Board Thread:Role Ideas (Other)/@comment-31680260-20170627071731

I'm just going to put it bluntly. Vigilante, in many circumstances, is a negative utility. It takes out two townies in a random shot, almost a quarter of the town, and does the Mafia's job for them.

Random-lynching Mayors aren't as common, but it's still annoying when they're complete retards who don't care about winning at all.

Gamethrowing is defined as such: "Actively going against your faction's win condition, and attempting to make them lose". Vigilantes shooting with no proof early on have a high chance of shooting a fellow townie (and screwing the Town).

This is more directed at people who BMG will listen to (such as Yami or Naru). Please at least suggest this, I can't tell you how many times I've been randomly shot by a Vigilante but then couldn't report them since "I'm not throwing, stop being salty". 