Custom Setups (Classic)

Custom Setups are a fun way the Host can set up a Custom Mode game. Below is a list of some setups people have made. If you do not like the setups below, a good way to think of a great setup is to center it around one role, like the Serial Killer. How to center it around the role is easy, just think of ways it could be countered (Sheriff, Investigator, Escort, Jailor.) Then put roles which help the Serial Killer(s). (Neutral Evil, etc). Thus you have made a great setup which many will enjoy as all the roles will surely be useful. If you know any other fun setups feel free to add them to this list below. However, please try the setup first to see if it is possible, or lasts at least three nights (unique roles are unique, maximum of 15 players, minimum 7, no more than 6 Mafia, at least 2 opposing factions).

Trick or Treat

 * 1 Veteran
 * 1 Investigator
 * 1 Escort
 * 1 Vigilante
 * 1 Random Town
 * 1 Town Protective
 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 4 Executioner
 * 4 Jester

8,3,3,1

 * 1  Jailor
 * 2 Town Investigative
 * 2 Town Protective
 * 1 Town Killing
 * 2 Town Support
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafia Support
 * 1 Mafia Deception
 * 1 Neutral Benign
 * 1 Neutral Evil
 * 1 Neutral Killing
 * 1 Any

Variation:

 * 1 Jailor
 * 2 Town Investigative
 * 2 Town Protective
 * 1 Town Killing
 * 2 Town Support
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafia Support
 * 1 Mafia Deception
 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 1 Witch
 * 1 Amnesiac
 * 1 Any

8, 3, 4:

 * 1 Jailor
 * 2 Town Investigative
 * 2 Town Protective
 * 2 Town Support
 * 2 Random Mafia
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Town Killing
 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 1 Neutral Evil
 * 1 Werewolf
 * 1 Neutral Benign

Taking Sides

 * 5 Vigilantes
 * 5 Amnesiacs
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafioso
 * 1 Consort
 * 1 Disguiser
 * 1 Janitor

Balanced

 * 1 Doctor
 * 1 Investigator
 * 1 Town Protective
 * 1 Town Investigative
 * 1 Medium
 * 1 Town Killing (You may pick a specific role if you like)
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafioso
 * 1 Mafia Deception
 * 1 Mafia Support
 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 1 Arsonist
 * 1 Werewolf
 * 1 Neutral Killing
 * 1 Amnesiac

Variation

 * 1 Doctor
 * 1 Investigator
 * 1 Medium
 * 1 Town Investigative
 * 1 Town Killing
 * 1 Town Support
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafioso
 * 1 Mafia Deception
 * 1 Mafia Deception
 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 1 Arsonist
 * 1 Werewolf
 * 1 Random Neutral
 * 1 Amnesiac

Rainbow!
Note: It needs to be set up in this order for the rainbow to show.
 * Godfather
 * Mafioso
 * 2x Arsonist
 * 2x Survivor
 * Jailor
 * Veteran
 * Transporter or Vigilante
 * 2x Amnesiac
 * 2x Serial Killer
 * 2x Witch

Variation 1:

 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafioso
 * 2 Arsonist
 * 2 Survivor
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Veteran
 * 2 Amnesiac
 * 2 Serial Killer
 * 0 or 2 Witches
 * 0 or 2 Jesters
 * 1 Werewolf

Variation 2:

 * 1 Godfather
 * 2 Random Mafia
 * 2 Arsonist
 * 1 Survivor
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Veteran
 * 1 Doctor/Transporter
 * 1 Retributionist
 * 2 Amnesiac
 * 2 Serial Killer
 * 1 Witch

Variation 3:

 * 1 Godfather
 * 1/2 Random Mafia
 * 1 Arsonist
 * 1/2 Survivor (If two Survivors, then it has to be one Amnesiac or 1 Random Mafia. Same applies for other two.)
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Veteran
 * 1 Doctor
 * 1/2 Amnesiac
 * 1 Witch
 * 1 Jester
 * 1 Any

Varation 4:

 * Godfather
 * Arsonist
 * Survivor
 * Jailor
 * Amnesiac
 * Serial Killer
 * Witch
 * Werewolf/Jester
 * Witch
 * Serial Killer
 * Amnesiac
 * Veteran
 * Survivor
 * Arsonist
 * Any Mafia

Variation 5:

 * Godfather
 * Blackmailer
 * 2x Arsonist
 * 2x Survivor
 * Investigator
 * Jailor
 * 2x Amnesiac
 * 2x Serial Killer
 * 2x Witch
 * Jester

