Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-30105631-20171210013838/@comment-32783587-20171211233946

In my scenario, there is still 1 more evil than townie... so even if you dont know how many more evils there are, it can still be beneficial to shoot.

i stand corrected about the part where it is ALWAYS beneficial to shoot if theres one more evil. but it still is sometimes.

if theres 1 more town than evil, lets just say theres 50% chance of it being a good idea to shoot.

if theres 2 more, let's say its a 90% chance of a good idea to shoot.

assuming theres an equal chance of there being 1 more and 2 more (if you truly have no idea) than the average is more than 50%, so you should still shoot.

and how random are we talking here? if you have NO idea who's evil, not even by scumreading, that must be you not paying attention. if its that late in the game, you should have some leads, come on.