Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20171114075305/@comment-33307078-20171119213003

ProfessorArceus wrote:

Summary
UGH, contradictions galore. go crazy add.
 * The silencing is underpowered because of some exploits
 * The silencing is powerful enough to not have whisper-reading because Mafia can also abuse the exploits that Town use to avoid claiming and semi-confirm themselves as non-mafia. It can also silence people who might be able to counterclaim, or feed information to Town. The first sentence of this contradicts your earlier point in this post.
 * The whispers are used by town (I can't find any reasoning) Can't find reasoning? Anyone can use whispers.
 * Whispers are discouraged from Townies because Townies need to communicate. So if Townies don't whisper, who does? Mafia to Witch? Maybe, but there's little reason to have to read whispers since you have maf night chat. Witch and NK, though, will need whispers to communicate. However this prevents this communication because it is so risky. But, it could be invest checking roles.