Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20171011055146/@comment-31256456-20171017144955

DesertStorm11 wrote: Guardian Angel has two protections. In an average 8-day game, that's a quarter of the nights. You never know when your target or YOU will die, and it can happen at ANY time. You become a Survivor when your target dies, and if you don't choose the "right side", you get killed. When YOU die, sure, you can keep on healing your target, but is that actually good enough? You still only have two protections. There's always someone who can kill your target.

Which makes it more fun, you know what I mean?

With Executioner, there are some similarities. You never know when your target will die. Whatever you might have claimed, it can often lead perfectly into being a Jester.

'''Okay, but we are talking about executioner, not jester, so what's the point of discussing jester. If anything it proves that executioner is a bad role so everyone wants jester instead. '''

Executioner is also a great role in most situations. Whatever they claim can backfire on them. They claim Medium in a Janitor game? Accuse them as Janitor. They claim an investigative role? Counter claim it.

That's really great, but there's just one issue- people al,out never believe you since executioner is so common.

You have so many possibilities, and evils can often figure out you're an Executioner if they attack you, then be willing to help get an evil person lynched.

'''Okay, but guardian angel has even more possibilities. Let's say your protected is a town. The townie you whisper to can simply not talk until a sure majority is received and don't protect him until he asks for it. Let's say it's mafia. Work with the mafia to help that mafia member- that requires strategy and skill, voting the same people mafia vote up, and whispering to mafia members, being able to claim safely guardian angel. '''