Talk:Town of Salem Rules/@comment-27016593-20150925030153/@comment-25646419-20150925033224

There have been past reports somewhat similar to this where the mods have said that the mafia member being thrown under the bus must agree to it. However, everyone knows that is tricky because there could be a possible spy which would just ruin everything. What you did was pretty interesting.

"Amnesiacs would follow up on their promise to join the mafia" - Both amnesiacs said that out loud? In a whisper? If they never actually said anything about joining mafia, that won't look good for you. If you've typed in the chat (even at the end of the game) explaining why you did what you did, you may actually be alright. You did it for strategy. It really is a grey area, similar to when people write a will where they list one real mafia member and one fake one.

That will be shapesifter's call... or the judges' call if the report enters the Trial System whenever that's being released.