Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-33023876-20171016234445/@comment-32881402-20171022191700

DesertStorm11 wrote:

MLGSquadStuff wrote: Alignment- Town(Support)

Background Summary- You are a law-abiding resident with no skills.

I like the summary +1 creativity 

'''What? Uh okay. Creativity = lore and therefore shouldn't be taken into account.'''

Attack- none

Defence- none (basic with vest on)

'''There's a vest? Fancy +1 balance, +1 understandable'''

'''In fact, this should be removed. It adds nothing and buffs the role unnecessarily.'''

Unique- no

Abilities- You have 1 bulletproof vest,

It will be destroyed after you use it, even if you are not attacked.

+1 balance, +1 understandable

'''You just added +2 for a thing that shouldn't exist. '''

Attributes- You are control immune

'''I don't get why this is a thing... -1 balance, -1 understandable'''

'''What? I mean it's unnecessary, but ultimately doesn't affect the role at all. Points shouldn't be deducted.'''

If you are the last town member versus a mafia member or netural killing, the town will win.

I don't get this either -2 balance, -1 understandable

Agreed, this is very bad.

Mechanics- similar to a weaker survivor aligned with the town.

Investigative results

Sherrif- Not Suspicious

Investigator-Survivor, Vampire Hunter, Witch, Medusa, Psychic, or Citizen

+1 understandable

Consigliere/Witch/Coven Leader- You Target has no skills. They must be a citizen!

I would change this, idk what to tho

This isn't even remotely significant; I'm glad you didn't deduct any points for this.

Goal- Lynch every criminal and evildoer

wins with- who town wins with

must kill-who town must kill

You can spare anyone else 1/10 creativity

-1/10 balance

1/10 understandable

(1 - 1 + 1)/3 = 3.3%

Clearly the control immunity and broken 1v1 draw detector-thing is kind of making this role rejected!

'''The draw detector thing is unnecessary and makes it quite a powerful role. This is meant to nerf Town, not buff it. The control immunity is pointless, since the vest shouldn't exist. This is someone who has no defense and tries their best to contribute. '''

Changes:

-No vest

-No draw detector

-No control immunity

@DesertStorm: Please don't sum up scores like that - it doesn't work in many situations. Because you start at 0 and don't even have 10 opportunities to get balance points, it doesn't work. Just review it normally. Anons unite wrote: surv need buff tho and you right What. No. Why. Who. Where. Survs have one of the highest winrates. They haev 4 vests and if you can play it decently well you won't die. It's not a good role and needs a change, but not a buff.