Board Thread:Role Ideas/@comment-27.75.188.223-20160727125855/@comment-28912489-20160801231723

Vertroyer wrote: Emz Gurl wrote: Vertroyer wrote: 27.75.188.223 wrote: Vertroyer wrote: I really do like this role, it's very clever...

but it's luck based on who the random target will be....

breaks the role idea rules in the forums and could be really tipsy when implemented in-game. I was going to make this like a mafia's version of the witch but I think is too Op. Thank god you didn't, it's always horrible to make versions of a role for another faction regardless of what the roles,buffs or nerfs you do to it are. quite a few of the mafia roles are buffs from the town roles eg consort & consig (without the guesswork). Plus I made a role which is sort of a buff on the transporter (maf role) and people seem to think it is pretty good! But here's the thing, consort and consigliere were originally in the game and were not role ideas. The rules in the BMG forums clearly state that Roles Ideas should not use the concept of being a maf version of a town role as it usually ends up awfully.

Also, where did you make that role, in this wiki or the BMG forums? Wikia.