Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-31256456-20181228061901/@comment-31256456-20190119085855

Exactly. Generally for reviews you want to explain why the rule is in place and why the role doesn't work.

Like there are good autoconfirming roles that aren't broken, but reviewers often just go "oh it autoconfirms horrible idea"

Instead, at least provide context, go "It autoconfirms which isn't usually bad but in this case...."

I mean honestly, this must be a point of SOME discussion. It's ridiculous that this has been happening for so long.