Board Thread:Role Ideas (Rework)/@comment-2A02:8084:4EC0:6380:7D43:FA33:B150:A2A7-20171119024925/@comment-28112409-20171119031931

Hell nah, then the Poisoner would just be OP.

A powerful attack is too much, and no Coven role should have any form of permanent defense from the start of the game. Their KPN is already as chaotic as it is.

I think the Poisoner is fine with the Basic attack they have since they're trying to kill the Town, and no Town member has permanent defense so it's fine. As for the NK, other Coven members can take care of it such as Medusa and CL or it can be lynched later on.

If the Poisoner poisons someone every night, then it's just like killing every night with just a 1 night delay. Even if a Doc heals them every night, you can effectively be occupying the Doc from his job and lure him into healing other people. This allows for the other Coven members to continue with their job and there'll be one less protective off their mind for the time being.

As UP as Poisoner may seem, I don't see any major issues with the role. It works just fine =P