Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-37174991-20181220181420/@comment-37174991-20181220204525

ZedKiller13 wrote: There are multiple issues with this role:

Neutral Benigns should never be suspicious to the Sheriff whatsoever. Fair enough

Neutral Benigns shouldn’t be able to give abilities to other people by themselves as that is an unneeded support role. What did you say???

Neutral Benigns, or ANY role for that matter, should not specifically target other factions in order to win. Why not?

Jailed targets should always be given Powerful defense and if attacked should live, why would this role be killed while jailed from an attack! Because it shouldn't be able to say, "Deodat Lawsom is ! I know because I am Traitor! Jailor protect me!"

Why in the hell would they not be able to talk when jailed? That’s asking for an execution and makes the role pointless as they quickly lose. Ok, but my point is that then they can privately share the members, but maybe that could still work.

Why would you be unable to whisper? Because you can privately share members to non- once you figure them out.