Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-29779988-20161203164555/@comment-29779988-20161203204714

ChickenPieNuggetz wrote: Okay, so let's see here. 1. So you target someone and kill them and you? What if it was a NK? You win instantly.

'''Nonono. I don't mean it like that. I mean the fact that if it's a neutral at all, you cannot win with any neutral roles. This means survivor as well. '''

2. It's doesn't do anything much. You might say that Executioner and Jester don't have any abilities, but two words - Fun and Challenging. You might not see the fun in the witch, but it's definitely challenging. I see no fun or challenge in this role.

'''This is the very reason I cannot even make neutral roles. They're either too boring, or too complex. There is no 'in the middle' for roles like that. '''

'''And also, explain survivor. Explain how that's fun in the slightest compaired to this.'''

3. Too simple. (That sounds weird but trust me.)

'''But that's the thing. People try so hard to create such hard and complicated neutral roles that it's mainly the reason I reject them all the time. If you just look at a basic idea and spring off of it, that makes it different.'''

4. Why do you hate neutral roles?

'''Because it's too hard to create them, personally. I always reject them for being complex, not being complex enough, or just flat out being a copy of Serial Killer or survivor. They're almost all alike in some sort of way, shape, or form.'''

You can see what I think of the role (If you can't, then I would reject the role).

But I do like the originality of the idea. '''Why do I continue to try to fix this role? I hate making these kinds of roles. '''

'''HINT: Never ask me to make more neutral roles. I'll spoil you with town and mafia roles, sure. But that's it.'''

1. I'll make it more challenging for the unibomber to specifically win. For example, they're not night immune so they can be killed easily.

2. I see no way for now how to make it a challenge. Feel free to leave suggestions I guess.

3. If you see anything else, tell me, but I believe I'm going to scrap this role.