Board Thread:Role Ideas (Rework)/@comment-38127112-20190330192255/@comment-32651233-20190403220617

Connortheandroid wrote: Orecreeper wrote:

Connortheandroid wrote: Orecreeper wrote:

Connortheandroid wrote: Orecreeper wrote: Like literally not necessary lol Yikes, you clearly havent been in a game with a blackmailer Yes I have, and it's perfectly fine the way it is. Not the best role ever but its perfectly fine. People will vote up and down when BM’d, this stops their whispering ability from being useful because they’re found out instantly and no useful info is spread, sure you can just not BM, but is not using your main ability fun? But this makes it worse because if someone gets voted up and one vote is missing, the proof of a Blackmailer existing is even more definitive. What I mean is, someone can fake blackmailed, but no one can make an invisible vote unless they are BMed. That doesnt make it worse because people are most likely not gonna notice that, and the odds of that situation occuring is far less than just voting up and down You're telling me that no one would notice that John Hathorne was voted up with only "four" votes when five is the requirement? And also if this IS implemented, you bet that people would notice, not that they already wouldn't with all the scumreading and VFR.