Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-33167183-20171226213657/@comment-33877233-20171229143224

Betimawesome wrote: Voltingshock wrote: Betimawesome wrote: Summary: You have an ice thrower and you want to kill everyone. (Unique role)

Attack: Powerful | Defense: Basic

Attributes: Your targets will and role will not be revealed to the town (Oh god, a game with Medusa, Janitor, and this..)

Abilities: On non full nights, you can freeze someone.

On full moon nights, you are getting more ice.

Investigator: Your target could be a Sheriff, Executioner, Werewolf, Poisoner, or Cyromancer

Consigliere/pm/witch/cl: Your target freezes people into ice. They must be a Cyromancer.

Sheriff: Your target is a cyromancer!

Goal: Live to see everyone freeze.

Wins with: Witches, Cyromancer, survivors. Pirates, GA etc.  

Must kill: Town, Mafia, Serial killers, Werewolves, Arsonists, Vampires, Coven, Juggernaunts, Plaguebearers, pestilence.

I am so sick of condensending people screaming "THIS IDEA IS HORRIBLE!" Please stop. Hmm. This is kinda like a Serial Killler plus Medusa combo, reply with a nice argument why its not and ill give you a nice long review as to why it is Saying this is like a serial killer, is also like saying Werewolf is a serial killer with a day cooldown, rampage ability, and powerful attack. I don't see how this is like SK.

This cleans, SK does not.

This has a day cooldown, SK does not.

This has Powerful attack, SK does not.

Werewolf rampages, this does not.

Werewolf doesn't clean, this does.

Medusa can kill visitors, This can't.

Medusa has teamates, This doesn't.

This role isn't TOO similar to other roles. Alright ill give you that, now after reading it through again its that it is quite UP, being able to only attack every other night would stop the CM (cyromancer) from attacking often, and by N6. they might only have 3 kills, this makes it very hard to win in the long run. the attacking every other night wouldnt work, but if it attacked every night then it would be too similar to SK, and if it had rampage it would be to similar to WW, Etc. I think this roles needs quite a bit of rework to balance it, otherwise its kinda of trapped between existing roles and cant make its own place in the game if that makes sense