Board Thread:General Ideas/@comment-32659738-20180814141017/@comment-31919347-20180819231620

NightmareGhost23 wrote: Retributionist: Revive a Vampire Hunter, "Vampire Curse"

'''Seems fine to me. Retri gets an achievement for ressing Sheriff (nothing against Sheriff but only worse plans to revive are the other TI's), so why not? '''

Revive an Investigator "Sleuth Trouble"

'''No. Ressing a Sheriff is dumb. Ressing an Inv... No. Don't reward it. Encourages throw, watch achievement hunters revive the Inv above a TPow.'''

Revive a Transporter "Getting my Car Back" ,reference to the dead transporter gettin his vehicle back.

'''Good. Like VH, but I think only 1 achievement for Retri should be added tbh.'''

Revive a Trapper "Same Old Oil Smell"

Same explanation as Trans.

Revive a Lookout "Stalker Came Back"

No. Don't encourage throw pls.

Revive a Tracker "Brother Stalker"

Ugh.

Revive a Crusader "Killer Protective"

'''Haha that name genius. Seems fine tbh.'''

Revive a Vigilante "Suicidal Comeback!"

Just like the other good Retri ideas.

Revive a Veteran "Why?" , reference to why revive a confirmed Veteran.

'''Ressing a Vet is better then ressing a TI. Would get a confirmed townie, like the Inv should give the town. However, Vet can kill evils. I don't see Inv killing a mafia tbh.'''

Revive a Bodyguard "Double Life"

Seems fine.

Revive a Spy "Bugging Me Again?"

'''Hahahahaha. No. Same reason as the other TI's.'''

Jester- Haunt a Werewolf "Werewolf's Apparition"

Seems fine.

Survivor- Win with a Werewolf "Trusting a Monster"

'''Seems fine. If SK has one, why not WW and Arso? (Also review to the next) according to the latest statistics WW wins the least in ranked practice and ranked. In other chaotic gamemodes, like custom or allany, WW can't have a buddy. And Arso is weak also. This makes Surv more nicer, helping an NK above their town buddies 'helping' them through the game. On the other side, Survivor wasn't killed by the killer either! So yes, these 2 achievements are great plans actually.'''

Win with an Arsonist "Trusting a Pyrokiller"

Arsonist- Ignite a SK, GF and werewolf on the same night "There can never be more than me"

'''Isn't this a WW achievement? Not needed tbh. A good achievement would be 'kill all mafia or coven in 1 night' or something like that.'''

Tracker- be roleblocked 6 times, "Love removed my Senses"

'''Seems fine. Consort could rb Tracker whole game. Happened today also (when I was the Godfather hehe) 2-mafia game won Coven AllAny, boom!'''

Amnesiac- Remember as Pestilence, "Delayed Invincibility?"

'''Seems fine. Could happen. All others seem fine also, but I think only 1/2 should be added. And I don't like the Coven once tbh. Pestil, Exe, VH and GA seem the best.'''

Remember as Werewolf, "Monster in the Inside"

Remember as a Serial Killer, "Prescriptions Removed"

Remember as a Arsonist, "Forgotten Love for Fire"

Remember as a Guardian Angel, "Angelic Secret"

Remember as a Executioner, "Forgotten Hatred"

Remember as Jester "Phantom Comeback"

Remember as a Vampire Hunter "Aggro Vampires"

Remember as a Vampire, "Pinion Start"

Remember as a Potion Master "Recipes Returned"

Remember as a Hex Master "Lover of Curses"

Remember as Medusa "Stone Frailty"

Framer- Get your framed target lynched

'''Yes! This one should be so badly added. Also a new one: Get your framed mafia buddy get lynched. This could only happen with Trans/Witch/CL. If both of them were added: :)'''

Investigator- Investigate a framed Juggernaut "No Info?, Nevermind"

'''Good. But this one or Sheriff. Not both.'''

Sheriff- Interoggate a framed Juggernaut "Mafia or Not?"

Witch- control Vet to alert forcefully "Control Issues!" , note you will die for doing this.

Encourages throw, so no.

- Control Vigi to shoot mafia member day one, "Unexpected Development"

'''Nah. Giving someone two achievements for making a Vigil shoot someone, nah. Also encourages throw in rare cases (Rainbow)''' Some of your ideas were great! Hope you can use my review.