Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-35455734-20180501182404/@comment-33927649-20180507162810

GamesManiac wrote: 2001:1C03:3403:C900:90C3:B8B4:5580:826D wrote: NoCarbonRequired wrote: Even then

If you get into a medium vs medium vs gargoyle and it goes into night time, then being able to kill them would be good, because if it gets back into daytime, it's likely you'll get lynched (unless town has just been doing nothing) i love it when poeple bring up situations that have a 1/1000 chance of happening (i'd say 1/10000 times but you'd say that im exaggerating) 1/1000 chance of happening doesn't mean it wouldn't happen. If this really happen in a game, then we should send an automated message that says:"Oppss.. We don't expect this to happen. This game will end in a Draw for balance purpose"?

The point is

It doesn't matter what other two roles are left

Why would they visit. Even if they don't know who the gargoyle is they still have a 50/50 chance of dying. And if they die they lose. They'll be able to visit on the night it is stoning, but

If it's mafioso vs vigi vs gargoyle

Neither the mafioso or vigi would kill because then they automatically would lose. They have no way of defeating the gargoyle solo.

Even if they aren't killing roles, the gargoyle would have a hard time winning when three people are left. Once the gargoyle is outed, they are lynched. Do kill the non-gargoyle is suicide, but to die trying is also a loss. Any encounter with this role will likely end in a draw if it survives to the end.