Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-34955620-20180605012610/@comment-35356104-20180610052740

NC role has the excuse for having some nonsensical ability or attribute to break the norm or regular pattern of playstyle. NC can be any kind of thing as long as it is fun-to-play and well-receive by the community. NC is designed for roles that serve no actual purpose but soley for chaotic fun. All da comments above already indicated "something". Do you know because of the one hateful trait of Vamp where it robs win from Town, people are asking for Vamp removal? And I see the same thing happen on this role again. How is robbing win fair? At least Vamp fights for its faction, and this role does nothing but leeching.

This role contributes nothing to aid Mafia win and adversely affect their routine. What can Mastermind do throughout the game? Vote to kill, interupting coordination, causing civil strife, encourage gamethrowing and basically does what Mafioso is capable of but with a huge chunk of unwanted add-on. With Jailor META & VFR, Mafia's winrate is close to extinction. Adding the existence of this role, Mafia's winrate can just be banish beyond void. "If this role dies mafia wont be anonymous and they can no longer attack anyone" - quoted from the original role card. If this role dies, Mafia is screwed. If this role lives, Mafia can't win. In short, Mafia can leave game D1 if they can't see members' role & name.

Please use proper format everytime you post a role idea and bewary of your tone. You can't blame us for treating your idea as a joke when you present your idea just like one of them. I'm sorry to know that you see us "rude", but I see all the Wikians are keeping toxicity at minimal level, all of them have better patience than me. You can just post it at Forum right away, we always refers valid role idea to Official Forum anyway. We have no point of keeping role idea here. We can't implement it or do anything about it. All we can do is giving feedback. Where you post it doesn't affect us a slightest. If you think your role idea still have chance to work then just go for it. We aren't stopping you, but we also encourage you to do so.