Board Thread:Role Ideas/@comment-28112409-20160805100046/@comment-28112409-20160807052058

BobbytheBlobby wrote: In an average or balanced game of SC2 Mafia, you don't have Mafia and Triad in the same game. (unless you are playing a mode with no town, Lawless). It naturally simply either Town vs Mafia or Town vs Triad. You will not find many games with Town vs Mafia vs Triad, unless you are looking for an unbalanced chaotic game.

Also, I have a question. Why can the ingame roles break the rules but the role ideas cannot? Are they too good for the rules?

SC2 Mafia follows the same balanced setup as ToS, with the uninformed majority (Town) versus the informed minority (Mafia). In no way a balanced game in SC2 Mafia has less Town members. Its just like Classic ToS, 9-3-3.

Therefore, what I am really trying to prove is that some roles, breaking the rules up there, can work just fine. Then what''re you circling around here for? Go ahead and tell the people in the BMG forums and get the exact same replies everyone else got before you =P

You can also ask them for why the roles already in-game break these rules and got away with it.

I'll just be going in circles trying to explain it to ya, so just ask someone in the BMG forums for a rock solid answer.