Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-34916788-20180330080212/@comment-98.196.96.29-20180410044627

This role would instantly become everyone's least favorite role in the game, even less so than medium, due to its inability to make its own decisions. That alone is reason enough to keep this role out of the game, but I will list some other problems with it as well. 1) It would be too confusing for the highest ranked mafia member to pick what they do and what the victim does. 2) It would make absolutely no sense for the mafia to kill the victim because it helps them win, so I'm not quite sure why you added that mechanic 3) If the victim is chosen to take notes on the mafia member that is killing that night, then he would be investigating a target that will likely die that night, rendering "taking notes" virtually useless. 4) It just doesn't feel right for someone to essentially be the slave of the mafia; I just don't think it will fit well in the game. 5) The taking notes ability makes this role essentially a consigliere rehash, which is obviously not desirable. 6) This role is too underpowered and will bring the mafia's win-rates down too much. REJECTED

I hope this was helpful