Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-32487879-20170323194807/@comment-32487879-20170325175257

Yeah...

but I think I have some ideas.

First off, let's look at which roles don't visit, which would be detected by the Lookout:

Town:

Medium, Retributionist, Mayor, Spy, Veteran. I'm not so sure about whether Jailor visits or not, but it wouldn't be visible by the lookout.

Mafia: None. They're all pretty spic-and-span people.

Neutral: Everything EXCEPT NK and NC.

So basically, all that really matters is: how do you get rid of the remaining six Townies that don't visit?

I would argue that you could first off, change mechanics once all visiting roles die (and I mean ALL). However, there are two roles that interfere with this: the Retributionist and Amnesiac.

Both of these can bring visiting roles back into the game, and therefore somehow these "changed mechanics" have to be able to affect them too.

See, Passive Neutral Killing is surprisingly difficult. So keeping all of these in mind, let's think together of a way to counter these shenanigans.