Board Thread:General Ideas/@comment-30088034-20190329010104/@comment-34403911-20190330042234

Connortheandroid wrote: Custom game system is really not good currently. Its actually pretty fine tbh   'Talking from personal experience, it takes a lot of time and retries to get one of my own servers where i can create a role list. What evidence do you have to support your claim that the Custom Game System is fine?'

So my idea is to scrap repicking, and let players see all available lobbies and their role lists: this finna prevent every custon game from being ruined by repickers and last second leavers. 15 second ban for leaving a game before it starts, not letting repicking is a terrible idea, this allows trolls to make bad role lists and not get removed at all

'''What he wants is room/lobby lists. If the trolls want to make lobbies, they can, but no one will join theirs. And also, trolls with two accounts is enough to bypass this.'''

this will also fix the problem where if you leave a custon match, you will join back in the same one, yeah but like, this also results in everyone just making their own lobby instead of joining others

'''Basic common sense dictates that eventually people are going to not make their own lobby and join a good role list lobby; political parties are a good metaphor. People with bad role lists will get tired of people immediately coming into the server, seeing a horrible role list, and leaving; they'll eventually move to a better server.'''

creating an infinite cycle of joining and leaving 15 second ban

What he means is that you're trying to find another room, not trolling intentionally

--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--/--

1. what's an example of a bad role list? even highly unbalanced ones, like 6 arsos and 1 town, are still pretty fun. Even bad AND unfun ones will have no one join them making the problem obsolete. How you sayin thats fun my man? Being the townie would just suck because you’d get lynched upon discoverey

'''Sometimes your version of fun is different from other people's; You can't really say rainbow mode is fair for the town, or that ranked is fair for the werewolf, but they are good role lists nonetheless. Sometimes a challenge is what people need, if there is no guaranteed way to win for either team. The arsonists could easily burn up the other arsonists, and a good town, especially something like a vet could definitely be seen winning.'''

2. maybe a limit for the amount of total lobbies? i think the problem fixes itself- if there are too many lobbies and not enough people, they will get bored and simply decide to join other ones, evening out then if there are trolls they will flud the lobbies

'''That's the reason for "hosts" of a certain lobby. Another point that is wrong with custom mode rn is how Hosts have so little power; they only make the role list and that too will make the host face the trial of votekicking. If the hosts, instead, are allowed to kick people or even make passworded lobbies, it would be way better. Don't know if this is what OP intends, but I'm taking my room inspiration from http://bonk.io/.'''

3. the 15 second ban thing is the worst! it punishes you for leaving games you dont want to do, and you still end up joining the exact same match causing games to never start. my idea will also fix that  you dont end up in the same match because by then the server was filled

'''Not always; most of the time it isnt, and sometimes its literally just 4 people, or even worse some afk host in a solo room. And plus, your point that you just gave directly counters your point 2; the match will fill up after the trolls leave.'''