Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-44873601-20200201205200/@comment-32651233-20200210022114

Oh for christs sake. Does no one ever THINK before they post a role idea? Like, EVER?

This would not work for the following reasons:

- It gives Mafia an extra kill, which already makes this ridiculously broken especially in Ranked, putting Town at 7v6 on day 2 already. What if there's an SK? Town loses majority on day 2.

- There's no indication this is unique, so what if there are TWO of this role in Ranked? 3 mafia kpn? Did you seriously think this would be good?

- This can kill NK. Now, winning as NK is already pretty hard, now imagine the additional barrier of a MAFIA ROLE THAT CAN KILL THEM AT NIGHT.

Yeah, the problems are pretty apparent...