Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20181230235210/@comment-33307613-20190108124451

Response to BobbytheBlobby.

--

Medium: No opinion.

Transporter: I agree.

Framer: If the Framer actually received the permanent frames, it wouldn't have necessarily been overpowered, but it would've been more swingy (it still doesn't affect the Spy or Lookout). Frame+focus Framer is better, in my opinion.

Agent: Yes, that's what Orangeandblack's Osservatore does (it also acts as a Tracker).

Framer: Not sure what you mean by a "double frame".

Spy: I'd rather rework the Spy so that it cannot see Mafia visits at all. The entire concept is broken.

Jester/Executioner: I don't think it's necessary.

Serial Killer: I wouldn't care too much about roleblock immunity... idk. Attacks should still be healable.

Full Moon: The Werewolf should inherit the mechanics of the TG Werewolf; it's so much better. The Juggernaut should also be changed.

TP/LO Vet Bait: Yes.

Disguiser: Disguising is not only a rare success, but when it does succeed, it normally only gets one player lynched. It should be reworked (again).

Witch: No opinion.

Vampire Hunter: Cause Vampires multiply and are hard to take care of. I doubt BMG is going to remove the role, so we're just going to have to suggest changes. I have some ideas on my profile, but most of them are probably garbage.

Coven Expansion: No opinion.

Defined ELO: Neutral Killings should get at least +10 after winning a game.

Report System: One of the required sections to fill in should be where the scenario happened (what day).

Retributionist: If Town Power is added to the game (containing Jailor, Mayor, and Retributionist), the Retributionist won't be that big of a problem anymore because the role can no longer spawn in Ranked. Obviously, that's a "sweep it under the rug" kind of solution, but it does work.

Mafia Transporter: No opinion.

Neutral Evils: I would like some more Neutral Evils with the Witch's win condition.

Arsonist: I'd rather the Arsonist use "douse charges". http://blankmediagames.com/phpbb/viewtopic.php?f=14&t=77395

Mayor: TOS would be accused of stealing from TOL's King.