Board Thread:Role Ideas (Other)/@comment-32892260-20170821154227/@comment-29253708-20170821164903

Dude this sounds awesome

But it changes a lot of game mechanics.

And the SK is exactly the same as GF here... So maybe replace GF? Also having two SK's I feel would be too... weird... you know? Like it's less exciting with two of the same generic killing role. With GF that makes three of the same generic killing role.

What I would do (because of Spy below), is make sure no one can see the role of their teammates. If someone comes out and says every one of their teammates' roles, boom that's game over. They could still even do that during the day. But this game mode kind of encourages gamethrowing. So either remove the Spy and keep knowledge of your teammates' roles, or keep the Spy and make it so no one on your team knows your role. This is a controversial topic so it's open for discussion.

Bodyguard - Probably the best Protective role to have in this mode.

Crusader - Way too OP. You automatically know you're going to kill a person who isn't on your team. With the regular Crusader you have to have that random chance for balance. Replace this.

Serial Killer - I would replace one of these... I'm not sure what role you would do instead.

Godfather - Replace this

Spy - So he gets to read the entire chat of the other team. I like the idea, but it's very overpowered. People will never talk because they already KNOW there's a Spy.

Witch - I love the idea of a Witch in this mode. It's perfect.