Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32994909-20180607203338/@comment-32994909-20180609144427

Jamieawesome wrote: JamJamalWiki wrote: Well, this is a great tragedy. I hate alternative solutions, but it seems two might have been found for the first question.

> If 's attack potion is not used up when visiting a jailed target, THEN GamesManiac would be correct in saying that the attacked Player X on the first night causing Player X to receive the first notification, and the second notification could have been produced if Player X was a  and got a notification from failing to duel its target due to being hauled off to jail, as HAWAIIANpikachu said.

> If can attack a  who counter-attacks the  THEN Jamieawesome would be correct in saying Player X was a, and got it's first notification from attacking the , and the second from being attacked by the.

However, I'm not accepting either as complete solutions. In this riddle, the true solution also proves what Player Y and Player Z are. I know that BG can defend from Sk that breaks out of Jail, I'm pretty sure that Crus can too

'''Well, let's just assume that can for now. You found an alternative solution for the first part of the question, but I need a solution which would step-by-step also prove what Player Y and Player Z.'''

Also i just realised X can't be pirate ​​​​​​​Well I did state that as my first hint, but okay.