Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-70.176.17.173-20171104061201/@comment-32881402-20171105200858

Raven1207 wrote: 70.176.17.173 wrote: Name:  Bomber

Alignment:  (Mafia Killing)

Attack: Powerful

Defense: none

So basically it's OP Mafioso

Unique Role: yes

Abilities:Plant a bomb at someones house

your bombs deliver a powerful rampage attack

Very OP Mafioso 

you have 2 bombs

Attributes: you can read the mafia chat

if there are no kill capable mafia left you will become a mafioso

That's for if there is no capable Mafia KILLING, but then again, Mafioso gets promoted to Godfather when the original dies

Mechanics: Bombs are a day ability

you choose a deactivation wire out of 3

the person your bombing will have to choose the correct deactivation wire or be delt a powerful rampage attack

-Investigative Results-

Sheriff: Mafia

Investigator: Sheriff, Executioner, Werewolf, Poisoner, or B  omber

Consigliere/Witch: Your target is a master of demolition the must be a bomber

Goal: kill anyone who will not submit to the mafia

this is a mafia killing so yeah but it has only 2 attacks and they can both be defused so feel fre to critisize. Rejected no need for anymore MK tfw when you don't explain a thing. Top quality reviewing, I must say. Why is there no need for any more MK? How is it an OP Mafioso? And please don't say that the reasoning is in previous posts, because if it is, then your whole point of rejecting it was unhelpful because it has already been said.

Because, in fact, it isn't an OP Mafioso at all. Mafioso has a steady KPN. This can get a kill twice and the Powerful attack only affects NKs, so sure it's a little more powerful, but it's so minor that it's not enough jusitifcation to dismiss a role. But oh wait, you didn't even explain that because your review was just that bad.

It's swingy, so we can't compare it the the Mafioso. Mafioso has a steady KPN, but it is limited to 1 kill a night. You managed to ignore the fact that it a limit to its uses because that's what a great reviewer does, right? It's too swingy to compare, because it is dependent on visits. And it depends on how long the game goes on for, because as it continues, Mafioso gains the upper hand with no limit on killing. Now, please, finish your review.