Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-36558623-20181201153829/@comment-35026689-20181210170112

It depends on how everybody plays.

Jester and Executioner CAN be more harmful than Witch, if they choose to do so. Jesters can choose to kill the, or the , and one is obviously more preferable to the town. Executioners can also choose to help town once they win, or they can cause chaos amongst town instead.

I will ignore these, and pursue what the NE's do by default.

Jesters:

Wastes a day's worth of a lynch for the town, however, the town does not have to deal with the NE anymore. They're gone.

Executioner

Wastes a day's worth of a lynch for the town, but the Exe is still alive and also the lynch is a guaranteed townie rather than a jester, which doesnt always hurt the town so much. More harmful than the Jester.

Witch

Witch is the odd one out here, as they HAVE to win with Evils, they have no choice. This means that numbers of people in the town are guaranteed to be increased by one for the evils, whereas in Jest/Exe, they can chose either side, and will often lynch with the majority. The Witch has to work with evils, and tends to vote up townies based on their results from controlling. The witch also messes up the town during night time, and disrupts information from TIs and such, but really doesn't effect voting. I still believe that Witch is the most harmful by default.