Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-32994909-20171130210430/@comment-25990889-20180107185721

2601:281:202:41F0:556E:AE4F:F36B:1B13 wrote: I feel like this role would require too little skill and too much luck (far more than even the jester relies on) to be implemented into the game. Also, from a realistic standpoint, I'm not sure how sleep gives you a powerful defense and coffee didn't become popularized in America until 1773 during the Boston Tea Party, which occured nearly 100 years after the Salem Witch Trials (1692-1693). Since when Town of Salem have to be realistic? I mean, italian mobsters in a pilgrim town? Why they are even killing the towns without any reasons? Veterans in real life dont just go on alert and kill everyone. Dont forget that, from a "realistic standpoint" Werewolf, Witches and stuff arent real. And from a realistic standpoint, how the fuck the Mayor or the Sheriff works? I mean, the mayor just "reveals himself" as mayor, nobody voted to have him as a mayor. And a sheriff its supposed to be a "known" person of a town. Also, from a "realistic standpoint" why the Doctor cant heal himself more than once? He runs out of medicine? But then why he can heal other people infinitelty? Also what the fuck is wrong with the Escort? From a realistic standpoint, if you are a mafioso and need to killl someone, or even you need to kill the Escort, and then she just says "You want to f*ck with me?* And you just forget everything about your goals and do it? And dont forget that, most of the time, you dont even know who is the escort that you f*cked with. She just drugged you to make you forget who she was? Or she f*cked with you wearing a mask? Why being an executioner grants you being night immune to attacks? If investigator can know the possible roles of someone with obvious observations like "He has a gun", "He have blood in his clothes" why dont the other roles notice that when they visit someone? How a sheriff "interrogates you" and you dont know who is the sheriff? He wears a mask too? Why if you are evil he knows instantly your role, considering that it was only a interrogation, Did he ask you "you are mafioso" and you told him the truth? Even if you dont know who he is because he is wearing a mask? Or he used some "Truth Serum" and also erased your memory with a laser like the Men in Black? That even existed during the Salem Witch Trials? Why mafia have to kill all the Town? That isnt reallistic, i mean, real life mafia just used to kill one or two to intimidate and stuff, the main goal of real life mafia wasnt kill everyone, not to mention that ... FRICKIN ITALIAN MOBSTER in the "SALEM TRAILS".

This isnt a Rant over Town of Salem realism, because isnt a game about realism, is perfect (well no perfect, but its ok) the way it is, it was never realistic and it will never be, because isnt meant like that, is meant to be fun. The actual rant was over that anonymous user that was saying about unrealism in this role Idea.

Also, i liked this role, is pretty balanced, original and interesting. The only thing is, that it would be easy in the case that a Jailor Jails you Night 3, for example, and you just dont post anything, and the Jailor exe you and Easy Win. But it also can have some good strategy like Vet/Medusa. I would like to see it in game.