Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-31240203-20190827075213/@comment-40087242-20190924104551

GenocideNotAUndertaleReference wrote: Name: Faceless what?? Alingment: Mafia Support ok

Summary: You're a Mafia member that offers stealth and support to Organized Crime

Attack: None ok

Defense: None ok

Unique: Yes ok....

Ability: The Faceless can visit someone each night, if they are a town member the Faceless will be able to "derank" the Townie, deranking a Townie means they won't be able to use their role's abilities anymore(2 uses) mafia roles with limited uses have 3 (like forger and janitor), why would there be two? the Townie will still be able to vote,chat etc.(This ability will not work on town members with an Unique role such as Retributionist) '''seem incredibly overpowered to be able to just stop someone from using their ability for the entire game. Imagine being visited by the 'faceless' n1 and not being able to use their role for the entire game. '''

what about someone who has been visited by the 'faceless' and dies, and is later ressed by the retri - are they still not able to use their ability or?

Attribute: The first 3 nights when the Faceless is still alive it will give itself and a chosen Mafia member detection immunity, it can choose which Mafia member it'll make Detection immune. '''thats literally so unneccessary? what if theres only two maf ? ti are pretty much useless?'''

why give this already seemingly overpowering role ANOTHER overpowered attrivute?

Investigative Results:

Investigator: Framer, Vampire, Jester or Hex Master. When detection immune: Bodyguard, Godfather, Arsonist or Crusader '''already a mafia role under that allignment and no town members, seems a bit dumb. If the role was JUST to give temporary detection immunity that would make way more sense but this just seems incredibly unneccessary. '''

Sheriff: Your target is suspicious. When detection immune: You cannot find evidence of wrongdoing. Your target seems innocent. ok

Consigliere: Your target is a man that roams stealthily in the night. They must be a Faceless. that doesnt really make sense

Goal: Kill anyone who doesn't submit to the Mafia

'''​​​​​​​the name does not fit the theme of the game (salem witch trials era) at all. it also doesn't fit the 'organised crime' thing either. the detection immunity is actually really smart and could go on to produce a really good role idea for mafia, but this role just seems overpowered and unneccessary'''