Talk:Consigliere/@comment-25876622-20150501143100

An IP recently added the strategy to claim a Mafia member (let's call him John) is a Veteran at night. However, there are only three ways for a Mafia member to know the Veteran:

1. The Vet is confirmed. In that case, the Spy knows that John isn't Vet.

2. A Mafia member visited the Vet and died. In that case, the Spy has seen who was visited at night, and will know one of these people is the Vet, not John.

3. A Consigliere found the Vet. The Spy will know that John was not yet visited, so it would not make sense for the Consigliere to know John's role.

The strategy doesn't work if the Spy knows how to spy.