Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-34703140-20190223021406/@comment-35195751-20190224214641

209.249.55.37 wrote:

(I was typing the above review while this was posted)

I definetly like the idea. I would like to play this. My only problem is it basicly turns someone else into a werewolf (wich is cool in all) but its kind of op.

I guess that is a little OP but I have a suggestion...

I like how you ballenced it by be unique and can kill the night by making a husk. If I were to change something, I would make it that is a Doctor (Or any other healing role) heals a husk then they are back to normal.

'''Oooh, good idea actually... (Though does the Doctor still die?)'''

Thanks you for the examples, but I am confused on some other things:

1) So lets say we have 6 people left. A Mafioso (A), Another mafia (B), The soul eater (C), and three townies (D-F). If the soul eater makes the GF a husk, does Mafia B become a Mafioso? If not, that would make it so that the mafia gets no kills. If so, Wouldnt the mafia now that the Gf turned into a husk? (Wich defeats the purpose of the husk)

(This sentence was hard to read but)

So if I understand correctly, this is questioning mafia promotions.

Allow me to generalize this

What happens if GF becomes a husk, if mafia promoted?

What happens if youngest vamp dies, does another become one?

What happens to the Necronomicon if its user dies?

2) If their is a medium, and the medium sees the husk in the chat, wouldnt he/she know who the husk is and tell the town not to visit him?

3) Ok. New senaryio. Mafia People (A-C), A transporter (D), Doctor (E), More townies (F-G), and Soul eater (H) The Soul eater eats the Doctor E. On the same night, Transporter D transes Doctor E and Soul Eater H. Does the soul eater eat his/her own soul? And What if a witch makes them self target?

'''​​​​​​​Basic defence vs Basic attack. Soul eater tries to eat his own soul and fails.'''

4) I know im just playing what if here, but if there is just like 5 player left, couldnt they all just claim and the person who doesnt talk is the husk?

Heh, yeah.

(Lol the Soul eater should just pretend to be a husk)

I dont know, seems realy good and but also confusing. If I worked at BMG, I would put this role into the game. The Eater could use the soul as a "Pawn" Like a witch, necromancer, or hynotist. If you could please answer my questions, that would be grreat!