Talk:Town of Salem Rules/@comment-153.9.81.23-20151028155144

So... question for if this is reportable/gamethrowing...

Was in a game with an investigator that claimed on day 2 that player 1 was mafia. On day 3, they told us that player 2 was protective. On day 4, they were killed, and there was no forger in the game. There will stated that player 1 was Mayor/GF, and player 2 was BG, Jailor, Lookout. So, we procede to vote up and hang player 1.

Turns out, Player 1 was jester.

I see people all the time claiming "Its not gamethrowing to help a neutral faction get their win" and other such technicalities...

But, because this investigator lied in his will, we voted up the jester. The mafia saw all the town was voting, because the "mayor/GF" wouldnt reveal... so none of them voted. We killed the jester, and they ended up taking out a town member. In the end, the game was lost to the mafia, in large part because of the investigators lie.

So, reportable? Is it considered gamethrowing/cheating, or is it just a really jerk thing to do but not against the rules?