Talk:Roles/@comment-25831186-20141208021935/@comment-187.127.130.171-20141208033912

as you stated, you can't choose your role. But it actually is pretty much an amnesiac who can't choose his exact role. You can only wait a little bit to see who's mafia and who's not, just like an amnesiac waits for the role he wants to appear on the graveyard.

Well, you didn't explain what happens when you send a letter to other roles, you only specified investigator, godfather and serial killer. So, by this logic, you would remain an apprentice, but you would also know that the person you sent that letter to is not an investigator, nor a godfather, neither a sk.

Also, i don't think you should gain such an ability when helping serial killer, it would be like creating another mafia, with gf and janitor - and even if it's just two cleanings, it can mess up a game entirely -. I also don't think you should get specific abilities, but reborning as a random role. The townie night ability shouldn't give 3 possible choices: there are many roles who gives only two choices and that would make a big mess out of everything, also, framer only gives one choice.

I think that it would be better having no effect in sending letters to a neutral killing. You would become a random town if you sent a letter to someone from town (because if all the investigators died, theoretically you would never be able to become a townie). You would become a random mafia if you sent a letter to someone from mafia. You would become a neutral of the same kind if you sent a letter to a neutral benign or evil - if you sent a letter to a witch, you would become a witch, for example. You would become any kind of role (totally random) if you sent a letter to a neutral killing.

Well, that's my oppinion. Plus, you have not explained the investigation results. Such as > investigator: owns weapons, works with dead bodies, leader among men, etc. Sheriff> suspicious, not suspicious, serial killer. Consigliere> your target _________________, he may be an apprentice. It's not a bad idea, but it needs to be adapted.