Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-31680260-20170408232521/@comment-30154040-20170410193433

Jallybwan wrote: Duck, while I understand Role Dependency, the only role lists that don't involve Jailor are Vigilantics (which can't have Convict) and All Any (Pretty much any decent Custom game will have a Jailor as well). Maybe I could change it so that if there isn't a Jailor, there cannot be a Convict. Also, if Jailor dies then he becomes a Surv, so he can still win. '''Also, Executioner has a similar mechanic in which when his target dies at night he becomes a different role. HEY. SAYING IN GAME ROLES DON'T FOLLOW THE RULES DOES NOT MATTER. YOUR ROLE STILL HAS TO FOLLOW THE RULES.''' As for Hardcounters, I don't think it nerfs Jailor THAT heavily. It just means they have to be more careful when executing people. '''Even more carfeul than he already is? Also, I know Balance > Lore, but why would jailor lose their executes by executing a convict? '''Town also has the highest win rate of all factions and Jailor is the most powerful role IMO. Also, by that same logic, Jester can serve as a counter to Mayor. '''Please see the above note for what I think about this. '''Mayor's greatest power lies in having 3 votes, and Jesters are TRYING to get voted up.

I do appreciate the constructive criticism though :)

'''You're welcome, but I'm not an expert role-reviewer. FirePyre, Addfire, or SpicyBoiFelix could probably give you a better review.'''