Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-35455734-20180506152315/@comment-35356104-20180510024010

RainyPlace wrote: GamesManiac wrote: RainyPlace wrote: GamesManiac wrote: I never expect the basic defense you meant is permenant. Even though you didn't answer my question, I hope this role can't protect a Mayor and this is a Unique role. Combining with self-confirmed role like Jailor and Mayor, this role is OP.

Insomniac is immune before giving someone basic defense. They can still talk to defend themselves if they're out to be immune right? It's true that if evil wouldn't hit immune target twice. Insomniac can reveal the next day and simply give up their self-defense to start giving basic defense. They could have tell everyone about their target beforehand and ask Vigilante to shoot their target for confirmation. Once they are muted for protecting someone and for worse being lynched because they're not be able to defense themselves, they can just write those targets they had given basic defense in their Last Will. Anyone immune besides those listed in Insomniac's Last Will are evils for sure. Sheriff and Investigator can also check those immune as all NK except Arsonist don't have detection immunity.

The "fault" you mentioned is only the matters of strategy. Oh no, you misunderstand me. Once you give up your defense, you don't get it back.The Insomniac also cannot protect the Mayor. I don't think I misunderstood anything. Mind to explain which part I said makes you think I misunderstood that? You misunderstood that this role's downside is requiring strategy. Which Arc already mentioned.​​​​​​​ I don't understand even more. I was asking which part I mentioned makes you think that "I misunderstand Insomniac doesn't get the their defense back after giving up defense". I thought Arcy meant to say:"Strategy is the best way to balance a role". The downside is not consider a downside when it can be fixed by playstyle. A fixable fault by any mean of strategy shouldn't be accounted as downside that balance a powerful ability.

If I misunderstand anything again, just assume that I'm a stupid here and apologize for the mess. LOL I also think my english is at fault here. I swear I won't sleep during my english lesson anymore.