Board Thread:Role Ideas (Rework)/@comment-37889585-20190128131535/@comment-37421692-20190130004408

Yeah retributionist not being able to rezz jailor would just cause them to bring back another powerful role, sometimes even more so than the jailor (e.g. Transporter or Mayor late game when town no longer has majority and everyone is confirmed can be really annoying for evils and those roles can steal their win easier than jailor can).

Doctor is not a role in need of a nerf. If anything, it needs a buff in order to compete with Bodyguard, or its literal direct upgrade, the crusader. Heck, even trapper is more powerful because it can kill an evil without having to worry about dying, and it can even kill more than one evil sometimes.

Second option is essentially useless, and it would just encourage jailors even more to claim day one, and the mafia generally WANTS a hidden jailor so that they can hope for the best and hit a jailor by random.