Talk:Town of Salem Rules/@comment-27016593-20150925030153/@comment-25876622-20150926174236

1. Fair game, if there really was such a promise. See below... this is the point I am most hung up on.

2. He publicly claimed Survivor without opposition, so leaving him alive is more than reasonable.

3. See 1 - fair game, but you can't blame him for being mad at you. If there was a Spy who listened to you making plans, the lynch wouldn't have succeeded. See Yami's response.

4. So you didn't share any new gameplay-relevant information - fair game.

5. Uh. Okay. Your Mafia teammates can be reported for gamethrowing, whether or not you were rude ingame.

6. More gamethrowing by your teammates.

To sum it up:


 * Your teammates threw the game and may be reported for it.


 * I don't know how the Amnesiacs made a promise to join Mafia. They couldn't have whispered any of you, not knowing who a Mafia member is. It would be amazingly stupid to say it in public chat, especially since everyone will know they are Mafia once they actually become Consigliere.