Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-3560733-20170116051328/@comment-3560733-20170117233341

Yes I&#039;m single wrote: A. Ok, so what does that have to do with this is role in any way?

B: Otherwise, a simple roleblock or jail would not only cause mafia not to kill, but also bring suspicious on who was jailed or roleblocked. It's a similarity, but a useful similarity.

C: They COUNTER town. They don't HARDCOUNTER town (making it unfair) This obviously makes it unfair. Why? Because you can kill town every night! Sure, that's an sk. but it can only kill town! It's literally the same thing as a vampire hunter but with town! despite town's winrate, do you realize how unfair that is?

CPN: Sure, it hangs 1 town. But after that, it's basically a surv that can go either wait. Doesn't really harm mafia or town near the game's end.

Azrael: I know the dissimilarities. Not Night immune, different goal, and only kills town. Oh and look at that? We have a witch! and even if witch didn't exist, it's an sk that can only kill town! simple as that.

For the unique NK thing, fine. Go tell BMG what you think. Tell them there should be an nk specifically designed to counter town. See how that goes. It's not a witch nor is it an SK. Witch controls roles, this doesn't; SK kills anything not night immune, this doesn't. In fact, the similarity to the VH is the closest thing you've mentioned so far; good job, you did something good. And I have posted this on the BMG forums, so umm, done?