Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-37826186-20181223202755/@comment-35813313-20181224014751

Oh.

Sorry to be blunt, but I honestly don't see any way this role could work. If you see the murderer but stay mute, how will you be confirmed or communicate your information? Also, you see the murderer. That defeats the whole point of the game--it's supposed to be a game that involves trickery and lying. You could easily get around the whole mute thing by writing the murderer in your last will. Because everyone knows you were a Bystander after you die, there's no way the evil role can defend themselves. This is a Lookout rehash that I just don't like. Sorry about that.