Board Thread:Fun and Games/@comment-29585050-20161122101745/@comment-24675428-20161123090420

There was a duplicate padlock made by the murderer, who then swapped the padlocks, so you locked the skeleton padlock. The only difference between the padlocks being, the second skeleton padlock doesnt need a key to be opened, it just LOOKS like it does. The murderer does the murder, leaves, and then switches back the padlocks.