Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32994909-20180607203338/@comment-35026689-20180610131906

knew it.

Theory 8:

1 Jailor

2 Invest

3 BG

4 Spy

5 Tracker

6 Vigi

7 Retri

8 Mayor

9 Cl

10 PM

11 PSner

12 Exe

13 Pirate

14 Vamp

15 Trans

Night 1

Player X is jailed. He is Mayor

One player attempted to visit Player X. This is PM attacking but failing, so he does not lose the potion, therefore being able to use it N3.

Player X received two regular notifications (the ones with white text and a red background, such as ‘You have died!’. Do not include ‘You did not perform your night ability.’)

'Somebody tried to attack you but you were in Jail!'

'You did not perform your day ability'

The Coven Leader controlled the Jailor.

Day 2

The actual Spy said that one member of the Coven visited Player X.

X reveals here

Night 2

The actual Tracker saw the Spy stay at home. The Spy was Pirated and the Pirate won.

X is bitten by Vampire

Player Y claimed Lookout and said that he saw the Jailor visit the revealed Mayor.

Cl controlled Jailor here as PM was in jail and he wanted to save the PM. Jailor visited Mayor as a result. Y however is lying, as Mayor was actually turned and and the Vampire was not seen, therefore Y is lying and is CL because it is not an Exe play. The Invest checked Y N2 and saw Lo forger CL

Night 3

The actual Tracker said that Player X visited the Jailor. The Jailor did not die.

The CL controlled the Vampire, X into the Jailor. The Jailor is not converted but still visited.

Someone was killed by a Potion Master. This is the BG, he was also pirated so he wasn't on Mayor. X was killed at this point by the CL who thought he was still mayor somehow (Whisper test the Mayor every day when there are vamps), Mayor is high priority for evils.

Player Z claimed Lookout and said that he saw the actual Retributionist visit the revealed Mayor. This is executioner, framing the Retri, his target, to look like CL. He is Exe as he did not watch the Mayor N2 and see that he was converted, nor the controlled jailor. He was transed with Z and Y N3, resulting in the Invest thinking N3 that Z is lo forger CL

The Investigator, who investigated both of them, is sure, but not certain, that one of the Lookout claims are evil.

Assuming the Investigator is correct...

> What notifications did Player X receive in jail?

'You did not perform your day ability'

'Somebody tried to attack you last night but you were in Jail!'

> Suggest the roles of Player X, Player Y and Player Z, give full reasoning for your answer.

X is the Mayor, the only other roles that can produce multiple messages with only 1 coven visit. If he was SK, he would have killed the Jailor N3 and there is no room for TP to protect Jailor N1 without killing the SK as well, like BG. X is not pirate, as from the tips before. He is converted N2 and then is Controlled N3 by the CL, which does not turn the Jailor but kills the Vamp and counts as a visit, which the Tracker Saw. The Cl wanted to controll him N3 to remove the high priority mayor, and N2 the BG was jailed, resulting in no guard, and N3 the BG was killed by PM and Pirated.

This is why there were no visits by the BG to Mayor N2 or N3, and this is why the Mayor was converted as Bg blocks vamps conversions.

Y is the Coven leader, as the CL controlled jailor into Mayor because the PM was in Jail and the Cl wanted to save them, so he controlled them into Mayor. Y is CL as they said that Jailor visited the Mayor, because they controlled them. However, the mayor was turned N2, and the 'Lookout' did not see that, so Y is CL. N2 Y was invested and they got Lo forger CL.

Z is Exe, as the Mayor died N3 to CL and he is framing the Retri for visiting the Mayor. He is Exe as he did not watch the Mayor N2 and see that he was converted. He was transed with Z and Y N3, resulting in the Invest thinking N3 that Z is lo forger CL

The invest, who thinks they are both Lo forger CL, knows one is lying because neither could determine that Mayor was killed by CL, and only one knew who it was, and they were lying. At least one of them is therefore lying, otherwise the CL would have been found easily.

There IS a Vigilante, a Pirate, and an Executioner