Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-31926729-20171009183600/@comment-33307613-20171010014008

Lazuli-Heart wrote: DragonClaw66 wrote: Lazuli-Heart wrote: I'm rather confused.

First off, Town Deception??? This is not an alignment.

So the first night do you pick a mafia role to imitate? I honestly don't know how this works. Please explain. You get the ability of a RANDOM Mafia Support/Deception. You will see the accurate visits of all Mafia members (The Godfather has decided to kill Edward Bishop. A Blackmailer has decided to blackmail Abigail Hobbs.)

You will appear to be in the Mafia box with whatever role you are taking on.

Consider the role a Town Investigative, not a Town "Deception". Ok, so it's Town Investigative. And you know who the GF is. That's a GF hardcounter boio. Also RNG isn't liked by BMG. Also if it can talk in the nightchat it's a Nightchat Town.

I'm sorry, but although it is nerfed by being shown as Mafia it's a little bit OP for the town to know who the GF is. Mayhaps it shouldn't know the name of the GF or Mafioso since they often use the name of the roles anyway, and just know the roles and the number of the mafia and have a secondary ability like a spy.

I'm trying to give you ideas to fix this, but in it's current state it makes games impossible for a Godfather or Starting Mafioso.

I'm gonna have to Reject this in it's current state. Don't give up on the role idea though, it could end up good! I just realised the role also pretty much replaces the Spy. At first it sounded like you were speaking to me as if I was the creator of this role, so I just blamed my misunderstanding of the way you were talking. Then I realized you were talking to me as if it was my role. I was just trying to specify what the creator was saying. That's also the nicest way to reject somebody's idea. Also, the Godfather isn't revealed, just who the Mafia targets.