Board Thread:Role Ideas/@comment-29857251-20160906140607/@comment-29857251-20160910125750

Vertroyer wrote: Kotsthepro wrote: Vertroyer wrote: Neutral evils are supposed to harm Town, which this role does not provide.

It's also a role swapper, even if temporary, it still remains a bad concept.

Rejected. If you change a lnvestlgator - Bg to a dead medium, it is harming town.

And if you change a Mafia Support or Mafia Deception to a bg that can work for maf, it counts as harming town.

And if you change a TI and TP to a surv, even for 1 night, it IS harming town.

It is maybe bad concept for someone but it is a DIFFERENT concept when it may turn to very fun role in game.

So pls, stop destroy other peoples ideas like "Rejected" and give them feedback like "You should add/remove/change that. I mistaken the "Town harming part", sorry for that.

But regardless, the role swapping mechanic remains a bad one not just for me, but for the people of the BMG forums.

And I'm not changing the way I review roles. If the role has no potential cuz it's completely useless or based on one of the majorly terrible concepts, I just point out what's wrong with this role, and that's it, cuz no fixing, replacing,removing or adding will give the role a slight chance at being considered by BMG.

If it has potential, I'd give more detailed feedback and possible fixes or just to give it a shot at BMG, simple.

If my "rejection" methods seem offensive to you already, I can't imagine how agonizing it would be for you to see the BMG people. Maybe swapper can be a bad idea, but I need to ask 2 things.

If I make little differences and change the alignment to NC, can it become a better role?