Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-2001:1C03:3403:C900:6D0E:252E:145C:99D5-20180424205824/@comment-2001:1C03:3403:C900:2C05:EB96:7BB:D2CD-20180425114146

GamesManiac wrote: Ok, honey, listen! I don't deserve your love. I'm a games maniac anyway. Games is love, Games is life, and also my one and only. Honestly, I really don't know how to review this. You must have love Combination Role so much. Not slightly, but broken at its finest. Like I always said, I never call off any role that break the rule right away without proper reviewing, but that doesn't mean I encourage breaking rules. Did you actually read my previous review and take in some consideration? Do you actually filter your idea? Or just throw in everything you can think of as usual? The same problems keep resurfacing  to an extent that I can copy my previous review and still can apply on almost every of your role idea, considering the amount of roles and the changes you have made. I DON'T KNOW IF I'M OVERREACTING OR BEING RUDE BUT SOMEBODY HELP! I review roles NOT because I want to seek attention or to show how superior I am towards the community, but I want to show support to those who make serious effort, giving them tips for improvement and encourage quality role-making. If you want to chat with me or whatsoever, you can post things on my message wall or link me to any discussion, just beware that my sense of humor is long dead in the ditch.

Still, I'm going to write a short review:


 * 1) Combination Role and Slightly Changed Role. An investigative role who can detect evil AND check someone's alignment AND someone's exact role AND hear all the dead. I remember I have once said: Narrow the ability scope and don't do everything under that spectrum. If you're an investigative role, you must know what aspect you want to check but not checking everything.
 * 2) Role-dependency where Medium must present in the game. If Medium is killed then this role is nothing more like a dead.
 * 3) Night Immune Town. Can't be killed at night and nobody would stupid enough to attack this role. If you don't what I mean, please reread your own role card.
 * 4) Messing with voting system. You can't vote or be voted. If this doesn't reduce overall vote to get someone on stand, then this hardcounter Town's voting power as lynching is the most effective way of killing for Town.
 * 5) You don't have to be killed for evil to win. So this role is basically dead from the beginning.

Please do not make role solely based on lore or any sort of inspiration without taking any practical measure. Please Please consider as many aspect as possible for balancing purpose. Please Please Please read and study all the reviews for you and THAT IS THE WHOLE POINT OF ROLE REVIEWING. If you don't want serious review or simply like sharing, please mention earlier for the sake of reviewers' time & effort and also my blood pressure. if it'll make senpai happy :c