Board Thread:Role Ideas (Rework)/@comment-28278669-20190307210702/@comment-37322933-20190309225501

Orecreeper wrote: DragonClaw66 wrote: Jailor: Yes. The Jailor acts as multiple different Town roles: Doctor, Escort, Vigilante, and a Town Investigative (speaking with the target). It's provided defense should be basic, the attack should be basic (allows Guardian Angel protection), and it shouldn't be able to jail the same player twice in a row (less of an Escort). Additionally, the Jailor should only have two executions. Also, make it Town Power.''' Basic is too little imo, it should at least be powerful.  He meant Powerful. Seeing as there's no difference in Ranked, I don't care.'''

Vampire Hunter: This role needs a lot of changes. It should be guaranteed to spawn with a Vampire but it should also not be overpowered against them.

Vigilante: Yes.

​​​​​​​neutral, but this is a huge nerf to witches

mhmm

Veteran: Good, this role is fine.

'''veteran is too dependent on other people, but i guess its fine. I would incorporate ToR Bill's changes and I would make Vet's defense powerful though.'''

k

Investigator: Every evil role should have two Town claims except for the Framer, Disguiser, Hex Master, Vampire, and Pestilence.

Some roles like Consig or Consort really only need one tbh.

Consig already has a good one, Consort is hardcountered by a Spy that shouldn't exist.

Lookout: The role itself is fine, but the Osservatore (a Mafia Lookout/Tracker hybrid) should be added.

LO needs to be less easily confirmed but random rehash combination roles are not the way to go

why not?

Psychic: Rework it (otherwise the Coven players will get angry, which would be justified).

make it less RNG yeah

Sheriff: Good.

'''no, sheriff is not good the way it is. here are some changes:'''

you should be able to find witch without their magical barrier

you should be able to find juggernaut and pestilence (not plaguebearer)

you should be able to find vampires

'''Juggernaut, Pestilence, and Vamps don't exist in Ranked. I don't care. Still, Jugg should have Det Immunity.'''

Being able to find Witch is okay, actually.

Spy: The Spy shouldn't be able to see Mafia visits, but it should also be given a heavy buff to its bug ability.

'''Make it see whispers but also make it so that it can only see mafia visits half the days. Also it cant see mafia visits to non town to not make spy op to neutral killing.'''

Tracker: Good.

Doctor: Indeed.

Bodyguard: :) no this buff is even more of a middle finger to doctor

Crusader: In my opinion, this should be the priority list: Coven Evil, Mafia Killing, Neutral Killing, Town Killing... Mafia Support, Mafia Deception, Neutral Evil, Town Support, Town Investigative, Town Protective. With this list, the Crusader prioritizes killers, those with non-lethal evil intentions, and then protective. '''ok first of all, Mafia Support, Deception should definitely be first. It should be non-Killing evils and coven, Killing evils, Town Killing, and then the rest of the town.'''

It should be non-killing evils, TS, TI, killing evils, TK, TP.

Trapper: No opinion.

Escort: Ok.

Mayor: Buff it and make it Town Power.

'''buff mayor. sure. yes buff mayor. 100% what a great idea. would definitely be balanced. just no.'''

​​​​​​​He said make it Town Power.

Medium: No opinion.

ill take that as a no

Retributionist: I'd prefer a complete rework.

ok and ideas? I find it fun to review reviews of reviews.