Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32994909-20180607203338/@comment-35026689-20180611211240

THEORY GOD DAMN 11

NoCarbonRequired and I created this riddle. Warning, there’s only one solution; we’ve scanned the whole thing for alternative method and can’t any.

''' Jamieawesome: Great. t('-'t) '''

Night 1

Player X is jailed. He is BG

One player attempted to visit Player X. This is PM attacking the SK.

Player X received two regular notifications (the ones with white text and a red background, such as ‘You have died!’. Do not include ‘You did not perform your night ability.’)

'The guardian angel was watcing over you'

'Somebody attacked you in Jail'

These messages i believe layer over each other

The Coven Leader controlled the Jailor.

Day 2

The actual Spy said that one member of the Coven visited Player X.

Mayor Reveals here

Night 2

The actual Tracker saw the Spy stay at home. Spy visited a Jailed target, the coven member N2

Someone died from poison.

Player Y claimed Lookout and said that he saw the Jailor visit the revealed Mayor.

This is the Actual lookout, as Mayor revealed D2 and This Lookout was on them N2, the CL controlled the Jailor away from the Execution of one coven member, and onto the Jailor, which Y saw. Y then accused the Jailor, which outed the Jailor as a result.

Night 3

The actual Tracker said that Player X visited the Jailor. The Jailor did not die. X is TP, so he visits the Jailor after he was outed by Y

Someone was killed by a Potion Master. Potions are not used when failed by a Jail.

The Pm kileld Mayor

Player Z claimed Lookout and said that he saw the actual Retributionist visit the revealed Mayor. This is the CL, as if they were Lookout, they would have seen Y visit and saw the Jailor visit as well. He controlled the Retributionist to confirm themselves as 'Lookout'

The Investigator, who investigated both of them, is sure, but not certain, that one of the Lookoutclaims are evil.

Assuming the Investigator is correct...

> What notifications did Player X receive in jail?

Guardian angel watched

was attacked in jail

I dont think these messages overlap each other

> Suggest the roles of Player X, Player Y and Player Z, give full reasoning for your answer.

X is TP, who was attacked by the PM night one in Jail, and also has a GA. After hearing the Jailor getting outed, he decided to guard them N3 as N2 he was Pirated. N3 he guarded the Jailor which the Tracker saw.

Y is Lookout, as after Mayor revealed D2, they decided to watch the Mayor. The CL controlled away the Jailor from exeing an arbitrary coven member, and into the Mayor. Y saw this and outed the Jailor for visiting the mayor. As a result, X decided to Guard the Jailor N3 as he was pirated and prevented from visiting Mayor N2.

Z is Coven leader, the Lookout claim should have been on the Mayor and seen Y. he obviously didnt see that the Jailor was controleld into Mayor, and claims that retri visited mayor killed by PM, looking like an Exe to explain their basic defence they aquired. However, they cant be Lo because they did not see the rogue jailor. Y was Pirated N3 so did not see the Mayor get Killed.

There IS a Vigilante, a Pirate, and an Executioner

The Mafia does NOT have a Hypnotist

Player Y and Player Z were never jailed.

If I respond ‘incorrect’ to your answer, it’s does not mean it’s totally wrong. In fact it could be very close to the: real answer, I’m just being picky.

I Bet it is

- Jamieawesome       \('o')P          v('~')v

Jailor

Investigator

Spy

Tracker

Mayor

Retributionist

Vigilante

Pirate

Executioner

Bodyguard

Coven Leader

Poisoner

Potion Master

Lookout

Guardian Angel

I am 99 percent sure the 2 messages dont overlap