Talk:Town of Salem Rules/@comment-84.236.125.38-20160530173422/@comment-25646419-20160530182220

That would be gamethrowing, yes. This would very rarely ever work out to help the Mafia. Think of all the things that can go wrong.

Town will ask, "so-and-so, role?" ... Your mafia will then be forced to think of a role to claim on the spot. It draws unnecessary attention to them. An Investigator and/or Sheriff may check out those names the night after to see if you're telling the truth.

One of the Mafia members might think you're intentionally trying to gamethrow. As a result, they may blurt, "REPORT HIM FOR GAMETHROWING." - and your Mafia will die immediately.