Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-30105631-20161117060909/@comment-24675428-20161123220815

Vertroyer&#039;s Boyfriend wrote: 1. yes but it's whether you GET that role or not. Like sometimes you can help out your team  ALOT or just help them out an average amount

if you roll Jailor and are bad at Jailor, it is your skill that effects the game

2. mind controlling isn't even real in this game.... it's not like you can be a witch in real life... if you mean false info... it's how they TAKE that info which makes it luck

'''/w 14 im inv, i know you are vig/vet/maf. 12 came up to me as framer/vamp/jest and there can't be a framer if theres a consort blocking n1'''

note: im a consigliere who found a vig and a jailor and im telling the vig to shoot the jailor.

thats manipulation

3. well i only play ranked practice... but maybe it's in ranked only idk. but let's take a different example. they kill witch n1. or surv. or jester. UNLUCKY!!!! but then they kill bg, mayor.. etc night 2.... LUCKY!!!! maybe with jailor it isnt but with a lot of other roles it is

'''killing witch n1 is luck, true, but you should be able to determine a possible jester or surv d1. (lookout for IM IMPORTANT TOWN TP ON ME) If you kill the bg or mayor it might be becuase you saw them vote 3rd on someone, a sign that they might be important Town.'''

4. but it's luck  if the scumreading works or not. it INCREASES the chance of you finding an evil ,which is skill, but definitely not always. lots of townies act like maf and vice versa.. and dont forget about vets/jesters, which act like maf a lot.

'''if im good at scumreading, thats my skill. if my scumread fails, thats my lack of skill'''

5. i didnt say i had poor skill!!!!!!!!!!!!! i have average luck. just saying there's a lot more luck than you think.

'''i wasnt saying you had poor skill. Im just saying you could choose not to read behavior patterns and choose not to scumread and then the game is luck. or you could read behavior patterns and scumread and then the game is skill'''