Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-29669939-20161026105829/@comment-25876622-20161027221751

A. Yes, you basically stated the concept of random lynching - it could hit anyone. However, this is worse: Not even the Mafia know if they are lynching a Mafia member, and that would really hurt. Random lynching 3 players would have a 55% chance to lynch at least one Mafia member (on day one).

B. Yes, unless you're Witch. Jester and Exe have completely independent goals. The Witch has the same goal as you: see the Town lose. The Witch can team up with the Mafia or the NK, you can't.

D. Why 2 Sheriffs? If you want to do some statistics, here is a gross oversimplification: ...which would make this the worst claim in the game. I'm not considering Framer/Vampire/Jester because it is execution material
 * Arso/BG/GF
 * NK=Arso: 33%, TP1=BG: 50%, TP2=BG: 50%, GF: 100% - chance for evil is about 57%
 * if people know there is no Arso: chance for evil is about 50%
 * Sheriff/Exe/WW/Hangman: People know there aren't two Sheriffs because an Invest found you!
 * NK=WW: 33%, NE=Exe: 25%, NE=Hangman: 25%, TI2=Sheriff: 25% - chance for evil is about 77%