Custom Setups (Classic)

Below is a list of fun ways The Host can set up a Custom Mode game:

8,3,4

 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Town Investigative
 * 1 Town Protective
 * 1 Town Killing
 * 1 Town Support
 * 3 Random Town
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafia Support
 * 1 Mafia Deception
 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 1 Arsonist
 * 1 Neutral Benign
 * 1 Neutral Evil

8,3,3,1
More standard version:
 * 2 Town Investigative
 * 2 Town Protective
 * 2 Town Killing
 * 2 Town Support
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafia Support
 * 1 Mafia Deception
 * 1 Neutral Benign
 * 1 Neutral Evil
 * 1 Neutral Killing
 * 1 Any
 * 2 Town Investigative
 * 2 Town Protective
 * 1 Town Killing
 * 1 Jailor
 * 2 Town Support
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafia Support
 * 1 Mafia Deception
 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 1 Witch
 * 1 Amnesiac
 * 1 Any

Lookouts v Mafia

 * 11 Lookouts
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafioso
 * 2 Consorts

This Could Go Any Way

 * 3 Arsonists
 * 3 Serial Killers
 * 3 Witches
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Consigliere
 * 4 Consorts

Let The Gods Decide

 * 8 Random Town
 * 1 Godfather
 * 2 Random Mafia
 * 4 Random Neutral

All Any

 * 15 Any

Town vs Mafia

 * 1 Mayor
 * 1 Jailor
 * 2 Town Investigative
 * 2 Town Protective
 * 2 Town Killing
 * 2 Town Support
 * 1 Godfather
 * 2 Mafia Support
 * 2 Mafia Deception

Transporters vs Mafia

 * 10 Transporter
 * 1 Godfather
 * 4 Random Mafia

Mafia vs Neutral
More standard version:
 * 1 Godfather
 * 5 Random Mafia
 * 1 Arsonist
 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 7 Random Neutral
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Mafioso
 * 2 Mafia Support
 * 2 Random Mafia
 * 1 Arsonist
 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 1 Neutral Killing
 * 3 Neutral Benign
 * 2 Neutral Evil
 * 1 Random Neutral

Witch Hunt (Classic)

 * 1 Witch
 * 1 Mafioso
 * 1 Consigliere
 * 1 Jailor
 * 4 Town Protective
 * 3 Town Killing
 * 4 Town Support

Witch Hunt (Chaotic)

 * 12 Vigilante
 * 3 Witch

"Skilled With Knives."

 * 1 Investigator
 * 1 Sheriff
 * 10 Doctor
 * 2 Serial Killer
 * 1 Executioner

"No, It's You!"

 * 1 Godfather
 * 3 Framer
 * 1 Mayor
 * 10 Sheriffs

15 Gunmen

 * 14 Vigilante
 * 1 Mafioso

All-Out War

 * 1 Mayor
 * 9 BodyGuard
 * 5 Serial Killer

Survival

 * 2 Town Killing
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Veteran
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Consigliere
 * 1 Consort
 * 1 Mafioso
 * 3 Arsonist
 * 3 Serial Killer
 * 1 Witch

Hunger Games

 * 10 Survivor
 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Serial Killer
 * 1 Arsonist
 * 1 Veteran
 * 1 Jester

Pentacle

 * 1 Witch
 * 2 Survivor
 * 3 Serial Killer
 * 4 Jester
 * 1 Godfather
 * 2 Mafia Support
 * 2 Mafia Deception

Rainbow

 * 1 Godfather
 * 1 Random Mafia
 * 2 Arsonist
 * 1 Jailor
 * 1 Veteran
 * 2 Survivor
 * 2 Amnesiac
 * 2 Serial Killer
 * 2 Witch
 * 1 Jester

VIP

 * 1 Mayor
 * 8 Bodyguard
 * 3 Survivor
 * 3 Serial Killer

If you know any other fun setups feel free to add them to this list. However, please try the setup first to see if it works. This prevents the game from ending in a draw on Day 2.