Board Thread:Role Ideas (Other)/@comment-28278669-20170702163112/@comment-29253708-20170704181808

Just saying "it wasn't rejected" doesn't mean it was accepted. "Not rejected" does not equal "accepted".

If it didn't get a review, then that's even worse. It means no one even LOOKED at the role to see if it's good or not. If no one reviewed the Firefighter, then it's automatically accepted? That's just dumb.

If we say it's up for debate, it means the role is still supposed to be in discussion about what can make it better.

What I need you to do for a LEGITIMATE list, is look at each role thread, and say, "what EXACTLY was the verdict here?" Take each review that looked legitimate (It doesn't have to be extensive to be a legit review. If someone said their thoughts about the role, with criticism of any form, it's a review), and add it to the average. Whatever the average is, that's the verdict.

If the verdict says it was ACTUALLY accepted, then, yes, you can say it was accepted. If not, you can't claim that.

If it was up for debate, never reviewed, or died, then send a link to have us go over it. If it got changed, then I guess that means it is still up for debate, so send us a link.

So do that, and I will get back to you.