Custom Setups (Classic)

Below is a list of fun ways the Host can set up a Custom Mode game. If you know any other fun setups feel free to add them to this list. However, please try the setup first to see if it is possible, or lasts at least three nights (unique roles are unique, no more than 6 Mafia, at least 2 opposing factions).

Zipper Mode
13xTransporter

1 Lonely Jester

And 1 Serial Killer~Zipper

Neutral Madness

 * 1 Vigilante
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafioso
 * 1 Random Mafia
 * 3-2 Survivors
 * 1-2 Witch(es)
 * 2 Serial Killers
 * 0-1 Werewolf
 * 2 Amnesiac
 * 1 Arsonist
 * 1 Jester

Town v. Mafia

 * Jailor
 * Mayor
 * 1 Sheriff
 * 1 Investigator
 * 1 Lookout
 * 1 Doctor
 * 1 Transporter
 * 1 Medium
 * 1 Bodyguard
 * 1 Town Killing
 * Godfather
 * 1 Consigliere
 * 1 Consort
 * 1 Janitor
 * 1 Disguiser

Variation:

 * Jailor
 * Mayor
 * 3 Town Investigative
 * 2 Town Protective
 * 3 Town Support
 * Godfather
 * 2 Mafia Support
 * 2 Mafia Deception

Honorary Mafia:

 * Jailor
 * Mayor
 * 1 Sheriff
 * 1 Lookout
 * 2 Town Protective
 * 2 Town Support
 * 2 Town Killing
 * Godfather
 * 2 Consigliere
 * 1 Consort
 * 1 Witch

Mental Hospital Field Trip

 * 2 Doctors
 * 2 Serial Killers
 * 2 Arsonists
 * 1 Veteran
 * 1 Vigilante
 * 1 Medium
 * 1 Jester
 * 5 Amnesiacs

8,3,3,1

 * 2 Town Investigative
 * 2 Town Protective
 * 2 Town Killing
 * 2 Town Support
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafia Support
 * 1 Mafia Deception
 * 1 Neutral Benign
 * 1 Neutral Evil
 * 1 Neutral Killing
 * 1 Any

Variation:

 * 2 Town Investigative
 * 2 Town Protective
 * 1 Town Killing
 * 1 Jailor
 * 2 Town Support
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafia Support
 * 1 Mafia Deception
 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 1 Witch
 * 1 Amnesiac
 * 1 Any

8, 3, 4:

 * 2 Town Investigative
 * 2 Town Protective
 * 1 Town Killing
 * 1 Jailor
 * 2 Town Support
 * 1 Godfather
 * 2 Random Mafia
 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 1 Neutral Evil
 * 1 Werewolf
 * 1 Neutral Benign

Let The Gods Decide
Variation:
 * 8 Random Town
 * 1 Godfather
 * 2 Random Mafia
 * 4 Random Neutral
 * 4 Random Town
 * 1 Godfather
 * 3 Random Mafia
 * 4 Random Neutral
 * 3 Any

Mafia vs Neutral

 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafioso
 * 2 Mafia Support
 * 2 Random Mafia
 * 1 Arsonist
 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 1 Neutral Killing
 * 3 Neutral Benign
 * 2 Neutral Evil
 * 1 Random Neutral

Witch Hunt

 * 1 Witch
 * 1 Mafioso
 * 1 Consigliere
 * 1 Jailor
 * 4 Town Protective
 * 3 Town Killing
 * 4 Town Support

Skilled With Knives

 * 1 Investigator
 * 1 Sheriff
 * 10 Doctor
 * 2 Serial Killer
 * 1 Executioner

"No, It's You!"

