Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-39990017-20190922020849/@comment-39067078-20190923004913

I use food analogies because they're the most indepth way for me to review.

Let's take the Guardian Angel, who wants their target to live. They are a Ramen, who only needs basic flavoring to win.

This role, the King, is Spaghetti, who not only does it need the sauces to win, it can't exist without it. It's not so much win as topple the Spaghetti by removing the sauces and creating a bland, noodly thing.

Guardian Angel makes you feel nice because you are truly innocent. You don't have to egg on the evils to kill others, you just need to keep your one person alive.

And then this Spaghetti man comes in. He wins from the start unless people defuse the bomb by toppling the people under him. Everyone hates him, and especially if Pestilence is involved, other factions automatically lose. On top of that, the Sauces that are perfectly fine with the Nachos of town or the Tacos of Mafia now have no free will. Everytime they do anything, they go "sorry but my mom said no" to the faction they're part of.

Also, nothing is stopping them from selling out their identity. Some may just sacrifice themselves to harm the overall.

Tl;Dr:

Your role is annoying for everyone to play as. Your role is annoying to play against.