Supports are underestimated

 * 1 Town Investigative
 * 3 Town Protective
 * 2 Town Killing
 * 3 Town Support
 * 1 Godfather/Mafioso
 * 2 Random Mafia (Or specific Mafia roles)
 * 2 Neutral Evil
 * 1 Neutral Killing (Or specific Neutral Killing)

Variation:

 * 5 Town Support
 * 3 Town Protective
 * 2 Mafia (your pick of random or specific, but it's best with 1 Random Mafia/1 Mafia Support)
 * 2 Neutral Evil
 * 1 Town Killing
 * 1 Godfather/Mafioso
 * 1 Neutral Killing

(C)Old War

 * 5 Arsonists
 * 5 Witches
 * 1 Veteran
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1-2 Vigilantes
 * 1-2 Town Protective

RMLH Vs FIEO

 * Jailor
 * Mayor
 * 1 Sheriff
 * 1 Investigator
 * 1 Lookout
 * 1 Doctor
 * 1 Transporter
 * 1 Medium
 * 1 Bodyguard
 * 1 Town Killing
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Consigliere
 * 1 Consort
 * 1 Janitor
 * 1 Disguiser

Variation:

 * 3 Town Support
 * 3 Town Investigative
 * 2 Mafia Support
 * 2 Mafia Deception
 * 2 Town Protective
 * Jailor
 * Mayor
 * Godfather

"They did it!"

 * 4 Executioner
 * 2 Town Investigative
 * 2 Neutral Evil
 * 1 Neutral Killing
 * 1 Vigilantes
 * 1 Disguiser
 * 1 Mafioso
 * 1 Framer
 * 1 Jester
 * 1 Town Support

Honorary Mafia:

 * 2 Town Protective
 * 2 Town Support
 * 2 Town Killing
 * 2 Consigliere
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Mayor
 * 1 Sheriff
 * 1 Lookout
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Consort
 * 1 Witch

Let The Gods Decide

 * 8 Random Town
 * 4 Random Neutral
 * 2 Random Mafia
 * 1 Godfather

Variation:

 * 4 Random Town
 * 4 Random Neutral
 * 3 Random Mafia
 * 3 Any
 * 1 Godfather

Mafia vs Neutral

 * 3 Neutral Benign
 * 2 Mafia Support
 * 2 Random Mafia
 * 2 Neutral Evil
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafioso
 * 1 Arsonist
 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 1 Neutral Killing
 * 1 Random Neutral

Witch Hunt

 * 4 Town Protective
 * 4 Town Support
 * 3 Town Killing
 * 1 Witch
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Consigliere
 * 1 Jailor

Variation:

 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Transporter
 * 1 Bodyguard
 * 2 Town Protective
 * 2 Town Investigative
 * 1 Town Support
 * 2 Witch
 * 1 Werewolf
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Consigliere
 * 1 or 2 Random Mafia
 * 1 or no Random Neutral

Skilled With Knives

 * 9 Doctor
 * 2 Serial Killer
 * 2 Investigator
 * 1 Sheriff
 * 1 Executioner

"No, It's You!"

 * 5 Investigator
 * 5 Sheriff
 * 3 Framer
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Veteran

Mindgames

 * 4 Sheriff
 * 3 Transporter
 * 2 Framer
 * 2 Jester
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mayor
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Investigator

All-Out War

 * 3 Bodyguard
 * 3 Neutral Killing
 * 3 Amnesiac
 * 2 Lookout
 * 1 Mayor
 * 1 Transporter
 * 1 Witch
 * 1 Random Town

VIP

 * 8 Bodyguards
 * 1 Mayor
 * 3 Survivor
 * 2 Serial Killer
 * 1 Godfather

Variation:

 * 7 Bodyguards
 * 3 Serial Killer
 * 1 Mayor
 * 1 Werewolf
 * 1 Neutral Evil
 * 1 Veteran
 * 1 Survivor

King of the Hill

 * 2 Serial Killer
 * 2 Amnesiac
 * 2 Jester
 * 1 Mayor
 * 1 Bodyguards
 * 1 Veteran/Investigator
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Consigliere
 * 1 Janitor/Mafioso
 * 1 Arsonist
 * 1 Werewolf
 * 0-1 Survivor
 * 0-1 Witch

Witch Playground

 * 2 Consort
 * 2 Serial Killer
 * 2 Arsonist
 * 2 Witches
 * 2 Escort
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafioso
 * 1 Werewolf
 * 1 Transporter
 * 1 Investigator/Sheriff

How to Lie

 * 6 Random Town
 * 3 Random Mafia
 * 3 Executioner
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Sheriff
 * 1 Godfather

Surprise, I'm Jester!
Variation:
 * 12 Jester
 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 1 Mayor
 * 1 Bodyguard
 * 12 Jester
 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 1 Mayor
 * 1 Arsonist

Protect the King!

