Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-30307222-20170116214344/@comment-30307222-20170325191037

SpicyboiFelix wrote: ALRIGHT LET'S RIP THIS APART

FiretigerIsMLG wrote:

Ill get this first, this also could be a town role. '''Boi. One or the other, cuz Neutral Benign has one issue: it picks sides. Your role, as I see, is Town-Supportive. So make it like Town Investigative (#ripTP)'''

Role: Will Seeker

Neutral (Benign)

Town Investigative, mayt

Immunities:

Getting RBed

'''...Why? Escort, Consort, Transporter, Veteran, Witch... that list seems magical enough. Why?'''

Attributes: You may look at someone's will 5 times, at night, and ONCE you may see someone's Death Note at day (if the person you looked at doesnt have a Death Note, you may retry again for someone else.). '''Death note is too obvious and revealing, and people can't have fun with their death note. Besides, realize that people are gonna have pretty much changing death notes EVERY. SINGLE. NIGHT.'''

Death notes are supposed to be fun!

'''Besides, five times? The game lasts about 8 to 10, so as EVERYTHING'S RULE, make it the magic number of BMG: 3.'''

Goal: Tell the town who the baddies are, and hang all baddies.

And thus, this cannot be a netural role.

Investigative results:

Sheriff: Your target Is not suspisous.

Invest:Investigator ,  Consigliere, Will Seeker or  Mayor  - Your target has sensitive information to reveal. or

Spy, Blackmailer, Will Seeker  or Jailor - Your target knows your darkest secrets.

oh god what happened to the formatting here

Consiligere: Your target is a Will Seeker - Your target can be on their own side.

'''that's not how consig works! Should be like, "Your target takes careful notes on people's wills. They're a Will Seeker!"'''

This is my first time doing this, give me feedback! (Also tell me if this should be town, or not Benign!) First off, the name.

Will Seeker sounds more like a role that finds for Jesters (#williamPhipsTheJesterConfirmed). Change it to something like the Attorney, idk. Make the name not have to do with Default names, is my point, cuz Will Seeker sounds just as bad as John Seeker. See? It doesn't ring.

Second off, wills are supposed to be private information, and has always been. If this role were in the game, people would go CRAZY and terrified on what to write. This completely changes the purpose of why wills exist: as a notepad for people and log for what actions they've done/ info they've gained. WHICH IS WHY THIS ROLE MUST BE TOWN, IN ORDER FOR IT TO NOT SCARE THE HELL OUT OF EM.

But then, we have an issue. Town wins A LOT. And BREAKINGLY A LOT. All this does is nerf the Neutral Investigatives existing in the game, and people will be TERRIFIED!

Sorry, in short, considering what wills are supposed to serve in the game as, I say this role is '''A LOST CAUSE. GONE.'''

the sed feelingz when u relize u renteded soo muhj i love how you didnt read the updated version made by other people and me in this thread OHHHHHH