Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-39651156-20190614183954/@comment-30757827-20190620234037

Uniqueness: This is amnesiac but for mafia, with the difference of waiting 3 days instead of choosing a dead role. With amnesiac, it adds the strategy of winning over the amnesiac onto your side, as they have to pick a side, and the amnesiac has to decide what to pick and when to pick it. This role has to be mafia, and has the option of every mafia role in three days. It's not going to add any new strategies other than "wha shud i bee?" which imo will just come down to what the best mafia roles are, and it won't have that much depth.

'''Verdict: Scrap. '''The role, while not a rehash, does not add many new strategies, the balance is fine but a new role must add new strategies for both sides, which this does not. It only adds new strategies for one side, and that one side's strategies aren't even that deep.

P.S this role is actually very well balanced and simple, and seems like it would be fun to play, but the role as a whole is built on the idea of becoming another role in the same faction, which is fundementally broken. Basically, it's a polished turd. In the future, i reccomend thinking if the base of the role is a good idea before balancing and streamlining it.

P.P.S I spent so long remaking this review it's not even funny