Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-28236721-20161030171328/@comment-29779988-20161030182445

RiotRews wrote: Alignment: Neutral Benign

Attributes: Take a life from one living, and give it to one dead person at night. You can do it 3 times

If this has the power to kill, that means it should not be neutral benign.

Investigative results:

Investigator: This person deals with taking lives. He might be Mafioso, Switcher or Vigilante.

Consigliere: This person brings people back to life, but owns a gun. He must be Switcher

'''Already, it seems as if this role is complicated. And if it's complicated, I don't think BMG will take this role very seriously.'''

Victory Conditions:

Wins with Town

Wins with Mafia

Wins with Serial Killer

Wins with Survivor

Wins with Exeutioner

Wins with Jester

Must kill Vampires

Must kill Witches

<p style="font-weight:normal;">May spare anyone else

<p style="font-weight:normal;">Why:'' Retributionist is pretty much useless after his resurrection. ''But switcher wont give town too easy game, so we will give him a chance to align with Mafia and bad guys also. But why to kill vampires and Witches? Witches can choose from who he will take life, vampires can make him vampire. But he doesn't want to be vampire, and witches make him kill wrong people. Also, it would be good, if we could switch afk's to people, who should be alive. But for that he wouldn't be too good, he can do this only 3 times. Constructive criticism Please :)!

<p style="font-weight:normal;">PS: I had idea to put it in town, but as earlier mentioned, it would give town too big advantage :P

My problem is the fact that it allows for a retributionist like role to revive someone more than once.

And with that there is mayhem.

There is a specific reason that retributionist is a unique role and can only do it once: Because then it becomes complicated.

SO FOR THAT REASON, the role is rejected.

But if you feel a need to have retributionist be a much more interesting role, try posting something about buffing it.