Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-32994909-20170916135329/@comment-32994909-20170916152453

JamJamalWiki wrote: KarpToEndAllKarps wrote: This role is either OP or UP.

If you must tell the truth, it allows any townie to autoconfirm, and then the Emmisary can show the entire town (townies anonamously communicating is bad, that's why TK death notes aren't a thing anymore). That would make the role OP.

If you can give back a fake role to the Emmissary, it's just like asking someone for their role during the day time, which all Town roles can do, making this role UP.

Most of the time, I try to think of ways to make the role better, but this concept would just not fit very well into the game.

Rejected Yes, you can give a fake role back to the Emissary. But I don't think that would make it underpowered. For example, if an Emissary sends a letter to the Jailor, he does that have to announce to the town that he is the Jailor (since this would out him and Mafia would attack him).

If they their confession seems fake, then the Emissary can announce it and the town will decide if they are lying or not.