Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32994909-20180620175521/@comment-35836120-20180622013007

Okay I'll try again.

Reasons why Lookout is real

- Lookout was able to confirm Medium, and SK through it's ability.

- Lookout Is a risky role to claim, as this Is a visiting role which needs confirming, and since Player B had the guts to claim Lookout and knowing that his answer was correct.

Reasons why Lookout is not real

- Lookout is a common evil claim, the Investigative result's is also not accurate to tell whether Player B is lying.

- Still considering the Player Z is Necromancer, and Player X as Consort, Looukout should've seen the Consort visit the Jailor.

- Assuming that there is a Transporter, Transporter might've swapped Player B with someone who is either a Lookout, Forger or Necromancer.

ALL POSSIBLE ROLES IN GAME

Considering this is a Custom game (15 Players)

Jailor (Died N6 killed by the SK, also seanced by the Medium, and since this Is a legit role.)

Medium (Died N2 killed by either Mafioso, Werewolf, or Ambusher)

Retributionist (Is Player Y, Died N5 was executed by Jailor)

Necromancer (Player Z, Alive)

Consort (Died N2, through being executed by Jailor)

Sheriff (Died N2 killed by either, Mafioso, Werewolf, or Ambusher)

Mafioso (Not part of the whole Jailor plot, but was killed N2, or N3 either by Vigilante, Werewolf, or even the Mafioso himself.)

Werewolf (Not part of the whole Jailor plot, Is alive)

Ambusher (Not part of the whole Jailor plot, but was killed N2, or N3 either killed by Vigilante, Werewolf, Vigilante, or even the Mafioso.)

Vigilante (Not part of the whole Jailor plot, but is killed N3 either killed by the Mafioso, or even shot himself.)

Lookout (Is possible to be Player B, and Is still alive)

Necromancer (Possible to be Player Z, and Is alive)

Coven Leader (Assumed role, might've cause chaos to the whole town, Is alive)

Transporter (Is Alive)

Investigator (Is alive)

Consigliere (Assumed role, Is alive)

Scenario

Day 3

Consigliere found out the Coven Leader

Consort died, executed by Jailor

Sheriff also died by getting killed by Ambusher who was at the SK's house

Medium also died, killed by the Werewolf

Mafioso was also killed by the Vigilante. (Ambusher turns to Mafioso)

Coven Leader finds out Retributionist

Day 4

Mafioso dies of getting shot by the Vigilante (Consiglier turns to Mafioso)

Jailor dies.

Consigliere finds the Retributionist.

Coven Leader received the Necronomicon, and found out the Transporter, but they were immune. (Since Transporter targets SK with them)

Day 5

Jailor is revived

Necromancer, and Retributionist both claim to be Retributionist.

Investigator targets Necromancer, and finds the same result with the real Retributionist

Mafioso, and Vigilante attacks Transporter, Transporter targeted SK again with themselves. (which means Transporter Is safe)

Werewolf tried not to attack anyone

Day 6

Retributionist dies by getting executed by Jailor

Vigilante is suspicious of Transporter, Transporter reveals themselves. Everyone are suspicous of SK

Coven Leader finds SK, then informs Necromancer

Jailor is suspicious of SK as an Immune NK, in which he jailed him the next night. (CL, and Necromancer also suspects this to hapen)

Day 7

Jailor died because of SK

Transporter targeted Lookout with Necromancer

Investigator targeted Necromancer

Necromancer takes advantage, and claims to know what happened. (the seance, attack, and roleblock)

Werewolf was also trying to play safe, and go along with the SK being suspicous.

Players who are alive:

Lookout

Transporter

Investigator

Vigilante

Mafioso (Consigliere)

Serial Killer

Werewolf

Necromancer

Coven Leader

Players who died

Consort

Ambusher

Mafioso

Sheriff

Medium

Retributionist

In general: The Transporter messed up, and Coven was smart to take advantage of the Situation, Werewolf, Vigilante, Mafioso were also quite smart to not be too active In their pursuit of victory, Investigator was the true victim, and the plot device he/she did nothing much, they just move the plot forward, Lookout was useless, a flat character just there to be used by others, they were either unlucky to find any crucial info, or was just plain dumb