Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20181230235210/@comment-32421214-20190108204556

ZedKiller13 wrote: Vertroyer wrote: WolfiZee wrote:. '''But, considering i haven't seen it once in almost a year of play, that would signify the rarity of the event. Have you ever seen a make a difference in a game, besides being an extra vote for the ?'''  What game mode and what Ranked elo do you play at? '''Coven All Any (This is a rather recent change) & Silver ELO. I might've got higher if i weren't dragged down by everyone else, or maybe that's wishful thinking. Maybe it's just the fact that i only play Ranked once every 5 years.''' Yes, I have. I've reached gold and near on Platinum, and I've seen Disguisers absolutely fool the Town because they played Disguiser the way it should be played. For the last time, player incompetency does not decide how good a role is and what changes it needs. And if you were playing Ranked once every 5 years, at silver elo, then on what grounds and based on what reasoning or evidence are you saying Disguiser is terrible?

Your experience, which we've said about half a dozen of times in this thread that it doesn't generalize to everyone else's?

Old post but he’s completely right. Once I fooled an entire goddamn town by dying N1 yet appearing as the Jailor. Guess what? The Jailor also got BLACKMAILED. Town lost major hope, enough a Townie got executed the next night by talking shit about the towns incompetence whilst not claiming shit themselves while we killed the jailor the next night.

Another thing: talking back to Vert about the same reasoning or useing a demands move won’t work well.

You have experience?