Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-30150155-20161103014322/@comment-25876622-20161103211122

Any visitors that visit you while offering drinks will [...] have all the letters in words scrambled Are you sure this is Benign? It seems more like a Blackmailer, or at least a Neutral Evil.

The faction you win with is the faction that visits you the most while you offer drinks. In other words, you win with the faction you hurt the most by wasting their night and blackmailing them as well. Hmm.

The town will have a notification of the innkeepers current fraction he wins with. Aka "he wins only with Town". Town has more members, which means more visits in average. Mafia Support/Deception can't waste time visiting the Innkeeper. Transporters can double visit. Witches would prefer finding roles with killing abilities. If the lead on visits switches to Mafia, Town can just lynch the Innkeeper. (I can think of more reasons...)