Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-30392322-20190319041712/@comment-34703140-20190319045242

Drcyan wrote: Goal: Win 5 bets

Alignment: Neutral Benign I’m intrigued since we could do with more

Summary: Bet on people’s lives to win the game. Im now very intrigued

Attack: None

Defense: Basic (Or, if you lose a bet, None)

Attributes: Select a person to “bet” on each night. If your target dies (either during that night or from lynching the next day), you win the bet, and retain your basic defense the next night. If your target lives, your immunity is removed the next night. You don’t have to bet, not choosing a target has you retain your basic defense, but you cannot win unless you win 5 bets. You can also bet on yourself, and you can win by being killed but winning the bet on your own life. This is really cool but I feel like 5 is way too much, maybe 2-3

Investigation Results:

Investigator: Your target could be a Bodyguard, Godfather, Arsonist, or Crusader. Ok

Sheriff: Your target seems innocent.

Consigliere/witch: Your target visits the casino often. They must be a Gambler! Cool

This is my first idea on this forum. I hope you all enjoyed this idea I’ve been thinking about. I’m open to critique.

I really like this idea as a neutral benign but I think that it would be very hard to win with needing 5 bets won, I’d say about 2 or three would be balanced.

Another problem though, this role is completely indifferent, it doesn’t add anything to the game. For example with other nbs (and pirate)
 * survivor is the indifferent role whose goal is just to survive, it adds an easy claim and a who you want to get to side with you.
 * amnesiac adds the ability for tables to quickly turn
 * guardian angel makes one particular person harder to target
 * pirate is basically a survivor with the ability to role-block and kill

If you want this role to add something (which all roles added do) then try think of some way that it could impact the game, without it being another pirate.