Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-24.197.251.113-20171007234341/@comment-28112409-20171008011207

(Squirtle voice)

Another goddamn Blacksmith role? You do know that usually ends up being a supplier role and that's bad right? I mean, you're asking for a rejection over here, kinda suicide? Good role, you say? Alright alright, I trust you then...

(Reads the role, still in Squirtle voice, gives out a long sigh)

I TRUSTED YOOOOOOUUUUU!!!!!!

Joke aside, this is actually a supplier role and is weak as all hell and gamebreaking as all hell too. The first ability is useless, because a Doc can give powerful defense which is better than a vest, in just one night and the healed target doesn't have to waste a turn. The vest ability the Blacksmith has takes 1 night to craft and gives a vest, and using a vest wastes a night for the role too, they won't be able to use their night ability. Doc is better than this role

Giving people basic attack is bad, and horrible at that. Now you're giving the possiblity for all roles to kill, and that alters the role completely. Not to mention, the 3 nights wasted to make that... 3 nights is a lot for something that weak to a Townie and that harmful when given to a non-killing evil.

Don't make up Investigation results of your own, use the current investigation results and fit your role in.

Also, Town lacking roles? Town, the effing biggest faction in the game, is lacking roles?

Here's some statistics, Coven DLC included. Town has 19 roles in total, Mafia has 11 roles in total, Coven has 6, and the Neutrals have 14. Town has the most roles in the game, they're the last faction to ever "lack" roles. Town, if anything, has an OP Retribrokenist, Spy and a Transporter along with Mayor and Jailor in their setup, they don't need new roles when they have a bunch of OP ones. And even if they needed new roles, this role idea is not and never will be a candidate for being accepted because of one major flaw: Its a supplier role.

There's no fixing, nerfing, buffing or reworking that will fix this role. Scrap it completely, play the game a ton more, check the forums and the wiki a lot more, put more effort, you'll get a good role idea. Godspeed pilgirm.