Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-36558623-20181111001105/@comment-35420390-20181111202447

Seems like poeple have ignored your role idea, but don't worry my friend! I'll review it for you :)

Faraday242 wrote: Name: Astrologist

Alignment: Neutral (Killing) '''Astrologist? That don't sound like a killer type role, but lets see what you have to offer'''

Attack: Basic

Defense: Basic

Unique Role: No

Priority: 5

Abilities: Kill people who do not cause friction Okay..?

Attributes: Players who cause friction are two roles that normally do not win with each other. Ooooh, well this may get intresting

Mechanics: (How It Works)

- Select two players.

- If those two players can win with each other, kill them both '''Sounds cool on paper, but this would make it hard to kill and  /  members before the end of the game. This may be a problem since you will not have majority and may be lynched, but it also may not be a problem'''

- If those two players cannot win with each other, they both receive basic defense that night and you may never select them again. Wow, that may be a problem.

- You may study someone alone (clicking both the buttons next to their name like witching someone into themselves or (you can't do this anymore) transporting someone with themselves)

- Studying someone alone will deal an Unstoppable Astral attack but you cannot attack the next night. WOAH, dude, isn't that OP?

-Investigative Results-

Sheriff: Your target is an Astrologist! no {{Sheriff} nerf i see

Investigator: Your target is a Spy/Blackmailer/Jailor (no claim space, but this role is powerful) indeed

Consigliere/Witch: Your target enjoys watching arguments, they must be an Astrologist. '''Cool result, but it don't fit along the role. But I don't know what will since its a kinda odd one'''

Goal: Kill all who oppose you.

Wins With: NB, NE And i assume?

Must Kill: All else

Okay first off, this role kinda must use the Unstoppable attack unless they know that the targets may win whit each other. Since if they fail to kill them, they may not target them ever again (assuming not whit the Unstoppable either) and that means you most likely have a member or, or both, you can't attack.

Second, maybe change it to a powerful attack instead of unstoppable? Having the ability to kill healed and jailed people is kinda OP. Powerful is enough to kill opposing roles whit defence so.

Third, this role will just walk through the. Since they may kill two of them every night they become super OP against. And since they can't kill if they also target a  they may just call them out the following day (using he ). And if this role senses a, they may just slay them, both of them if there's more than one.

Forth, whit that investigation result and  will be slayn everytime someone claimes it since this role is so strong. This also nerfs to some degree since  is the easies role to fake for.

Fifth, to build more on the third this role will just say "screw majority!" and wreck factions that come out when they have majority. This means the must be ALL FOUR members to be able to lynch this role (if it has a night to kill) something that no other  even can dream of doing. And has a better chance of dealing whit it since they may roleblock him. on the other hand need s to have a alive AND four members alive to be able to not lose (/draw the game)