Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-26494712-20161127171212/@comment-30105631-20161220083558

So, I have a bunch of problems with this role.

Firstly, I see no reason as to why we need this in the game. When Vertroyer asked you this question, you responded with a long tirade that ended in 'why not'.

That answer is bullshit. Tell us what the purpose of this role is - why does it exist? Why do we need it in the game?

Secondly, this is a neutral killing with heavily restricted killing ability. It's an indirect buff to the town, and what the town does not need are buffs, so it's off the table unless it's NE. End of story.

Thirdly, why these four roles? Any particular reason? Why not more? 4 roles out of 33 - that's a lot of roles that are not those 4 roles.

Finally, we have no 'ambassadors from BMG' here. This is a fan website, and although Uli holds a lot of status here, he and you and I are just the same rank in the official forums. This is on the fandom, after all. So that means that arguing here about the rules instated by the official BMG staff won't get you anywhere because we can't change them, just enforce them. If you have a serious problem with them, take it to BMG, but I can't imagine they'll listen to you.

Currently, my opinions are:

I don't like your attitude. I'm sure you're a nice guy, so lighten up a bit. Vertroyer may have sounded condescending and unreasonable, but he's nothing like the people you'll encounter on the actual BMG forums. Trust me - I have personal experience in that department.

I don't like this role. It's got too many problems currently, and it doesn't seem like it has any purpose other than "Originality! Yay!", although I must highlight that it is an original idea, so props to you on that one. Of course, original doesn't mean good, and that's why I declare that this role has been SCORCHED.