Board Thread:Role Ideas (Rework)/@comment-38127112-20190314223611/@comment-28092296-20190317003805

Your Framer buff I think just adds more complexity to the Framer. I think swapping results with people is great, however I think due to the nature of the ToS community and the game mechanics, a more consistant role where you had more control over what you specifically did would be better. I like the idea of knowing if your Frame went through, although, I don't think there's a single mechanic that would stop your frame from working without giving you a message like a roleblocked message or so.

I like your Forger buff. It really makes people consider their Forges carefully, and removes the need for a Consig/Forger combo. However, I hope that your role doesn't cause the Mafia to be too overpowered. I.e. you have your Godfather claim Sheriff or something and then the Mafia attacks the guy the Sheriff called guilty, so the GF is 'confirmed Sheriff'.

There's not much of a point to your Disguiser/Mayor change, as it's really just countered by people being aware of the 'Mayors' activity and I feel like it would be too counterable, kinda like the Vampire/Mayor issue RN. Also, "but the person cant control what one of them say". I dunno what that means.

I also like your Consigliere buff. I would only recommend some kind of archive feature instead, like a button next to the report players and leave game buttons so everybody can use it and to avoid confusing new players as to what their target's role actually was and what the Consigliere does.

Not sure what to think about your Janitor buff. Maybe if your cleans blocked the Medium's daytime ability, that would be cool.

You have interesting ideas, however, I do not think Mafia in general needs a buff. Good job, though.