Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20180318084436/@comment-32994909-20180407105746

Since everybody is on the side of Jailor not being OP, I am going to join the side of Jailor being just as broken as your dad's condom.

Alright, so Jailor is the most powerful town role. It's so powerful that it's ON the role list for Ranked. The problem with this is, it's too much pressure for just one player. The player who gets Jailor has such a big responsibility - and whether the Jailor is a good player or not is a huge gamechanger for town. For example, the Jailor could execute 3 evils which is literally half of all the evils in Ranked, or he could just execute a townie and become useless. Roles should not be so powerful like this, all of the town roles should be somewhat equally powerful, so everybody has the same chance of changing/carrying the game for town.

It makes other roles literally useless. Why would you need an Escort, Vigilante or Doctor when you have a Jailor?

- it's a role blocker, but unlike Escort it overrides role block immunity and cannot be controlled to random role block someone.

- it's a killer, but unlike Vigilante it has an Unstoppable attack which can kill roles with basic defence, and again it cannot be controlled to random kill someone unless the controller guesses who the Jailor has jailed - which is a rare chance. it also does not commit suicide after executing a towne.

- it even works as a Doctor, it gives the prisoner Powerful defence. But a better Doctor, because even if it's role blocked or controlled, the prisoner will still have Powerful defence. It can even protect revealed Mayors!