Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-36558623-20180903030749/@comment-36558623-20180903042021

Read the full role,

if the Detective kills a townie, it doesn't get the leverage of seeing their target kills anymore, but it gains Powerful Attack

Besides, in each (vanilla) game there is jailor, gf, mafioso, nk and tk

not to mention three rts which all have a good chance of being tk and ne could be jester

so it's basically like 5-7 'killing roles' per game

half of those are town, meaning even if you find someone who you can kill, if you don't read them correctly you could seriously screw town over. (keep in mind the chance of town having a rt tk is likely so having like 6 roles 3 v 3)

Even after you do that you gain powerful attack though, making a trade you may actually need to kill nk or maf.

Furthermore, if the Detective even finds an evil and scumreads correctly, godfather and nk are immune to their initial attack, so if they attacked them they would be immune.

So I think it's safe to say that this role has its fair share of problems