Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-2A02:A03F:48A8:4300:48E7:88CA:C7B3:EA58-20180623154419/@comment-25615841-20180628212015

2A02:A03F:48A8:4300:48E7:88CA:C7B3:EA58 wrote: alignment:neutral chaos

this'll be interesting

immunities:attack:none

defense:basic

and its neutral chaos?

actions:sun icon:choose 2 people to switch their roles with

role switchers aren't allowed rip

target self:none

target other:2 people switch their roles with each other for 1 night

investigation results:sheriff:ns

'''why? there isn't a point in nerfing sheriff anymore ;-;'''

investigator:classic:sheriff, executioner, werewolf or switcher

coven:sheriff, executioner, werewolf, poisoner or switcher

1-0-1-2. Not the best, it only has one townie.

consigliere:your target switches peoples roles. They must be a switcher

'''pretty basic. This can be improved.'''

game information:summary:you are a towns member who likes to switch people's roles

'''...town's member? its not even town...'''

ability:switch 2 people's roles each day

attributes:make 2 people act at night for the other person

goal:make 3 people you switched use their abilities on the other

'''another problem. This goal is a rehash of the pirates in that it's goal is simply to carry out its ability a certain amount of times. these aren't accepted, anyway.''' Main points:

-Off the bat, I can see it's a role switcher. Sorry to say, but BMG just doesn't accept these roles into the game. You can find a complete list of guidelines in a link located at the bottom of this reply.

-The goal should be changed, since BMG doesn't accept goals which simply require you to carry out your ability a certain amount of times. If you wonder why, it's probably because that makes it a survivor rehash, as the goal would require you to survive long enough to just use your ability enough times.

-Another huge flaw is that if you switch a townie with a mafia member, the mafia turned townie will know that the other player is evil. This is not good. Additionally, it also creates problems with the trial system, and will confuse new players to hecketh with the role's complexity o.0

+I do like how clearly the information is displayed, and most of the results and details you have nailed :)

Overall, I'd give this a

ehhh, maybe not?/10 IGN

Anyway, even if this doesn't get accepted by too many people, do keep in mind that it is very rare for someone's role to actually get implemented into the game. You still did a pretty good job

If you haven't already, please take a look at this page, it helps a lot when creating roles: http://town-of-salem.wikia.com/wiki/Making_New_Roles

Also, I'd like to interest you in making an account. It would allow you to edit your own messages, it would help us track you and your role ideas, and you could even become part of this community :D

And yeah, I know it's five days old, but one review isn't enough for me :P