Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-37322933-20190811225906/@comment-30757827-20190817163226

I don't really want to do an in-depth review of this, as this is simply too close to PMer. Normally, if, say, you were adapting a town support to mafia support, there would be no problem, but the fact of the matter is, BMG won't accept the role because players will have less motivation to buy coven. Even if it's perfectly balanced, fun, simple, plus with different abilities, PMer is no longer something players are looking forward to getting to play/play against, something similar is already in classic. Plus, coven is fundamentally the same as mafia but with different roles, so to add a role this similar defeats the purpose of having coven, even if coven wasn't a paid expansion, this role would still never get into the game. Sorry.