Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-38648550-20190507143438/@comment-30757827-20190510224009

-You don't get to choose what effect you place on them, they do, making the role less interesting to play as you only get to select the person, not what they get.

-Even if it's only on full moons, defense until attacked is OP. It would only be balanced if as doctor, people healed the attacked around 50% of the time. This is not true.

-Vigilante is useless now that this role can just give someone the ability to kill - without suicide mind you.

-Giving supply ruins everything, as the number of times you can use your ability is one of the main ways roles are balanced. If you remove this, the roles can just use their ability willy nilly.

-Janitor and forger could be selected and get extra supplies, buffing the mafia by a lot.

'''Verdict: Revamp. '''Change the different wishes, let the role decide, and keep the role about using a lot of abilities, but uses any of them rarely.