Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20171025060017/@comment-30105631-20171025100622

Charliep2 wrote:

FirePyre wrote: Team BG by far. As Prof Arceus said, this weeks debate is weak af.

Bodyguard is better overall. It can protect revealed mayor, so that's a plus. Yes it dies upon successfully protecting something, but it kills the attacker, The doctor will stay alive, helping majority in lynching  it has lynching ability? That's your argument? That's such a weak ability compared to the huge power of killing an evil, and lynching isn't infallible  and most doctors won't even be able to protect more than two people in a game, Well later both early and late game, doctors can provide value in a single game, which bg relies on retri or doc to do  it can, in instances, but most times it isn't useful at all, and this is assuming the doc isn't killed early or mid game which is possible  which is not much considering they don't kill the attacker. '''Neither do the doctors die, may lead to majority and by the time you figure out a killer is attacking someone, you'll probably find out the killer to lynch them. ''' Yeah, by the time you find out a killer attacking someone you'll be late game. The BG could've killed em n1. This argument doesn't mean anything because the BG is still just as useful regardless  Both can protect themselves, only BG will kill attacker, but doctor always survives already explained why BG's ability is more powerful anyway   I mean honestly, BG is better than Doc in every way. Yea not all ways '''Love? charlie'''