Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-26234016-20161024115545/@comment-30300013-20161027012518

Addfire wrote: My stuff about lynching has been talked of... Again... And again... And again...

About the jailor... I originally thought that an execution would count as being killed by a townie and therefore the Reckoner is against town. And your point is valid...

But I think that if the Reckoner automatically loses when executed, then that makes him too underpowered? He might be able to play the sympathy card to escape, but the Reckoner couldn't hurt him too much, realistically...

...

Can the Reckoner even affect people that much?

I just realized how weak the Reckoner is...

=c In the game Town of Salem, the other NE roles such as Executioner, Jester, and maybe the Reckoner would all be (and are all) impacted very negatively by the Jailor. However, the addition of Reckoner would upgrade both Jester and itself, as they could use each other's death abilities to scare townies. But as you said, it's goal is to get the team that killed it to lose. Maybe it should be able to kill someone..? I don't know. This role seems fun to play as, but needs some sort of buffing.