Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-31680260-20170428082957/@comment-27398195-20170503213437

Addfire wrote: Um... First: Bodygaurd is the worst, just above sheriff in terms of power. As in, it is absolute trash.

'''​You mean besides the fact it protects someone from one attack 100% (except arso ignite if already doused), and killing the attack, which is probably going to be immune, getting rid of either 1/2 of the mafia killing or a total of 100% of neutral killing (unless any is also NK, which rare chance) and is more likely to be revived by Ret (Under Mayor and Jailor and tied with doctor), limiting the deaths per day ratio or the mafia majority chance, it's underpowered? Addfire please.'''

Second: The message, if you think about it, buffs mediums, so they could know about the attack before anyone else.

'''​The dead would know at the end of night, most likely, which is when this killing role will be revealed at the start of day. It doesn't buff mediums.'''

Third: I know that you play ranked and ranked practice a ton, but what about All Any (my favorite mode)? This role would be a lot more powerful there...

​It would be a lot more powerful there because all any is meant to be chaotic, don't compare roles with All Any, as it just doesn't work, as Ranked is supposed to be balanced while All any is unbalanced.

And it's actually, if anything, a buffed sk clone as it has the potential to kill through immunity.

​For only chance of killing 1/2 night immune roles, big whoop.

Depending on the mafia? Maybe.

But I still think it's doable.

​And I don't think it is, as it's an UP sk