Board Thread:Role Ideas (Rework)/@comment-32994909-20171221154748/@comment-27575896-20171221163839

Now, overall this is an interesting idea, but I would think it would lower the morale of ever being an Executioner.

The Executioner is 'Neutral Evil. 'He is supposed to influence the game as he can choose his allies however he wants. Plus, killing him afterwards will mkae the player have less fun. Being dead means they have to sit and watch the game unfold, and otherwise they can chat and mess around with the voting, making it more fun. Being dead is never fun, sitting still watching the clock slowly go down to win is boring.

Neutral Evil isn't as if to help town. Sure, it isn't the most liable choice, but Executioners rarely help town anyway unless forced to, or the town is already going to win instantly. They lean towards the Mafia more, and especially Neutral Killing overall.

This is also a follow-up of the Jester. Once thye get lynched and kill a person, now comes the boring waiting game to win.

Keep the Exectioner alive. Let them do however they want. A boring game is never a fun game.