Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-36558623-20181022031957/@comment-36558623-20181029000440

BendBones wrote: Suppose you want a review?

Faraday242 wrote: Name: look up buddy mhm, usual name, but if "look up buddy" is your chosen name, thats ok like of course it's gonna be called the stree fighter haha

Alignment: Neutral (Evil)

Game Information/Background: (optional) no

Attack: None

Defense: None

Unique Role: No

Priority: 2 okay, so can or can't it be roleblocked?

Abilities: You will overkill those who have recently suffered from attacks. ooh, lets see

Attributes: If any of your targets die, their role and will won't be revealed to anyone. Not even you. '''why? This may make this role kinda OP if they fint a killing role that want a boost. If helping or  it would be like having a '''

'''the point of an NE is to cause chaos, and this does exactly that. besides, it wouldn't be easy to find Mafia/Coven anyway'''

Mechanics: (How It Works)

- There will be five buttons, 1 (players 1-3), 2 (players 4-6) 3 (players 7-9) 4 (players 10-12) and 5 (players 12-15) Okay, seems resonnable, but if multiple people whitin one group is attacked, who do you attack?

'''good question. my natural instinct would be both, but if that's too OP it could just be from 1-3 (if 1 and 2 is attacked 1 will be beat)'''

- If any of the people in your button die you will increase their attack by one (basic ---> powerful ---> unstoppable) mhm

- If you beat someone that night, you gain basic defense that night. sounds fair

- If you beat someone, their will and role are both not revealed to the town. As said earlier, kinda strong, would change this to only will

'''that would be heavily UP, because it would barely do anything. TK doesn't use a will. TP/TS barely need it. TI is the only one.'''

-Investigative Results-

Sheriff: Your target is Not Suspicious. k

Investigator: Your target must be a Medium, Janitor, Retributionist, or Street Fighter. + and 

tbh, I feel like BG/GF/Arso or Sheriff/Exe/WW works better, but that would make 3 evils in 1 result, which is UP for those roles. mhm, but working whit dead bodies is what he does, right?

Consigliere/Witch: Your target only fights those who are already defeated, they must be a Street Fighter. Cool, you managed to make it atleast kinda original

Goal: Beat four people. Again, if you join the early on you will win easily, maybe live till the end of the game or see the  lose, idk

Wins With: Evils

Must Kill: Town

Hungry for more? these are mostly un-reviewed. Detective, Tactician , Gravedigger, Revenant, Historian, Western From you? see senõr

Also, this role could be re-worked into a Town (Protective) that selects 1-3 targets. if someone dies they deal a powerful attack to the attacker and bash them. if there's more then one attack, the street fighter kills someone with higher priority. (seems to similar to bg rn though so i made this from that) I like it as  Overall: Cool role, but it should be changed so it isnt too much of a /  look alike

how so? thanks for reviewing!