Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-33601385-20180609054252/@comment-35420390-20180609095813

SCl007 wrote: Name: Carpenter cool name

Alignment: Town protective Attack: None

Defense: None

Unique Role: no

Priority: 3

Abilities: reinforce someone's house each night or upgrade the previous reinforcement okay, maybe too OP but lets see

Attributes: your reinforcement will automatically fall apart after a day unmaintained okay

Mechanics: reinforcing a home gives your target basic defense you can choose to upgrade it the next night to powerful then invincible. '''this is quite OP since you can make anyone survive any attack, so this will just strengthen the Meta and make revealed  / a confirmed  bloody strong. And since it takes some time for the reinforcement to fall apart they will have 3 night were they wont be attacked.'''

An unmaintained house will degrade after one day you cannot visit a person if you have made their reinforcement invincible. So if you have made someones defence invincible, they will automaticly have their house degraded the next night

attacks will damage the reinforcement basic will make invincible powerful and remove basic and downgrade powerful to basic. so a powerful attack will downgrade a powerful defence to none and so on?

an arsonist can bypass the defense of a full reinforced house '''what, why? I can see one reason why (its because of logic right?) but he shouldn't be able to''' -Investigative Results-

Sheriff: Your target is not suspicious

Investigator: Doctor, Disguiser, Serial Killer, Potion Master, or Carpenter 2-1-1-1, thats good

Consigliere/Witch: Your target is a builder who protects people '''Your target is a Builder who Builder defences on peoples house to make them survive attacks. They must be an Carpenter.'''

Goal: town

Wins With: town wins with

Must Kill: town must kill

This role is way to OP. Giving confirmed people a invincible defence sounds way to strong. And what if there is more than one of him? This would make way to likely to win. He can basicly just deal out defence.

And what happens to people who have a defence? and if there are multiple Carpenters, can the make someone go from none to powerful defence in one night? And will a attack downgrade a defence twise if the defence was downgraded that night? And may a bypass since the target isn't home? And what about rampaging attacks, will they kill the traget if the target visits?

Overall score: maybe with changes / 10