Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32994909-20180604181712/@comment-32994909-20180604184437

50.203.254.248 wrote: fuck you faggot

BASICALLY Player X is Mafia and Player Y is Survivor (as claimed)

Player X knew he was jailed, and in doing so he told Player Y he was jailed... But what I think is the real answer.. is that this was a trick question.

Player X was most likely the Forger and Player Y was the another member of the mafia, but was immune giving the free right to claim Survivor. Player Y being jailed, and having known the if a mafia member is jailed, Mafia is notified. So usin g the advanatge that Player X was jailed Night 1 and that Player Y (mafia) was jailed Night 2, he used this to his advanatge to sway Town's Way to lead. Player X would give himself a safe role to claim whilst Player Y a role to get him a safe role as well, however, in doing so, Player X would get SOME way to get Player X lynched to make it more clear on his role being "confirmed"

This is an interesting answer, but it does not explain how the knew who the  was, so I’m afraid that’s incorrect.