment-29779988-20161002160054

Ecaille13 wrote: In regards to providing criticism:

The last thing we want is a toxic community. Be supportive.
 * All are welcome to provide constructive criticism.
 * Criticism should explain why a role works well or does not work well. It should not simply be "no" or "it's bad".
 * Comments should not attempt to provoke users or discourage users.

If you want criticism, I'll give it to you: But if I'm harsh, you asked for it.

1.) The Coven Chief. This is basically adding leadership to a witch, which shouldn't be a thing. Town of Salem is a game of choices, and with this role, you're giving the witch almost little to no choice. You join or you die. It's also a Neutral Evil role and for that, it shouldn't even be allowed to kill or it turns into a nerfed serial killer. That is why I rejected it.

2.) Once again, same thing. Town of Salem is a game of choices. Voting is one of the only choices that nobody can manipulate. Because of the mermaid, you get rid of the idea of having a choice, and it ruins the game for everyone. That is why I rejected it.

3.) This role isn't helpful at all to town. What people are looking for is something that is beneficial. This is only a wall in the middle of the battlefield and can cause numerous problems. Along with the fact that it's almost immune to everything, the Inegue would only cause problems on the towns side. If they get bitten, then they only cause problems for the vampire. This role proves useless. That is why I rejected it.

I tried to be nice to you and if you don't see that 'nice' in the slightest, then I'm done trying.