 * 1 Mayor
 * 6 Bodyguards
 * 1 Godfather
 * 5 Random Mafia
 * 1 Survivor
 * 1 Werewolf

Mafia Down

 * 3 Neutral Benign
 * 2 Neutral Evil
 * 2 Neutral Killing
 * 2 Town Investigative
 * 2 Town Protective
 * 2 Town Killing
 * 2 Town Support

Pachinko

 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 1 Doctor
 * 5-13 Transporters

PENTAKILL!

 * 13 Transporters
 * 1 Jester
 * 1 Werewolf

All Evil

 * 4 Serial Killer
 * 2 Witches
 * 1 Werewolf
 * 2 Arsonists
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafioso
 * 1 Random Mafia
 * 1 Janitor
 * 2 Consigliere

Wolf Hunt

 * 14 Vigilante
 * 1 Werewolf

Detective Work

 * 2 Investigators
 * 2 Sheriffs
 * 1 Lookout
 * 1 Spy
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Vigilante
 * 1 Veteran
 * 1 Medium
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Consigliere
 * 2 Mafia Deception
 * 1 Serial Killer

Variation

 * 2 Investigators
 * 1 Sheriff
 * 1 Lookout
 * 1 Spy
 * 1 Medium
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Transporter
 * 1 Town Killing
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1-2 Consigliere(s)
 * 1-2 Mafia Deception
 * 1 Framer
 * 1 Neutral Killing

Variation 2

 * 2 Investigators
 * 1 Sheriff
 * 1 Medium
 * 1 Spy
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Lookout
 * 1 Town Support
 * 1 Town Killing
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Consigliere
 * 2 Mafia Deception
 * 1 Mafia Support
 * 1 Random Neutral

Variation 3

 * 2 Investigators
 * 1 Sheriff
 * 1 Medium
 * 1 Spy
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Lookout
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Consigliere
 * 0-1 Town Killing
 * 2 Mafia Deception
 * 1-2 Neutral Killing
 * 1-2 Executioner(s)
 * 1 Jester
 * 0-1 Amnesiac

Variation 4

 * 1 Investigator
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Medium
 * 4 Town Investigative
 * 2 Random Town
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Consigliere
 * 1 Mafia Deception
 * 2 Random Mafia
 * 1 Random Neutral

Variation 5

 * 1 Investigator
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Medium
 * 4 Town Investigative
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Consigliere
 * 1 Mafia Deception
 * 1 Random Mafia
 * 2 Neutral Evil
 * 1 Neutral Killing
 * 1 Neutral Benign

No Pressure

 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 2 Sheriffs
 * 13 Jesters

Taking Sides

 * 4 Vigilantes
 * 4 Amnesiacs
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafioso
 * 1 Consort
 * 1 Disguiser
 * 1 Janitor

Stop, Drop 'n' Roll

 * 5 Arsonists
 * 5 Transporters
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Witch
 * 2 Executioners
 * 1 Jester

Tricking People

 * 5 Jesters
 * 4 Disguisers
 * 4 Investigators
 * 1 Mafioso
 * 1 Vigilante

Town's Revenge

 * 1 Godfather
 * 2 Mafia Support
 * 1 Random Mafia
 * 4 Town Killing
 * 2 Neutral Evil
 * 2 Neutral Killing
 * 1 Neutral Benign
 * 1 Random Neutral
 * 1 Witch

Blood & Fire

 * 1 Veteran
 * 1 Werewolf
 * 4 Arsonists
 * 9 Serial Killer

Find the Serial Killers (See Top)

 * 2x Serial Killer
 * 2x Witch
 * 1x Executioner
 * 1x Jester
 * 2x Town Protective
 * 3x Town Investigative
 * 1x Jailor
 * 1x Escort
 * 1x Mafioso
 * 1x Any

Variations

 * If you change the number of Serial Killers, make sure the ammount of Neutral Evil goes up 1 or down one. 
 * Changing the Investigative to exact roles makes the game very easy, as Serial Killers can't claim them without being called out, a way around this is reducing the Escort and Mafioso to Anys, and making the Invest roles exact.
 * The Only way a role in this game will not be very effective is if an Town investigative is a Spy, replacing the Any with a Mafia can fix that if needed/wanted.
 * If Witches are annoying, and you remove them be aware of Town's chance to win, as it will go up alot if you remove them without putting in more Evil.
 * The Mafioso can be traded for a Godfather, but then he is immune to the Serial Killer.