Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-37421692-20190430215039/@comment-32651233-20190502015454

what we're considering here is literally not "is Ret overpowered" but "if Ret is as powerful as it can get, is it powerful?" Well, hate to break it to ya'll but any role at it's max power and luck is overpowered. Sheriff is literally overpowered if he finds a suspicious person each night. Medium is OP if there are 4 mediums. This is stupid. There's been a recent poll that shows that out of all the Ret games of 30 total games, only around 60% of those Ret games were won by Town. Now that's more than 50% but a lot of Town roles have a higher than 50% WR. And there's nothing we can do about that, as no Town role by themself is capable of "carrying" the game, and believe it or not, every person contributes a significant amount to Town's higher WR. It's the entire town working together that makes Town win more, not just one or two specific roles. If the TI doesn't find any mafia early enough, it is unlikely that the Town would get off its feet in time.

Ret is powerful but it doesnt deserve this "unstoppable role" bullcrap.