Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-27398195-20200121233049

What's your mafia role's tier list comparing all mafia roles to each other. Make sure to explain reasoning.

S tier: Godfather (Best mafia member)

A tier: Janitor, Mafioso, Blackmailer (Heavily supports mafia)

B tier: Consigilere, Consort, Ambusher (Likely will support mafia)

C tier: Disguiser, Hypnotist, Framer (Might support mafia, needs buffs)

D tier: Forger (Needs a rework and a buff)

Godfather- Leader of the mafia, ignores many TIs in the early game (except investigator and psychic) and has basic immunity. His goal is to lead and protect the mafia from direct harm (such as TIs and Vigilantes) while the mafia help him work out with the other problems.

Janitor- Helps remove some 100% claim space from town and can help mafia gain some possible claim space.

Mafioso- Supports the godfather from mafia, decent claimspace, makes mafia basically immune to roleblocking (except with extreme bad luck). Can become the godfather.

Blackmailer- Can quiet some people that might need to be silence for a bit. Possible claimspace, needs to be talkative though to make the best.

Consigilere- Lost some time and claimspace due to confirmable meta, but can help find and elimate some key town members such as TPs and TIs and can lead mafia to victory by eliminating those key targets.

Consort: Might buy mafia a bit by the chaos of someone roleblocking someone a lot, without a lookout you can keep a confirmed TP or TI at bay.

Ambusher: Can elimate some town before getting spotted, but could easily also get caught and lynched. Might be able to kill some town.

Disguiser: Can pretend to be any role as long as you have claim space and someone to visit with that role in it's investigation. Can be pretty accurate as any role with almost no differences except with Spy or Sheriff.

Hypnotist: Lots of possible claim spaces, similar to Disguiser, but cannot be 100% faked as many roles as him and doesn't have as strong claim spaces, as people could argue that they're fake.

Framer: Not as strong as a role, but has some claimspace due to the role's lack of strong power and identifiable means of being found if you claim and visit the right things.

Forger: Just a super weaker Janitor without as much power as the other role, unless they have support from other roles and have enough time. 