Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-37447096-20190201130059/@comment-27575896-20190201185853

Like others, this role is screaming Coven DLC only.

The weaken ability is pretty much useless and OP, as it counters every immune role in the game as they only have Basic defense, and there IS NO WAY TO REGAIN IT. Plus, it comes the issue of knowing who is immune. No immune role will out themselves, and even if you have suspections it doesn’t do much rather than confirm your existence. In Ranked game modes and classic ones, there is only one to two other immune roles: The Godfather/Coven Leader (and not early on) and the Executioner. Neither of which can harm you evidently enough whatsoever, so why would you need them dead?

You could make an argument about them killing you, but that’s a waste of two nights of killing if you have your Defense potion ready, and nobody constantly attacks NK anyway being they are immune, maybe other than Vigilantes, who again have to shoot you three times to kill you, when Mafia/Coven may be more important.

I assume being immune to Sheriff is fine for one night only upon using it, although it is such a low chance of a Sher visiting you, and making it permanent is overpowered, so I wouldn’t include it.

Basic attacks on targets who visit should kill one other visitor, as the difference to make it less overpowered is the fact it can be roleblocked by Escorts/Consorts/Pirates.

Death Note is required by all NK’s to be able to our immune roles before they gain majority to keep balance between the Town and Mafia/Coven/Vampires. Why would this one not have it? What “balance” does that make?

Veil twice to gain Astral again screams Coven, but I consider it to be just too much overpowered due to the fact no other NK has that ability and are all affected by the same roles that can catch them, so no Astral visits.

The Consigliere message needs grammar changes to have two sentences instead of one, as in “wields mystical powers. They must be a Sorcerer.”

Change the mystical barrier defense into something more unique to its role rather than be a witch mimic, Sorcerers are different than witches. Try something around evasion or healing.

Other than that, the role seems good to me by itself and very interesting. /support once changes are made!