Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32994909-20180620175521/@comment-35836120-20180621134236

I'll try this is going to be a hard one.

Reasons why Player B is a real lookout.

-Absolutely none since a real Lookout can see the Medium seance a person and the Medium talking to the (which I'm assuming Is Player Y) Jailor is 100% Legit.

Reasons why Player B is not a real lookout

- The fact that the Lookout didn't see the Medium seance the Jailor is a main clue that Player B is lying.

- He/she might have been a Coven Leader, or Forger as Investigator's investigative result is not accurate enough.

- Still assuming Player Y as the Medium, the Jailor must've lost their executions as a result which led to his/her demise.

- It is also quite possible that Player Y is the Retributionist, and Player Z as the Necromancer, and as Player X is actually a Consort used by the Necromancer to roleblock Jailor, and by random chance the Jailor jailed the Serial Killer (Jailor had no executions, but if this happened surely the Lookout should've seen the Consort.).