Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-2600:6C46:7A00:CA:590F:CB42:FF97:7222-20180716022244/@comment-28092296-20180716215011

TO FIX THE GOOGLE DOCS ISSUE: Copy and paste this into Notepad. Then copy+paste what's in the notepad to get rid of bold.

I like the idea. It's a buying+gambling-type of role. A big problem, though: Since you can only gather one soul per night, you can only expect to buy a couple of things—most likely basic attack and some detection immunity/night defense. Most games don't go past night 9, so you probably won't find yourself using the soul mechanics much. (I guess that answers your "should the price in the Devil shop be changed?" question, ha)

Response to your main feedback request:

- Yeah, probably. Most likely, people's upgrades would overlap—defense, basic attack, etc.

- I see that as fine, as long as it blocks just one attack and it gives you basic defense.

- YESS!!!! You should not have powerful defense as a permanent ability. That's a big no-no. Your "regenerating" souls thingy should be removed—it'll take six more days until you actually gain something from it, plus you need to wait an extra five nights. That means you only really get something by night eleven!! The main problem with the upgrades are that you can only get one soul per night, so again, you probably will only get two things by the time the game is over.

- Um, yeah. Make the devil shop thingy available every day.

- No. Everything is fine the way it is No curing. No purging (that may cause you to have "-1 souls", i.e. you have 5 souls, you buy a 5-soul upgrade, and somebody is purged, meaning you lose 6 souls.)

- the invest results are fine

- yeah, have them trigger traps/Bgs.

'''BIGGEST PROBLEM: VERY IMPORTANT!! (pls read)''' After three nights, you will only have the same attack/defense levels of a serial killer. Three nights is a long time. I suggest re-evaluating your upgrades, especially since you take so long to become a normal killer, or you can become an overpowered killer by getting astral and powerful attack. (but yeah pls remove the powerful defense trait)

Uh, also a tiny side note:

"(Each player except the Deal Maker has one soul.)"

"“Because of your debt the devil has decided to take your soul as collateral.”"