Board Thread:Role Ideas (Town)/@comment-62.238.196.147-20190226172031/@comment-38648550-20190227160350

(I didn't create a account before posting this so I can't edit my role idea) I agree with changing the investigator result. With the point that the torturer should not be a town role: in real life, torturers were in service of the town. They also tortured the suspected people and did not just torture who they wanted to torture.

1: Because well, torturers in real life don't just randomly go into people's houses with their bag full of torture devices and torture them. I though it would make most sense when they were 'in prison'.

2: Well, I didn't know any other way to make this work. Maybe it could be so some roles have 'torture immunity, but then town, mafia, coven and neutral would have to have some roles that have torture immunity. (Like bodyguard, godfather, coven leader, etc...)

3: Having this as a non-role-reliant role it would be kinda OP. I couldn't edit the role idea but I agreed with the first comment that you get 2 names at the beginning of the night and you have to guess which one. If the role didn't require someone to be jailed, it would, again, be (in my opinion) OP and just a buffed investigator.