Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-33167183-20180712213230/@comment-33167183-20180713012006

MilkyWay90 wrote: Betimawesome wrote: It does

-It's invest results are the "Time to get vig'd

-It can be found by the sheriff

-It's existance gets announced to the town on day three. I'll shorten this to day 2.

-It's a threat to not just the, but to the and  as well. If the nk is sk or ww, it's likely to get attacked on night five, or more likely, earlier. If there are multiple NK's, then you're screwed. The Mafia are probably willing to give up their N5 kill for you if they know.

-It doesn't win on a hang during the day. If they know. If the maniac stays silent, the town won't be suspicious of it until D8 or something like that. '''Not true. Vfr is a thing.'''

Invest results should shorten it to 1 role (like a consig) that says MaNiAc! The existance report on D2 is probably the only obstacle, and the Town would have around only a 3/13 chance of finding you if they're smart. That's uhhh Up.

Here are my suggestions:

Make the attack on full moon nights and is a Basic Rampage attack. The invest results will say Maniac, not 3/4/5 options, but it straight-out says "Your target is the Maniac!"

Also, make it so it's like the Jester. By N5, don't end the game if the Maniac survives. However, make it so the Maniac wins but then the Maniac will be revealed, then the Maniac will win, and can die but still win afterwards.'''​​​​​​​ That makes it a completely pointless role that does nothing but vote. Might as well just leave it alone the whole game, like a survivor.'''