Thread:Vertroyer/@comment-37421692-20190123010755/@comment-37421692-20190126204751

Vertroyer wrote: And? The Disguiser is not going to be acting suspicious, he will be acting like a townie. That's the point. Are we assuming the player holding Disg is also stupid now? Essentially when does disguiser become useful? When it is alive, it is essentially just any other mafia member without an ability. When it dies, perhaps you can have one mislynch before the town realizes that you are a disguiser. A 1 for 1 tradeoff is NEVER in the Mafia's favor, unless that role is a particularly important one like Jailor or Retributionist. But if the role the Disguiser has disguised as is indeed a powerful and easily confirmable role, then all it literally takes is one more night to prove that person's innocence. Disguiser simply does not work. It can claim and act like a Townie with less pressure, yes, but all that does is make the town divert their attention onto your fellow mafia members. And you will most likely be lynched if you aren't "confirmed" as a Sheriff or Investigator by finding a member of the mafia or a neutral killing in a few nights, and honestly, there really isn't that many roles that the Disguiser can disguise as with comfortability. The Disguiser will be lynched eventually no matter how townie-like they act, if they cannot get confirmed. And once you get killed, well, read my point about the part when disguiser dies.