Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-28112409-20190123101502/@comment-28112409-20190124181246

Not everyone comes in with that sort of game knowledge and typing ability, but it is completely possible to improve to such a level. I don't have a guarantee on the reviewers improving to whatever standard I hold, since I do not possess psychic powers or control over their minds. It's why I believe attempting to criticize the bad reviewers is a waste of time as the results cannot be set in stone nor is there a guarantee that it will work.

On the other hand, good reviewers already convey enough for the creator to see. Role creators will consider all perspectives provided when looking at criticism, and good reviewers will naturally stomp over the bad reviewer's logic which essentially benefits the role creator and the general tendency for good feedback to appear.

Adjusting the Making New Roles page is to limit the number of bad reviewers coming to the area, and it is necessary to improve it as well because the page represents the community's view on this subject inlcluding both the staff and the good reviewers. It's a terrible overlooking act to promote good reviewing on one front and not the other, especially when the other is more prominent and gets promoted at a larger scale.

The bad apples will always be there, you can't exactly stop them unless you start banning every single one and that's not exactly fair nor reasonable. Why would you bother trying to catch a constantly reproducing population of pests when you can just introduce a predator and let nature take its course?

New reviewers will eventually grow and come to realize just how inaccurate and unreliable their method of criticism is. They can see what other people say just as much as the next guy, and they will eventually follow suit given enough time.

Once again, the guide is not plan A here. It's just a quality of life change that was long overdue, but it won't just solve all our problems. It will assist in solving them, but it is not as consistent as letting the good reviewers take the lead.