 * 1 Godfather
 * 3 Framer
 * 1 Mayor
 * 10 Sheriffs

Mindgames

 * 1 Godfather
 * 2 Framer
 * 1 Mayor
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Investigator
 * 4 Sheriff
 * 3 Transporter
 * 2 Jester

All-Out War

 * 1 Mayor
 * 3 Bodyguard
 * 3 Neutral Killing
 * 2 Lookout
 * 1 Transporter
 * 3 Amnesiac
 * 1 Witch
 * 1 Random Town

VIP

 * 1 Mayor
 * 8 Bodyguards
 * 3 Survivor
 * 3 Serial Killer

Variation:

 * 1 Mayor
 * 1 Werewolf
 * 3 Serial Killer
 * 1 Neutral Evil
 * 1 Veteran
 * 1 Survivor
 * 7 Bodyguards

Communication Skills

 * 1 Arsonist
 * 2 Jester
 * 2 Survivor
 * 1 Executioner
 * 9 Escort

King of the Hill

 * Godfather
 * Consigliere
 * Janitor / Mafioso
 * 2 Serial Killer
 * Arsonist
 * Werewolf
 * 1-2 Witch
 * 2 Amnesiac
 * 1-2 Survivor
 * 2-3 Jester

King of the Town variant:

 * Mayor
 * Bodyguard
 * Veteran / Investigator
 * Godfather
 * Consigliere
 * Janitor / Mafioso
 * 2 Serial Killer
 * Arsonist
 * Werewolf
 * 2 Amnesiac
 * 0-1 Survivor
 * 0-1 Witch
 * 2 Jester

Who Wants To Die?

 * 8 Escort
 * Godfather
 * 3 Consort
 * 2 Serial Killer
 * 1 Any (Jailor is best option)

Mass Control

 * 11 Witch
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 1 Werewolf

(C)Old War

 * 1 Veteran
 * 5 Arsonists
 * 5 Witches
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1-2 Vigilantes
 * (Optional) 1-2 Town Protective (Subs out Vigs and/or Vets)

Hangman

 * 2 Executioners
 * 2 Jesters
 * 3 Mafia (Godfather, Mafioso, Framer)
 * 2 Town Investigative
 * 2 Random Town
 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 1 Doctor
 * 1 Escort
 * 1 Vigilante

Witch playground

 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafioso
 * 2 Consort
 * 2 Serial Killer
 * 2 Arsonist
 * 2 Witches
 * 1 Werewolf
 * 2-4 Amnesiac
 * 0-2 Survivor

I am crazy enough?

 * 1 Godfather
 * 2 Serial Killer
 * 2 Arsonist
 * 2 Amnesiac
 * 2 Survivor
 * 2 Witches
 * 1 Werewolf
 * 1 Jester
 * 1 Veteran
 * 1 Jailor

Rainbow!
Note: It needs to be set up in this order for the rainbow to show.
 * Godfather
 * Mafioso
 * 2x Arsonist
 * 2x Survivor
 * Jailor
 * Veteran
 * Transporter or Vigilante
 * 2x Amnesiac
 * 2x Serial Killer
 * 2x Witch

Variation

 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafioso
 * 2 Arsonist
 * 2 Survivor
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Veteran
 * 2 Amnesiac
 * 2 Serial Killer
 * 0 or 2 Witches
 * 0 or 2 Jesters
 * 1 Werewolf

Supports are underestimated

 * 1 Town Investigative
 * 3 Town Protective
 * 2 Town Killing
 * 3 Town Support
 * 1 Godfather/Mafioso
 * 2 Random Mafia (or specific mafia roles)
 * 2 Neutral Evil
 * 1 Neutral Killing (Or specific Neutral Killing)

Variation:

 * 3 Town Protective
 * 1 Town Killing
 * 5 Town Support
 * 1 Godfather/Mafioso
 * 2 Mafia (your pick of random or specific, but it's best with 1 Random Mafia 1 Mafia Support)
 * 2 Neutral Evil
 * 1 Neutral Killing

Mafia and Neutrals

 * 1 Godfather
 * 2 Mafia Deception
 * 2 Mafia Support
 * 4 Neutral Evil
 * 3 Neutral Benign
 * 3 Neutral Killing

I can hear dead people

 * 10x Medium
 * Godfather
 * 2x Janitor
 * 2x Disguiser

The Butterfly Effect

 * 13x Transporter
 * 1x Doctor
 * 1x Serial Killer

One v One

 * 1x Jailor
 * 1x Godfather
 * 13x Survivor