Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-171.6.206.168-20171208015544/@comment-33877233-20171208131308

171.6.206.168 wrote:

The name makes no sense

Attack: None

Defense: None

Unique: Yes

Astral: No

Mechanics:

You think about someone to know what their class type is. (You can see 2 Hynotist, the reason of that is because Hynotist can either claim TP or TS so it will show up 50% for each, if thinker watch hynotist once, the rest of the time it will remain the same class type)

TI = Executioner, Consigilere, Sheriff, Investigator, Lookout, Tracker, Psychic, Spy, Witch, Forger, Blackmailer, Coven Leader, Werewolf, Poisoner, Plauguebearer/Pestilence, Forger.

TP = Bodyguard, Crusader, Doctor, Trapper, Godfather, Arsonist, Serial Killer, Potion Master, Hynotist

TK = Vigilante, Veteran, Jailor, Vampire Hunter, Ambusher, Mafioso, Medusa, Pirate.

TS = Escort, Transporter, Retributionist, Medium, Mayor, Consort, Hynotist, Janitor, Necromancer.

Unsure = Disguiser, Framer, Framed Target, Hex Master, Hexed Target, Juggernaut, Vampire, Jester, Survivor, Amnesiac. '''Disguiser should show up as their disguised target. Hex Master: TS (probably)'''

Message shown:

TI = He will claim Town Investigative

TP = He will claim Town Protective

TK = He will claim Town Killing

TS = He will claim Town Support

Unsure = I am not sure that what he will claim

Sheriff: Your Target is not suspicious.

Investigator:  Your target could be a Investigator, Consigilere, Mayor, Tracker, Plauguebearer or Thinker.

Witch/Consigilere: Your target think about what another people might claim. They must be Thinker.

Achievement:

Think about it - Win 1 game as thinker

Smarty - Win 5 game as thinker

The brainy one - win 10 game as thinker

The mastermind - win 25 game as thinker

mmmmm? - found all class type in 1 game

Way too much - find 3 of the same class type in a row

Im not that smart - find 5 unsure in total in 1 game

BMG makes Achievements, but nice ideas for them Okay alrighty First, isnt this breaking the fourth wall? Dont mafia members already have like a Job or Role in real life? Anyways lets just take a look at the role

The first issue is how UP, or Underpowered this role is, you basically made a list of the most common claims made by evils, and to be the most common well, its the most used, so this is basically just making a list of common claims by evil, and you get anyone who claims something other then that, I think it is very UP for that reason and for 1 more. The other reason it is very UP is because of the fact that it does not differentiate between Mafia/Coven/Neutral and Town, you can investigate 4 people, an Exe, a Sheriff, another Sheriff, and a WW. And they will all appear as TI, thats the issue. This is only a way to confirm if they claim, and if they are evil then by then they will already be lynched or winning. this is just very UP in general. also the name doesnt make sense