Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20171114075305/@comment-33307078-20171120020407

ProfessorArceus wrote:

Thatsmuggamer wrote:

ProfessorArceus wrote:

Addfire wrote:

ProfessorArceus wrote:

Addfire wrote: Reading whispers is very helpful for finding important town roles. During mayor games, for instance. Whispers can't be directed at revealed mayors. Problem is already solved. 'mayor games' doesn't literally refer to revealed mayors, also roles that can confirm themselves. See: Escort, Transporter, any revived role, Lookout, Sheriff, Investigator, Veteran. And even if whispers are useful for Town, this still won't work. Its own ability is incredibly powerful already. Giving it whisper reading buffs it unnecessarily. I agree, we need to remove whispers entirely, or find a better alternative. Whisper reading should be exclusive to NEs and should not be used by Mafia. It unnecessarily nerfs the NK giving it less ability to communicate. So? NKs work on their own, it's not hurting their team. WHAT. NKs are insanely underpowered and can only team with NEs. It's hurting them massively by preventing communication. They also have night immunity and couldn't care less who they kill, so yeah. whispering doesn't effect them all that much