Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-26715110-20170331063629/@comment-26715110-20170331065754

Pokechurin wrote: This is RNG, and this is simply broken. Even the other ability is completely random, makes no sense. Sorry, but this is a role that's really too casual and wouldn't work. The transporter can transport important roles with mafias and stuff, but this, at best, would just confuse everyone, including the mafiosos, as their abilities are COMPLETELY different.

Exhibit A: Mafioso changes with Mayor, GF changes with lookout, you now have no killing mafia role

Okay so isn't  it clear you can't target  fellow mafia

Exhibit B: Lookout uses sk ability on someone else, and it would show "he was stabbbed by a serial killer" even though he's town

Okay so janitor messes information up, whats wrong with janitor, i don't get it (Im fine if you just want to tweak it so no murder roles)

Exhibit C: Two roles switch places, the next morning, one person dies, but no one knows who did who because your ability is completely random Okay i should add it so it adds a notification when you get swapped

0/10

rejected