Talk:Vigilante/@comment-5366868-20150812011902/@comment-186.244.10.54-20150822164846

Smart mafia will act talkative, so you never know when a mafia is shy or talkative... In the end it will always be random shooting, no matter how much you reason behind it (unless solid proof, but still high chance of fail).

Vigi is a really weak role. Jailor overpowers him in every way. He can effectively roleblock, protect, speak to, execute immunes and survive a failed execution on his target - imba, still lives after executing a townie. Vigilante can only go 360 no scope and hoping to kill a baddie. Heck, he doesn't even know when your target was healed or whatnot, just to shoot him again and confirm. Good vigilantes should be the ones who carefully examinate their targets before shooting then - but, by the time he shoots someone, it's already too late for him, for the town, or the target is sk/gf/arso or something. The only real good vigilantes will be those that go hipfire and keel the hell of a mafia... Just like people comment "good job jailor" when the jailor execute gf n2 cuz... cuz the gf didn't talk, and will comment "good job jailor" sarcastically when he executes the mayor n2 cuz... cuz he didn't talk.