Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-38125282-20200206192651/@comment-165.138.86.117-20200207122442

... there's a lot of things wrong here, but I'm not the best at reviewing mechanics so I'll focus on the win conditions.

Firstly, what kind of neutral is this? Neutral Evil? Neutral Chaos?

Two, the win conditions make zero sense and I have no clue who you can win with? Why can you win with Serial Killers but not Coven/Mafia? Why can't you win with Arsonist despite it being an NK? Why can't you win with Pestilence?

If it's a Neutral Evil it should be able to win with other evils and only need Town to die. If it's a Neutral Chaos w\hy does it need some factions to die but not others? Is it like Pirate where it needs to pursue a certain number of people? If your goal is pursueing a certain number of people once you reach your goal you should be able to win with absolutely everyone, not just a certain few.

Another problem I see is that this... is more often then not you'll only be affected townies which... yeah, if it's NE it's meant to but it seems more like NC. You're gonna have either an extremely easy time as this role to chase away 3 people or just keep hitting people you can't chase. There's 19 roles you have the possibility of not being able to chase away, out of around 49/50.

Overall this role is plain confusing, it's win conditions make no sense, and it could be easily too easy or too hard depending sheerly on role chance.