Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20181230235210/@comment-37322933-20190204204436

Asew54321 wrote: Alright, time to get three of my major opinions off my chest.

1. Retributionist is the worst Town role. I have never found Retributionist fun to play at all. You press a button and boom bip boppidy bam you're done for the game. Sure you can scumread, but who's going to listen to you? If you try to accuse somebody, and you don't have "P R O O F" then you're not going to get listened to. This isn't even mentioning how OP it is confirming two Townies at once, but at that point, I'd to preach to the choir. This role needs to be removed. And then my least favorite Town role would be Escort due to it being useless, but that's a different argument I don't want to get into.

'''Not removed, nerfed. One idea I like is that the target only stays alive for 3 days. Another could be that if the Ret dies, the target dies, v.v., so that can make it so it has to figure out which one to protect.'''

2. Pirate is the worst Coven DLC role. This role is completely RNG. You're playing rock paper scissors in a game about strategy. I can't see how a role about picking randomly is fun. Essentially this role boils down to "lol i don't like you die hehe xd." Also, I HATE kingmaking so much. I personally think that kingmaking should be eliminated with an autowin system if there is a Survivor, won Executioner or Pirate along with one member of two factions by letting the stalemate detector pick the winner. But this role is not fun to play as and it's not fun to play against.

'''I hate it too. I agree with kingmaking, should be Arso > WW > SK > Maf > Town instead of Arso v GF v Townie and Townie annoyingly lynches the Arso.'''

3. Hex Master is the best Coven DLC role. Arsonist is only as weak as it is because it's an NK, and Hex Master is the remedy. I will agree that the Necronomicon ability is trash, but the whole factor of picking who's gonna live to the end is really much more fun now that you have teammates to coordinate with you and help you carry out that goal.

​​​​​​​Sure.