Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-2001:E68:544C:D6EF:B5C5:2183:99A8:8014-20180408144455/@comment-2001:E68:544C:DCC1:79CD:FC45:9647:D6DE-20180409040046

Thanks for reviewing. I love all of you. I come up with a final fixed mechanic. I was informed that this role is OP because Town suffer no consequence at all and heavily affects factional activites like Coven & Mafia. If this doesn't work, I'll just give up.

1) EVERYONE are protected with BASIC defense. *Vig could no longer shoot freely. Other Neutral could still do their job as usual except SK*

2) EVERYONE receives message at the beginning of the night. *Forger/Janitor/Medusa wouldn't waste the use of their ability. Save Potion Master a killing potion. Necromancer wouldn't waste a corpse for killing*

3) Only 1 use.

IMPACTS ON EVERY ROLE IN TOS:

TI- 1 free night for important information

TP- N/A

TK- Save Veteran an alert but still need to watch out Powerful attacker. Vig's shot is pointless. Jailor still need to consider before executing.

TS- N/A

Mafia- Framer/Consig have same advantages as TI. Consort still have chance to RB TI

Coven- Doesn't affect much. Witches can still do things beside killing.

Neutral Benign- It only provides Basic defense. Survivor/GA still need to consider using ability if Powerful attacker present.

Neutral Evil- Witch can still mess up TI & a free night for a person's role.

Neutral Chaos- PB has a free night to plagued more players. Vampire can't kill.

Neutral Killing- Only SK can't kill a night.

FAQ

Q1) This role is OP.

A1) Look at my analysis above. Town only have slight advantages for TI. Some Evils' also have the same advantages. It just that they can't kill for a night. Forced them for another playstyle.

Q2) This role is UP.

A2) This role has no negative utility against Town. TI could manage to get vital information.

Q3) Giving EVERYONE defense is OP.

A3) Op for who? Town? Neutral? Mafia? Coven? How is it OP? Basic Defense only counter faction. It's not like they can't do other things.

Q4) This role hardcounter SK.

A4) Probably. SK can't kill & can't counterattack Jailor. Only if SK counterattack change to Powerful. However, compare to WW, SK killing mechanic is still better.

Q5) Still couldn't accept this role for various kind of reasons.

A5) If that is the case, just let this role RIP. I don't think it could fix anyway better anymore. ​​​​​ ​​​​​​