Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20171002223259/@comment-31680260-20171004000512

SpacedefenderX wrote: Another things to mention

1 Coven CANNOT subsitute for 2, reason?Mafioso and consilgere can invest and kill, potion master can't invest and kill on the same night. (Fair point, but there's more chance of getting a Potion Master in the game than a Consig.)

Also, voting power is important, especially in the coven, because of 1 role:Pestilence, if you can't vote Pestilence up, GG. And the lack of voting power may get you killed, because someone gets voted up, it is hard to save them. (I fail to see your point here... Coven has voting power just as much as the Mafia does.)

Some other things, Potion master not healing and not providing healing may be a suspicious sugn if the Town is unknown of who has the Necronomicon, and there is always the Guardian Angel (Potion Master not healing is just as suspicious as a Doctor not healing, and I'd bet that most of the time the Townies wouldn't notice after the Doc was confirmed. No idea what you meant with the Guardian Angel.)

Sure you can lure the doctor, but what if ww is afk, and you visit on a full moon... (Then no harm is done, and you try again on a later night.)

As for Medusa, it has several weakness, such as luring in a killer to stone gaze, but you are afraid of gettig killed, so you get potion master to heal you...Oops, dead PM (We're assuming the people playing aren't complete idiots here... only a real dumb PM would try and heal a Stone Gazing Medusa.)

At last, Necro, as mentioned before, without voting power this role is quite useless, killer is dead and you want to kill, done, but what after that? (You make ghouls with your fancy little Necronomicon.)