Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-30425672-20161106103158/@comment-29669939-20161218182135

73.31.212.25 wrote:

This is rejected and this is why.

1. You can use 6 times. That's too much.

how about we bring it down to 3?

That makes it a little better.

2. This is a supplier role in a way. It gives the ability to kill someone to non-killing roles.

yes

'''And supplier roles are bad. I mean, I don't have anything against it, but BMG despise of them.'''

3. The fact that it can give away a knife to a non-townie makes this roll basically useless

ARE YOU KIDDING ME IF THEY DIDNT IT WOULD BE TO OP

Yeah buy give it to a witch and it will probably kill your Jailor, because the witch has the consigliere abilities.

4. This isn't needed in the game.

so neither are bodyguards(we allready have doctors), AND FUCKING SURVIVORS ARE USELESS AND BORING.

'''Bodyguards kill the attacker, which is REALLY USEFUL. And survivors are the best ally to Neutrals, Mafia and even Town.'''

REJECTED.