Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-39468482-20190514220241/@comment-33307613-20190517153031

TheCakeyBoy wrote: DragonClaw66 wrote: Orecreeper wrote: No maf kills

Spy: x2 visits on this dead guy who was shot by a Vigi.

Entire town: CORONER!!!!!!!!!! Spy is a horrible role; we shouldn't make balance decisions on Mafia roles based on it.

This role isn't anywhere near as useful as some of the other Random Mafias (such as Consort and Janitor). Not only does changing the kill message have almost no effect on the game, but it can easily be discovered if there are "no Mafia kills". Spy was a good role until they buffed it. Now it's terrible, but it's better than Medium. Spy has always been a bad role; ever since the release of Town of Salem it has been able to see Mafia visits​​​​​​​. No role should be able to counter other roles (or factions, in the case of the Spy) simply by existing.