Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-35199255-20171024233817/@comment-33224790-20171024235507

SalemMurders wrote: Name: Physician Alignment: Mafia (Support)

Good with the Alignment Game Information/Background: A man who used to work as the doctor's rival, but got banned from practice after found using treatments to heal his patients deemed illegal by the Massachusetts Board of Medicine. His frustration towards the board led him to work for the Godfather. Attack: Basic (read all the way to understand) Defense: None

Unique Role: No

'''Okaaay. This now seems a little bit more Mafia Killing.''' Priority: 3 (same as doctor)

Ok! Abilities: Heal someone each night. You may choose to heal a non-mafia member. You may choose to heal yourself one time, giving basic defense.

'''Ok, this is a nerfed Doctor. For the Mafia.'''

Attributes: You will be promoted to mafioso if they are no kill capable roles left. If you choose to heal a non-mafia member, they will either get hit with a basic attack or actually get healed. (similar to vampire's bite or kill) You will know if your target is attacked.

'''Ok. Let me see how this works.'''

Mechanics: Similar to Vampire, 50% chance of killing the non-mafia member or healing them. You will have a 100% chance healing mafia. (obviously) You can choose to heal who the mafia attack, but it won't matter because unless you are a troll, you wouldn’t do that.

'''I believe this is RNG. This is not similar to the Vampire, because to decide who the Vampire kills and bites, it's dependant on their role.'''

-Investigative Results- Sheriff: Your target is a member of the mafia! Investigator: Your target could be a Doctor, Serial Killer, Disguiser, or Physician. Consigliere/Witch: Your target is an evil doctor, they must be a Physician!

Ok, so this is meant for classic I assume? Goal: Same as Mafia Wins With: Same as Mafia Must Kill: Same as Mafia

Good.

Anything Else: I am considering giving him limited heals. What do you guys think? Maybe takes a little power away from him. I also might consider making it so if you try to attack the mafia's target, it won't heal them, no matter what.

'''Yeah, the No Healing Mafia's Target sounds good. The heal already isn't enough to save from a WW though, so maybe not limited.''' Ok! These are the only problems I've picked out from the Making New Roles page. The text is copied directly from there.

Re-hash  -  Mafia / Neutral  versions of  Town  roles or vice-versa.

Mafia Protective - Any  Mafia  that is copy of any  Town  Protective  or protects  Mafia  in any way is most likely not going to work.

RNG Role  - Any role that depends on random chance.

Nurse  - A role that basically copies  Doctor  but works with  Mafia

Note the last thing is from the Specific Roles Not To Create page.

So, therefore, this role is REJECTED. Sorry, I don't know how to help, as the whole idea is just the Nurse idea.

Try your best, and don't give up!