Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26715110-20170909064535/@comment-27398195-20170909073903

Okay, as from what I understood, from what you're saying is that we role reviewers should stop rejecting roles if they are a rehash, or as I call them, a "clone".

I do not agree with that though.

A rehash, by definition, is you simply making a role that already exists(or making one that is simliar) and slapping it under a different alignment (or even worse, the same alignment.)

We already have roles that do this in the game. Such as the Escort and Consort, the Investigator and Consigilere, and the Arsonist and Hex master, the Veteran and Medusa. I even count the executioner and guardian angels of being clones due to them doing basically the exact same thing but reversed, and for the exact same reason the lookout and tracker.

''​So why do we need more of these roles? That's nearly 25% of the roles are clones that ALREADY exist. And that's just off the top of my head.''

​Role ideas town of salem (where all the role ideas on the wikia are) is not an ingame version of ToS so why judge roles on that.

​Keep in mind that if you're making a role, you are ​seeing if people like your role enough to be possibly added into town of salem, so we are allowed to judge them like if they were going into town of salem.

That's all I have to say on this topic.