Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-31126981-20171126024202/@comment-25990889-20180108035923

What if it turns into an ACTUAL Role? I mean, usually theres a trial in day 2 or at least at day 3. Considering that he cant abstain. He will be an almost useless role the most part of the game. I mean, Amnesiac have a similar mechanic, in the downside, he can only choose the roles between the dead people, but at least he becomes an USEFUL role, and he can wait to choose a role, and he can also, wait til he thinks is a good moment. While the Judge is basically drafted in day 2 or 3 to turn into, either a useless mafioso or in a useless town.

What i think can make this idea viable is one of the following:

a) If he abstain, he just keep being a Judge.

b) Instead of choosing between "Citizen and Lackey" he can choose between... idk... real roles... Maybe between a Janitor with 2 cleanings and a Vigi with 2 shots? Or choosing between sheriff and framer.  That can be better than Citizen and Lackey.

Or maybe, both of the ideas.