Board Thread:Ask Questions/@comment-31919347-20180811215858

Well, I heard rejecting role ideas is not allowed anymore. But I got a funny system that can easily rate a role! Is this sytem allowed?

First, I rate the creativity and originality. Then how fun it would be to play with, most likely. The third point is balance. And the fourth point is invest results. The fifth point is if it broke any rules.

The first will be 'investigative'.

This is the scores you can get:

10. Sheriff.

9. Tracker.

8. Investigator.

7. Lookout.

6. Consigliere.

5. Psychic.

4. Spy.

3. Witch.

2. Jailor.

1. Janitor.

So if I give you a 7 for the creativity and originality, I would say: Investigative - Lookout.

The second is 'Neutral' because Neutral is the most liked alignment! This is for how well it would be liked to play with.

These are the scores:

10. Amnesiac.

9. Werewolf.

8. Serial Killer.

7. Jester.

6. Plaguebearer.

5. Pirate.

4. Witch.

3. Arsonist.

2. Juggernaut.

1. Survivor.

So if I think ppl will like the role very much, and I give a 9, I would say: Neutral - Werewolf!

The third point 'balance' gets the name Support since most support roles are balanced.

This is what you can score:

10. Transporter

9. Consigliere (again xD)

8. Escort

7. Medium

6. Consort

5. Blackmailer

4. Retributionist

3. Mayor

2. Amnesiac (Can be anything)

1. Potion Master (Wasn't it support first?)

So if the balance is medium you would get Support - Consort!

The fourth is Killing, because the Vigilante can use the invest results well to decide to shoot evils.

10. Vigilante

9. Werewolf

8. Godfather

7. Veteran

6. Jailor

5. Serial Killer

4. Arsonist

3. Juggernaut

2. Poisoner

1. Mafioso

If te result is fine and worth an 8, I would say Killing - Godfather!

The fifth and last rating is: rulebreaking! Crusader breaks the rule harming town SOMETIMES NOT ALWAYS CRUS IS PRETTY FINE so that's why Protective is a good alignment for this one! Oh and if it breaks rules and you know it it protects you from /nosupport's on the forum.

10. Bodyguard.

9. Doctor.

8. Guardian Angel.

7. Crusader.

6. Trapper.

5. Transporter.

4. Jailor.

3. Lookout.

2. Consort (rb's the jailor to save other mafia)

1. Escort (^ but other way around)

So if it doesn't break any rule even a little you would get Protective - Bodyguard!

I will calculate the middle of the numbers and next up is the final alignment! The middle of the numbers will be rounded. These are the possible alignments:

10. Town Power

9. Town Protective

8. Town Killing

7. Town Support

6. Town Investigative

5. Town Citizen

4. Neutral Benign

3. Neutral Evil

2. Pirate

1. EVIL!!!

Is this system allowed, or is it 'rejecting' roles? 