Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-184.148.138.185-20170428171434/@comment-26234016-20170428195807

Don't worry about 'em! 184.148.138.185 wrote: ~Deporter~

The Donnie?

Summary: You are a trained proffesional, skilled in the deportation of human remains.

Abilities:

-Choose 1 af the Godfather's/Mafioso's targets to deport

-The next morning, their slot will be empty, as if they never exsisted

- Their Name/Role will not appear in the graveyard

Attributes:

-If there are no capable Mafia members, you will become a Mafioso.

Victory Conditions: You can win with Mafia, Witches and Surviviors.

Investigation Results:

Sheriff- Your target is a member of the Mafia

Investigator- Your target is dkilled at disturbing others. They could be Escort, Deporter, Transporter or Consort

OR.....

Your target deals with dead bodies.They could be Medium, Deporter, Retributionist or Janitor.

Consigliere/Witch- Your target transports dead bodies. They must be a Deporter!

So basically what i was thinking was i thought that a role were you cause the slot that a player was in to be suddenly empty, like he or she died 2 nights ago.I feel as if tyhis would cause a lot of cunfusion fo the Town, not knowing anything. This isn't really a rehash of the Janitor, more of a improvement. The Town will not know:

There's the problem.

-Who killed your target

-Your target's role

-Your target's last will

So, tell me what you think! Do you think it should be ACCEPTED or REJECTED? Okay.

You said so yourself that it was 'not a rehash of the Janitor, but an improvement.' I mean, it is a rehash but...

Janitor already gets rid of the last will and role. To that you add their name and who killed them. That would probably work best as a Janitor rework (see: '... but an improvement') but even then it's still pretty darned OP and softcounters TIs.

REJECTED