Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-39067078-20190408053327/@comment-38999535-20190408162456

Duwiiton wrote: The Sniper is a MK. Alright

Don't worry, it isn't completely horrible. I doubt it

Sniper

Mafia Killing

Attack: Basic good Defense: None makes sense

Sheriff Results: Suspicious Yep

Investigator Results: Your target owns weapons. (Vig/Vet/Mafioso/Sniper) Why not

Consigiliere/Witch Results: Your target is a deadshot. They must be a sniper! you should probably change the result, it's a bit too edgy imo

At night, select a target what else would you do at night

They get dealt an astral basic attack. astral attacks are broken for mafia, it makes LO useless

If anyone visits you, the boom will be so loud that they will be notified. so basically every role turns into sherrif?

Notification is "A loud boom was heard at your target's house!" just because astral attacks are broken doesn't mean that mafia should be plagued with what is, in essence, just a worse mafioso

The Visiting mechanic is to make up for the power of astral attacks. '''those don't balance out at all, and simply amplify the "luck" aspect of ToS. ''' 3/10 role, the visiting mechanic does not balance the power of astral attacks, due to the fact that this role is essentially just "Oh hey guys, you know how sherrif is really annoying because he can discover all of the mafia by D5? Yeah, this is like that, but worse." Also, new NKs are bad due to the fact that then mafia can kill two people per night.