Board Thread:Role Ideas (Rework)/@comment-38127112-20190317175832/@comment-33307613-20190318222132

Connortheandroid wrote:

All my responses refer to ranked games.

Your target leads a group they might be a   or a

'''Leaves only the Bodyguarrd as claimspace for the Coven Leader. As I stated before, all evil roles should be able to claim at least two Town roles in their investigative result. Also, the target is confirmed as Mayor/Bodyguard once the Coven Leader dies.'''

Your target has mental damage they might be a   or a

'''Two Neutral Killings in the same result. Additionally, once the Neutral Killing is revealed as Werewolf or Arsonist, this result confirms the player as Veteran/Vigilante.'''

Your target wastes others time they might be an   or a

'''Confirmed Escort/Transporter, but that's BMG's fault for not making a Coven role that gives a roleblock notification. Fine as is.'''

Your target uses melee weapons they might be a   or a

'''Crusader/Arsonist. I would prefer more claimspace for the Arsonist (but not necessary).'''

Your target is involved with discussions they might be a   or a

'''Medium/Jailor confirmed. Needs a Coven.'''

Your target isn’t a normal human they might be a   or a

'''Werewolf/Psychic. More claimspace for evils (but not necessary).'''

Your target creates items they might be a   or a

'''Doctor/Trapper/Potion Master. Ok.'''

Your target wants chaos they might be a   or a

'''Tracker/Medusa. Claimspace thingy.'''

Your target is stealthy they might be a   or a

'''Spy/Lookout/Poisoner. That's fine.'''

Your target affects the dead they might be a   or a

No claimspace for any evil in this result (except for Disguiser who rarely shows up as its own result).

Your target gathers information they might be an   or a

'''Investigator/Sheriff/Executioner. It's pretty bad, but not horrible. There should be at least a Coven in here.'''

Your target manipulates information they might be a   or an

'''​​​​​​​I don't see why Amnesiac is in here. Additonally, the Jester doesn't belong in framed results. That prevents the Investigator from wanting to hang someone who shows this result.''' Now that I have reread this, I see that it isn't that bad, especially considering the results are for the expansion (there aren't many roles you can pair with Town in a ranked game). All of those that give evils only one Town claim should be worked on but it isn't a necessity. The Retributionist should never be the only Town role in a result.