Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20180318084436/@comment-33586669-20180326180755

Tinylad wrote: Yeah, well, I understand you Poly. Jailor is OP. It is 4 roles combined. But I think it add an air of danger for the evils. Who's side are you on, ma dude? SK/WW/Pest (on a Full Moon): You want that Jailor dead before he jails you and you are revealed. Jailors usally jail silent people, and considering how SK/WW/Pest are usally quiet, it sort of forces the NKs to talk. Also, if Jailor exe's you and Escort/Consort is impossible, yet you don't die, '''YOU ARE ONE DEAD PESTILENCE. ''You say usually. Stop misjudging everything just based off of a specific scenario. It's not common SK kills you if you're Jailor, thus there's an achievement for it. And it's not the type of achievement that's cheap and common, like the Investigator investigating someone, or a Sheriff achievement. Again, this is a possibilty, not a guarantee that this will happen. '

Mafia: Once the Jailor sees the mafia DN was different when he jailed the mafioso, your mafioso is done for. You and GF could share DNs, but a new player will be caught out with this. Stop stop stop stop stop basing this off of possible scenariosssssssss

Jester: When it's painfully obvious that you are Jester, the execution may be coming your way. Jailor may be mercyful, but the vigilante is also a factor. So the Jesters have to be believable. '''That all depends on the jester, and the jailor's choice of whether or not the Jester will survive. It also depends on the town of the Vigilante, so it's not absolutely impossible. '''

Exe: If someone is claiming Sheriff, Invest, LO or Tracker goes haywire on a townie, and produces no other results, everyone knows who the exe is. Again, Jailor may be merciful, but.... maybe not. 'You can actually say something, you know. Player's arent mute in jail, they're allowed to talk. And if you went haywire on a townie, then you can just say you're exe and you won if that "haywire" was a trigger on the exe's target. '

So, it forces the evils to step up their game, I think it is very good. '''There's a jailor in every ranked and ranked practice game, so like, you always need to be alert. Not like you can just slack off while playing just beause they'res not a specific role there. It's a game where you lie and act like you're a townie if you're evil, not a situational something. '''