Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-31363605-20170223224543/@comment-29253708-20170224051225

Knoify wrote: Roll: Concierge

Alignment: Mafia Support


 * Cracks knuckles

Summary: A security guard who makes a living by guarding an unknown lair

Please tell me this isn't a Mafia BodyGuard

Goal: Kill anyone that will not submit to the Mafia

Wins with: Mafia, Survivors, Witches

Abilities: Guard the Mafia base to see who visits them at night

Nope, it's a Mafia LOOKOUT

Attributes:

- You will see who visits ANY member of the Mafia

Please don't

Example:

"Candy123 visited Blue(godfather) last night!"

I know this is basically a Lookout for the Mafia, but it'd be really helpful to the Mafia.

Sure, but it's a Copy Cat role anyway

Plus, the Consigliere is the only Mafia that can find roles...

And, shouldn't a Mafia base have some sort of bodyguard at its entrance? Or do people enter whenever they want?

'''The Mafia just meet in some alleyway. If they had a base, then it would be obvious who the Mafia are and the Vigilante would short 'em up. And no, they don't have a BodyGuard, they're the friggin Mafia after all.'''

How the Concierge can be used:

"Red visited Blue last night!"

When its night time again and talk with the Mafia, Blue claims he/she was roleblocked, you can infer that Red is the Escort

Me: So whaddaya say?

Other person ME: No.  :|

Me: :( Okay, so this is a Mafia copy of the Lookout role, which means it breaks two rules:

Re-hashes - Mafia/Neutral versions of Town roles or vice-versa.

Copycat - Any role that uses other role's night abilities.

What others have said is true, I guess, but this Role is rule-breaking, and cannot be changed enough to make it otherwise. A Mafia Lookout is not the way to go.

And therefore, this role has been instantly OBLITERATED.