Board Thread:Role Ideas (Rework)/@comment-31379122-20170311234342/@comment-30088034-20170312144443

RoysOurBoii wrote: blackmailer -blackmailed target cannot vote guilty or innocent, but can still vote someone up (cmon guys, blackmailer is somewhat up and it's just 1 vote


 * I have to disagree with you there. Blackmailer can stop a confirmed townie from talking, making them basically useless, especially a Mayor. Also, they can stop a town from whispering, which can be important. Noww, not saying it's op, but still.

forger

-during the day, pick one person to check their will and forge it. once that target is killed, your forger will show up. this has 3 uses (so that way forgeries won't be so obvious)


 * I could agree to this, but i smell opness. (don't say that out loud)

consigliere

-you cannot check jailed targets because there is no evidence to check from them while they are in jail


 * As i said before, I like this nerf. COnsig is still op during non arso games

framer

-choose to deframe mafia members to make them innocent to sheriffs and give them a invest result that will not make them obvious


 * I agree. But what invest result?

-to try and increase successful frames, if you frame one person, you place a "lure" next to their neighbors, so sheriffs and investigators are forced to visit the framed person if they tried visited the framed person's neighbors


 * That's be a little too op combined with the first one. But I like the idea! I'm not sure which one will be bteer, becuse we can't impleent both as it would be OP

nothing for gf, mafioso, disguiser, or janitor


 * These roles are fine.

So some are accepted and some aren't