Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-37441588-20181110144041/@comment-36539941-20181110171113

Xaq0023 wrote: Name: Drug Dealer

Alignment: Mafia (possibly neutral chaos)

Attack: None

Defense: Basic

'''No. Change defense to none, please. Mafia with defense shouldn't exist : only leaders of their faction should have any defense (GF, CL)'''

Unique Role: Yes

Abilities: Offers another player different vials each does something different. One kills them instantly no matter defense, another gives them basic(or higher) defense, and one roleblocks them. (maybe other ones as well like one that publicly reveals their role the next day but thats probably to OP and 3 seems like enough. also should probably have more benifitial vials)

'''Killing drug : Just change the attack to basic. Otherwise, you'd be able to kill Pestilence or some sh*t like that in one night. Without lynching. Giving defense drug : There are 2 ways this could go wrong. If it could use this drug on Mafia, that's a big nono. Mafia protective roles and abilities are heavily frowned upon. If it can't use it on Mafia, that really does nothing useful for Mafia. Roleblocking drug : This is something Consort already does. ​​​​'''

Attributes: Can only visit on non full moon nights to conceal identity

'''Ok, that's cool. The problem is that it kinda limits it's usage, but eh.'''

Can't be roleblocked

If someone visits you at night to invest or attack you they find that you are gone but they see drugs in your house

'''So, if anyone visits you while you are out drugging someone, they'll immediately know who you are? Or is it any night you are alive, and they visit you, they'll know who you are? Either way, that really kills their claimspace.'''

Anyone you sell to will have drugs in there house as well and an invest will see them and get drug dealer results

'''That's Framer and Hex Master's job. And it should only be Framer and Hex Master's job, as their whole gimmick of changing invest results is changing the invest result to a pure evil result. Had they changed it to any result with town, their gimmick would be completely pointless. '''

-Investigative Results-

Sheriff: Suspicious

Investigator: Spy, Blackmailer, Jailor, Guardian Angel, or drug dealer

'''​​​​​​​It's essentially forced to claim Spy for town, and sometimes Gaurdian Angel. Okay. That seems pretty balanced, considering Spy is such an easy claim for any Mafia member, and, as long as there is no BM'r, is not inherently suspicious.'''

Consigliere/Witch:Your target has an unmistakable smell to them they must be a drug dealer

Goal: kill all who apose he mafia

Wins With: Mafia

Must Kill: all those against mafia

Anything Else: doesn't have to be drugs just that was the easiest way to put it for now Overall, I like the concept of having drugs and all that, but this is way too similar to PM.

A few changes I'd suggest, if this should ever become a role, are

- Bringing Defense down to none

- Putting a drug limit of 3 (But you get to choose any of the 3 drugs) or putting a cooldown on the drugs (similar to non Necronomicron PM)

- Make it able to drug someone every night, instead of non-full moon nights (increases utility)

- Making the killing drug a basic attack (thus changing attack to basic)

- Switching the defense drug out for any other drug (One that reveals role, or one that forces your target to visit a player of your choice would be 2 suggestions I have, preferably the latter)

- Making the Roleblock drug unique by extending the roleblock to 2 nights, and giving a new action name instead of Roleblock ("You have been drugged by the Drug dealer! You are too sick to go anywhere!" or something like that).