Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-35420390-20180428132409/@comment-35420390-20180428202935

TheRetroPioneer wrote: Hello! First of all "Neutral Being" isn't a faction; you're probably thinking of neutral BENIGN. Second of all, I would say this is a Neutral Evil role, since it has (Like GamesManiac said) the "anti-town" bias. the anti town bias i something i have thought of, but technically since this role has the possibility to work with town i don't feel like its directly a "anti town" but i have thought of that this role maybe could change team based on goal (say that the targeted faction is mafia or coven this role could be changed to or something)

Some problems:

- Executioner rehash—you're up against an enemy faction, and if your enemy faction is mafia (for example), you might as well be an overpowered town role. I know, this is why i sugested to have multiple factions as target so you have both the and  or the town and 

- You didn't put how strong the bullets are. i think i wrote that he had a basic attack and powerful is the targeted faction is 

- This is also kind-of a Vampire Hunter rehash '''How? this role targets the entire coven /town insted of a little group of people that all have the same ability'''

- Is this immune to bites? idk, would say yes since it has a basic defence

- Roles that are made to counter other roles/factions are generally not accepted. this role isn't ment to directly "counter" a faction since the faction is kinda random

- What if you need to kill, let's say, Jesters? '''You shoot the jester? Or convince the town its the Godfather and make the jailor exe or the town to lynch?'''

Admittingly, I've seen similar concepts to this before, maybe less on the creative side but if you can think of something that would make this less "anti-faction"-based, that would make this role much better. if I make it less "anti-faction"-based it will be too much like an exe to me, but i actually have an consept for just that, which im going to post later on