Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-32651233-20180605022148/@comment-35356104-20180607033745

Whatta hot debate above.

I would say, Inspector, Sher & Inves are in their own league, I rather not to compare any of them. I can hardly get any sense of measurement when the investigative directions are different. This role is an archetypal TI, clicking only a button & get a result every night, scum-reading, etc. No fault in terms of mechanic, but it's just a matter of "necessary" and "unnecessary".

It's totally fine to brush off the labels like OP or UP for now. We don't know if this role is OP or simply strong without clear evidence. All da points above are only debating on certain state of affair. Instead of popping random points and argument out of the thin air, you may write a simple passage on "why this role is necessary" or "how impactful is this role to the game" to actually pinpoint the path of discussion leading to it a desirable way & getting feedbacks you're looking for. We can also understand your role better that way.

For me, after reading your role card, I grasp no core idea of this role. Only some casual thoughts floating around in mah head. Perhaps you can do a small presentation? In any form you like, as long as the readers are able to understand the point & purpose of this role. It's okay not to do it if you're satisfied with the feedbacks.

It's only a tip if you want some useful feedback. Cycle continues in Official Forum. Here, if you're ready.