Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-30105631-20161117060909/@comment-24675428-20161122225901

Vertroyer&#039;s Boyfriend wrote: Addfire wrote:

Vertroyer&#039;s Boyfriend wrote: its luck if you get a role that you suck at

its luck that everyone else on your team gets a role that they suck at

its luck that everyone else on the opposite faction gets a role that they're good at

its luck if mafia finds jailor night one

if bodyguard gets a counter attack

'''Not nessecarily... You could protect people who the Mafia want dead.'''

but it doesn't work out that way every time, sometimes mafia will risk a TP and sometimes they won't, which is luck

if doctor heals the right people (even though some choices are more logical than others, doesn't make it skill)

'''Oh you acknowledged it. But yeah see above, and Id say that it's skill.'''

if vampires bite important town

That's skill

'no i mean when you are NOT the vampire. so if vamps get lucky and find jailor or tp night one, and you are town its unlucky.'

if amne remembers good or evil

'''If you are the amne, you can win a team the game. So that's skill.'''

once again i meant if ANOTHER amne remembers something, which could screw you or give you free elo (should have clarified)

if sheriff finds anyone sus or not sus

if town sucks

and ANY SLOT that could get filled with consig or mayor.

also basically every random town neutral or evil slot

Okay, getting roles is luck, yes, but skill is based on how good you are with all the roles.

Someone who is good with all the Roles isnt going to complain about the random draw of roles, so skill is involved there.

The other players you play with is luck, yes, ill admit to that, but how you manipulate the minds of bad players on either side to vote or use abilities or dont attack or do attack is skill. If they suck, manipulate them, if they are good, play with them, if evil against them.

n1 killing isnt luck. As Jailor, calling for TP or sayin something to deter evils from killing you n1 is SKILL

and all other things about finding or attacking roles or doing your ability on the correct role comes from scumreading, claim space, and in total skill and if you WANT to play it using luck, that is your choice.