Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-197.133.86.130-20190501152237/@comment-28278669-20190501195843

The argument "If Town is dumb" does not work because in every situation, you assume everybody does the most optimal course of action. Saying that this role is good in situations where Town is dumb does not make this role good overall.

Your example is situational and does not always happen and you also don't win in that situation because Mafioso is a thing that exists.

And if you think someone is Town and Town is killing them because they're being dumb, it's your fault for not being able to convince them that they're Town.