Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-2001:1C03:3403:C900:98DA:3DBE:C44A:CC9D-20180911222815/@comment-36558623-20180912061454

Before I review this role, let me advise you to create a accound for this wiki, thank you!

2001:1C03:3403:C900:98DA:3DBE:C44A:CC9D wrote: Alingment: Neutral(Benign)

Unique: Yes

Summary: You are a beautiful young lady with a beautiful voice.

Defense: None

Attack: None

Ability: Sing at your own house, you can only sing once.

Attributes: When you are singing and a role visits you at the same night you will be converted to the faction the role is in.

If the role that visited you had any negative effects then they will be negated.

If the role that visits you is Neutral then nothing will happen.

If several roles visit you at once then the one with highest priority will be able to get your faction changed.

- Investigative Results -

Investigator: Bodyguard, Godfather, Arsonist, Crusader or Singer

"your target is not afraid to get their hands dirty" - doesn't really fit

"your target is skilled in distracting others" - this fits better, escort/consort/transporter, besides there are two town in that result already

Sheriff: Your target is not suspicious

Consigliere/Witch: Your target is feeling lonely and wants to join someone. They must be a Singer

Goal: Find someone to join.

the different kinds of singers:

Mafia Singer:

Alingment: Mafia(Support)

Attack: None

Defense: None

Ability: Sing a song to 2 mafia members, this will inspire the first person you picked to imitate the abilities of the second mafia member. Example: If you pick a Framer first then a Consigliere then the Framer will be able to investigate someone that night (3 time use only)

Attributes: this will NOT work on killing roles except for the Ambusher.

-Investigative Results-

Investigator: Investigator: Bodyguard, Godfather, Arsonist, Crusader or Singer

Sheriff: Your target is a member of the Mafia.

Consigliere: Your target inspires the Mafia to do a better job. They must be a Singer

Goal: (regular mafia goal)

Townie Singer

Alingment: Town(Support)

Attack: None

Defense: None

Ability: Sing in the middle of the night making Evil roles visit you. (1 time use only)

Attributes: When all evil roles visit you the rampage effect will not take place/a lookout won't be able to view who visits you and you will gain basic defense for that night.

Investigative Results

Investigator: Bodyguard, Godfather, Arsonist, Crusader or Singer

Sheriff: Your target is not suspicious

Consigliere: Your target distracts those with an unpure heart. They must be a Singer.

Coven Singer

Alingment: Coven(Evil)

Attack: None(Basic with necronomicon)

Defense: None

Ability: Scream towards anyone that visits a coven member(1 time use only)

Attributes: Poeple who were screamed at become unable to read the chat and their words will become scrambled for 3 days, Their wills will become scrambled too.

this is way too op, especially compared to the mafia-singer and town-singer

Necronomicon: With the Necronomicon you can visit poeple and scream at them directly, they will die of a basic attack if they manage to live however they will still get the effects that are listed in the attributes.

-Investigative Results-

Investigator: Bodyguard, Godfather, Arsonist, Crusader or Singer

Sheriff: Your target is a part of the coven. With the Necronomicon: Your target is not suspicious.

Consigliere: Your target can produce unhumanly high pitched screams. They must be a Singer.

Vampire Singer

In the case that the Singer gets visited by a vampire, they will just be converted into a vampire and not get any special abilities Excellent role, the best I have seen on the wiki so far. Really well done, polished idea. I still have my issues however.

1.) Having five mafia in a game would be almost unstoppable, 5 v 1 v 9? on average 3 nights is when they'd lose majority

2.) You only get one chance to sing? If no one visits you, the player just sits around and does nothing for the whole game. That's very boring.

3.) Looking at priority, 2 town roles, then a mafia and coven, then 3 town roles, then 4 mafia. Seems pretty fair for town v mafia, but coven get's screwed by this. It seems like the town or mafia would just always get singer compared to the other two.

4.) A one time op ability is not fun or balanced, look at ret for an example. The town-singer is this. It blocks all attacks for one night.

​​​​​​​​​I sincerely reccomend you create more roles, because this one was ​​fantastic. Great role, and with some polishing it's flaws could be erased.