Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-33281350-20171120191533/@comment-31540897-20171120192355

Mooagain wrote: name: photographer alighnment: ti attack: none
 * Great.
 * As if we didn't have already enough Investigatives...

defence: none imunitys: detection imunity, veteran, medusa, trapper, and juggernaut will not find you. when you print, you have rol block imunity atributes: every night you can stalk someone, or print pictures. you may only stalk famous people. famous people are: veteran, jailor, mayor, sherif, executioner, godfather, coven leader, medium, plage bearer, consiglere, retributionist, (I need more evils, but I can't decide which ones. please sugest more) abilitys: every night you may select any famous person, or your self. if you select a famous person, you will get a photograph of what happened to them. if you select you self, you will print out all photos you have not yet printed. photos will show what roles visit your target. invest: sheriff, exe, ww, poisoner, photographer sheriff: ns
 * I think this is purely a typo and not trying to be British.
 * Okay, it's Town. Detection Immunity DOES NOT MATTER. Second off, you're saying this role is immune to Veteran? Yeah no, not buying it. I'm gonna have to veto that decision. But furthermore, Medusa, Trapper, Juggernaut? Please, you're making this too easy. And RB TOO.
 * That...okay, the problem is that I can argue this is extremely subjective. I also must say that this is fairly pointless, this is just a Sheriff with a different slotset.
 * ...what? This is fairly confusing. What is the point of a photo? What is PRINTING?
 * Serves little to balance, but it balances nonetheless...

consig/cl/pm/witch: your target is a stalker! they must be a photographer! achivements: First off, I don't think this role has potential. Just saying. The English was also kinda hard to understand; usually people have better impressions towards roles if the English is well-written.
 * You could've just named it Paparazzi at this point.
 * Achievements don't matter towards the role if it doesn't get accepted!!!

Anyways, onto the actual role. The role? I'm gonna admit it, it's not even that good. Sure, people will try and target important roles, but nobody will actually KNOW what these roles are. This also causes a bit of game disbalance, in my opinion. Just a gut feeling.

Overall, I'll have to say REJECTED for the overspecific role detection, and considering that it really is just a modified Lookout, with too many immunities.

I suggest reading Making New Roles beforehand...

(Hey guys, can we get people to update the Making New Roles page? Thanks)