Thread:MemeDaddy1233/@comment-27398195-20180525054855/@comment-34797858-20180526130133

HAWAIIANpikachu wrote: '''But this is a solution to the Disguiser issue if it was brought back to its roots. I do get your point though, this is only necessary if disg was brought back to its root.''' And disguiser does not need to, disguiser is it's own man now.

Well shit, then Pirate is nerfed Jailor, Poisoner, Vigilante and VH is nerfed Mafioso, CL w necro is buffed SK, Witch is nerfed Cl, Medusa is nerfed Vet, etc etc etc.  You see how your logic can be applied to other roles as well. 

You take my "logic" and then do what BMG did to it's disguiser and completely change it to suit your own argument. That's not how it works. Also most of these roles are laughably comparable. If you compare poisoner to anything it's a nerfed werewolf. Pirate is more likely a buffed version of both Consort and Escort. Witch is a buffed version of CL because witches commonly die from lynching or jailor rather than bullets.

See above.

This does not work the same way, what consigliere does to most roles is that it's like "X(Mafia role) should target Y" where Consigilere to Forger ends up being the only reason forger becomes viable to use. Most roles can just "randomly" target people without consig and can still end up doing their job. Forger requires consigliere to be decent and if there's none it's a completely nerfed janitor. And disguiser does not need to, disguiser is it's own man now.

But disguiser is shit.

You take my "logic" and then do what BMG did to it's disguiser and completely change it to suit your own argument. That's not how it works. Also most of these roles are laughably comparable. If you compare poisoner to anything it's a nerfed werewolf. Pirate is more likely a buffed version of both Consort and Escort. Witch is a buffed version of CL because witches commonly die from lynching or jailor rather than bullets.

How am I changing your logic to suit my argurment?

This does not work the same way, what consigliere does to most roles is that it's like "X(Mafia role) should target Y" where Consigilere to Forger ends up being the only reason forger becomes viable to use. Most roles can just "randomly" target people without consig and can still end up doing their job. Forger requires consigliere to be decent and if there's none it's a completely nerfed janitor.

​​​​​​​Fair point.