Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32994909-20180607203338/@comment-5498154-20180608171240

Player X is a Pirate who tried to plunder the Jailor on Night 3 but failed.

Player Y is the actual Lookout (because the only other option is that they are a Forger).

Player Z is the Coven Leader because the Retributionist cannot visit living targets, meaning they must have been controlled to visit the confirmed Mayor and logged it in their will for their lookout claim. If the Mayor was dead, they wouldn't be able to target them because the Lookout can't target dead targets.

Whoever visited Player X on Night 1 is either a Hex Master or the Potion Master, because the CL controlled the Jailor that night and someone died from poisoning on night 2 (that wasn't Player X, because Player X reappears later) and a Medusa wouldn't have the Necronomicon that night.