Board Thread:Off-Topic Posts/@comment-39067078-20190814024731/@comment-30757827-20190815015539

(Wait what i'm considered the best reviewer-)

Many reviewing techniques aren't actually techniques and appear to be a mess of ideas about a role, so i think it's nice for people to have an actual method to reviewing, rather than the former.

I really like the hint of flavor part, it's, well, a hint of flavor to this reviewing tactic, i kind of use this tactic myself, but it's more spread out throughout the whole thing, rather than it's own thing to concentrate on like it is here.

However, i must say that the reviewing thing at the end... i don't like it. Rating roles leads to people with bad roles to feel terrible, imagine playing 15 games of town of salem, think it's cool, see if theres a place to reccomend roles, come here, submit a role, some dood comes on and gives you a 0/10 or "0/3 michelin stars." most people would just leave, this is the same reason we've abandoned the "Rejected" meme.

Now i know what you're thinking, "but tringle dood you rate rolls with your verdict meme you hippocrip" and to that i say, my verdict meme doesn't use stars or n/10, it just has 4 things that are all different and essential.

'''Scrap. '''Your role is a clone of another role or has a concept that simply does not work, move on to another role.

'''Revamp. '''Your role has a good core concept that can be expanded on, but the role needs to be changed a lot, change it significantly.

'''Tweak. '''Your role is good but a few things could be tweaked to make it perfect

'''Submit. '''Never seen this one before? this one is rare as almost no role is perfect, no matter how thouroughly thought through it is, you need other's feedback for it to be perfect. Actually, i think i've only given this to two roles before, ever, one role before reviewing it prior. Pretty self explanitory, the role is already perfect, submit it to the official forums now.

So yeah, i think there are better ways than stars or 1-10 scales.

P.S

I'm trademarking my verdict meme and all reviewing methods associated.