Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-39990017-20190922020922/@comment-34797996-20190922160208

There are a few glaring issues with this:

1. This is a rehash of the Mayor (see the Role Guidelines post)

2. This is very, very UP. A mafia slot gets wasted for what? An extra vote?

3. Instantly confirms you as a member of the mafia. Sure, you cannot be lynched that day or killed the night after, but now that everyone knows you're evil, they'll lynch you the next day afterwards.

4. You can only whisper? That creates suspicion from d2 if you aren't talking in chat but you are still whispering.

There isn't really a world in which this would work. Sorry for being harsh, I just need to get my point across.