Board Thread:What happens in Salem/@comment-35195751-20181110173824

You've all played with "that one maf"

The Mafioso who claims vigilante despite the other 3 TK being dead

The Consort that posts their escort will AFTER the spy reveals who the mafia visited

Well today I played in a game where every single maf was "that guy"

Mafia 1:

On Day 2 a sheriff claim (Jack) says that he is Mafia

He claims he was framed all the way up to the stand

with 10 seconds left he posts a sloppy will along the lines of

Sheriff: N1-Jack/Mafia

He was Consigliere

Mafia 2:

Not much to say here except that a Disguiser should never claim Veteran in jail

Mafia 3:

He gets jailed and attacked twice (this is the mafioso)

He says this to town

At this point there are 2 vig claims and a vet claim

He claims Veteran

He is lynched immediately

Mafia 4:


 * Ok there are 3 people who havent claimed  (including the Godfather) one is an Arsonist and one is a vig.


 * There are only 5 players, most of them are TI but there is a Jailor without Exes


 * An unrevealed Vigilante just shot the Vet (Whos will was seriously "Im not alerting to teach vig a lesson")


 * and the Invests screwed up their jobs, so no one was investigated.

YOU'D EXPECT: He claim that  he was the Vigilante who just shot the Veteran, have the (rather obvious) Arsonist lynched and kill the Jailor, leaving only him and the Sheriff

BUT NOPE: He states that anyone could be the arsonist and trys to get the Sheriff to claim (again)

At least there was no ine to feel bad for 