Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-98.116.89.145-20171105235559/@comment-33636831-20171123053755

ProfessorArceus wrote: Salem, it's Town Support. It isn't going to have any additional attack value or any additional defence value because Night Immune Townies are both nonexistent and awful. I think you know why. I'll wait until your edit. The Cat is no different from the Escort. The dog is objectively more powerful than the cat, since you'll just become and Escort and you'll kill scum. In the end, this is a JoAT for Town. The point of having more roles is do that we don't need these roles that can do anything and everything. The idea of a dog is just a more powerful Bodyguard, when Bodyguard is already insanely overpowered (see the debate) since it's only eliminating 1 of the Tamer's tools. The cat shows no originality and is objectively worse than the dog since they both RB. It's an Escort-BG hybrid, which is too powerful for the Town. Agreed, I feel that it really is very Op but I can't put my finger on why.