Board Thread:Fun and Games/@comment-36288154-20180726130428/@comment-35195751-20180726222751

In my opinion

Best    -

TK: Jailor and Veteran, for Obvious reasons

TI: Lookout, for practically being a TP, and Investigator on a meta level for shaping people's claims and making the game all around easier, even when they arent in a game

TP: Doctor, very basic, very powerful, and Trapper, for being the only major variation of TP

TS: Escort and Medium, Medium because it helps prevent leaving

Mafia: Consigliere and Hypnotist, No particular reason, they just seem the most useful to me

Coven: Necromancer and Potion master, Potion master, is fun to stratigize with, and Necromancer is one of the more unique roles to me

Neutral: Jester just makes the game better for me by limiting random lynching, and Pestilences OP Night abilitys make him fun to play

Worst

TK: Crusader... Wait, this ISNT town killing? oh

.....Then Vigilante, for only being able to kill weak evils and townies, and vamp hunters for so many reasons I cant list here. Mostly that it cant do anything to anyone but vamps, and that it turns into a weak vigilante (wow)

TI: Spy and sheriff can only get certain kinds of evils and are generally suspicious to claim

TP: Crusader, come on... Bodyguard is also kinda sad but at least it only kills enemys... Oh, unless a vig, or VH attacks.

TS:

Mafia: Ambusher: So he attacks a visitor to a target... but gets revealed if there was more than one visitor  ....what? That makes this role practically unplayable without a TON of luck. Forger, Disguiser is pretty weak, but Im going with Forger, it just feels like a weak janitor, I know it has more useful potential than disguiser but I just hate playing as forger more. ....the limited usage really kills it for me

Coven: Almost every role (Without the necronomicon) aside from Necromancer, and Potion Master

-Coven Leader, Witch that only wins with her team, although it is nice that this one always gets necronomicon first

-Medusa, Weaker Veteran, She doesnt even know who she kills and she doesnt get any defence

-Hex Master, Admitedly stronger than Arso since she has a team, still pretty pathetic

-Poisoner, Maybe if it werent so counterable? WHY would anyone want weak delayed kills?

Neutral: Survivor.... BORING!!! This should only exist as the thing a GA turns into (Or a VH?)

And I know Arso and WW are hard to win with but...

Serial Killer is my 2nd least favorite neutral to play with, Its basically just a godfather that doesnt have a mafia, it ONLY wins ties agains Godfathers, and frankly, has WAY too many auto-attacks that make one really easy to find, Its not really the worst role, but its the one I have the least fun with

aside from survivors :(