Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-28595360-20161106024248/@comment-29669939-20161108071850

Dongarinos wrote: Seth1299 wrote: Dongarinos wrote: CasketRemover wrote: It has a good concept, maybe it could replace sheriff altogether. No. Why are you so opposed to this role? It is not overpowered since it is both unique and cannot have a last will, thus preventing you from confirming people as town in death. You would have to reveal yourself. If the Mafia has a Blackmailer to keep you under wraps, you become completely worthless. However, if there is a Doctor or Bodyguard and you reveal, you may be able to change the game completely and force doubt on people. As Vertroyer once said in response to one of my previous role suggestions, "It is either very strong or completely worthless." 1. It cannot have a last will, and basically leaves nothing behind for others to look at and read. This can make it useless.

2. Alignment investigation is slightly unique. But when you really think about it, where does the detection immunity come into play? Remember how arsonist is detection immune? Unless there is something added to this then I see no need for it.

3. '''Sheriff is perfectly fine the way it is. Sheriff is a classic! Why do we need to get rid of it.'''

Sheriff is a Classic who doesn't do much.

At least buff it to find Neutrals