Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-27552918-20170417131623/@comment-31722862-20170417133718

Alright lets try this reviewing thing again shall we?

So its a Neutral Killing Unique role? I guess that makes sense. I like Neutral Killing

Thats certainly a lot of immunites, but I guess thats pretty normal for a neutral killing role.

The goal, invest and Consig stuff is all fine I believe.

So reading the abilites this seems like an op bm and executioner rehash, let me explain.

First off, you have a target youre trying to kill, thats something kinda specfic to the executioner and I think its on the suggessted "don't-make-roles-like-this" list (dont quote me on that.

And youre right, the silencing is a blackmailer rehash, which will bring  a lot of attention to a person, like not talking at all for 2 days? So even earlier on in the game this could attract a lot of attention, leading to people asking for their role.

So once you choose a target, that person will automatically die in the next two days? Theres no chance for them? Thats... pretty unfair in my opinion. And I think its just flat out, op for people to be killed just by mentioning the targets name or ability. Like what if theyre just being casual like "oh hey, thanks doc" and the doctor was the target. Or that theyre trying tp figure out someones role so they mention the roles name of the target?