Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-35744521-20190319122046/@comment-38127112-20190321204102

RedDeathNick wrote: You obviously know this is a rehash, (a role that is the same as an existing role but for another faction,) but what you might NOT know is that rehashes are not allowed, but maybe you don't care which is cool, so i'll review it apart from that.

The role seems like a way to counter town protection. Townie B has TP and Townie A doesn't, swap them and target townie A so tp is ACTUALLY on Townie A and you've ACTUALLY killed Townie B. Beyond that i love how the mind games come into play, because you have to choose someone who wont have LO or TP on them. This role is very versatile and interesting... however... it almost seems TOO versatile... I'd add a limit so that A. The mind games increase into betting if there is TP or LO and B so that it isn't over powered.

Now, normally, i just give one verdict, but i think this needs three...

As it stands: Verdict: Revamp. Rehashes are never accepted. i'd make it more about countering TP without being trans.

Ignoring rehash issue: '''Verdict: Needs work. '''Needs to be balanced better

Taking critiscism and ignoring rehash issue: '''Verdict: Amazing. '''I love this role and it's great and interesting and honestly it's just... well... AMAZING!

P.S you should name it kidnapper because it's evil and you're essentially kidnapping people. Rehashes are allowed my guy, as long as they have a faction change