Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20181230235210/@comment-33307613-20190123151315

Vertroyer wrote: TheOnlyFoxCat wrote: NapstablookInfinity wrote: im going to keep stalking vert until he gives a legitimate response to this:

Forger > Disguiser forger is waaaay better than disg tbh Nah Both of the roles are completely horrible, but the Disguiser is much better than the Forger. The Forger's goal is to (typically) forge a Town Investigatives will and accuse a non-Mafia of being evil. There are many problems with this; (1) You are completely hard-countered by the Spy. Double visit on the kill target? Forged. (2) You are completely hard-countered by Mediums and Retributionists. At least you get one day to try to trick the Town before having your plans foiled. (3) What if there are only two Town Investigatives and they die early? You're basically useless at that point. Who cares if the Town Protective had their visits changed? (4) Town Investigatives should be posting their wills. Which means you can't change the information anymore. Additionally, why would a Sheriff be silent about a "suspicious" finding? Always reveal immediately. (5) Janitor is better than you. "It can remove the will if you can't forge properly". The Janitor can remove the will and the role.