Board Thread:Role Ideas (Other)/@comment-36558623-20180923215238/@comment-36558623-20181003044404

45.50.100.114 wrote:

Thank you for reviewing I had some questions and reviews for the roles and the general Carnival idea, though some of the questions could've been answered already.

General: Does the Carnival also win with all NB's and pirate?

'''Yes! sorry for not mentioning that''' Are all of the roles in a group like the mafia?

Yes

Or is it like the town where they don't know who each other are? If the mafia question is true, then what is the maximum amount of members?

the role lists at the bottom state 3-4 per game

Joker: If someone voted against someone who wasn't the Joker, then that same person was put on trial, do they get an unstoppable or powerful attack?

Unstoppable

Entertainer: It seems kind of op with a Joker because if they blackmail someone, the blackmailed person might vote for someone to convey that they are blackmailed, allowing the Joker to kill someone.

That's the point

Mirrorboy: If he placed a mirror on someone, some people visited that person, then the person died, do the people have to visit them again, or can they visit other people?

Interesting question, no they do not

Mimicker: Are you able to mimic the non-unique Carnival roles? Let's say that the Mimicker mimics the disguiser, then the mimicker disguises as someone. If the Mimicker dies, then what role will be displayed? This also seems op since the Mimicker will know the person's role.

The consig knows everyone roles, but the mimicker could also sometimes not get results at all.

could be nerfed, you're right.

Thief: Off-Topic but this role reminds me of the Robber in One night Ultimate Werewolf. I think that the Thief should replace his will with the will of the person he killed and vice versa so it doesn't look too suspicious. Since the person he killed shows as Freak, it would look less suspicious, especially if they claimed before.

good idea

Trapezist: "(because your such a skilled acrobat)" you're "Jester attacks will always kill your target" You mean clown? Also, does the Clown's attack ignore the trapezist's hidings? Or would the clown kill both targets if they target the first house?

'''Yes, my mistake. Clown will always kill your targets.'''

Lion-Tamer: To be clear, if they kill a town member, they won't be able to kill anymore?

Yes.

Strongman: This seems kind of op if they find someone with an attack. since only 2 town roles have powerful attack and only 1 town role has unstoppable attack, anyone they find with those attack are almost guaranteed to be evil. If there isn't a sign of a vigilante, then the roles with basic attack seem to be exposed once the Strongman found them.

basic - mafioso, godfather, serial killer, vigilante - yes, this is the point of the role to find these things, but Witches are a 1/2 in this mode so if you find a basic attacker then it could be bad for a vig

powerful - veteran, werewolf - you could die when investing these two, and they're both sort of rare roles so this is a rare result

unstoppable - jailor, arsonist - if you claim you found unstoppable it's more likely to be a jailor, so if you claim you find unstoppable people will be mad if you're wrong

Vendor: Is the defense permanent or temporary?

temporary

Oracle: Does the Oracle not have the option to choose the carnival members? Or will they have the option to choose one, but the ability will fail.

Oracle is mafia, so they can select carnival but they will not know if it is them or not THANK YOU FOR REVIEWING THIS. YOUR FEEDBACK IS VERY APPRECIATED AND TOMMORROW I WILL INSTALL ALL OF YOUR EDITS.