Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-37174991-20181208000534/@comment-28112409-20181208083916

This role is too swingy and luck-based.

Depending purely on RNG, this role can be as worthless as an afk Framer or as decent as any other investigative thata manages to get the right results on the right person for the right situation. The player has no real control over the value of the role or how much he can do for the team, he's as much of a sitting duck as a Psychic is and can only say stuff in the day while being spoonfed in the night.

Worse is the fact that full moon nights can end up being completely useless by picking out a role that's in the graveyard and there is absolutely nothing you can do about it. Another worthless thing is if either nights give you a role that is already known to be in the game, like an already deduced NK or a confirmed role in the rolelist. Again, the issue is the fact that you can do nothing about it.

The evils have nothing to do against a Prophet because of how unpredictable the role is and even the player themselves cannot do anything with the role or make any plays unless RNGesus says "Yes, my child".

Consequently, the role is too swingy.