Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-33601385-20180503224909/@comment-33459116-20180514145538

SCl007 wrote: ok let me go through each _________________________________Mafia____________________________________

Disguiser: it changes so it depends on the disguised role 7/10 '''But do you know what that role is? Unless you have a consig, which means the only way this role would be good is if it had some shred of evidence that Jimbob was the Sheriff, and you should disguise as him. 3/10'''

Forger: Lol? not great but not awful 5/10 '''I agree with you on this one. Forger's main reason to is to get rid of good wills calling out people like the Jailor and Sheriff, but the Janitor does it twice as better, since he also takes out their role from the equation aswell. 3/10'''

Framer: can claimed to be hexed or framed but not the best 4/10 '''Framer should be astral, imo. 4/10'''

Hypnotist: Almost anything 9/10 '''Yeah, but he works badly. He cant claim trans, as you would need two people to claim they were transported, and most people see through trans claims anyways. Escort is off the list, as people who were 'roleblocked' would still get their results. Consort is also off the list, for the same reason and it being a mafia role, which is even worse.'''

Janitor: trapper or medium are ok claims 6/10 '''The second best non-mafia-killing role. 8/10'''

Ambusher: vigi and vet vigi is more difficult to claim than vet 6/10 '''ambusher is a mafia crusader that tells people that he is in the mafia. 2/10'''

Godfather: Bg and crus not great but worst case scenario an claim to be doused 6.5/10 '''best mafia-killing role there is, and easily can take down town by himself. 7/10'''

Mafioso: Same as ambusher 6/10 weaker godfather 5/10

Blackmailer: Spy is fairly safe and since the but doesn't see useful info 9/10 time decent 7/10 3rd best mafia role 8/10

Consigliere: Invest or tracker work invest is much better though 8/10 best role ever to exist in salem, 11/10

Consort: Escort 8/10 Escort rehash for the mafia 2/10

____________________________________Coven________________________________

Coven leader: Same as forger 5/10 '''Are. You. Okay? What does some dude who writes wills have to do with someone who can literally make you kill yourself right after you do their dirty work?'''

Hex Master: Same as framer 4/10 'Meh, but Hex is astral, basic, and at the end, he deals unstoppable,  meaning he can take down the town single-handedly '' (be warned, you will see that phrase often). 9/10 best Coven Role ever'''

Medusa: like janitor but slightly worse due to not receiving the stoned persons role and will 5/10 I agree here 5/10

Necromancer: same as Janitor 6/10 But...

Okie let me do this for Jally.

Janitor - cleans their will and role, unless they dont die, then it is wasted.

'''Necromancer - useful when they die. He can use them to do whatever their role was, and then also have a ghoul to deal a basic attack to whoever he wants. Late-game, he can take down the town single-handedly '''

Poisoner: Only good role is sheriff witch evils often claim as 4/10 role claims shouldnt mean anything, unless youre a low elo scumbag, poisoner can s ingle-handedly destroy the town as well

Potion master: only good role is doc 4.5/10 '''again with the role claims, yikes. You do realize that not only does PM have killing potential, he can also save his fellow Coven, and be a consigliere for them, all in one! and with necromicon, he can  singlehandedly destroy the town. '''

i dont like math so you dont have to see this​​​​​​​