Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20171101070508/@comment-31680260-20171102013136

FirePyre wrote: No tactical mafia.

The tactical mafia would make role lists too complicated, (How? It doesn't add any more roles >_>) and make the mafia have less chance of having good non-killing roles, (...no it doesn't. It means that all those good non-killing roles actually have the ability to kill. And since this is "tactical" Mafia, you would expect that the Godfather would carry out the kill since it doesn't have any other abilities. Maybe the Mafioso if it hasn't used its amne power yet.) and especially since their winrates are already lower than town's, this is a no-brainer. (I think you've missed the idea of Tactical Mafia... it's a buff. It won't lower their winrates at all.)