Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-37747636-20181221065721/@comment-35356104-20181221142240

It's not that bad actually, just some issue with main mechanic. As long as it isn't going to turn the game upside down, NC role is generally acceptable since it barely has any standard of balance. However, its main mechanic possesses some swing element, and it doesn't seems to match with its alignment not in term of purpose or utility, but setting. Its killing power heavily relies on the presence of visiting role. If RNG rolls bunches of non-visiting role and TP, it can hardly earn any kill by itself, and vice versa. Plus, the game mode where NC can appear doesn't set up a desirable layout for its existence, namely All Any, while it can't be made solely for Custom, it would be too profligate in all aspects.

In case TL;DR: The root of its swing, is the inconsistency of rolelist, but it can't appear in game mode with more consistent rolelist except Custom. It's too wasteful to make a role only for Custom.