Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-33002215-20171008022435/@comment-28112409-20171008025032

This shouldn't be TP, it should be TS, first off.

The ability of taking detection immunity away is unfair especially to the GF, Arso and WW. Arso and WW have low win rates, while GF is the only mafia with detection immunity and its one of the only 2 buffs he has that makes him the GF. Without it, he'd just be a Mafioso buffed with basic defense, nothing more.

2nd off, why control immunity? Witch has been buffed twice because of how hard it has been for her to win with any evils. Nerfing her down like that is a bad idea.

3rd off, Roleblock immunity is just stupid, you're essentially making Escort foolproof and countering Consort. Both of which are not needed because these two are fine as they are and they don't have any issues.

But the 4th and biggest problem of them all that beats everything above is what makes this role 100% rejected. If its effects last for only one night, like Framer's framing, then that means this role can also be just as useless as Framer. If the effect is permanent, then the role is just OP and is giving buffs here and there with no skill at all. To make matters worse, at least a Framer always frames someone who ain't Mafia. This role could end up buffing scum roles.

Its not a good role, its not needed, it should be scrapped.