Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-31881924-20170501012741/@comment-32487879-20170518193001

DrakeTheRake wrote: Alright, this is my first attempt at a role, tell me why it's bad. Thanks
 * It will be bad. Trust me. Also, I'm gonna take out every single rule from Making New Roles and just think about it from its own...

Abilites: Deal alcohol to your targets to disrupt their senses and perception for one day and night. Attributes: Dealing alcohol to someone will disrupt someone's abilities depending on their role, and also remove the selected persons' ability to vote the following day. You may only serve 3 flasks.
 * Oh god.
 * So the role will basically be roleblocked, and their voting ability will be taken away?

Goal: Kill anyone who will not submit to the mafia.
 * Gee, this is Consort/Blackmailer but on a whole new level

Those that have Intoxication Immunity: All neutral roles ,MD,Godfather,Blackmailer, and Consort(in case of being controlled by a witch) and TS, Spy, Jailor, and Doctor.
 * WHY DO YOU DISCRIMINATE AGAINST CONSIGLIERE

If Investigated by Inv(sober): "Tippler, Escort, Consort, or Transporter. Your target is skilled at disrupting others." Anybody investigated by Inv(drunk)- Framer, Vampire, or switch. Your target is not what they seem." Investigated by Sheriff(sober): "Your target is a member of the mafia!"
 * Also, that's way too many roles. Kinda pointless at that point.
 * imean... hmm
 * OR SWITCH? WHAT?

Investigated by Sheriff(drunk): "Your target is not suspicious."

Investigated by Consigliere(sober): "Your target deals alcohol to other citizens. They must be the Tippler.

Investigated by Consigliere(drunk): "Your target is difficult to identify. They must be the Disguiser.

When morning comes: You've drank large amounts of alcohol. You are intoxicated!

Town killing roles besides the Jailor and the BodyGuard will miss attacks the night they are intoxicated,as will Mafioso. Investigating roles with obviously get the wrong results, and nobody intoxicated will be able to vote. I put this as Mafia Support because at morning, you will be told you're intoxicated, similarly to blackmailer. Tell me what you think. There is no way they can figure out how to implement to "those specific roles". And, Consigliere racism.

It seems too much complications.


 * rejected