Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-50.37.85.112-20190226155913/@comment-35195751-20190227215743

50.37.85.112 wrote: Attack: None

Defense: Basic

Ahhh that kind of NE, noted.

Unique: What do you guys think?

No offence but NE being neutral is somewhat of a bad sign (reads on)

(After reading the entire thing, I would make this Neutral Benign, maybe that's just me)

Abilities: Try to lynch one of your neighbors.

...Please tell me this isn't an Exe clone

Attributes:

If either of your neighbors die during the day phase, you win.

uh oh

There's a catch.

This might seem like a buffed executioner,

Yes

however, if both of your neighbors die... (After reading further I have come to the conclusion that you do not count lynching as a cause of this specific loss, which is good because MAN would that be unwinnable)

You lose.

No matter what.

'''Wait wut? Thats absurd...'''

Ok among other issues:

What if one is revived before the other one dies?

What if your Neighbors are Jailor and Mayor (Unlynchable really)

However, if one of your neighbors is lynched, it doesn't matter what happens to the other neighbor and...

You win.

No matter what.

Yeah ok

Goal: Lynch one of your neighbors before they die.

Actually that one line sums up the role pretty well :)

Results:

Sheriff: Your target seems innocent.

Investigator: Your target keeps to themselves. They must be a Survivor, Vampire Hunter, Amnesiac, Medusa, Psychic, or Mortician

​​​​​​​Thats actually a pretty good result for this

Consigliere/PotionMaster/CovenLeader: Your target uses their job to take care of their neighbors. They must be a Mortician! This actually looks like a pretty decent role all things considered, but leavers are going to screw it up a loooot

Maybe turn it into a Survivor/Jester if both its neighbors die? Anyone?