Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32994909-20180607203338/@comment-35026689-20180613131907

I WONT GIVE UP

Night 1

Player X is jailed. He is Arsonist He claimed BG in Jail

One player attempted to visit Player X. PM visited with Attact Potion

Player X received two regular notifications (the ones with white text and a red background, such as ‘You have died!’. Do not include ‘You did not perform your night ability.’)

Somebody attacked you last night but you were in Jail!

Somebody attacked you last night but your defence was too high!

The Coven Leader controlled the Jailor.

Day 2

The actual Spy said that one member of the Coven visited Player X.

Mayor reveals here

Night 2

The actual Tracker saw the Spy stay at home. Spy was trying to visit jailed target and failed

Someone died from poison. This is the BG

BG is pirated N2 as well so they didnt guard the Mayor that they should have

Player Y claimed Lookout and said that he saw the Jailor visit the revealed Mayor.

Cl controlled the Jailor to try and get a crusader to kill a townie

Y is the Lookout as they were watching the Mayor after they revealed

Night 3

The actual Tracker said that Player X visited the Jailor. The Jailor did not die.

X doused the Jailor arbitratily because all the tp is on the Mayor

Someone was killed by a Potion Master. this is the Spy. Potions are not used when failing like Vigilante shooting fail

Player Z claimed Lookout and said that he saw the actual Retributionist visit the revealed Mayor. This is the Cl as they should have seen Y N2 and the Jailor visit. Z should have been on them N2 and Z n3 controlled the Retri into the Mayor to attempt to get a crus kill on the retri. However, he didnt and knew there was no Crus, so Claimed lookout on the mayor. However, he should have seen more than the retri visit, possibly Y if they were on the mayor

The Investigator, who investigated both of them, is sure, but not certain, that one of the Lookoutclaims are evil.

Assuming the Investigator is correct...

> What notifications did Player X receive in jail?

Somebody attacked you last night but you were in Jail!

Somebody attacked you last night but your defence was too high!

> Suggest the roles of Player X, Player Y and Player Z, give full reasoning for your answer.

X cannot be a Member of the Coven, as no coven role has a reason to visit X N1. He has to have basic defence to get the high defence message, but should not be able to kill. He is either PB or Arsonist. Either way the messages fit. He doused the Jailor safely after they were revealed because all the TP is on the Mayor, if any at all. The Tracker saw X visit the Jailor, and thought that they were TP because he knew the Jailor and the Jailor didn't die.

Y is the Lookout, whom after seeing the Mayor reveal D2 then he was on the Mayor to find TP. unfortunately, the BG was poisoned N1 and Pirated N2. Y also saw the Jailor visit after the CL tried to kill the Jailor by making them visit the Mayor hoping a Crusader was on them. There wasn't as it was apparent nobody died to Crusader. If Z was an actual lookout, they should have been seen by Y as the Lookout should have been on the Mayor to confirm themselves.

Z is the Coven leader, as they were not on the Mayor N2 as they should have been to confirm themselves. They tried to control the Jailor N2 because their poisoner was in Jail and Z wanted to save them. Z did not visit the Mayor N2 and was on them N3, apparently seeing the Retributionist. He tried to control somebody so his lookout claim would be solidified by seeing the Retri on the Mayor, but he did not see Y or see the Jailor.

There IS a Vigilante, a Pirate, and an Executioner

The Mafia does NOT have a Hypnotist

Player Y and Player Z were never jailed.