Board Thread:What happens in Salem/@comment-31953669-20180923003253

This was a Ranked Practice game.

I roll Godfather. Mafia consists of two Janitors, myself and a fairly competent Mafioso.

N1 a Janitor dies and ends up in the Graveyard. D2 someone claims Serial Killer. We think "bad Jester or bad evil masquerading as Jester". An executioner gets Town to lynch the Lookout, so everyone's thinking SK claim is just an evil trying to do the Jester thing that some people try sometimes.

That night, we kill and clean someone. Jailor kills me (the Jailor was too aggressive that game, which bit him in the ass later), but my mafia live on. That day, the SK claim is dead by Vigilante.

Role: Lookout. Because there was a Janitor in the Graveyard and a Cleaned corpse the following night, Town knew that he wasn't Disguiser.

This is where the game got stupid. I was telling everyone to report the SK claiming bumfuzzle when he tried to defend himself by basically saying that in Town of Salem, everyone lies.

''This wasn't fucking classic. ''

He didn't justify the claim, which made zero strategic sense for the town. We ended up winning the game because of my Mafioso pulling through and Jailor jumping the gun on a suspected Mafia, but it felt hollow. Fuck throwers, honestly. 