Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-34969116-20180510183422/@comment-35356104-20180513031728

To: TheSheriff1

No offense, but I find the rating or scoring thingie annoying sometimes. Although you have valid argument for your point, element of objectivity in it is questionable. Not everybody see the problem you mentioned as a problem. Not everyone weighs the pros and cons the same. If judging from the number of pros and cons, then the score loses its effectiveness. A good role could have a lot of minor cons, but the pros can outweigh the drawback. A lot of things are polemical, point from any individual isn't necessarily a fact, but could only be a standpoint. I personally suggest not to put particular number unless you have scoring scheme or criteria. Try your best to keep subjectivity minimum. I mean it's fine if it won't hurt, but score is a pretty sensitive matter. If you want to do this for fun, I suggest you to do it like Rubik. I've never seen any number in the slot for score, but expressions like "eehhh", "maybe yes" or "maybe not"/10 IGN. Your score definitely gives an all-around idea of the role's practicalities from your perspective. However, it's a little bit upsetting to see how people define someone's hardwork with number.

I'm not forcing you throw that away. I'm not saying you have bad intention. But I want to tell you how I feel about the scoring system. The decision is still up to you and I respect that.