Board Thread:Role Ideas/@comment-28112409-20160805100046/@comment-28112409-20160806041702

BobbytheBlobby wrote: '''" Independent Mafia Killing". ''' Not necessarily a bad thing. SC2 Mafia has the Kidnapper (and its own version of Disguiser), and it works just fine. This doesn't make Mafia OP, but balances it with Disguiser and Kidnapper only having one kill. And don't forget ToS wouldn't exist if it were not for SC2 Mafia.

Omniscient Town Killing

VH always breaks this rule, but I agree with this. I think VH needs to be reworked. It also breaks Role Dependency and Hard Counters

Re-Hashes

Again, not necessarily a bad thing. Escort/Consort? Invest/Consig? SC2 Mafia also has Jailor/Kidnapper.

Night Town Chat

SC2 Mafia has that, in the Mason (Mason/Mason Leader). It works perfectly fine.

Self-Confirming Town

Mayor breaks this rule. So does SC2 Mafia's Marshall.

I posted my opinions here to see what you guys think about them. Also, how am I supposed to tell the creator of these suggestions if I don't have the link? I also am aware that someone on the forums created this..

BTW, this thread includes Octo's suggestions to making roles. (http://town-of-salem.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:66415) While SC2:Mafia and ToS are pretty similar, they're also different in ways were some roles of SC2:Mafia won't work in ToS.

In addition, you can't say that in-game roles break these rules because these rules go towards Role ideas not already implemented roles.

People have also said it frequently that they don't want ToS to be an absolute copy of SC2:Mafia. They want to try out unique ideas and not just being copycats and taking all their role ideas from SC2:Mafia.

I edited the post, there's a link to the page, you can go post what you said there and see the responses.