Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-31680260-20170408232521/@comment-27575896-20170413141634

Addfire wrote:

RubikJohn wrote: It's balanced. It breaks a rule? So what? If this did get accepted and became a role, nobody would mind. What I mean is that breaking one rule shouldn't be an auto - reject. With the new changes, I like this role even more... Listen.

I'll give you an example, the Vampire Hunter.

There is literally no one who plays ToS that likes the VH. It's insanely broken, but because vampires needed a nerf it was implemented.

I like VH....I buy scrolls to GET it!

VH is a buddy role, it self-confirms, an omniscient town killing... But it still got accepted. And now BMG's doing everything it can to kill it.

'''VH lists: Yes to buddy role. HOW DOES IT SELF CONFIRM? Any Mafioso can claim he same thing even if it says no vamps are left! Omniscent Town Killing because it targets one role, but once that role is done, it can target other factions, making it balanced more.'''

The only rule that can be broken without the auto-reject that I can remember now is the role rule and that's only in exceptional cases.

'''True. Neutral Chaos doesn't need to be a converter role.'''

Just deal with it. Vampire Hunter is the only allowed buddy role, since it HAS to target Vampires only cause of the fact they can spead undetected and multiply quickly.

'''Because of that it's omnicient for a reason. Although this is off-topic, Convict just can't go ahead for now.'''