Board Thread:Fun and Games/@comment-30154040-20161012205020/@comment-25876622-20161014221706

Theory 1 Theory 2
 * The real Doctor (8) was afk before (didn't heal Jailor).
 * Real Doctor comes back and didn't see the Mayor ask for them to heal the Bodyguard. Or, they don't remember who claimed Bodyguard. So, they selfheal because only four people are left alive and they can't heal the Mayor.
 * The last Mafia (7) knows the real Doctor was afk, so they hope the Doctor is afk again. They attack the Bodyguard even though the Mayor said they should be healed.
 * The Bodyguard vests and gets attack. The message: "You are immune at night"
 * They whisper the Mayor "I vested... but I wasn't healed". It's true.
 * The real Doctor (7) is back from afk and listened to the Mayor, so they healed the Bodyguard.
 * The last Mafia (8) attacked the Bodyguard. They cannot kill the Mayor because of the Bodyguard. If they kill the Doctor, the last two Townies can lynch them.
 * The Bodyguard was immune at night (vest). If the Bodyguard uses a vest, they will not know that they were visited by a Doctor, because Mafia attacks don't ignore night immunity.
 * They whisper the Mayor "I vested... but I wasn't healed". It isn't really a lie, the Bodyguard just doesn't know.

In any case, Mafia loses. One "Doctor" is lynched today. If they lynch the wrong one, the Bodyguard and Mayor are still alive. The Mayor can't be killed at night because of the Bodyguard; the Mayor lynches the fake Doctor the next day, even if the Bodyguard dies.