Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-31256456-20190820045459

This format was sitting in a google doc for a good few months, and I decided to rewrite it and update the information. Do what you want with it. I'm well aware that many of my posts are poorly made and quite horribly written. However, this could actually be somewhat useful. Perhaps someone could make a better version of it. Sorry if I sound pretentious at all in this post. I'm a bit nervous posting this, in fact. Anyways, take a look at what's below.

For a role review to be comprehensive and complete, in my opinion, would require: -One reply or more -Some form of explanation on the role's flaws -Some suggestion on how to fix the role's flaws -Some form of explanation on what the role does right

Anything that only meets a few of these criteria is considered brief and incomplete in my opinion. Anything that has none of these requirements means that there's been no review process at all.

Role Reviews (Town): Review process is comprehensive and complete: 5 Review process is brief and incomplete: 3 Review process has not been done: 0

Role Reviews (Mafia):  Review process is comprehensive and complete: 1 Review process is brief and incomplete: 3 Review process has not been done: 0

Role Reviews (Neutral): Review process is comprehensive and complete: 8 Review process is brief and incomplete: 5 Review process has not been done: 2

Role Reviews (Other): Review process is comprehensive and complete: 0 Review process is brief and incomplete: 2 Review process has not been done: 0

Role Reviews (Coven):  Review process is comprehensive and complete: 1 Review process is brief and incomplete: 0 Review process has not been done: 0

Role Ideas that have NOT been reviewed and are NOT yet outdated (Not been done):  Entomologist (Neutral Chaos) (No comments yet) Viking (Neutral Chaos) (No comments yet)

Role Ideas that should have more opinions from more reviewers and are NOT yet outdated (Incomplete): Gardener (Town Protective) (Needs more suggestions and ways to fix potential problems) Insomniac (Town Investigative) (Needs more suggestions and ways to fix potential problems) Prosecutor (Town Investigative/Town Support) (Needs more suggestions and ways to fix potential problems) Insurgent (Neutral Killing) (This was located on the Town board) (Needs to go more in-depth into issues and how to fix them) Obscurantist (Mafia Support) (Many issues were covered, but no ways to fix them were discussed) Executive (Mafia Deception) (Issues are presented, but no way to fix them) ID Thief (Mafia Deception) (Suggestions given, can have more explanation on issues and how to solve them) Surgeon (Neutral Evil) (Many comments presenting issues and compliments, but no solution to some potential issues) Controller (Neutral Benign) (Almost there, just needs to go a little bit more in depth) Surgeon/Misanthrope/Vindicator (Neutral Benign) (Needs more explanation, and a re-review of the role as the original role idea maker requests) Night Performer (I have no idea) (Explanation on ideas, how to fix its flaws, suggestions for the future) Neutrals re-imagined as mafia (Other) (More explanation, more flaws presented, more suggestions) Yakuza (Other) (Everything)

If there were any copies or any misplaced role, I: -Did not count it because it is unnecessary -Put it into its proper section, but explained the circumstances

I am unable to fully read every single word, so it's kind of a 2 minute skim through each thread, and as such, there might be some details missing. I'm not a great role reviewer myself, so I know it's kind of unfair for me to make this when I could be reviewing roles. I'll be trying to cover roles that haven't been visited and go more in depth. It will help me with my reviews in the future, and could point out possible roles that people can cover that haven't been covered too in depth yet. There's probably a few mistakes here, so please point them out.  