Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32994909-20180604181712/@comment-50.203.254.248-20180604182452

The Forger knew who the Jailor was because even though it says Mafia had no Consigilere, you never said they left the game thus leading to mafia having no Cosnigilere. So to that I say the Consigilere found the Jailor on Night 1, and gave the info to the mafia, HOWEVER, they left the game during to when the Jailor died.

That or it was a pre assumpted claim MOST LIKELY due to the Jailor having an odd name. Consider how Player X could actually be the Consigilere or a member of the Mafia to which convincing Player Y into joining forces into mafia, then Player X would spill the results out Player Y. Then knowing how the Consig found Jailor, he left the game to get less blood on his hands as possible, THEN the Mafioso would kill him, and then Player X (or to which I think is the Forger) forged the will to make it seem as the Player X claimed something to be proven, and that Player Y claimed something out the box