Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-33641934-20171128005220/@comment-32942597-20171128022954

190.99.18.203 wrote: Kidflersh wrote: FIRST OF ALL DON'T PUT IN CARD GAME, THIS IS NOT KID-FRIENDLY BY MOST PEOPLES'S STANDARDS

Name: Reluctant Suicidal (name needs work) (name color is magenta or indigo, or something else. It doesn't really matter)

Alignment: Neutral Benign (Maybe Neutral Evil?) neutral evil

Summary: A trainwreck who wants to end his life, but is too reluctant, and rather wishes to be killed by someone else, not publicly.

Attack: None*

Defense: None

Unique Role

Priority: 6 it should be 5

Abilities: Trick Killing Roles into killing you in the night.

Attributes: Control Immunity why, Disguise Immunity why ' ' , Detection Immunity, and Roleblock Resistance why.  Kill whoever kills you in the night the night after.

Mechanics: The Reluctant Suicidal can only win by being killed in the night, and lynching or leaving the game way to easy to win(suicide) does not fufill this. The day after the Reluctant Suicidal is killed, a message will say "The Reluctant Suicidal will get his revenge on the [role of killer] !", in a similar way to the Jester's revenge message jester reaharsh. The message does not include a Witch if a Witch controlled the killer. The Killer of the Reluctant Suicidal will instead receive the message "The Reluctant Suicidal will get his revenge on you!" I don't understand The Reluctant Suicidal has no decision in who he kills, and he kills his Killer, and if Witch controlled the Killer, he still will only kill the Killer.

-Investigative Results-

Sheriff: Your target is Not Suspicious

Investigator: Your target could be a Framer, Vampire, Jester, Reluctant Suicidal, or Hex Master

Consigliere/Witch: Your target wants someone to end there life, privately, because they are too reluctant to do it themselves. They must be a Reluctant Suicidal.

Goal: Get yourself killed in the night, by any means.

Wins With : Town, Mafia, Arsonist, Serial Killer, Survior, Vampire, Werewolf, Witch/Coven, Guardian Angel, Juggernaut, Pirate, Plaguebearer/Pestilence

Must Kill: N/A

pls giv fadbek this is a jester reaharsh and way to easy to win i don't think this should be added I think this warrants a Parallax quote:

'Anyone who thinks rehashes are instantly bad are what we call 'retarded'.'

Maybe that was a little extreme, but that statement gives, quite literally, nothing helpful. If you can't explain why the Pirate is bad (and therefore a rehash wouldn't be good), then you don't have a point. Rehashes of good roles can be balanced. Originality might be a good trait for a role to have, but it is a very small argument when we talk about balance. (Yes, I took it from Arc)