Board Thread:Role Ideas (Other)/@comment-28278669-20170702163112/@comment-31953669-20170702192528

Allow to take some of these off your hands.

The Kidnapper can effectively role-block 2 people a night and also has a serious RNG element.

Rejected.

Benefactor: while an interesting concept, it is hard-countered by TPs. Also, you aren't supposed to make Neutral Chaos roles in general. ALSO also, changing the attributes of roles is just not a good idea.

Rejected.

Manager: Is a roleswapper, and doesn't make sense thematically (i don't think the brilliant crime lord that is the Godfather needs help managing 3 other people.)

Rejected.

Prophet: may be fun in All Any, but would struggle to get much value at all in Classic and Ranked.

Rejected.

Possesed: This would completely destroy the balance of any game. What if you get Vampire? Suddenly you have that threat planted in the game with no chance of a Vampire Hunter. What if you get Jailor or Mayor? Suddenly you're worthless to Town because they can only use their abilities during the day. You would be effectively worthless on Mafia nights beause the Mafia's biggest strength is knowing each other's identities. And that win condition would cause so many issues. A role that fluidly changes it's own role is a very bad idea.

Reject it to the moon, baby.