Board Thread:Role Ideas (Rework)/@comment-39530373-20190705022029/@comment-33586669-20190710034944

I'm confused on what roles are in here and what aren't anymore XD but i'll try to give an opinion here.

I don't believe a normal citizen has a sharp knife just as a Serial Killer would. They don't have defense. The gas result is extremely small, and could easily be confirmable as either role. Evil indeed does refer to all that is not with the town, so I'd change the description of that one. The sheriff's description is a "law enforcer forced into hiding from threat of murder." I don't think I'd quite put that in the Powerful list. I would probably go with something of "influencer" of their faction. Sticks in the shadows and Patient is too similar imo. Target is connected to the dead, I like. I think I would change "strong" to more of "trained. (All of this is is no particular order, I'm just scrolling around.)

I agree with Kurama's first topic of having influence over their factions. I'd keep that, and then remove Sheriff.

Something along the lines of "Your target has experienced trauma that drove them insane." Or something like that for Veteran, Medusa, Amnesiac, Surv, etc

I would personally connect Doctor and Serial Killer in a result, and Trapper and Vampire Hunter in another. Maybe even connect the VH with a Vampire.

Like I said above, "sticks in shadows" and "patient" is too similar of a description for me. Perhaps "patiently waits in the shadows" for roles like Spy and Lookout. Because if you're hiding in the shadows that's technically all the evil roles trying not to get caught XD

For the Escort/Consort/Hypnotist (which i believe they should all go together), something like "skilled at diverting attention" XD

"Your target has ties with the dead" for medium jani ret necro etc

For bodyguard, crusader, and mafioso, "Your target is willing to sacrifice themselves for their duty/cause" or something like that :P

Some overall fixes, and I agree with Kurama in certain aspects of this :P I do like the idea.