Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20171101070508/@comment-26234016-20171104163351

ProfessorArceus wrote: Add, here's where you're misunderstanding. See, it is impossible to achieve perfect balance. That's why we create seperate alignments like Town Power and Mafia Tactical - they're more powerful than the rest.

Note that with the proposed change, if Godfather kills, he has no extra layer of protection; he is vulnerable to many of the roles you stated.

Regarding the math. Uh how and how? Because I see no evidence.... or your point. It knows 3 roles from the start since Mafia is informed. So that math can't be right.

Regarding NKs, well, at what point in the game is that calculation based off of?

Your numbers mean nothing without the actual math to support it. It might be impossible to create 'perfect balance', sure.

But there is no way that this change to the Godfather would come anywhere near that. This is a Frankenstein, alright? It is insanely overpowered.

As for the NKs:

I... could you quote which post on NKs? Because there are a couple.