Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-30757827-20190322205511/@comment-38127112-20190330014040

RedDeathNick wrote: You aren't just guessing who the evils are, you can detect them with sheriff, or, like you said, counter claiming. Cultist leader doesn't have any town abilities or a way to confirm and then get converted like the cultists. You can be caught. You don't have to find the cultist leader the first night, you don't convert the entire town the second night, there's a high probability that they WON'T convert you the next night, actually there's a 0% chance that they will because if you didn't notice, there's a cooldown now still f*cks hard working townies up for contributing to their team that they’re supposed to contribute to, and the night after still has a low chance to get converted. All of what you have said is ignoring the fact that THE CULT LEADER CAN BE CAUGHT lets say I made a werewolf rehash but with no cooldown, “it isnt OP because it can be caught”, AND THEY DON'T INSTANTLY WIN NIGHT TWO ”this werewolf rehash doesnt instantly win night two”. And sure, maybe the sheriff doesn't find the cult leader and then gets converted the next night, but if you hadn't noticed, town of salem has a LOT of luck like that yeah it does, but with a role like psychic you don’t even choose who your targets are, making them RNG, with a role like serial killer they attack by choice, imagine if there was a role like serial killer who attacked random, unchoosable targets, would that be any fun whatsoever?, like the jailor getting killed N1 and the sheriff N2. RNG isn't neccesary at all! RNG is heavily discouraged because at least when you’re picking you use some strategywith your logic, serial killer is a binary role because either you kill the sheriff, jailor, investigator, or you kill the escort that posted who they visited in their will. Thats just the game, you cant avoid that, but it was still your choice to attack your target, doesn’t say anything good about RNG The truth is, we don’t need another conversion role, this kinda just screws up town in all any mode with the possibility of two converters