Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20171002223259/@comment-31680260-20171009231014

KarpToEndAllKarps wrote: Time's running out. Whoever's judging, start thinking of who won. Also (so I don't get slammed with the off-topic stick), you keep talking about how the Necro buffs members of the Coven, but besides Coven Leader, it's left to Lady Luck who gets the Necro. Did a Poisoner get a worthless Necro in a game with no Doctor? Too tarnation bad. That's one of the main mechanics that decides games with the Coven, which just further supports my earlier point of how Coven isn't consistent enough. '''One in three chance that said "useless Poisoner" gets the Necronomicon, and that's assuming it's one of FOUR other roles that could fill the Coven slot. And we're currently testing to see if there's a particular order.'''

'''Furthermore, your precious Mafia has an element of "Lady Luck" as well. Who becomes Mafioso when all killing roles are dead is dependent on who entered the lobby first. But who entered first IS BASED ON LUCK. Even if you kept track of every single person who joined, AND in what order, that's just their account names. It would be impossible to plan ahead as to who becomes the Mafioso.'''