Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20171114075305/@comment-32881402-20171120235838

Addfire wrote: ProfessorArceus wrote: Thatsmuggamer wrote: DO YOU NOT READ? I said what you're suggesting is making BM'er UP. Not satisfied? Here's why: silencing a player is not enough because that's one person. If you can hear whispers, you can easily decide who to silence next. It's an easy process. I do read, but you weren't getitng your point across.

The fact that it affects 1 person is irrelevant - majority of PRs affect 1 person.... Invest, Janitor, Consig, Consort, Escort, the list goes on.

If you can hear whispers, you prevent mayor games. Not a bad thing. But then you're also preventing communication between the NK and the NE. The NK already has horribly low winrates and it needs the NE on its team. To eliminate this problem, too, we give this ability to an NE role. Then, it prevents mayor games and doesn't harm anyone. So... why nerf BMer, then? Just buff another role, like maybe exe or witch, or even create a new role! Leave BMer alone. Because BMer has that issue that NEs wouldn't have. There are better alternatives to BMer hearing whispers. And if we don't need BMer, the problem is still there. We'd be buffing an NE role, yes. BMer still has that problem.