Board Thread:Role Ideas (Coven)/@comment-2001:1C03:3403:C900:85D:643D:A6CF:9BA1-20180419131540/@comment-2001:1C03:3403:C900:85D:643D:A6CF:9BA1-20180423104514

GamesManiac wrote: Greeting! Sorry for late review.

Overview: A mixture of a lot of roles? Adjusted version of, buffed and , exactly same like. Umm.. I feel lost reading the role card. Do you have a clear direction of what this role is suppose to do? Or you're just simply want to make a Succubus and give it a lot of abilities so it wouldn't be UP and worth being a role?

Demon: Talk to the dead day and night. Also hearing the real talking? For your information, if there are 2, they can't even hear each other talking. Demon: Look at someone's log to see who they visit UNTIL THAT POINT OF THE GAME Demon: Look at someone's log to see what happen to that player UNTIL THAT POINT OF THE GAME and take their investigative results if they're Demon: Haunt a player to see who visit them
 * Talk to the dead at night and seance one person alive when dead.
 * Track one person to who they visit THAT PARTICULAR NIGHT
 * Bugged someone house to see what happen to that player THAT PARTICULAR NIGHT and see all or  visits.
 * Visit a player to see who visit them

Conclusion: A very serious rehash and overpowered version of a bunch of roles. Like I always say, I'm not narrow-minded, as long as you have good reason for breaking rules and tradition of role making, I will accept it. So let's see things in-depth if this is a necessary evil.

Detailed Analyse: I have no idea how this role should originally be.


 * 1) Why a member needs to talk to the dead? You want to get information from dead ? No, you don't need to do that.  and  can get someone's exact role. That's already sufficient. AND SEE THE DEAD'S CHAT AT DAY? No, that's too much, the dead should stay dead and shouldn't interfere with the livings unnecessarily. Just suggest this to buff
 * 2) Buffed combination of, and . Why this role needs to do some much investigation?  can easily get somebody's exact role which is crucial to plot their killing plan, why bother to do other investigation? How those investigation can help ?
 * 3) Before getting, deal basic attack and can only attack 3 times. Ok! That MAYBE balanced. After receiving , it deals powerful attack and has unlimited kills. Same as after buffed by . This part MAYBE balanced too. That only part I don't understand is that: "You can only haunt someone's house again after you killed the player you haunted first" Do you mean Demon won't immediately kill off your target?

Final thought:

A member whose core ability is investigating. need all sort of to find the evil. The evil factions need investigative role to find their priority target such ,  or before those roles posing threat against their faction. Basically, knowing one's role is enough which and  are able to do so. If you're making a role, I suggest that you should have an aim for the role, covering the need of certain faction. Instead of doing EVERYTHING under that scope to fulfill the purpose of alignment, think of way to fix aspect that faction is lacking. senpai noticed me :o *huggles*