Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-38165883-20190817212249/@comment-30757827-20190830043309

exCUSE ME THAT FORMAT IS COPYRIGHTED AND I WILL BE CALLING MY LAWYERS NOW, YOU WILL NOT LIVE TO SEE YOUR CHILDREN TAKE THEIR FIRST STE- (Anyone can use that format as long as they dont have verdict :)

Originality: PMer but NE and with different, weird abilities. Being solo and having these weird abilities adds interesting strategies. However, mouth is a blatant copy of BMer. If it was a town ability that you adapted into an evil ability like with consort and escort, it would be fine, but not only are both of these roles evil, but they can win together, unlike SK and GF.

Enjoyment: Similar to BMer, losing the one ability everyone has isn't very fun. As stated by Retro, you could just add your name at the end of everything if someone claims blinded, which isn't very fun to do, and is nothing but a time waster, so claiming this to be an interesting meta is completely absurd. Ears is ok, i guess, enjoyment wise. Now for playing as this role instead of against it: Basically BMer. Taking away abilities from people. Making them unable to give information, making them very confused at who's suspicious with blinding, other things, not fun for the other person, but could potentially be fun for you.

Balance: Let's go through every ability, as the abilities make up the balance of the role. Eyes: Bashing on this even more, the "meta" would ruin this, completely nullifying the ability and making it nothing but a night wasted for Surgeon, and time wasted for the people forced to put their name at the end of everything they say. Ears: This is extremely underpowered. The only point of seeing whispers is to make it look suspicious if you do that, so if you're accused of being mafia, probably don't whisper information to your pals who are also quite suspicious, as it makes both of you look suspicious. However, the entire town other than the one affected by surgeon sees this, and they can just tell the person affected if it really comes down to it. As for mouth, i mean, they made an entire role based on it, BMer. Sure it's balanced, but, again, stolen.

Simplicity: About as simple as PMer, the abilities are a little more complex, but not so much that it would be too confusing for new players.

'''Verdict: Revamp. '''Love the concept of an NE pmer that causes chaos, but a lot of the abilities are underpowered and easily countered. Keep the concept, but redesign the abilities, i do have an idea for eyes, what if it swapped names instead of removing them, and didn't alert you that you had a surgery on your eyes? Just a thought. Do what you will.