Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32994909-20180607203338/@comment-35026689-20180609134025

Ok so time for Logic

Since there was 1 visit only and it was coven to X, then the following results are possible.

It can't be CL, as Jailor was controlled not X

It cant be Medusa, as Medusa can't visit without necro which doesn't exist N1 and CL would have it even if it was.

It can't be poisoner, as N2 somebody died to Poison, which means that Poisoner poisoned somebody else N1, not X

It can't be Necromancer, because it only visits dead people atm.

It can't be PM as PM can only produce messages from things like the attack potion, but the PM attacked N3 which means he didn't attack N2. (It can if CL dies n1/2)

It can only be HM most likely

The problem is that HM does not produce messages for X

So X's messages come from elsewhere.

As for N2, the Spy was Pirated N2 that's why he didn't visit anybody.

Z claimed Lookout that said that Mayor was visited by Retri, which isn't possible without control and by N3 they would die to control. Z is exe with target Retri.

Theory 1:

X is SK, who attacked jailor N1, and A Crus was on the jailor, killing the SK not the CL but Sk has high defence, so he gets 'You attacked the Jailor' and 'Somebody tried to attack you last night but your defence was too high!' (I'm sure this kind of attack does not interfere with jail, it works the same with BG as BG can kill SK who breaks out of jail'

Z is Executioner, as Mayor died to PM, this is the Kill, and is framing the Retri, who is Z's target to get lynched.

Y is Coven leader, as the Poisoner was in Jail that night, and Controlled the Jailor that Y knew off their kill, and into the Mayor instead, then afterwards Claimed lookout, which is a Common CL claim, and Jailor 'Visited the mayor'. Only CL would know that.

I don't think this is the solution as I'm not sure about the pirate messages

Theory 2:

The visit to X was an Attack by the PM, then He also attacked the Jailor who was guarded by the GA

X was attacked in Jail and Attacked the Jailor

Z is still Executioner

CL died N2 to a Vigilante shooting them, so PM got necro and Killed the Mayor

X is Still SK that attacked the Jailor N3 but he was Guarded by GA again.

Player Y is actually the GA who is guarding X but is 'evil' and the Visit from Jailor to Mayor was a misnomer

Theory 3:

X is a pirate who was jailed and Could not duel their target and were attacked in jail by a PM, accounting for 2 messages that he had.

Cl dies N2 to Vigilante, leaving the necro to PM who killed Mayor N3.

Z is still framing Retri with Executioner.

The reason there was no pirate N1 was that he was jailed, and pirated the spy N2, which the tracker saw as Spy did not visit N2.

X pirated the Jailor N3 and Lost again.

Y is An actual lookout who saw jailor visit Mayor as jailor was controlled n2 because the Poisoner was in jail so they controlled off it, but they controlled them into Mayor.

I bet they are all wrong