Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-31841299-20170518120826/@comment-30604075-20170522134541

Glorified Surgeon wrote:

HAWAIIANpikachu wrote:

Glorified Surgeon wrote:

HAWAIIANpikachu wrote:

Glorified Surgeon wrote: Either Neutral Killing or Neutral Chaos. Night Ability: Every odd numbered night you have the option to kill somebody.

​So a reversed nerfed werewolf clone.

Every even numbered night you have the option to visit somebody and convert them into a wendigo.

​reversed nerfed werewolf+vampire clone.

There can only be 2 wendigos alive at once,

​reversed nerfed werewolf+nerfed vampire clone.

and certain roles can't be converted. (GF, SK, Arsonist, WW, and Vampires). You will not know who the other Wendigos are, and the Wendigos can attack and kill each other.

​reversed nerfed werewolf+super-nerfed vampire clone.

The only way you will know if the person you targeted has turned is if there are multiple Wendigo kills the next night.

Night Immune: No.

RB Immune: No.

Unique: No.

Bite Immune: Yes.

Control Immune: No.

Death Message: You were consumed by a Wendigo. (Player) was consumed by the Wendigo.

Invest Results: Your target is covered in blood. They must be a Doctor/Disguiser/Serial Killer/ Wendigo.

Consig Results: You target eats the flesh of others. They must be a Wendigo.

Can win with: Survivors and Witches.

Please don't reject this because you guys say it's a rehash of vamp or SK because 90% of these ideas are basically rehashes of some role already in the game.

'''​That arguement sadly doesn't work... some tried that before, but it doesn't work as the name of the rules are called "Making new roles", those roles are either already added or about to be added into the game, so those roles ignore the rules. This role is neither, so the rules apply.''' reversed nerfed werewolf+super-nerfed vampire clone.

Rejected I don't think BMG really gives a shit about your rules. Also considering how the Medusa role is basically an altered janitor, and how the Consig and Consort are just mafia clones of the Invest and Escort I would really try to avoid rejecting roles just because they're similar to roles already in the game. Sure, BMG may not give a s**t about those rules, but guess what, I do and I follow them, wanna know why? We don't need a bajillion rehashes of roles. That just makes the game become bland. Do you think I want to reject the role just due to the fact it's a rehash because of the rules? No, I do it because it makes the game boring.

Also, please note that the consigilere, consort, investigator and escort where all added at the start of the game, you know, when the role rules didn't exist. Vampire and vampire hunter exist due to it being a reached goal. So the coven update is the only time they didn't follow the rules for an unexplained reason. And sure, while some of their roles are rehashes, there are some solid ones as well, like the pirate. Meaning that BMG actually somewhat cares about the rules, because if they didn't, I would have expected at least every new rule to be a rehash. But they didn't.

And just as a note, they aren't my rules, they are the communities rules. Town of salem forums use them, the wikia uses them, I wasn't even a role reviewer until I decided to review some roles after Vertroyer and Dongarinos, the 2 most active role reviewers, went on leave.

If you want my personal opinion, simple, scrap this role idea and make another one, or do some massive changes to this role to make it accepted. There are still reasons that I haven't said that make this role rejected. Then tell me all those reasons so I actually know everything I should change. Also, I know that these rules are the communities rules. Also it's starting to become more difficult to come up with roles that don't seem to be a rehash of current roles, and roles that you guys actually approve of. that's the point. Making good roles are supposed to be difficult, not easy and also not a thing everyone can do.

“We’re in a time when we must choose between what is right and what is easy."

~ Albert Dumbledore