Board Thread:Role Ideas (Rework)/@comment-121.54.54.143-20170413165736/@comment-31730332-20170414061354

It's hard to say whether this is necessary or not.

As an SK, when somebody else is accused of being SK (In the setting of an All Any game), your first instinct is usually to assume they're not SK, to frame them, and guilty them, or keep them alive to deter attention from you. The problem with this is, most SKs choose to lynch. Which will inevitably cause the dead player to ragequit, especially if they WERE SK. Same thing usually happens when SK finds an immune; You write them off as a threat to you, proceed to edit your deathnote and lynch. This causes a major problems in gamemodes like All Any and Custom where there's a high chance of double roles, so I could see why someone could want this. This also nerfs town a bit, which is needed considering their unbelievable winrate.

However, at any other point of view, this is seriously harmful and takes away some of the mystery, risk, and chance of the game. You could say this for any other NK role. For example, Arsonist.

Do you know what two arsonists, even if they aren't aware of whoever the other is, can do in a game? If not, here's an example.

>Person A douses Person C

>The same night, Person B ignites, as they had doused Person D

>Both Person C and Person D are dead.

>One was doused and ignited in the same night, causing much more effective and fast kills, as the Arsonists are now aware that there is another Arsonist.

>Now, lets say Person A douses Person B.

>Person B simply doesn't do anything that night, as Arsonist can clean themselves of gas if they don't do anything for a night.

And now let's go through the possibilities with SKs.

>Person A stabs Person B

>Person B is immune.

>Person A  whispers Person B at day for role.

>Person B claims to be the Doctor.

> Person A figures Person B out, tells Person B that they're also SK.

>Person B and Person A claim to be Jailor and jailed, backing each other up and stabbing everyone else throughout the game.

Now the SK one is a little iffy, for example, a spy could easily fiugre them out, and so could an investigator or a consigliere, so it could easily be stopped. However, this has happened to me as SK before (In fact, there were 3 SKs ingame!) so it's not impossible.

No judgement in my book.