Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-38045493-20190111033839/@comment-31256456-20190123221230

This is a great example of how to not role review.

Not only did you literally do what I asked the wiki not to do Mayor by saying what I suggested you shouldn't say: "This role is a complete abomination. It doesn't work, it has no creativity, and really has nothing to do with the game I know and love, Town of Salem Coven Edition."

Like really? I made that quote intentionally criticizing people who talk like that and you literally do it lmao hilarious.

Next, we have the fact that all the criticisms have NO REASONING AT ALL. IT'S ALL ABOUT THOSE IDIOTIC RULES. Explain WHY the role is trash instead of copypasting reasoning.

Alright, the role isn't good, it's pretty terrible. But explain how to do better next time and explain WHY hardcounters don't work, WHY rehashes don't work, WHY slightly changed roles don't work, WHY town plus doesn't work. You did none of that, all you did was to put random criticisms with no reasoning. If you ask people to put thought into their roles, you should do the same for your role reviews.

THANK you Faraday for condemning their obviously wrong actions.