Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-33167183-20171129002038/@comment-33245478-20171129224248

I do not think that this role is bad, but it is extremely UP and OP as well as unbalanced.

First off, this role is too OP because it kills all claimspace and completely kills off all potential Town threats, thus breaking the game. Also, Town threats would be called out if the Scout finds all living Town roles.

Second, this role is also weak because it has a limited number of uses. This should have infinite.

Third, this is more Consigliere-like than Spy-like, due to it giving you what roles are in the game, but without revealing a person's exact role. Also, only the Spy (and the other Mafia members) knows who the Mafia visits at night.

As of right now, im ABSTAINING, but many changes are needed. Try and make it more balanced across ALL game modes, instead of being useless in some and useful in some.