Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-39530373-20190706182056/@comment-32576568-20190713190839

Sandinmymuffin wrote: Name: Orb Master

Alignment: Neutral Confusion

Attack: Basic ok

Defence: None ok?

Unique Role: Yes good

Abilities:

- Pick a player to Ether Give a Good Orb or a Bad Orb

Attributes:

- You don't know if you gave a Good or Evil Orb So, in other words, you have no idea what you're doing at night, meaning you can't claim anything.

- Good Orbs will Heal see above

- Evil Orbs will Poison see above

Mechanics:

- The Game Will Pick, , or Randomly and that's your Team '''this promotes gamethrowing though. They're all apart of different factions for a reason. You and Your Teammates don't know that you guys are on a Team ​​​​​​what is even the point of them being on a team then?'''

- If you Picked someone who, not on your Team they will be given an Evil Orb sounds like PM

- If you Picked someone who, not on your Team they will be given a Good Orb see above

- If you are a  Can Be Targeting you but you're not Town, this is Neutral Confusion?

- If you Are Interrogated The Will get Not Susp if you are  and Susp, if you are not  see above

-Investigative Results-

Sheriff: Inno/Susp

Investigator:, , , Orb Master fair

/: Your Target is a Master of Orbs, They Must be The Orb Master

'''This is basically a nerfed PM, with not being able to see his own teammates and not being able to choose his orbs. I'd give it a 2/10'''

Name: Idiot

Alignment: Neutral Confusion

Attack: Depends what..?

Defence: Depends wtf

Unique Role: No

Abilities:

- None well okay then

Attributes:

- None that''s unexpected.

Mechanics:

- You, Will, Be Given A Random Investigative Role (, [{Investigator}},, , , , , , ) '''Trapper & Coven Leader aren't investigative roles. That's an attribute.'''

- You will Keep The Same Abilities and Attributes, Like the You will Still Witch Them Into your Second Target but, There is a 50% 50% Chance of Getting The Right and Ronge Info. '''This makes no sense. A Coven Leader who gets the wrong info is like putting an Investigator who has everyone as BG/GF/Arso/Crus'''

- When You Die You Will Be Reveled As The Ididot What was ever the point of letting him choose a role anyway?

-Investigative Results-

Sheriff: Depends on your role

Investigator: Depends on your role

/: Your Target Has the Ronge Info, They Must Be a Idiot!

'''I don't like this one. 3/10. It's literally a nerfed Amnesiac.'''

Name:  what..?

Alignment: Neutral Confusion

Attack: None

Defense: None

Unique Role: No

Abilities:

- You may Remeber a Dead Players Role ok then

Attributes:

- You Can't Remember a Unique Role Town Role ok then

- The Grave Yard Will all be Cleaned No. Just No.

- You Cant Hear The Other Players Talk and When you Talk They Will See next To There Name Intell You Remember someone wtf is the point of this?

- The Wont Know Who You Remebered ​​​​​​​even more no

-Investigative Results-


 * Not Susp



Consigliere/: You Target forgot Who They Were, They Must Be an !

Goal: Remember Someone and Win As There Goal All of these need to be reworked. They're all too underpowered, or just rehashes. Why does the Idiot get incorrect results? Why does the Amnesiac clean all dead roles? Everyone could claim literally anything and not even lynching would help. It would just cause the game to be "claim this and hope noone ccs." Why doesn't the Orb Master know his teammates? Why can't he choose what orb he delivers? These roles have too many flaws, and they need to be tweaked or removed.