Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-37421692-20190430215039/@comment-38127112-20190504233715

Orecreeper wrote: Connortheandroid wrote: Orecreeper wrote: Connortheandroid wrote: Orecreeper wrote: It negates a kill and confirms two townies only for one of them to be killed immediately in the next two nights. Also there is of course the chance that the Ret will be killed N1, which is honestly much higher than the chance of there being three mediums and a ret in the game which everyone acts like happens a lot. Yeah but I pointed out the possibility of having FIVE CONFIRMED TOWNIES BY D3 WITHOUT ANY FORM OF LOGICAL THINKING, ALL YOU DO IS PRESS A BUTTON if a Sheriff player was just randomly picking players to investigate and stumbles on an evil every single night and doesn't die, isn't that equally overpowered? The sheriff requires good judgement on who to check, and is rewarded if their judgement is good, the retribtionist presses one button once

if a Jailor jails 3 mafia with bad claims and wills in a row, and repeatedly jails a fourth, isn't that also very powerful? Same as above

If a Janitor cleans a Ret who hasn't claimed the night they revive and there are no mediums, isn't that also very overpowered? Same as above I was saying if the Sheriff was just randomly investigating people and the Jailor just got lucky. Also, it takes like, zero skill to play Janitor. Just clean the person the Mafia kills unless they are someone who has already claimed. There's no need to clean people who have already claimed because their will is probably in chat anyways if they claimed, the only real exception to this rule is if the Ret is alive and hasn't used their ability. But Janitor more or less doesn't take a lot of effort. Not a lot of deduction is needed, most of the time you just look at who your teammates clicked on and click on that guy. Like I’ve already said, at least janitor chooses when to clean, allowing them to frame others if played right, still requires more strategy than pressing a singular button once