Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-33167183-20180524211938/@comment-34797858-20180524222616

HAWAIIANpikachu wrote: And Pre-1.5 disguiser is not?

Pre-1.5 disguiser was garbage, I'm talking about worse than crusader.

A) You required either a janitor or forger to do work, and this was in the 8-3-3-1 rank, so you had to pray to the any slot if you got the disguiser role. If there wasn't, congratulations! Do you want to Alt+F4 or Wait to become Mafioso?

B) Disguising was boring. The skill of being a "good" disguiser was that you would have to memorize their role and their speech. People also abused the disguise function and the report system by spam/GT.

C) The claim space. "Oh, you are either a disguiser or jester? Well time to get the good old jailor/vigilante to kill you!"

D) Spies would instantly know that there's a disguiser if 3 people visited the same person. The only other two possible combinations are Consort+Mafioso+Janitor/Forger or Consort+Blackmailer+Consig A) You required either a janitor or forger to do work, and this was in the 8-3-3-1 rank, so you had to pray to the any slot if you got the disguiser role. If there wasn't, congratulations! Do you want to Alt+F4 or Wait to become Mafioso?

Then make it so that disguised targets dont appear in the graveyard, simple.

B) Disguising was boring. The skill of being a "good" disguiser was that you would have to memorize their role and their speech. People also abused the disguise function and the report system by spam/GT.

'''1. Roles that are boring can be useful. Just because they're boring doesn't mean they're useless.'''

2. Add a replay feature.

C) The claim space. "Oh, you are either a disguiser or jester? Well time to get the good old jailor/vigilante to kill you!"

'''These were old results, and we could just make it so that changes results to who they disguise as when they take their place. Remember, this isn't 1775, this is 2018.'''

D) Spies would instantly know that there's a disguiser if 3 people visited the same person. The only other two possible combinations are Consort+Mafioso+Janitor/Forger or Consort+Blackmailer+Consig

'''​​​​​​​Then rework and/or make a role dedicated to tracking evils and make a role dedicated to bugging. Issue solved.'''