Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32994909-20180620175521/@comment-32329805-20180621114406

Anyways, i'll attempt to solve the riddle.

Reasons FOR -

He correctly said that Player A stabbed the Jailor

He is under Lookout results

Reasons AGAINST -

He could easily be an evil role trying to fake it; the Jailor likely had in his will that he jailed Player A

He couldn't have only seen 1 person; There'd have to be a Coven Leader or Escort to prevent him from executing Player A

Lookout result is just suspicious in general.