Board Thread:Off-Topic Posts/@comment-39067078-20190813002916

I will start from Mafia > Town > Neutral > Coven

This tier list assumes no robot has passed the Turing Test.

S Tier - This role's job can be replaced by a robot more efficiently to the point there will be none left

Consigiliere - The Consigiliere is just looking things up and sending information to the Mafia. This one is easy.

Framer - Similar to the Consigiliere, the Framer edits files or implants evidence, both very easy.

Investigator - Also similar to the Consigiliere, but this time the Investigator has worse file banks.

Sheriff - Assuming he looks up the people in files, we can also assume he's the same.

Transporter - Your Uber has arrived. Self Driving Cars!

Serial Killer - It's pretty easy for this to happen, considering the Mechanical Muscles they have will overpower most others.

Plaguebearer - Robots trasmit a lot of disease when not cleaned properly.

Pestilence - Your new almight overlord! The computer!

Juggernaut - A self learning AI who learns to be more efficient would fit this role.

Poisoner - Airplanes can drop pesticides. Why not poison?

Potion Master - Robotic Bartenders already exist.

Janitor - We can assume that the Janitor "cleans" by just destroying evidence. Robots have no fingerprints either.

A Tier - This role can be automatized easily, but they are not perfect in skill and may make mistakes.

Blackmailer - A robot can look up a database on someone and draw according information, but they can't tell what hits hard.

Mafioso - A robotic murderer. Not too hard considering they use guns, but may be inaccurate.

Ambusher - Also a serial killer, but assumed to not be good at stealth.

Doctor - Surgical Precision is nice and all but not always perfect if there are abnormalities.

Jailor - Bad Interrogation, only ask assigned questions. They still detain though.

Lookout - They can't always detect motion correctly. Butterflies may activate it but some others won't.

Arsonist - People can burn but robots can too. If they were to accidentally douse themselves, they can't clean it if it's in their circuitry.

Pirate - Drones can steal, so can this. It would need human guidance to be effective without new software.

Crusader - Shoot everything in sight! How easy!

Trapper - Manufacturing seems very easy, and you should be able to set a lot more than 1 trap per day.

B - Less effective than humans.

Consort - No. Ain't catching me with the metallic thots.

Escort - No.

Disguiser - Robots can't perfectly mimic humans, even if they could. They can't act like something they don't know about because lying is a foreign concept.

Godfather - The Godfather picks and chooses targets, but is unable to inflict psychological warfare.

Hypnotist - Robots are unable to render human pyschology, and humans especially may not care. If this happens, the robot can't change it's methods in reactions because it doesn't know if humans are acting or not.

Bodyguard - In many forms of media, robotic bodyguards are shown having the weakness of not having a sense of danger and able to be baited easily.

Mayor - Humans tend to not care about robots' opinions. We already hate Sophia because she wants to be treated as a human and we already know how many problems that can cause.

Vampire Hunter - Again, robots are able to be baited. If they went around and checked everyone, it would be less efficient then checking blatantly suspicious people.

C - Very ineffective

Medusa - Even if a robot applied a petrifying compound or quick hardening concrete, it would be slow and humans can still wash it off.

Tracker - Robots being able to tell who someone is without looking at their face is significantly harder to program. Even so, robots are clunky and loud and could be thrown off.

Forger - Even if a will was wiped, keyboard bots have bad grammar and sense of sentences.

Spy - I just... why? Robots can't smell. They would fail to be able to detect douses. Or anything magical for that matter.

D - Human only.

Veteran - PTSD is human, and robots wouldn't be able to be effective as the Veteran himself is. He had training.

Vigilante - Vigilantism is a human only concept. Robots wouldn't get it and would probably just not do anything.

Amnesiac - Robots have to be specifically designed at a job to be good at it. Take Dexter, an all purpose robot. He learns by seeing but is very slow, or else he screws up. Robots with all-purpose functionality don't have human dexterity.

Survivor - Again, pretty foreign idea. A robot designed to be alive until the end isn't very productive because of the pyschology required.

Vampire - If we assume Vampirism is a disease which is similar to Rabies, it's just human.

Executioner - Grudges are very human.

Jester - Mental Damage is very human.

Not Possible by regular humans either -

Pyschic

Medium

Retributionist

Guardian Angel

Werewolf

Coven Leader

Hex Master

Necromancer 