Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-97.91.1.50-20190124010551/@comment-37322933-20190125000834

The Butcher, I'm assuming, is like Psycho in AH Mafia. In AH Mafia, it has two alerts and kills everyone that visits it that night, literally a Veteran for Mafia. I dunno how many alerts you'd give it.

That's actually a good idea, since it can kill a lot of people, but will be easily exposed if they have a will. However, it does seem like a more powerful ambusher, so I'd suggest that it doesn't get defense while alerting and only deals a Basic, with only two alerts, so it isn't so OP (Alerts can be changed to three if you think necessary)

Possessor is a Coven role, @TheLastHappyPotato.

What I'm reading is that it choose someone in the night to possess, then can talk & vote for them and switch back to itself. I generally don't review Coven roles, but being able to possess someone during the day is generally rejected due to buying Coven an extra vote, being a better Blackmailer, and possibly getting the possessed person reported.

The Rescuer is a Town role (Read the title, Potato guy!).

Sasuke made a really similar idea to this once called the Lawyer that can defend someone, so the next day, they can't be voted up (he can only do this 3 times)

The way I see it, your role shouldn't protect at night, since that makes it just a better Doctor, but should be able to protect one person from getting hung and from voting, like the Lawyer, except it doesn't need a charge limit since it also prevents the target from voting.

Overall, I don't like the Possessor, the Butcher is fine, and I think the Rescuer could be noice with some fixes.