Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-29493275-20170303213932/@comment-27398195-20170303222011

Garabic wrote: I was thinking of letting it kill every night and when no one is lynched the person you killed is there

But that is just really a buffed sk

Hawaiian pikachu take this into account:

If the town lynched someone every day they would deteriorate their numbers more than others unless they had info. So they couldn't really lynch to make you not there.

​Uh, not really, as if you kill, you wait a night before you kill again.

So the only reason TO lynch is with proof and that would lead to random lynches and jesters.

So think about it

N1. Lyncher kills D2.Oh no a Lyncher! Better lynch someone else randomly tomorrow so the Lyncher doesn't kill! N2.no Lyncher kill D3.LE RANDOM LYNCH OF DEATH NOW LYNCHER CAN'T USE GALLOWS oh wait it was a town member. N3. Le invest results no Lyncher kill D4.CHAOS ON TRYING TO FIND THE LYNCHER AND ANOTHER RANDOM LYNCH SO THAT LYNCHER DOESN'T KILL N4. Lyncher remains at home with no suspicion cast on him cause lookout can't see him D5. I AM,LE SHERIFF THIS GUY IS LYNCHER town be idiots and lynch sheriff

​You think that would happen.

​More likely then not in ranked town would not panic and just simply figure out all the mafia and this role and lynch them all in one swoop.

Think about it.

​I did think about it, I rejected it for how easily countered this is.

​NOBODY would like being this role, I would rather be an arsonist then this role.

How much chaos and confusion would this cause like with the suggested arso buff?

​The "arso buff" so far from what I've seen is everyone doused looks like arso but no silent douses.

Invest: EVERYONE IS BG GF OR ARSO or THIS GUY IS BG GF ARSO LYNCH HIM!! Was not BG Invest gets lynched out of suspicion.

​​Because there is no slient douses, the instant second someone gets doused they'll say "I've been doused!"

'​And besides, even IF this role somehow gets in, there would hardly ever be any game where Arso and this role were together in Ranked'