Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-2605:A000:1315:95A3:582A:FC7D:8993:C2D2-20200121034712/@comment-39067078-20200121195443

But then it literally removes a lot of claimspace, something that even Investigator can't do.

Say Investigator rolls someone up as and you investigative if there is Sheriff.
 * Sheriff, Executioner, Werewolf, Poisoner

If there is no sheriff, all these roles above and many others cannot claim sheriff.



It doesn't help to just eliminate a possible role from the rolepool, or it becomes like Werewolf Online where you are told exactly which roles are in the game and how many of each. WW Online ends games in 5 minutes because of the only fact that you can eliminate claimspace in such a way.



Even if it takes several nights, you shouldn't have the power to eliminate roles from the rolepool.