Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-30255850-20171015211902/@comment-26234016-20171021212211

Heck the big guns are here

First off, this post will reply to Arceus. I'll get to Herethere  (can't think of a better shorthand, sorry) afterwards.

Second off, thank you so much for dropping by! I get that you don't have the highest opinion of the wiki, but you're still a big name and I'm happy to see you here. Now, I'd like to say that locking the thread is something that I object to along the lines of why Herethere  objects to the REJECTED: It's too crushing to the reviewers, or restricting, or limiting, pick your verb. Normally, the creator should be allowed to disagree with the verdict, or another reviewer is allowed to think that the role is acceptable (as long as the role has been replied to in the past two weeks, otherwise you're reviving a dead thread which is just a nuisance to everyone).

I agree completely with the idea that this:

Volf049 wrote: Like rubik said, op survivor rehash. EJECTED

Is completely and utterly unhelpful. We don't condone that. Yes, that shouldn't be common, and honestly I don't think it is (although I haven't reviewed a new role in some time so that might not be true).

I try to be a good reviewer, as do all role reviewers, and of course there are bad apples. Aren't there some on the forums? I'd guess the forums deal with them more harshly, but...