Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-27398195-20200121233049/@comment-31256456-20200125034638

205.237.153.138 wrote: Yeah I've had many of those games, and many MANY more where that didn't happen, the likelyness that the escort chooses to roleblock YOU and doesn't die to something else during the roleblocking is next to none, I play all any all the time and the times where the godfather got roleblocked was to say the least, rare. The times I've played as mafioso with godfather and actually had an escort roleblock the Godfather specifically is next to none.

'''All Any is not considered a competitive meta imo, as it's inconsistent at best. GF+Mafioso is better than GF+Anything else because it ensures the kill will go through. Any potential killing role is good. WIthout the Mafioso, a Jailed GF would quickly lead to a dead GF. '''

The thing is that we will likely always disagree because i play all any and you likely don't

In all any getting mafioso without godfather is HORRIBLE, and i would not mind seeing that role become unrollable in game, we still need it if godfather dies so someone can become mafioso, but heres a question, have you ever played a game where you are the only mafia as mafioso? because if you had you would know well the fact that you are just a worse godfather, so in almost all situations where you would need a mafioso, a godfather would do it better.

'''Okay, so, getting Mafioso without godfather is horrible. Let's remove the mafioso from the game.'''

'''You have one GF and one Forger. The GF dies. The forger cannot kill. The end.'''

'''No one can claim that the Mafioso is better than the GF. But that's like saying "A pistol isn't effective at killing people because a machine gun is bad!". Being outclassed doesn't make the role bad. '''

'''​​​​​​​Mafioso is a necessary and good role in the game. '''