Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-26959384-20161108152544/@comment-26234016-20161108205256

OKAY

So I would say that all NC roles get rejected, but this is maybe the best and most well-thought out role that is NC that I have seen. So I won't hold the stigma of being NC against it.

Now, here's what Im thinking. The problem with your role is that it will ALWAYS ALWAYS beat the town because it is detection immune in all the ways. So here's what Im thinking:

For sheriff: reverse gm MAYBE, but Id keep it as NS for everyone

For Consig: obviously you find the correct role, BUT I think that if the consig finds a fairy who is not the gm, they also get this message: "Your target replaced a [original role].

For investigator: I like the idea of keeping the result, but it's too OP. So how about you get the same role list but instead of the prompt (I. E. Your target was covered in blood) they get "Your target isn't who they appear to be. They are either [original role list]."

My thinking is that most people just write down the roles listed without reading the prompt. And for consig, it would help with role claims.

So, there is that.