Board Thread:Role Ideas (Other)/@comment-28550540-20170510014335/@comment-28550540-20170518151055

DesertStorm11 wrote: So yeah. All of these break at least one rule, whether if it's a re-hash or has a certain ability, etc. while most of them break more than one rule.

Prophet is a conversion role, and basically a Vampire rehash. Rejected.

Darkcaller is just a buffed Escort for the cult. Rejected.

Acolyte is a Spy rehash, nuff said. Rejected.

Shadowpope... how is the "present killing role chosen?" Either way, it's a BodyGuard/Vet rehash so rejected.

Deathblade is a SK rehash. Rejected.

Citizen requires you to visit someone multiple times to win, meaning it's rejected.

Spotter is a reverse Lookout, and is rejected.

Ritualist is a Cultist Doctor that requires the Prophet to be in the game, but he can't even choose to protect him. The Prophet has to. Obliterated.

Chosen is a Framer rehash. Obviously rejected.

Necromancer is a Medium rehash that only talks to the Cultists. Obliterated.

Phantom is a buffed Disguiser. Obliterated.

So I feel like for this you were literally just trying to recreate the Mafia. Darkcaller, Acolyte, Deathblade, Chosen, and Phantom could all be Mafia rehashes. Several of the break multiple rules, and all but ONE of them (the Citizen) is a rehash of another role.

Every single one of these is rejected! Did you even read the rules for making roles? (that's a link to the page) I'm sure it would've saved you a lot of time. Yeah, kind of.... But I was trying to make one anyways <_< I guess it turned out bad, especially that most of it is just a recreation of such roles. But atleast I know my mistakes, there isn't anything bad at trying anyways. ._. (Especially my fail joke role, *cough* urm.)