Board Thread:Role Ideas (Coven)/@comment-35026689-20180422105908/@comment-35356104-20180422142049

I'm sorry to reply you in a shorter way. I just wrote a review and it disappeared upon pressing "Reply" button. Still, I'm gonna write you a feedback in point form.


 * 1) are all Unique, I suggest you to follow the pattern.
 * 2) Attack on non full moon night? Cool! I think this is meant to avoid and also to balance the killing power, equivalent to
 * 3) I assume the dead-person-who-appeared-to-be-alive(I rename it puppet) can be voted on stand and target at night. (Q was leeched by Extortionist on N1, Q appeared alive on D2, Q can be target on N2) Otherwise, it just exposed presence of Extortionist. I'm not sure if this is balance, I have not deal such mechanic in any Mafia Game. Main attraction of the role, yet the most controversial part.
 * 4) This role MAYBE OP after receiving . Roleblock upon killing not only affect but all role that can visit and this role can kill everyday. This may not reach the OP standard in your mind, but you can't deny that this definitely crossed the line of balance.
 * 5) This role outshined despite sharing similarity in term of killing power especially after having . Some ability can apply to 's buff: Roleblock the target the next night after being poisoned.

I'm not going to label this anything yet as some parts are very perceptive. This role is well thought-through. Nice attempt, thanks for sharing idea here! If you have question or you're not agree with me, I wouldn't mind to explain in detail.