Board Thread:Role Ideas (Coven)/@comment-34720888-20180419051951/@comment-35356104-20180421131058

Hi! I'm new here. This is my first time reviewing a role so allow me to introduce myself. I personally dislike reviewing role simply because I suck at it. If someone else already give quality feedback, then I even don't bother to be nosy. I'm not a native english speaker, please tolerate with my grammar.

So here's my opinion on your role:

First Impression: '''AIRBENDER! '''I don't mind Coven recruits all the Avatar character btw. This role kind of reminds me of and /.

- Pick A as first target and B as second. Result: A visits B.

- Pick A as first target and B as second. Result: Visitors of A visit B, B's visitors visit A.

Aeromancer - Pick A as first target and B as second. Result: Visitors of A visit B.

Conclusion: Basically Aeromancer is a one-way and  who controls visitors of your first target.

Deeper Thoughts:

Final Thought:
 * 1) They are both from the same faction. Their abilities just overlap.
 * 2) Evil who has the ability to MASSIVELY manipulate visiting mechanic is overpowered. (Transporter alone is enough to cause a lot of chaos to the town like messing with  &  etc.) In this case, would have a farming day.
 * 3) It is overpowered not to notice the visitors that they are forced to visit someone else. Hard-countering  too much. They already suffer enough wasting a night to search for nothing and misleading them some more...
 * 4) does the same like  and . Unlike other, their  buff their abilities, making them a lot more unique. In this case, it doesn't buff Aeromancer ability but it changes the whole mechanic upon receiving , from manipulating to straight off killing.
 * 5) Immune to roleblock is a big no-no. To me, it is acceptable for to have roleblock immunity, but even  doesn't have that thing.

Thanks for making effort to post your idea here. I personally not against rehash as long as it is needed. When you're brainstorming ideas of new role, maybe you can think of questions like "what are the factions lacking of?", "how does the role impact on the factions? It is balance?" , "what kind of playstyle you would love to see? clicking one button for the whole game?" '''No sarcasm intended. '''"What's the role abilites and mechanics? already exist? is it neccessary?"

I'm sorry if I sound offensive, judgemental and arrogant. I totally mean no offense. I'm sharing my perceptive so you can take in my point of view for your role idea next time. Look forward to see your next role idea.