Talk:Jailor/@comment-73.32.56.76-20160701151136/@comment-73.32.56.76-20160707035608

The Jailor's summary states that a Jailor is "a prison guard who secretly detains suspects". That's it. A Jailor can CHOOSE to be protective, but they are ultimately a Town Killing and it is ultimately their job to detain suspects, not protect a Mayor.

Either way, you said it yourself- Mayors are really overpowered IF the power is in the right hands. My Mayor threw three townies under the bus, one of which was the guy protecting him. Even if I HAD jailed him after he got me voted up, mafia now knew my and the Doctor's identities, so they'd just have to pick off the doc, myself, then the Mayor, meaning he'd inevitably get killed pretty quickly. I'd understand if you disagreed with a Jailor who didn't want to protect a good Mayor, but saying I'm "trying badly" because I didn't protect a Mayor who was not doing town any favors is just... ridiculous.

It should be mentioned that this Mayor didn't even write anything in his will (as in, no role claims, no suspects, no nothing) and never told me any of the role claims other than the doc, which meant his entire existence in the game only served to get other important townies killed. You really think I should have protected this guy despite the fact that he was an awful Mayor?