Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-40105855-20190727063426/@comment-31256456-20190816010726

LoneMafioso20 wrote: Role Name: Executive

Role Alignment: Mafia Deception

Abilities: Choose a player to change his role appearance and death reason that night, and prevent a Retributionist from reviving that player no matter if that player is really a Town member or not.
 * Before going on rampage about "No role swappers allowed" and "No chaos role allowed" rules, read this note first: Changing role appearance works like a current Disguiser but to prevent a chaos, a Retributionist cannot choose to revive that player at all. (No button present)

Attributes:

Attack: None

Defense: None

Unique role: Yes

Notifications: None

Goal: Kill anyone who will not submit to the Mafia

Win Conditions:

You win with.

You win with.

You must kill.

You must kill.

You must kill.

You must kill.

You must kill.

You must kill.

You must kill.

You must kill.

You must kill.

You may spare anyone else.

Investigation Results:


 * : Your target is suspicious!
 * : Your target is covered in blood. They could be, , , or Executive.
 * : Your target spreads a false information towards people in town. They must be Executive!

Special Attributes: ​​​​​​​Hello LoneMafioso20, I will be reviewing your role today. I am not particularly experienced and I am still working on my role reviewing. Today I will be using: Summarize, Suggest, Scale.
 * You can only cover player's role 3 times per game.
 * Exclusive to Coven Expansion
 * Mafia chat

Summarize: This role is meant to help change several aspects of the Town of Salem game by causing confusion in the Town.

Suggestions: Though the role appearance seems to be completely balanced, there's one major flaw in this role that prevents it from doing its job efficiently. The fact that Last Wills exist. Last Wills often contain the role or crucial information that makes it obvious what role the player is. This is why a Janitor wipes the whole will when his role is used. The only role that can work with this role effectively is Forger, as without Forger, the role becomes useless. Unfortunately, this takes up both slots of the Random Mafia, so Forger cannot find information. Other than this, the role is quite well done. To fix this problem, we need to:

1. Find a way to get rid of the Last Will dilemma without making it a better version of Janitor or changing the core concept completely

2. Find a way to get more synergy between the role.

I don't know how to do this, but I'm sure there are some other reviewers that could help you with this.

Scale: 6/10, meaning that this role is close to having its major flaws removed. Remember that this is not a meter of how good the role concept is or how good the role is, it's simply my measure of saying how close this is to being accepted by BMG. Keep on working around possible flaws and you'll get there :)