Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-209.105.187.238-20200101181731/@comment-31256456-20200103024456

If you think of crusader it's just doc with one extra effect. this is a role that is actually more interesting and varied than crusader. I agree with Desert that items don't necessarily break a game- yes, item roles are more likely to be unbalanced, but they CAN be balanced.

I was writing a review until i realized that everything was positive and i couldn't find many things to say (rusty at reviewing as i haven't played the game for a while). There are some unbalanced aspects like the fact that the vest lasts forever. It's pretty good as a role though.

One thing that's unrelated, try to use a specific format that's easier to read. It's a little hard to decipher information from this format.

I think it's important to mention that the goal of a role review is NOT to present a finished product. It is an IDEA that is being presented to all users to check for holes in the role and things to fix, leading up to a finished product. We are not judges but people who want to provide insightful feedback. To immediately deny the role as "irredeemable" is inappropriate. It should only be done if it is clear that the core concept would never work. In this case, I really disagree that "having mechanics similar to doc" destroys the concept completely. Is every single role that gives powerful defence now suddenly a "doc clone"?