Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-77.139.100.68-20161025055058/@comment-30105631-20161025060435

77.139.100.68 wrote: 1. its unique

'''Yes... but still brokenly OP'''

2. in custom games maf is always way too strong

'''In custom games. *clears throat* We are not adding a role into Town of Salem purely to make the mafia weaker in custom games. WE DO NOT NEED THAT!!!'''

3.randomly the game chooses and its too confuse the mafia

'''Why do we want to confuse the mafia? Why do we want to make it harder on them? TOWN IS EASIER!!!'''

4:gf cant be ound  by sheriffs wich makes it harder

'''So that means you should automatically know his identity, right from the get-go? ''' I don't think you understand. As a role, this role is brokenly OP. It has powers that make it completely OP no matter how many nerfs you give it.

It's incredibly similar to the spy, which makes it a rehash.

And it counters the mafia, who DO NOT NEED A COUNTER.

My advice: Get an account, lay low, look at other people's role ideas, and figure out balance and fairness before you start making the broken town even more broken.

That is all.