Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-38045493-20190202130005/@comment-33307613-20190203235803

I don't think that the Sheriff needs a buff at all. It's my opinion that most Town Investigative roles in the game are overtuned and need some nerfs (excluding the Tracker and Sheriff). The Sheriff can reliably find three Mafia and sometimes the Neutral Killing but not the Godfather or Neutral Evils. The Tracker can determine killers and evildoers with "loud" notifications but may confuse it with other visitors. Those are examples of balanced Town Investigatives but then there are the other ones. The Investigator locks most evildoers into only one Town claim, which doesn't provide much wiggle room. The Lookout is truly only powerful because it can confirm itself very easily (please add the Osservatore). The Spy confirms all visitors as non-Mafia, can determine who the Neutral Killing/Executioner/Witch are, and confirms Town members alongside a Lookout. The Psychic is just stupid. It can reliably find a non-Town role every other night with 100% accuracy. Additionally, its ability is way too passive for its level of power.

TLDR: Sheriff and Tracker are balanced Town Investigatives. The other four need nerfs/overhauls.