Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-98.21.80.23-20180421222702/@comment-2001:1C03:3403:C900:85D:643D:A6CF:9BA1-20180422055312

GamesManiac wrote: Hi Hi! Thanks for sharing your role idea! I'm still inexperienced at reviewing role and I'm open to argument. P.S: My English sucks. Let's gooo :D

First Impression: Cool concept! I have seen the idea of a bomber as a part of and I like it so much but sadly it's very overpowered as it heavily buffs 's killing power. Moving this idea here is wise I say. Quite a versatile. However, as a part of, try to refrain from the idea of killings limit. Bomber only has 7 killing counts in total, making him only able to kill up to N7. Game lasts longer than that is pretty rare but Bomber will be at disadvantage if this really happen. Not to mention any failed murder, wasting a night and a use of limited ability are painful to roles. I love to concept of killing people of all sort such as visitors, target themselves, attackers and non-attackers. This killing mechanic of  which doesn't target only a specific group is desirable.

In-depth analyse: Wide array of killing methods. Enable flexible playstyle. Cool!

Lemme imagine some scenes here: Scenario 1: A is suspicious to. Land mine planted on A. Next day, a whole chunk of corpses of, , , etc. etc. lying outside. At the end, A is a member of ! (Can still be applied on Bomber) Scenario 2: B is a confirmed. Land mine planted on B. Next day, B has been killed by. was blown to bits by Bomber. You know what's happening there right? I'm imagining this because I only have vague idea of the utility of Land Mine. I don't know how to feel about this. But I gotta say MAYBE good and balance. Scenario 1: shot  and both of them were bombed out. was blown to bits by Bomber. survives?? HOW?! Scenario 2: X was killed and blown to bits by and Bomber. was blown to bits by Bomber. survives?? HOW?! Scenario 3: Bomber placed grenade on themselves. or and  attacked Bomber. RNG time? My brain cell are dying. Technically this role is SOMEHOW balance, but no offense, I feel weird 'bout it. Final Thought:
 * C4: The most basic form of killing and also the most balanced one. But only 2 times? After using all the C4s and Grenades (aside from Nuke), you can no longer directly kill off any threat of yours. Leaving bomber vulnerable.
 * 1) Land Mine: A with 2 uses? A nerfed version of rampage? It doesn't stop  and  from killing? So you want to  KA-BOOM!  the visitors of famous target?
 * 1) Grenade: A who kills everyone besides attacker. Same as Land Mine, I don't know how to express how I feel, so I will just write the scene I imagine.
 * 1) Nuke: This is simply overpowered and unneccessary considering Bomber already possessed versatile utility kits. Unstoppable attack bypasses protect and 's jail. NOTHING survives besides .  need to douse target before dealing Unstoppable attack and still can be purged by .  only gain Unstoppable attack at full charge after FIVE NIGHTS OF SUCCESSFUL KILLS. Meanwhile, Bomber has such power at the beginning of the game and there is no way to prevent it?

Objectively, this is a decent role. Some fixings are needed to make this role balance. Most importantly, does Bomber immune to detection? Subjectively, I personally wouldn't like to play this. I don't feel unique playing as a Bomber as this role's mechanic is little like a mash-up of . There isn't any exclusive ability for this role. I love explosive anyway :D This role has the potential. Hope to see a remake or adjusted version of this role. Please keep it up!
 * pats the maniac* cute~