Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-38165883-20190706152634/@comment-40273789-20190727045147

TheRetroPioneer, I really like that idea, but... what if the game doesn't generate mafia? Or only one mafia? Same could be said for neutrals. We could be playing any game mode at all: we have no idea what factions will exist.

If we are playing normal ranked, I see how that could work (dispite ranked not having a NC role in it). If the role was switched to a NE, then it would be allowed in ranked but I see problems with this as well. 1) It can kill, its not similar at all to the other NE roles. 2) It would cause way too much death in the first few nights.

Maybe have the win conditions be "kill 2 players of different factions" along with the earlier suggestion of having a cooldown night similar to the vampire. That way, you can't nessisarily side with mafia because they know that after you kill a town, you can just turn on them for an easy win. You could promise to work with them in exchange for a sacrafice but just like a jester, you don't really have to.

Anyway, great ideas all around, I'm just here to make suggestions that I think make the role better. It is really what you choose.