Board Thread:Role Ideas (Rework)/@comment-35420390-20180812210605/@comment-31919347-20180813113156

BendBones wrote:

Give a Ace. Make him not so easy to foul. My idea for this is give him a one time use faction check. This will ignore detection immunity and frames and so on and tell you if your target is "good" or "evil" (,  or ).

It is a nice buff idea for the Sheriff, but I don't think Sheriff is weak tbh. It is one of the more powerful roles in Town of Salem. And about the Ace, how could you use it? Btw, don't get me wrong, it's an amazing idea, but I think the Sheriff would be too powerful if he could do this.



Once a wants to resurrect someone they will choose themself. The next day the following message appears for the evils: "A strong magical force is trying to bring back a . You have to stop this!" and if the evils don't stop this (by role blocking them to reset the process) or kill them the will be resurrected.

Tbh, this is the best Retri idea I've seen in a while. Ppl talk about 'Let the retri die when he revives someone' but that is way to boring. And why remove it? This is much better! Just a question: Will the evils be told who the Retributionist is?



A priority list and a powerful attack. My suggestion for a list:, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , (a buff), ,.

This seems a good plan on the first sight. One of my ideas also. But seriously, why the PB nerf? Also, Arso doesn't get attacked by Crusaders right? I would put Jugg on first place, SK 2nd, CL, GF and than WW and PB in any order. WW and PB don't need a nerf atm. And maybe swap Escort and Consort just to give mafia the upperhead in a rare situation, so Consort wouldn't be revealed yet.



You will know if any other member failed their ability, but not the reason: "The * role* failed their job!".

I assume you fail your job when you:

- Visit the jailed person.

- You don't do anything.

- You are jailed.

- You are roleblocked.

Seems good overall.



You will also bug your target, like the. This way you know if your target was investigated or not.

Sounds good tbh. But most Framer buffs are well. But I think this is better!



You will get the investigation result for your target.

I agree, Disguiser needs a buff. But I think this is gonna be a bit like Consigliere. Because Disguiser could figure out the whole result of the person. What if you would get bigger results? For example: Your target is Lookout, Forger, Coven Leader, Spy, Blackmailer, Jailor or Guardian Angel! Like 2 results at once. (And also a 3 because there is an odd number of results, right?)

Overall, I think it are great changes! I think the Retributionist buff is the best, but we shouldn't forget the Crusader and Framer buff!

I also like the Mafioso buff, but I don't think it will be added because there's already another mafioso change in the TG.

The Disguiser buff needs a change I think, because you can obviously erase most mafias out of the result if there isn't a CL/Witch/Trans. And if the NK is revealed in a ranked practice/ranked/custom list... I think you get what I mean. I don't like this buff very much.

The Sheriff buff... Nah. Sorry, but I think it will give Sheriff OP powers, even when it is just 1 time. The Framer got a hard time already. This nerfs Framer also in an indirect way.

Hope you can use this review!