Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-34287581-20180110165701/@comment-33877233-20180111030845

INeverLye wrote: Well
 * SpaceDefenderX:

Seems a lot like a counter

A bit too OP, makes janitors and Medusa useless

   You should make the investigating limited, like once or twice 17:04 November 4, 2017 WellSeems a lot like a counter
 * TheRetroPioneer: SpacedefenderX wrote:

A bit too OP, makes janitors and Medusa useless

   You should make the investigating limited, like once or twice

-- What if I removed the ability to investigate Cleaned and Stoned targets, and maybe have, like, 3 or 4 records at max? 17:40, November 4, 2017 It seems that the Officer should stay known as a TI role, since it is based more off results from visting(dead bodies). I believe the Officer should have a limit to 3 records max, because if there's a Janitor, you counter it your results, but if a Medusa, there's most likely no way you can get records on ALL the stoned. The claim of making Janitor useless is the one that should be most concerning but if anything, the cleans makes it so it delays the information that the town would have otherwise.
 * iNeverLye:

   Keeping it a unique role is a must, so sadly Amnesiac can't remember Officer. The                 thing I think I like about it the most is, the fact that a Janitor could fake claim Officer,               it's not impossible.

Its a Hardcounter for Janitor and Medusa
 * Bambino86:

With the fact that it's unlimited use as well completely destroys the roles

Its a Hardcounter for Janitor and Medusa With the fact that it's unlimited use as well completely destroys the roles
 * iNeverLye:  Bambino86 wrote:

-- Bambino, as I stated before, If it was limited to 3 it's a perfect balance. It doesn't make Janitor useless because he can still clean and delay information that would be revealed to the town otherwise. The Officer just recovers the information, a bit like the Medium. It doesn't effect Medusa too much because they most likely stone more than 3 people in a long game. He also counters a Forger, as stated in the abilites. Vampire Hunter is a hard counter to Vampire also, and it doesn't make it heavily town sided to a way that Vampires can't win.

this is really confusing