Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20171025060017/@comment-33380803-20171026061951

In ranked, wit 9 townies, 4 mafia and 1 nk, bg is definitely better. it will kill one of teh mafia or the nk. If it kills teh nk, basically an auto-town win. If it kills the mafia, that’s one quarter of their team gone while it’s only 1/9 of teh town’s team gone. Doctor howerver may be able to slow things down, which can allow town to have an extra day to vfr, give information. Even if the doctor can save two people, this only retracts two townies from dying, while the bg will cause one mafia to die.

Overall, bg = one mafia dead while doc = save one/two townies BG is better.