Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-30255850-20171015211902/@comment-27804907-20171022163215

Only 5% of the time you can reject a role, because it's utter garbage? Sometimes the concept of a role just doesn't work at all? I'm sorry, but anyone who believes these are the type of role it's okay to reject should not be reviewing roles. These are the most important roles to discuss properly, not with some half-donkied rejection because you think it's bad. Why? Because someone made that role. Someone believes that role can work. So you not properly saying why it's bad means that even if they do drop the role, they can very well go and make another role. Another terrible role that you'll just reject. They wont learn, you'll just keep rejecting their roles until they decide to just leave, because of the unhelpful people who think that they're doing something they're not. Help people learn, don't make it easier on yourself by killing off the role rather than explaining why it can't work. I'll give you a little pointer in role reviewing: if the best you can do to review a role isn't meaningful, and is only about one line long, don't post it. If you can't muster up two sentences for a role, then don't post on that role. I remember someone on the forums being incredibly rude, their lame excuse was "These roles honestly physically make me sick, so no, I can't just stop being rude." Are you guys like him? Do you not see the incredible flaw in that attitude? If you can't manage anything meaningful to post about a role, or it physically pains you to see the role, don't post on the role. You don't have to, in fact, it's better you don't. There's bound to be someone helpful who will post for you. So just stay away from roles that make you want to lazily dismiss them. The only person making you post lazy and thoughtless statements is yourself.

Even the starter of the rejection trend hates it. Just stop, it really doesn't help. Even /nosupport or /support are crutches for real reviewing. You could summarize your thoughts and opinions on a role with just one word, but you shouldn't. If they want that, they should make a poll. If they don't, then don't do it. Don't summarize your opinion, even if it's ten paragraphs. As long as it's ten paragraphs of thought-provoking and logically sound material that doesn't repeat itself seventy times - or any number of times other than a conclusion or Tl;dr preferably - post it.