Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20180410024518/@comment-30154040-20180428142944

WaffleMan wrote: Ok so lets see here.

This is just for maths sake because i like math.

Tracker: You pick 1 person each night to watch who they visit. That gives you a 1/14 chance that you will a evil if mafia is the only killing role. At the start of the game, yes.(Coven makes it 10 times easier because then MORE people are poisoned attacked controlled stuff like that).Yes, generally Coven's visits are more discernable than Mafia's visits.

Lookout: You both have to vist the same target. Also if they attack you you cannot find them. So if you have 14 to pick from and they have 14 as well(Not including you). Then its like a very low chance you will both visit the same target

HOWEVER the lookout CAN be used as a protecter for say like a mayor. The tracker cannot directly help in any way if there is a revealed mayor. '''But, remember my point earlier, how if they think there's a TP, they won't visit mayor. Also, lat's say that there's 2 mafia, a revealed mayor, and a lookout. Town is screwed, no? Lookout is an Investigative role, not Protective.'''

So now its 1-1

Overall, I like playing tracker more, because more people will vist SOMEBODY then vist your target. Tracker gives something to think about like, why did this person vist this. As i went over earlier lookout is harder to find those roles.

Im still kinda torn, but i am leaning to tracker

Note: I only got coven like yesterday so i am not so famillar to the roles, but i have played tracker mulitple times and i enjoy it more then lookout