Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-30757827-20191008213859/@comment-30757827-20191019021837

Pathologist:

+More simple, kill your target and their target

Reaper:

-Though you might argue it has more skill, I think mostly it comes down to the luck that you get the right people, maybe there is some skill in who they visit the first night, but it will be almost impossible to tell who the next night, making the role more rng focused

-More complicated, see who your target visits for two nights and then kill both targets the next night (you can also only stalk two players at a time)

Peace:

+Pathologist is more about maximising priority kills via guessing who will visit who.

+Pathologist has a high motivation to target TP.

+Reaper is more about killing a lot of people, but having it hard to kill who you want to. (Reaper's KPN is maxed at 1.33(I did the math))

+Werewolf is also about guessing who will visit who, so if one of these could get into the game, perhaps both could.

-Both kill their target's target.

Conclusion:

They could probably both be in the game, but if they couldn't Pathologist would possibly have a better chance.

I'm not Einstein though, so make your own conclusion.