Board Thread:Role Ideas (Other)/@comment-40040340-20190830105201/@comment-40040340-20190830234007

Duwiiton wrote: Doctor: is threatened for witchcraft

The Medium and Retributionist:

hmmm

Doctor: am i a joke to you

This is a pretty interesting faction in the sense there are only 2 roles, but I could be ninja'ing and I would feel pretty bad.

My main problem with this faction is the odd win conditions, which I cannot decide an opinion on. The fact that you can win when there are an even number of both factions is unlikely but may happen more commonly than thought. This may frustrate many players. It can also win with 2/3 kills with luck, which also is unlikely. If it keeps all factions on edge, it's probably not good for the fact that they win so easily.

The roles are a bit odd. The Revolt is a little ill-suited for Salem as there's just many better options. Although useful, it really feels like Sheriff. He sees Innocent on Town and Sus on most others, so that's really all you need.

The Mutineer I have a disinterest in. Mafia relies on consistent kills, and Coven relies on sheer firepower. The Mutineer cannot choose who to kill, and is useless in situations with plenty of non-visiting roles. I've seen it done before and it doesn't really work.

This faction needs some reworking in my opinion, but that may just be from Ninja Post.

''' I understand with this win condition it may seems too easy to win. I did try to make it a bit more challenging by adding ‘no other leaders’. This means that at least 2 mafia (Godfather and Mafioso->Godfather) has to die. The 2nd ‘nerf’ i did to this faction is in the role itself, i wanted to give the Mutineer a constant kill night ability but i figured that it’s just gonna win 9/10 of the time, thus the ‘Mutineer cannot choose who to kill’. Since this faction is replacing Neutrals, i don’t think not killing everyday would be a problem: seeing that ww only can attack on full moon night; and doused target may be killed by other faction.

I think the problem lies in the roles itself and not the win condition. I mean Pacifist Killing is just an oxymoron lul.

Thanks for the feedback! '''