Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-26959384-20161108152544/@comment-25876622-20161108220909

Some thoughts on the smaller points:
 * Rather than "Godmother", how about "Fairy Queen"? You can abbreviate it to FaQ, which is funny.
 * Converting Vigilante and preventing suicide seems alright! Some people just forget about them or find a more important target the next night. It's balanced enough. Whether the Vigi is a Town or a Fairy doesn't give them more information, especially considering the realistic members (see below). They may also be lynched or executed anyway.
 * I'm not sure about the Amnesiac. I'd just say yes, they will become a Fairy - the point of Amnesiacs are to unbalance the factions, so let them do that.
 * Jailor: I'm not sure if they should be immune. Let's think about that later.
 * Here's a silly idea: Allow Mediums to hear Fairy night chat. (I didn't think too much about it.) It would give the Medium a nice buff while also weakening Fairy lategame.

For the following, I am assuming the Fairies start with only the main fairy.

I completely neglected to think about which roles can realistically be converted: I now no longer think Fae is an overpowered faction - their numbers will rarely increase: LO, Doc, BG and Trans are the most realistic options.
 * Transporter, Lookout and Doctor/Bodyguard and may visit the same target multiple times. Transporters are relatively rare. Ranked usually has only 1 Protective.
 * Escort and VH may sometimes visit the same target multiple times.
 * Invest and Sheriff can be converted, but they will rarely visit the same target twice.
 * Vigilante kills their target, so you do not gain any fairies. Also, they will get lynched if they survive. No other Town members can be converted.
 * Mafia and Neutrals will never be converted (unless you get lucky with the Witch).
 * If you don't manage to bait any of them soon, you will stay at 1 Fairy. You will at some point be visited by Maf/NK/Invest and be forced to claim a role without having any ability. Without any ability or allies, you will eventually be lynched.
 * If you manage to bait one of the four mentioned Townies into becoming a Fae, you can start a conversion chain by having them ask for protection/lookout-ing/transporting. This will quickly bring you to 3 Fairies. If one of them dies, you can find quick replacement from another protector (TP/LO/Trans). You will most likely win against Town and NK and will face off against the Mafia, if you haven't wiped them out yet.

Conclusion: If the main fairy can bait someone into conversion, it is relatively easy to bait more while also having protection and perfect private communication. If the Main Fairy fails to bait someone before being found by the Invest/Maf/NK, they will most likely be lynched.

You know what, I like this role. It can create a subgroup inside the Town faction, which will lower the Town win rate. TL;DR my updated suggestions, please discuss:
 * "Fairy Queen" can talk to changelings at night, but they cannot talk back. OR:
 * Medium can hear fairy chat.
 * Keep "not suspicious" for all Fairies. Keep normal Invest results for all Changelings.
 * Allow immediate Vigilante conversion without suicide.
 * No Jailor conversion.