Board Thread:Role Ideas (Other)/@comment-26715110-20170720043215/@comment-29253708-20170720081131

Charliep2 wrote: Psychic - Way too op and easy to claim REJECTED

''They nerfed it. It's okay now.''

Tracker - TRACKER ROLE REJECTED!

''Why? It breaks a rule, but BMG created those rules. If they want to break them, it's their choice. Personally I think it's a very well-thought out idea.''

Crusader - BG Buff REJECTED!

''Actually it's a nerf. It kills Town a lot.''

Trapper - Can confirm which roles are in the game and can also save other players with one trap, too OP REJECTED!

''"can also save other players with one trap"? What the heck? The Doctor can save other players with one heal. I don't get what you're even trying to say here...''

Hypnotisit - So it is basicly a better disguiser since it can just claim trans/escort just to confirm itself, REJECTED!

''Disguiser? Claiming has nothing to do with Disguiser. You can claim anything as any role.''

Ambusher - Mafia Killing REJECTED!

Same thing as Tracker

Guardian Angel - Buddy role REJECTED!

''No... GA doesn't require any specific role to be in the game. <_<''

Pirate - Neutral Chaos, Its a gamble whether or not you can win the duel REJECTED!

''That's the whole point. You gotta anticipate your opponent's choice in order to win.''

Plaguebearer - Basicly when your pest there is a rolecall and you get outed and if you don't get outed everyone stays home so only 1 kill. REJECTED!

''And you want to organize everyone JUST to make it so no one visits other people? Have fun with that.''

Juggernaut - Whats the point in having a hidden role, it's just too much of a hassle to new coven players and why can invest see nothing for jugg, confirming that they are jugg. REJECTED!

''I believe they're currently working on a result for it, not sure tho. Also, not having an Invest result is a stupid reason to reject a role.''

Coven Leader - WITCH BUT IT HAS DIFFERENT WIN CONDITION INSTANT REJECTED!

THE WHOLE HECKING POINT OF THE COVEN LEADER IS THAT IT IS THE WITCH YA DOINK

Hex Master - Arsonist rehash REJECTED!

''Nope. It's less OP, because it can't choose when to kill.''

Medusa - Veteran and Jaintor rehash REJECTED!

Already mentioned why this is wrong in your OTHER thread.

Necromancer - Witch but only with dead REJECTED!

''Yes. That's exactly what it is. It uses dead players' abilities, and with the Necronomicon, it can kill people.''

Poisoner - So its made to be hardcountered by Doctor REJECTED!

No it isn't. There's a fair chance that Doctor and Poisoner won't even be in the same game.

Potion Master - So just a basic attack and steals steals consigs results and doctors heal and you put it together and you get Potion Master REJECTED!

Same as Medusa. So... yeah. Bai