Board Thread:Ask Questions/@comment-30739178-20180420041442/@comment-33224790-20180420050849

What was their role?

If it was Forger, heck yes!

If it was Witch, no, Witches when dying can out anyone as it no longer effects their win. It is a dick move though. They can't claim you're throwing as Mafia doesn't technically need to leave the witch alive, as they can win without them.

I'm willing to bet it wasn't a Lookout.