Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-33927649-20180226201644/@comment-34797858-20180302200000

reply to #30

MemeDaddy1233 wrote: Drunk (Mafia Support)

NoCarbonRequired

Name: Drunk

Alignment: Mafia Support''' Neutral Chaos sounds better. ''' What would its goal be then? Fair enough.

...

Abilities: Select a player at night and cause them to target a player that is 2 numbers higher (wraps around) than the original target (unaffected by dead people)Ok, what does that mean, does that mean if the drunk affect targeted a dead person, nothing would happen or does that mean if it does, the target of the drunk still uses their ability on the targets original target?,  it means that if I click player 5 (and get targeted by drunk), and player 6 is dead, it will skip player 6, and then move me to Player 8 (2 higherThanks.) in this case, they will not be told. However, this may seem too OP so ability usage may need to be adjusted. I would like a way that made them unsure of who they visited but still tells them they got drunk. Kinda like witch, but intersting none the less.

I thought about it causing a random target but that is RNG so >:(  I hate rng aswell.

Attributes: Role block Immune '''Does this even need rb immunity?  YES IT DOESOk, can you explain why?'''

...

Drunk immune roles-Jailor, Veteran, Retributionist, Transporter, Drunk Why should drunk be immune to being drunk?(Get it?)   lol but it has to pls no hurt me, Coven Leader, Necromancer, Pirate, Pestilence, Guardian Angel, Psychic, Survivor, All Neutral Killings. Ret,  Jailor,Coven leader, ga, psychic, surv and any nk is not immune to a witch's control( and I think necro is aswell), why should these be immune to being drunk?

Ret and Necromancer target dead people, so i don't think this would work wellFair.

Jailor kinda has to be since it would be unfair, but it could be argued againstUnless the drunk affect targets the jailed person, it basically just prevents an execution.

Pest has to be to basically everything,I never said pest didn't need to be immune to drunk. Coven Leader would not work, could break gameFair.

GA/Surv/Psy can only self-target/don't target (clarified for psy because one could remove their visions, but this doesn't)Fair.

NK is immune because mafia needs to be balanced with neutrals 

I am thinking of having Medusa (by gazing at home and losing a gaze) attack the Drunk, might change. Unless medusa's gaze has higher priorty then drunk's and gazes when the drunk visits, no.  Can you clarify?  

What I am saying is that the drunk shouldn't be gazed unless the medusa gazed and has a higher priorty than drunk, and doesnt have the necromancer.

Should an Amnesiac be forced to remember a drunk if they try to remember but get targeted by the drunk? '''It should stop the anmeisac to remember something, but it shouldn't make anmeisac the role of the new target, even if they are dead. '''   I kinda agree with that

Yes, I understand this is similar to a witch. If that's all you wanted to say, B E G O N E!''' Had a little more to say, but this is basically a witch with less control, doesnt know what role they target and has the support of the mafia.   Its job is to mess with town more than anythingJust like witch, but to also win with the mafia.'''

'''This role is intersting, to say the least. Abstrain. ''' ABSTAIN* REEEEE

Edited by NoCarbonRequired 2 days ago