Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-30158586-20161119215935/@comment-30158586-20161120185844

Calllack wrote: If you ask me it seems rather over/under powered. As in, both at once. Because too few players actually talk at night, so if you listen in on someone the chances of you getting anything out of it are really slim. On the other hand, if you listen in to a Mafia member they are instantly confirmed Guilty pretty much if they say anything relevant at all. It would also indirectly nerf Spy since the Mafia wouldn't speak if they knew a Listener was present. This if actually pretty balanced chances are not actually that slim since medium, jailor, mafia, jailed people, and vampires talk at night. No, you are not confirmed mafia because there are 4 roles and one player who talk almost every night. This could make it harder for mafia since mafia win most games(As far as I know). This could make the mafia act like a jailor or a medium, almost forcing the spy and listener to co-operate.