Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-34969116-20180510183422/@comment-35010010-20180512223111

Shebbyking wrote: Name: Mime Seems odd as a name, but, okay.

Alignment: Town Protective K

Attack: Changeable Interesting.

Defense: Changeable Interesting.

Unique Role: No If two mimes were to visit the same person, that may cause issues due to them mimicing one another, which does nothing.

Abilities: At night guard someone's house, if someone tries to visit your target you will perform the same action on the that they tried to perform on their target. (details below) You will also gain the same defence level as the player that visits your target (details below) You can also choose on one occasion to stay at your home and give yourself the same ability. '''What if there are multiple visitors? Also, this seems like some sort of alternate, which I don't feel great about. This role also breaks a rule to making roles, which is essentially being a copycat to other roles.'''

Attributes: None Does this role's attributes change with mimicing other roles' attributes?

Mechanics: When guarding someone you will inflict the following on anyone who tries to visit your target

Escort/consort - roleblock them instead (this will fail because of their immunity but you get the idea) If this role used their self-target ability, or if another of this role targeted this role, and an / visited, it could cause a paradox, which I find absolutely ridiculous.

Mafioso/Godfather/Serial killer/Vigilante - Deal a basic attack '''Seems like behavior except weaker. This seems it could do more harm than good.'''

Werewolf/pestilence/Rampaging  - Deal a powerful rampage attack (this will kill your target as well) This would do more harm than good in many situations.

Arsonist - Douse them instead '''The would be notified of them being doused, and clean it off by doing nothing the next night. Pretty useless, but it slows the a little, I guess.'''

Evil status roles (bmer, janitor, poisoner etc) - inflict the status on them instead Seems like  behavior even more but it also reflects visits that mean no harm.

Jugg - dependable on their power level but do an according attack

Witch - Controls the witch (not to any location) Basically, role blocking the .

Town roles besides mentioned - No effect If this role can't backfire unless they reflect a, than this role just seems OP and broken.

Your defence will also change depending on who is visiting your target - for example you will gain a basic defence if a serial killer attacks your target, because of this you will die if a mafioso, vigilante or werewolf attacks as their attack value is high than their defence. '''Seems quite broken, honestly. roles shouldn't have defenses like this often.'''

-Investigative Results-

Sheriff: Your target is not suspicious

Investigator: Bodyguard, godfather, arsonist, mine Seems like a decent nerf to make this their investigative result, due to it having major evildoers within it.

Consigliere/Witch: Your target copies people, they must be a mime

Goal: Lynch all criminals and evildoers

Wins With: Standard for town

Must Kill: Standard for town

Notes: Though the mime inflicts status such as poison onto the visitor them mime is still affected by the status effect (the mime will be poisoned) Unsure about this but should the mime commit suicide if they mirror a vigilante and are healed. if I have missed anything do tell me. '''This seems even more like behavior. Also, will the visitor's effect be successful on the target or not?'''

Summary: This role seems broken overall.

1. It's a copycat role, which breaks a rule to making roles in ToS.

2. It's basically a, but much more OP in many ways, including:

- Only needs to worry about reflecting and  visits, while the rest of the  can perform their abilities successfully scot-free without interupption.

- Reflects harmful visits as well as non-harmful ones back on the visitor. (Which is most likely an evildoer.)

- Adapts the attack AND defense of a visitor, which seems broken for not just a role, but any role in general, really.

3. I just can't see this role exisiting in ToS. :I

Pros: Little to no pros.

Cons: An OP broken version of the, not much information cleared up regarding whether this role reflects multiple visitors' effects or only a single one's.

OVERALL RATING: 2/10!

Suggestions: Please fix the many issues addressed in the quote and Summary! Thanks!