Thread:Jamieawesome/@comment-35813313-20181218225905/@comment-35026689-20181220175116

I don't play coven and the roles do very different things.

I also accidentally deleted my more detailed reply so this will be in short.

Pirate comes top. I played as pirate during coven free weekend and it was pretty fun to play as. It seems very balanced even if it's partially based on chance.

I actually quite like disguiser, I don't think it should get that much hate. In ranked it has been useful multiple times, either when they think a disguiser is real and mislynch, or when they even think a real person is fake. It has won a fair share of games in ranked. This comes second.

Survivor is middle here, it's boring to play as, but still necessary in ToS as it gives claimspace to evils and it also fits the neutral benign slot perfectly.

Poisoner from what I can see, is not that useful. Doctor's render it redundant because it is easy to heal poisoned people than attacked players. Necro doesn't do much more either, just buffs it slightly.

Vampire hunter is broken as heck, I have played 20 ish games of Dracula's palace and town has won at least 15 of them, all due to VH. It is immune to vamps, has a 100% accuracy in killing vamps unlike vigi or jailor, and retalites in vampire attacks. A broken hardcounter to the broken vampires, and I would not give a fuck if they were obliterated from existence.