Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-35195751-20190301023045/@comment-50.37.92.220-20190301144234

TheLastHappyPotato wrote: Role: Professional Killer

Summary: You are the Mafia's top choice for professional murders

Alignment: Mafia Killing +1 sin

Attack: Powerful/Basic​​​​​​​ +1 sin

Defence: None

Unique: Yup

Mechanics: Once per night you may choose to dispatch a victim

If the target has no Defence, you deal a Basic attack, and remove the target's will

If the Target has Basic Defence, you will deal a Powerful attack to the target

If a Lookout visits your target, you will kill the Lookout instead  (You will not remove the will) (You can only kill one Lookout though)

Invest: Your target could be a Vigilante, Veteran, Mafioso, or a Professional Killer

Goal: Mafia Goal

Thoughts? This is...VERY op. You get a 2 kpn on mafia, and is hardcountering Lookouts for some reason...?

Deleting the will should not be able to happen...

Why should this be able to attack with a Powerful attack every night?

This role is more op than the Mafioso entirely from its kill power. That should not be.

No Mafia Killing should have: (except for the Mafioso/Godfather)

1kpn

A Powerful attack (ever)

Direct killing (or the killing is rare/limited)

Suggestions:

Delete the Powerful attack, will removal, and weird Lookout interaction.

Make it so it can only do a Basic attack, but only 3 times maybe?

Change Investigative results: In Coven Expansion, there's 3 Mafia in it.