Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-29669939-20161026105829/@comment-29669939-20161027183821

Ulithemuli wrote: Sorry, but I wouldn't want this role in the game.
 * It is completely about random lynching - you don't know your target, but since everyone is forced to lynch at least one person, they will just vote anyone to get it over with.
 * There is no counter-strategy for the victim, since everyone is anonymous and can vote guilty without repercussion.
 * There is no strategy for you, since you have no way of knowing who you are lynching (if they stay quiet and don't give clues to their identity) and can therefore not team up with anybody.
 * Considering everything above, everybody will be glad if you die early (not a nice experience). Since you are in the same investigation set as Executioner, Werewolf and Sheriff, Townies will have a 75% chance to lynch someone evil and will therefore have no qualms getting rid of you immediately.

I see your point.

A. One person at least be lynched, but that could be anyone You Could Lynch The Jailor, Or The Godfather. And the evil roles wil want to lynch even more people.

B. That's the problems with NE. You really can plead the jester to kill you, despite you being the only guilty target, or the Exe having you as a target. They really don't care who gets lynched. They just want to do their job. (Unless your witch).

C. That's true.

D. There's a likely chance you won't investigated before you call court. And if you are. Rest in peices. However, BG/GF/Arso is in the game, and that is also a hard claim, espicially when there's only 1 TP. So it is actually 60% (2 Sheriffs) to 66% (1 BG)

But thx for your opinion