Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-31583987-20181130154850/@comment-27575896-20181201055401

Faraday242 wrote: Zed and RAS both bring up very solid points, but I have to side with RAG here. Buying just a few nights is the difference when it comes to voting and lynching. Making people think someone died to a Vigilante or Veteran (this is great with forger btw) on just one night is great. ​​​​​​​Spies disprove it instantly.

The Veteran death is BS, since all the target needs to do is claim they aren't Veteran, and boom, M E is exposed to exist if they have a will.

Mediums and Retributionists disprove it instantly.

You must realize that this is not a Ranked role and only applies to the Coven DLC it seems. This means there is no "Ranked". This role is focused only on Custom and All Any, since that's the only time you will get Mafia roles in the Coven DLC other than Mafia Returns (which nobody does). If you want to create a good role, it must be able to apply to ALL GAME MODES. Look at the Town roles for instance.

Since this isn't a Classic role, I am treating as a location-specific role that is completely useless in the fact that 90% of deaths can de disproven, are immediately ruled out, and shrugged off while confirming a Medical examiner exists.

The only useful ones here are Vigilante and Vampire, and nothing else. In terms of Vampire, could make it think 4 exist. However, since it's a Coven role, this only will truly be plausible in ALL ANY.