Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-2001:1C03:3403:C900:85D:643D:A6CF:9BA1-20180422213519/@comment-34797858-20180423040821

2001:1C03:3403:C900:85D:643D:A6CF:9BA1 wrote: Jallybwan wrote: 2001:1C03:3403:C900:85D:643D:A6CF:9BA1 wrote: Name: Maniac

Alingment: Neutral Killing

Summary: You are a Maniac that keeps refusing to die.

Attack: Powerful

Defense: Unstoppable(first 3 times attacked) '''Already seeing a large problem here. This is overpowered. Powerful defense is generally the upper limit. Also, NK's should have permanent defense, which usually means basic or bust.'''

Passive(s): You have a passive that allows you to survive the first time you get lynched you will appear as normal the second day and the Town will still be able to lynch you. In the night you can talk in the chat and everyone will see it your name will appear as Maniac and the messages will be in pure crimson. '''Huh? Free Guardian Angel? That's way overpowered. That's literally better-defended than Pestilence. No.'''

Ability: Attack someone each night if you fail to attack someone you will get a message saying "You failed to feed your never ending thirst for blood you have lost an unstoppable defense!" So it's like Juggernaut, almost, in that regard.

Attributes - Your Defenses do not regain back once you lost one it's gone forever '''Interesting attempt to balance, but as it stands this role is either overpowered or underpowered. Mostly overpowered, though.'''

- Investigative Results -

Investigator: Framer, Vampire, Jester, Hex Master or Maniac '''I guess? At least you didn't add it to the Sheriff's result...'''

Sheriff: Your target is a Maniac

Consigliere: Your target is out to kill everything in their path. They must be a Maniac

Goal: Kill anyone that would oppose you

I was gonna name it something else but then a cutie with the name G[Data Expunged]Maniac poped into my head and I had to name the role Maniac <3 Summary:

The role's defense is too powerful. Unstoppable defense like that would stop the Jailor from executing you, and the first-time immunity to lynching means this role has a passive Guardian Angel that's guaranteed to activate when it needs to. Also, it's a hybrid of Juggernaut and Serial Killer.

I would recommend at least changing the defense to Powerful. That way, at least the Jailor could do something. Unstoppable defense is reserved for Pestilence, which is supposed to be overpowered to begin with. I would if I could edit my posts oh well I reccomend making an account.