Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20171025060017/@comment-31680260-20171027040338

KarpToEndAllKarps wrote: ProfessorArceus wrote: RubikJohn wrote: Team Doctor.Main reason why doctor is better is that he can save many lives and last a lot longer.

I'll argue more later, gtg sleep Haven't we addressed this point already? We don't have numbers on how many protections a Doctor gives on average. This relies heavily on something incalculable and unless you have numbers, this isn't really an argument. In order for Doctor to be on par with BG, it has to heal at least 2-3 people.

Get numbers or this argument is null.

It seems you're trying to avoid this argument.

Probably because you know it's a completely valid point. '''Completely valid, eh? False. Without evidence and numbers to back something up, all you rely on is opinion and emotional rhetoric. When someone resorts to that in an argument, the other person's already won - it's a last resort, and it means you have nothing else to go on.'''

Any argument about what's stronger in a game as reliant on skill as Town of Salem is should look at  ''potential. '''Doc and BG have different potential to do different things. You're thinking one-dimensionally. They're two different roles, so it makes sense they do two different things, yes?'

Doctor has the potential to heal ''infinite targets. ''BG has the potential to protect 1 and kill 1 (again, TK's do its job better). '''Keyword: POTENTIAL. And if we're speaking practically, the Doc can't heal infinite targets since a game doesn't last until the end of time. The Doctor heals someone, true, but that killer is still out there and still a threat - and it's unlikely you'll be able to protect their second victim unless it's late in the game. The BG, however, eliminates that evil PERMANENTLY, and it's one step closer to victory for the Town. It's not worth trading a temporary protection for something permanently crippling to the evils.'''