Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-31722163-20171207222921/@comment-33877233-20171208123417

InsaneGamer369 wrote: Name: Shill Eh Alignment: Mafia Deception

Attack: None

Defense: None

Unique: No

Priority: 3

Flavor Text: You're a guy addicted to gambling who racked up a debt with the mafia

Abilities: Once per night, select a perso to gamble with, and another to gamble on

Attriutes:

-You have 3 gambling choices

-You can't gamble on mafia

- Choice 1: The person you gambled on will die due to something other than mafia

- Choice 2: The person you gambled on wll kill some one the person you gambled on will die?

- Choice 3: The person you gambled on will be witched, roleblocked, or transported. Gambled on or with will be Witched/RbED?

Messages:

To Gambler: "You [won/lost] your bet with [player's name]"

To Person Gambler gambled with: "You [won/lost] a be with a gambler"

Invest results:

Investiagtor: Escort/Consort/Transporter/Hypnotist/Gambler

Witch/Consiglere: Your target loves to Gamble, they must bea gambler!

Sheriff: Your target s a member of the mafia! mm okay there have been Ideas like this before, but lets take it apart. No offense in advance, I just rip roles apart

So basically what i am seeing this is, is that you select 2 people during the day? or at night? and then you gamble with them, is Gambling RNG? is it like pirate? is it random? and someone you gamble on, as in they are the  ones who get roleblocked or killed? or is it who you play with? Not enough info really

The main concern is this: How do you gamble, is it like Pirate? is it RNG? like what? the second problem, do you gamble with someone during the day or the night? does it roleblock them? right now this seems to be a very RNG role, and as always a role that adds too much KPN to the mafia cant be accepted, especially if its not mafia killing. If it is like pirate then It would work as it would be a Pirate Rehash/Faction Change. If it is RNG, well you dont want RNG, as its against Town of Salem Rules. If you can find some other unique but not too dificult way of Gambling maybe, but first just clarify things a bit, its a little confusing but in its current state I dont think it is BMG worthy, but could use some work on specifics and how it all works and such. You have no description of the actual Gambling do that and I will get back to you, just clarify like everything