Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-33966114-20180225120604/@comment-33927649-20180227224034

I don't think you can tbh

I don't want to be harsh, but it's a conversion MAFIA

Mafia already wins quite a bit and has a pretty balanced win rate.

To add another member to the mafia means instead of having to kill 8 people, only 6 need to be killed (5 technically, since a tie vote doesn't pass). Also, if I convert the vigi into mafia, what does he become? A mafia vigi? Meaning it takes about 3 nights to win? What about a mafia mayor? This would be SO unbalanced. The mafia would only have to convert the mayor N1 and they basically win in one night. Even if you convert town into specific roles, it wouldn't work that well, since you are still getting an additional mafia for free.

Sorry for the mild rant, but I just think you should try making a different role

I still have my suspicions of a troll though, time will tell