Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20171025060017/@comment-32881402-20171030191049

UnrequiredDefiance wrote: I'll have to go with the doctor team here.

Reasons for my choice:

-You will not risk the consequence of death as much as the Bodyguard, and so you will be able to continue contributing to your allies.

/repeat what I've said so many times.

'''BG can advance the game and prolong the game at the same time - if it kills NK, it does exactly that, hugely reducing the KPN and pretty much securing a Town win. When it hits Mafia, it's less significant, but Townies will be less prone to deception/death (if GF/Mafioso is already killed, the faction would have a much less steady KPN, and a role might have to be promoted to Mafioso)'''

-Doctors are more powerful when it comes to self protection. You give powerful defense to yourself. '''This only affects the Werewolf. Sure, it's an argument, but not a very strong one. WW is already hilariously UP and it only appears every - what - 3rd game. And when it does appear, BG has the upper hand with interaction - it protects and kill the WW when protecting another player. This greatly reduces the KPN.'''

-Although not being able to heal the Mayor, they can still heal a Jailor, which can be a game decider. (or gamebreaker, don't know what you call it.) '''So can BG. This arument is null.'''