Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-39468482-20190514220241/@comment-35051747-20190514230640

I want to check this one out. I solely like this role idea, and it has a nice front page design.

Amnesiac can't remember unique roles, even if there's only one at a time, so that's easily debunked.

The Summary is good, but here's my version: "A former surgeon that now works with the Mafia to jeopardize the Town."

Now, this role sounds like a very fun role to play with. The only problem being, well, the fact that this can completely ruin Town's chances of winning. What if SK attacked Jailor and you changed the cause of death to a Mafia member? That basically just acquits the Serial Killer of wrongdoing, and that can be bad for the Mafia, since I assume you don't get the actual cause of death as the Coroner. Also, another problematic thing is, well, besides the Mafia kill, who do you know will die? If you were to change someone's cause of death and change it to SK, what if another SK killed? Also this role is basically useless in Ranked (and Practice), because since there's only one slot for neutral killing, which means that the Town will call out "THERE'S A CORONER!" And then the Town won't trust how people died, since it could be fake.

Don't get me wrong I can see you tried, and the script is awesome. It's just that it doesn't only ruin the Town's chances of winning, but your team's chances of winning too.