Talk:Roles/@comment-5498154-20150314171701

Since most of these roles are pointless, overpowered, underpowered, overused, or some other botch that people seem to make all the time, I'm going to make some role criteria. Use this before you post a role in order for it to make sense and be useful.

Criteria 1: Your role must not be overpowered. (Unless cases apply to Criteria 6.)

Criteria 2: Your role must not overlap with any other existing role. (Abilities/Passives must not overlap.)

Criteria 3: Your role must not deprive purpose of any other existing role. (eg. SuperDoctor cancels out Doctor)

Criteria 4: Your role must have a purpose/function that adds more gameplay value, or it is invalid. (Good examples of this can come from SCII Mafia: Judge, Beguiler, etc.)

Criteria 5: Your role must not add-on to another role. (Criteria 3) (You can change properties of a role, but not simply add-on to it or it may become overpowered.)

Crtieria 6: Should your role be exclusively for a single alignment or overpoweredness, you must have a counterpart of the opposite or third party alignment that can counter it in a mild fashion to balance it.

Use these criteria to make your roles good/not random.