Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32994909-20180620175521/@comment-35026689-20180704102520

Day 3

Player X was jailed and executed. He was a member of the Mafia.

Someone was shot by a Vigilante.

Someone was mauled by a Werewolf.

Someone was killed by a member of the Mafia.

Someone was killed by an Ambusher.

Day 4

Someone was shot by a Vigilante.

The Jailor was killed by a member of the Mafia.

His will stated that he jailed Player B on the first night, and executed Player X on the second night, and on the third night the player he jailed claimed Mayor.

The Player who was jailed was Player Y.

Town asked Player Y to reveal himself, but he did not. Town did not lynch anyone that day.

Day 5

The Jailor was resurrected.

Both Player Y and Player Z whispered to him claiming that they revived him.

The actual Investigator said he investigated Player Z, who came up as Medium, Janitor, Retributionist, Necromancer or Trapper.

Day 6

Player Y was jailed and executed.

Night 6

The Jailor received a seance from a Medium, who told him that a Sheriff died interrogating a Serial Killer, who was Player A. The Jailor realised that Player A was currently jailed, and he agreed that Player A is definitely Serial Killer because of his suspicious Doctor claim.

Day 7

The Jailor was stabbed by a Serial Killer.

He had announced that he'd been seanced in his last will.

Player B claimed Lookout, and said he was watching the Jailor, and only saw Player A visit him and the Medium, via the seance, visit him.

The actual Investigator said that Player B is Lookout, Forger or Coven Leader.

Give all the arguments for Player B being a real Lookout.

Give all the arguments for Player B being another role.

Justify your arguments fully, giving the roles of all mentioned Players in your answers.

Assume that…

> The Jailor never revealed himself, or said anything that would make people think he’s the Jailor, day or night.

> Nobody gamethrew.

> No whispers occurred throughout the game except the ones stated above.

Invest

Jailor

Serial Killer

Medium

Sheriff

Vigilante

Werewolf

Ambusher

Forger

Mafioso

Retributionist

- Necromancer

-Potion Master

-

-

There is 0 chance of Y being a real lookout, as they claimed to have seen the Serial Killer visit the Jailor, when they were actually jailed. When they are jailed, they cannot visit the Jailor and will still kill them. Y should not have seen the Serial Killer visit

Y is a forger, Mafioso, Forger, Ambusher, Consigliere

-Consigiliere found jailor

-N3 they forged the Jailors will, as they knew who was jailed N1 and knew who was Jailed N2, and therefore forged the person who was jailed N3, they made them claim mayor, nbut they were Retri

-Z the Necromancer assess the situation from the PM who found out the Retri, sees that he can claim retri by also claiming. The Jailor, should have known that his will was forged and the town told them to kill Y for not revealing. The Jailor immediately assumes that Y is the Jester without realisng the Willl was forged. Y is executed as Retri.

B is trying a lookout claim for themselvces,  they forged the jailors will when the jailor died, to mafia as a seria killer and B took advantage by saying that A is definately the serial killer.

HOwever A cannot have visited the Jailor as they were in jail, so they were fake. They cant have forged the will as they did not know that medium seanced them otherwise.

Ill try to come up with B = Coven Leader Argument

But B in no way can be lookout