Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-33601385-20180503224909/@comment-34797858-20180514141238

MewSeeko wrote: SCl007 wrote: ok let me go through each _________________________________Mafia________________________________________________

Disguiser: it changes so it depends on the disguised role 7/10 Bruh how hard is it to get a good role and will set up, and you mostly don't know the target's role, so wtf is that 7 doing here it should be just 5.5 or something

Forger: Lo not great but not awful 5/10 '''3 forges, it's hard if you don't know the target's role, otherwise it's mostly uesless. i do agree with the 5 tho. '''

Framer: can claimed to be hexed or framed but not the best 4/10 '''Not the best? It's the worst! (I agree with this.)'''

Hypnotist: Almost anything 9/10 '''I actually wanna point out that as Hypnotist, you can pretty much only claim doctor or transporter, and the transporter is sus because you can only "trans" one person a night, not including you. As Escort, you can be called out when maybe a TI role is there and they still get their results. I would agree with the 8.9-9 for Hypnotist. '''

Janitor: trapper or medium are ok claims 6/10 '''Agreed. '''

Ambusher: vigi and vet vigi is more difficult to claim than vet 6/10 '''Amby is..worse than a 6, sorry. If Janitor is a 6, then ambusher should be 4. I think you're messing the standards up, just saying. Janitor just as good as Ambusher? I wholeheartedly disagree. (They have the same results as mafioso, should be the same.)'''

Godfather: Bg and crus not great but worst case scenario an claim to be doused 6.5/10 '''Uhhh....okay.. but you can pull off many other claims too, you're overestimating and underestimating soem roles, and this is such a bad comment on this, just....fml this doesn't make aaaaany sense. (I agree, with the GF and Framer, you can claimed framed/doused and have infinite claimspace.)'''

Mafioso: Same as ambusher 6/10 '''Bruh mafioso is better than ambusher.... (They have the same results.)'''

Blackmailer: Spy is fairly safe and since the but doesn't see useful info 9/10 time decent 7/10

Consigliere: Invest or tracker work invest is much better though 8/10 '''The reasons why you're saying all of this, are just.......no. It doesn't make any sense. (A consig and a inves are nearly identical, but I do agree his reasons are bad.)'''

Consort: Escort 8/10

____________________________________Coven____________________________________________________

Coven leader: Same as forger 5/10 'WHAAAT!? The Coven Leader does not FORGE roles you idiot have you even played the role?! It's basically an attacking controlling witch, being able to see the target's role, and NOT their will, idiot. They  can work with the Medusa as well. (But they have the same results, also a CL claimng LO when their targets are visited by whoever is witched is hella susp.)'

Hex Master: Same as framer 4/10 IT IS NOT OQAUUUUUUUUUUUUUUGHGHGHGHGHQIEUFDNFIUBDSVNOIBUDSVJCOUA EFN YOU RUIN ME (Same results, I don't see why not.)

Medusa: like janitor but slightly worse due to not receiving the stoned persons role and will 5/10 '''This is the only reasonable thing on here. Except your standards are again, messed up. (The result for medusa and janitor are different.)'''

Necromancer: same as Janitor 6/10 IT'S NOT THE SAME AS JANITOR YOU'RE NOT EVEN GIVING ANY REASONS WHY IT SHOULD BE THE SAME RESULTS AS THIS FMLLLLLLLLLLLLL (They have the same inves result, I think he was basing it off of that.)

Poisoner: Only good role is sheriff witch evils often claim as 4/10 WHY DO YOU SAY ONLY GOOD ROLE PEOPLE ARE SMART AND WE CAN PULL OFF A LOT (They are, so we have to talk mechanically.)

Potion master: only good role is doc 4.5/10 'THATS NOT THE ONLY GOOD THING FML THEY CAN ATTACK AND ACT AS A CONSIGLIERE TOO YA KNOW SERIOUSLY?! POTION MASTER IS  (Potion master has the worst inves result I have ever seen besides poisoner inves results.)'

mafia overall:

72.5/110 or about 66%

coven overall:

28.5/60 or 47.5%

Mafia wins YOUR RESULTS ARE ABSOLUTE CRAP DUDE SERIOUSLY

BIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAASSSSS

YOU BASE THIS OFF OF WHAT THIS IS SO BAD  ​​​​​​​(I agree, SCI did very bad to prove his point.)