Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20171002223259/@comment-31680260-20171007013302

Addfire wrote: Jallybwan wrote: SpacedefenderX wrote: The bottom line is referencing to a weird rolelist

And sometimes it does have to do with some luck, in a classic game the mafia can kill an important role the first night That may be so, but ToS is predominantly skill-based. There's literally zero RNG involved (except for the Coven's inheritance of the Necronomicon... but each role is rather powerful with or without it anyway). I'd disagree that Coven roles can hold their own without the Necronomicon, that's kinda the point of it. We'll agree to disagree then... Potion Master is diverse and quite powerful without the Necronomicon, but with it the thing becomes a broken beast. Same goes for the Medusa - even more so for her.

But even if the Coven DID rely on the Necronomicon, that book is still part of the Coven. It's allowed, fair game, and it will happen in a game of ToS. Just because the Mafia don't have the Necronomicon doesn't mean the Coven aren't allowed to use it.