Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-37421692-20190430215039/@comment-33307613-20190503112550

Orecreeper wrote: Connortheandroid wrote:

NapstablookInfinity wrote:

Connortheandroid wrote: Auto confirms two townies which is problematic in general, wastes a night for an NK / mafioso kill, brings back a townie, allowing them to continue using their abilities, grants another vote from a confirmed townie, and is possibly the most mindless role there is, it requires literally no thought or skill to do good as, its just free confirming

Orecreeper, youre argument isnt good mainly because, like I said earlier, retributionist doesn’t require judgement, for something like sheriff, they would have to check on who they think is evil using their own judgement, meanwhile the retributionist presses one button But literally isn't Janitor like the exact same thing lmao. You just like, literally just clean the Mafia kill every night. Deciding when to clean is still more strategic than pressing one buttton But you have to decide when to rezz. You obviously wouldn't rezz a Medium, and you wouldn't rezz a Sheriff or a Spy unless there is a need for one. The challenge in Ret is to know when to revive, and not only that but who to revive. If you think about it, the earlier you revive, the earlier you become useless. You should always be reviving the first Town member that dies anyway. Doing anything else is risking way too much, especially when all Town Protectives and Lookouts are on the Jailor.