Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-30331403-20161120192130/@comment-30331403-20161128202129

Dongarinos wrote: KennyAriesInfiniteXV wrote: Role Name : Director Role Alignment : Neutral Benign

'''It doesn't make sense to have this as Neutral Benign. They don't really benefit anybody else by collecting film. Nevertheless, compare that to survivor or amnesiac. They actually help not only themselves, but they help other people as well. This role only seems to help themselves. So if anything, I'd see it as a... well... I don't really know. It cannot be Neutral (Chaos) or Neutral (Killing) since it cannot kill. The only available option would Neutral (Evil) but they aren't a harm...... So I don't really know.'''

'''I guess your only choice is Neutral Benign. But for me to approve this, it has to somehow benefit others.'''

Goal : Live to see your film published.

'''Oh no... I've already seen something like this. I'm actually kinda scared now. Lets hope this isn't what I think it is.'''

Summary : You are a movie director looking for his chance to make it big.

Abilities : Set a camera at somebodies house. After your film is published, you are immune.

Maybe, maaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaybe this has a chance!

Attributes : Put cameras at people's houses to collect a scene. (Recordable events are listed below). You need three recordable scenes to be able to publish your film. The killer will know they were recorded. Camera can be destroyed by a werewolf.

'''Annnnnnd nevermind.... this is exactly like I thought.... yikes. Well buddy, lemme tell you something. I highly doubt this will make it to BMG.'''

Sheriff - Your target is not suspicious.

Investigative Results -  Your target is waiting for the perfect moment to strike. They could be the  Sheriff,   Executioner,  Director  or  Werewolf.

'''Very lovely idea! I was hoping you'd put that here. Good idea!'''

Consig Results - Your target will stop at nothing to retrieve a film piece, he must be a  Director!

'''I would say create of something more original, but it would sound too corny. Maybe something like Your target has an eye for film success. They must be a director!'''

Recordable Scenes -

- Serial Killer, Mafia kills (must put your camera either on the killer or victim)

- Arsonist Ignites (On an ignited townie)

- Vigilante Shoots (camera on him only.)

- Bodyguard Protection (He must die protecting)

- Jailor Execution.

'''-Might I add something? An escort/consort roleblocking someone... for y'know... those kinds of scenes... I DIDN'T SAY WHAT. YOU GET THE POINT!!!!'''

'''Okay, so this is actually a bit different than what I saw before. So basically, all you want is to create your movie, and you don't get results as you said below. But now this is my problem. Does doing this potentially DAMAGE anything among these roles? '''

Messages In Certain Situations -

Killer is Recorder - You saw cameras outside the victims house! (This doesn't stop them from killing)

'''This might just be the changing point in this role for me. I can now see why it would be Neutral (Benign) more than I could before. The fact that it does not change anything is actually quite perfect.'''

Film Director Catching Recordable Scene - Your cameras caught something good!

'''OKAY PERFECT. So this role is actually different than I thought. This is a perfect idea. '''

Additional Info -

The killer knows they were recorded, but they will not know WHO did it.

Wins with -

Town, Mafia, Serial Killers, Arsonists, Survivors, Witches, Vampires

Must Kill -

Werewolves

'''What? This does not make sense. Are you saying you must kill werewolves because they ruin your film? Otherwise, this does not make sense.''' ...This role honestly needs a loooooooooooooooooooooooot of work... but I'll see...

1. I'm still on edge with the alignment of this because rather than helping other roles, this role mostly benefits itself. But at the same time, it also does not cause any trouble... plus later on, it's an additional vote. However, it's nearing survivor almost at the same time. So I'm concerned with it. But it at least gives you something to do!

2. Add one more boundary to the film case thingy...' You know what I mean. '

3. In my opinion, get rid of the need to kill werewolves.... I just dont see why it needs to be a thing. Most neutral benign roles can win with anything. I just see no need for the grudge other than destroying film.

4. I need to understand something. What happens if you get witched?

If you answer my questions, I'll either approve or reject it. http://town-of-salem.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:94393

That's an updated version I made that should clear all of these questions.