Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-30105631-20170128121805/@comment-30105631-20170129003759

Ignited isn't a rating. YIS is using my rating system. Ignited isn't one. Anyway, some replies:

Addfire:

A) I think 'mercenary' would be a better name. But that's just me.

'''Alright. Maybe. I'll think on it.'''

B) Once the specialist wins, (s)he knows what roles most of the people are because of the money mechanic. Not to say I dislike the mechanic, but... you have lots of knowledge that you can now sell to the highest bidder. And you're a neutral party.

'''Which makes it interesting. If you want, I might change it so that the Specialist only knows once they have received seven money. This way, they can only guess at the most who or what people are.'''

C) It shouldn't go through night immunity if it can do stuff an unlimited amount of times.

'''Alright, I'll change it. '''

D) This was probably answered earlier, but once the specialist completes their goal, can they still kill?

I don't see why not.

E) LOVE the goal/idea. Cannot stress that enough.

(: 

And as a note, @Addfire the Specialist will be confirmed as a role that exists in the game, but the person who actually is the Specialist will not be confirmed unless people figure him out.

YIS wrote:

1. this is not neutral evil if it helps town more than it harms it. chances are, the person you help will be a townie, possibly confirming him or killing an evil.

'''Didn't you just say earlier that you couldn't see how it helped town more than it hurt them? Also, mafia could hire you and make you kill the last person that hired you, etc. Things like that are very possible.'''

2. it makes town have the ability to kill. even indirectly, that's just a NO. It would either be gamethrowing or insanely overpowered....

'''Um... heard of a vig? Or a vet? Or a jailor? Also, Specialist doesn't have to accept someone's offer. He controls who hires him, just not what they do with him once they've hired him.'''

<p style="font-size:14px;">3. This is a role where it has to do a certain amount of things to win, which bmg does not like. i don't have too much of a problem with it, but why not give it the witche's goal? that also helps point one.

<p style="font-size:14px;">'''It originally had the witch's goal, believe it or not. I don't know why BMG wouldn't "like the goal". There's nothing in the rules about a goal like this, so it should be fine.'''

<p style="font-size:14px;">4.Kind of overpowered. Unlimited times which goes through night immunity? Hmm...... not sure about that. Not to mention it removes claimspace

<p style="font-size:14px;">Yeah, I'm changing it so that it can't kill through night immunity.