Board Thread:Role Ideas (Rework)/@comment-25493615-20180201142824/@comment-5498154-20180201173503

The way I see it, this idea is good because it makes the Pirate's actions influenced by the game itself. From the chat and other declarations, you'll be able to at least get a decent inference as to who might not be visited the next night. With the current mechanics, you can't MAKE a good guess as to what the person you're plundering might pick because the dueling mechanic doesn't matter anywhere else in the game, meaning the only way to make a proper estimate is to actually know the person you're dueling and make a guess based on what they often pick, which isn't exactly legal in ToS terms.