Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32994909-20180607203338/@comment-32994909-20180609143019

Well, this is a great tragedy. I hate alternative solutions, but it seems two might have been found for the first question.

> If 's attack potion is not used up when visiting a jailed target, THEN GamesManiac would be correct in saying that the attacked Player X on the first night causing Player X to receive the first notification, and the second notification could have been produced if Player X was a  and got a notification from failing to duel its target due to being hauled off to jail, as HAWAIIANpikachu said.

> If can attack a  who counter-attacks the  THEN Jamieawesome would be correct in saying Player X was a, and got it's first notification from attacking the , and the second from being attacked by the.

However, I'm not accepting either as complete solutions. In this riddle, the true solution also proves what Player Y and Player Z are.