Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-27552918-20170412143635/@comment-31722862-20170413042258

Alrighty, time to give my first try at reviewing.

First of a Neutral Benign role is meant to try and win with anyone, not just one role. They will side with whoever will give them the best chance, while this will only allow them to win with town and other neutral benign roles.

This is a lot like a vigilante, in which it needs to win with town, but can kill the town. Except this one can ONLY kill the town members and seems to be able to do this as many times as they want, which is a heavily nerfed vigilante.

Yes, this role could identify those who aren't town, but they could very well end up murdering many townies before that point. In a game that contains other killing roles, this could majorly mess up the town from the beginning. The mafia might not vote you up if they know youre this role because they have no real reason to. You cant kill them, and even if you point them out, your search results by the sheriff claim you as Serial Killer. It can make it seem like youre an Serial Killer just out to lynch a few randoms.

The town has even less reason to keep this role alive compared to the Survivor and Amnesiac. The Surivior cant harm them much, outside of lynching. And the amnesiac may decide to side with town if given good reason. Yes this role does need to win with town, but it could be easy for you to accidently kill a townie just by not knowing who they are or a transporter or witch messes you up.