Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-35806499-20180724041323/@comment-35195751-20180731204551

Ok, here’s a couple problems I can see with this at first glance:

1) This is actually a bigger waste of space than disguiser, a mafia member should be reasonably powerful since there are only 4, and this seems like a one role hardcounter

2) Every single improvement you just suggested is STILL just helping phantom hardcounter jailor

3) Any jailed target can just repeat who they are to confirm who they are in chat, and it would be PAINfully obvious when there is a phantom

4)It nerfs any potential BM since whispering would be discouraged

5) It only helps against jailor, and even then, not much. Unfortunately it sucks against anything else

6) Sure hope the phantom never gets jailed, it would be pretty obvious who’s evil if the phantom’s been busy

7) It has the SAME investigative result as BM, and they both hear whispers. As if spy wasn’t a mafia claim enough already