Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-39067078-20200201160528/@comment-63.199.33.66-20200221185209

ProfessorArceus wrote: this is problematic for a few reasons

1 - it's completely useless early game

Most roles are, like vigi, med, necromancer, etc....

2 - it can confirm roleclaims on dead players, rendering medium completely useless

How?

3 - late game it is completely broken and can be used to confirm suspected killers.

'''In late game, you're most likely gonna have a clear winning side. So if Mafia has majority, this role can't stop that.'''

so basically it makes medium completely useless

Medium still has its uses

1. Getting the roles and wills of Cleaned, Stoned, or Forged targets.

2. Confirming other mediums.

​​​​​​​3. ​​​​​​​Using its day ability to get info to other players.

and if it dies eary game it had literally nothing to add to the game

​​​​​​​Same with vigi, ret, pirate, etc...

otherwise a cool idea, shame it wont work