Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-30131225-20170520103009/@comment-30131225-20170521021340

LivingOvergrowth wrote: Secretive Gurl wrote: Name: Musician

Alignment: Mafia Support

Abilities: Play your musical instrument at someone's house. Ummm, ok

Attributes: Every visiting role in the game will go to your target house except for the Mafia, Neutrals role and Jailor. You can only play your instruments 4 times. You are immune to role blocks.

'''First off, that is EXTREMELY overpowered. It basically role blocks the entire town for a night. Second off, the fact that you can do it four times is already alot. You would have to nerf this down alot and reduce the number of times you could play your instrument.'''

'''Another thing, it would reveal all the mafia if there was a lookout (since all the people that did not come would be revealed). So that would do more harm to the mafia than good.'''

Win with: Mafia, Survivor, Witches

Good

Must kill: Town, Serial Killer, Werewolf, Vampire, Arsonist

Investigation results:

Investigator: Your target sticks to the shadows. They could be the Lookout, Forger, Amnesiac or Musician.

'''Oh good! You changed it!'''

Sheriff: Your target is a member if the Mafia.

Witch and Consigliere: Your target plays very beautifully with the instruments. They must be the Musician! So, I believe this role can either be extremely op for mafia, or extremely op for town (if there is a lookout, like I explained above). If you are going to have a luring mechanic, it needs to be nerfed a little bit and you should only be able to play your instrument 3 times, going with the trend of the rest of the mafia support alignment.

My verdict: Rejected (But can still be revised if you want) well, how about the Town Investigative will not effect by Musician abilities?