Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-32143322-20191229052439/@comment-30757827-20191229195539

If you can see other mafia's names, this role is incredibly overpowered as you can just tell town who all the mafia are D2 or even D1 depending on how you see their names.

If you can't see their names, the mafia could just make every non-killing mafia member say the name of the mafia member above them, whoever doesn't know the name is Spiare.

If you remove the ability to be seen as another mafia member and talk to the mafia, oopsie you just made the old or new version of spy.

'''Verdict: Scrap. '''Fundamentally flawed, impossible to fix without changing it so much that you might as well have made a completely different role. I've seen this role idea many times before and it never works.