Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-32942597-20171121174534/@comment-32881402-20171121181408

Please clarify the mechanic - does it kill the visitor or your target? There are problems in both routes you take.

You kill the visitor
This becomes an incredibly swingy role and you have no control over who you kill. This means that you cannot kill who you want and it becomes a worse serial killer. Its ability of will removal does not affect the role that much, because you can't count on killing the Townie who is dangerous with this lack of control.

Its powerful attack value really means very little, as it only affects the Godfather. The chances of hitting the Godfather are low, because not only do you have to target the same target as the Godfather, but you also have to rely on the Mafioso not taking action. Ultimately, this increase in attack value means too little to make this role much better.

You kill the target
This becomes an extremely swingy, often worse serial killer. You rely on your target not being visited twice, meaning that it doesn't even take a protective to stop you. Even if you hide last wills, it won't help you that much. The claim slot will still be gone, and Town is encouraged to share all important information. The reason why Janitor is powerful is because it cleans the role, too, giving more claimspace for the Mafia. Removing wills doesn't have a huge impact on the game because of the way that Town plays.

As I said before, the attack value does not balance this role because of its insignificance.