Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-33167183-20171224002504/@comment-33877233-20171229021838

Swagscope123 wrote: Betimawesome wrote: WHO SAID ROLES HAD TO BE HUMAN? ​BMG obviouslySummary: You are a loyal dog who wants your owner to live

Alignment: Neutral (Benign)

Unique? No.

Attack: Basic | Defense: None

Death message: He/She was bitten by a Dog

​

Attributes: You can't chat during the day, Only bark when put on trial. (This will appear as "Bark") '''​So your gonna be bmed every day? That would suck. Also, what about woof and ruff.'''

You will be assigned a random person, You must keep them alive during the whole game (Too similar to GA?)

'''​Yes. This is also closely knit to lovers mode too. '''

'''​Also will your owner know that your his dog? Or only you like GA?'''

Grants your owner Basic defense.

​Great...now you don't need to protect him as most attackers like mafioso and SK have basic attack.

If your owner dies, You will "run away from town" (Your character model (And house?) will be gone, and the town will be told in chat that a dog ran away)

'''​Does that mean your dead? Or just unable to do anything?'''

​If its the 2nd one then that would ruin a game.

(Your target is not a town member.)

Abilities: Every night, Give your target Basic defense. You will bite their attacker.

(You cannot write in a last will) ​Welp now alot of evil roles will claim dog so they won't have to make a will/

Sheriff: Your target is not suspicious.

Investigator: Your target could be a Survivor, Vampire Hunter, Witch, or dog | Your target could be a Survivor, Vampire hunter, Medusa, Psychic, Dog. (Idk what else)

Consigliere/witch/pm/cl : Your target is a loyal pet. They must be a dog.

Honestly, This is quite similar to the Guardian Angel, and I'm not even sure if animal-roles are allowed, other than that i dont see any problems. Problems

1) Too similar to GA

2) Evil roles will easily win by claiming dog

3) Dog would suck as you have to be bmed all day and attract a lot of suspicion

Suggestion

1)Fix the problems

2) Make it so the only person who can hear you are other dogs and your owner. Everyone else will just hear you say "woof" or "bark"

3)kys Dont make those jokes

otherwise I like your points I agree this feels like a GA Rehash, also NB cant kill and are exactly what they say: "benign" If it only helps evils it should be Neutral Evil or Neutral Chaos or something, just not NB.