Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-36709870-20181013011506/@comment-32651233-20181013012627

So this brings up some problems, and some questions:

1. Can't the Mafia just do a test where they get each member to whisper something random to the other 3 mafia members, and it would be obvious who the Agent is.

2. Old spy got removed for a reason. We don't need the "seeing mafia chat" thing back.

3. What do you mean by "Mafia Support or Disguiser". Will it be MS or Disg? If its MS, what role will it be?

4. What happens if there is both a Mafia and a Coven in game?

5. If you are a Coven, what will you be shown as instead?

6. What happens if you become a Mafioso? Do you kill for Town, like a stronger vigilante? Does Town automatically win if all other evils are dead?

7. If you cant be selected to be killed by the Mafia, that would be OP since it means you are invincible. In other words, it would always be a draw or loss for the Mafia, and Mafia's winrate is already low. We need a Mafia BUFF not a NERF.

8. Please don't tell me this is going to turn into "Mastermind V2". -_-