Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-27552918-20170512143410/@comment-27910165-20170513011502

TheDragonMaster825 wrote: Alignment; Mafia (Support)

Summary; A man who does anything to disrupt peoples activities

Ability; Select a person to observe and another to disrupt, the second target will use the first target's night ability instead of their own

'''Every night? Seems a bit powerful... I say give it limited uses and/or every other day.'''

Both targets become temporarily transport and control immune

This wouldn't work since this role +Trans/Witch all do their ability at night.

'''I say Trans/Witch have a higher priority. There  is no reason reason your targets should be immune.'''

You only visit the SECOND target.

You will be shot by the Veteran if you try to DISRUPT them.

No...Only if they are on alert...

 You cannot disrupt Non-town Killing roles, Your own Mafia, a Witch and Non-Visiting roles.

 '''This makes no sense... I say you should be able to disrupt everyone but Witch+Mafia. '''

 '''These rules should apply to who you can observe. You can't observe Witch, Jailor, WW, Arsonist, SK, and no Mafia (No NKs since you would know who they are AND Mafia/NK would get more kills per night.)'''

 If you are controlled by witch, your first target does   not change, but their second target becomes your second target.

 Good.

Unique effects will happen to people being observed, so if an investigator shot a townie with a vigilantes night ability, then the original vigilante will die of guilt for example.

Sounds good.

If someone would get a message (such as peoples roles), that someone would receive the message, not the other target.

'''So the person getting observed gets two results and the person you are disrupting gets none? Please explain. Also, does the person you observe get roleblocked or something, or do their role as normal?'''

If you disrupt someone using transporters night ability, they will transport themselves with who they visit.

'''Sounds good. '''

Sheriff; Your target is a member of the Mafia!

Investigator; Your target is skilled at disrupting others, they could be an escort, transporter, consort or a troublemaker

'''There's two problem with this. While yes, it makes sense, BUT... First: Esc/Con+Trans are all confirmable, revealing you immediatly. Second, TS/TS/MS/MS... Too many of one type of role in a single Invest result.'''

Consigliere; Your target is always up to no good, they must be a TroubleMaker!

Gameplay example; TroubleMaker decides to observe player 1 and disrupt player 2. Player 1 is escort, Player 2 is investigator. Player 2 will receive a message on a players role and that player will be roleblocked by Player 1.

Extra Notes; I didn't make this role Neutral (Evil) because they are supposed to only disrupt town, this role has the power to disrupt the entire Mafia aswell, which is why I made this role Mafia (Support) to get rid of the issue. But without that then this role could be too UP.

'''Witches can also harm the town. Neutral Evil isn't supposed to HELP Mafia... NE is supposed to HARM town. NE is allowed to harm Mafia/NKs.''' Ok, so, I'm a bit confused.

Player 1 is escort, and 2 is Invest.

2 uses his ability on 3. Does 2 still investigate him?

Does 2 visit him or does 1 visit him.

Do they both visit him?

Answer some of the questions please.

As of right now I am leaving this role as LOL IDK MAYBE KEK KMS