Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-30455007-20170427172740/@comment-26234016-20170502133204

Xtremesilly wrote: True, it can be harsh, but it's like SpicyboiFelix said. I guess sometimes people aren't sincere about it. Like, what if someone who came on here for the first time thought up the cupid role? People would explode, and that person wouldn't understand. It would be quite shocking, and it happens quite a lot. That's why I think we need to tone down the insincerety. Constructive critisism is Ok, and encouraged (duh) but it all comes down to if you are putting in extra 'crtisism' to the constructiveness.

Edit: This isn't about my idea anymore. We should move this to "wiki improvement" by now XD. Just dropping by to mediate this, and while we should move this conversation, I just want to say that there was a time when an anon created a Yandere role.

I flipped out. Like, started all caps yelling at him/her.

It wasn't okay, and I regret it.

But at the same time, if someone does create a role, they are strongly encouraged to go to the Making New Roles page, which has guidelines. There are links to it at the top of every role creating forum and most people know of its existence.

So I do think that it is partially a new person's fault if they create a Firefighter.

Because if you try role reviewing, it's impossible to not freak out at Necromancers.