Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-33167183-20180523235220/@comment-35356104-20180527035653

Boi. Wanting your new idea to be automatically liked by the community is impossible. It needs your effort to repetitively analyse and evaluate your own idea, accepting perspectives from the public with your sense of discretion while reasonably adhering to your own standpoint. You're not even far from the beginning. Don't give up if you think your idea is still workable.

My very personal feeling about the norm among creators: I've seen a lot of creators dump their idea here and there but the creators seems nowhere to be found after receiving feedback from the community, not a simple "thanks" from them. Showing sign or gesture of appreciation isn't meant for reviewers and isn't something necessary out of courtesy since not everyone has the habit to do so or they simply find the reviewers rude or whatsoever. However, it is for to respect their own idea with proper closure. I don't care if anyone hate me or not for reviewing their idea, I don't ask for any appreciation since I did this voluntarily, but I don't like people being irresponsible with their own idea. Posting a role idea and receive negative feedback from the community? So what now? Still want to fix it or not? Can't fix anything? Then just leave it there? Let those corpses of idea rot & decompose in the air? And next time the same problems with their role idea resurfacing again. The malicious cycle never end in that way. I wonder what kind of right they have to ask for wholehearted review when they're not respecting their own work. I wonder what's so hard about to write a simple closure if they feel like the idea can't be fix and do some reflection when people already rub facts and useful idea on their face. What's the whole point of role reviewing when people don't show a slightest sign of improvement? Sometimes the creators just expose their heart content through the format. I see only some raw random thoughts put out in words. You also know that creator doesn't know what they're doing when they can't defend their idea a bit. It's tiring to respect the creators who show a little to no enthusiasm and respect to their own pieces, but I still do that in hope that I may influence them. You can't blame the forumers to be rude sometimes. They are probably tired of same sh*t over and over again.

In short, you must like your own idea before wanting the others to like it too. How your idea is suppose to get its recognition when you give up without trying hard. It isn't hard to defend your own idea when you know what is your idea for. Of course, I'm not telling you to be stubborn. Accept suggestions at your discretion. If you feel like your idea can't be fix anymore while problems still can't be handled, you may want to move on. Respect your idea and do a proper closure. A closure may somehow prevent revive.

Back to your point, people are claiming this to be OP by judging the nature and purpose of this role that hunt down claimspace. Then tell them that this role is pretty situational to maximize its potential and it isn't OP by default. Elaborate the point yourself. You must know your own role idea better than I do. If you really want to abandon it then do it in a proper way.

EDIT: Lazuli makes a good point too.