Talk:Unique Role/@comment-28286738-20160714225631/@comment-28112409-20160715104317

We have a moderator who prefers the role ideas on a board for itself, thus, the link I posted.

You have some good solutions, excellent work!

You solved the 1st one very well....unless the rogue is a kill-happy newbie then it'll still suck for him till he gets the hang of the role

As for the 2nd one... I think I saw many Survivors and Executioners offering to help either mafia, town or whatever faction for the win. Most them ended up in the grave either by killing or lynching.The Rogue is even more threatening with his killing capabilities and you dunno when he might kill either faction's member. You also can't really know roles from the start every time you play, D1 to D3 usually start out blind with no info until you advance further. Some towns and mafia will accept the Rogue, others will just want him dead. But it's still a pretty good solution.

for the 3rd one, what guarantees that a Rogue will be peaceful? That would be very unlikely, because I have never seen a peaceful Killer at ALL! I got nothing wrong, you didn't get my point. I'm saying that killers can't just be peaceful all of a sudden and expect everyone else to be Ok with them being peaceful. They won't trust the Rogue and may even Proceed to eliminate him. Still a problem cuz he can flip to either faction at any moment, even when peaceful. In addition to the other factions trying to kill him if he sides with one.And don't forget, not everyone will think exactly like you do in terms of how to play the Rogue, players have different playstyles with every role and the difference won't be a surprise for this role as well.

It's a really good idea, but if you want people to see the role idea more in the place where it's supposed to be, use the link I posted. Our good ol' moderator Bobby The Blobby has made this specifically for role ideas so it's better if you post it there my good sir!

Thank you for your friendly talk and have a nice day!