Board Thread:Role Ideas (Coven)/@comment-36824889-20180904225653/@comment-32651233-20181103225422

TheRetroPioneer wrote: Orecreeper wrote: Sheriff being arguably one of the weakest and swingiest roles in the game does not need much of a nerf. I would rather say it needs a buff, as finding someone as "Not Sus" is completely useless and confirms nothing, and finding "Mafia" will get you called out as an Executioner/Jester or the target will just claim to be framed. Same with Coven. Finding SK/WW might work as they cannot claim framed or hexed, but it is rare and easier for them to call you an executioner than mafia. Also, Sheriff is probably the most common scum claim these days and due to this, Sheriff claims are usually treated with caution if not hanged. Personally, I want to make Sheriff less available as a scum claim (at least Investigator difficulty) as Sheriff claims are just annoying these days. That doesn't really happen to me. I agree with the Executioner part for 40% of the time, but that's about it. People ignore Frames since they're so rare to be effective, Executioner counter claims aren't super effective and people don't really care. Not suspicious is very useful information, since it means you target is not Mafia/Coven/Ww/Sk except they might be gf/coven member with Necronomicon/basically every neutral role except for sk or ww. that's more than half the evils in the game.