Board Thread:Role Ideas (Neutral)/@comment-35372286-20180422033421/@comment-35372286-20180422173749

GamesManiac wrote: Nice to meet you then :) Don't worry, most of us here aren't that harsh, some are just serious reviewer. They totally mean no harm. I'm still new here, but I'll give a try.

Overview: Hmm.. A lyncher? What has done to deserve this? In another word, this is an adjusted with specific role as their target. Aside from hardcountering, it's game mechanic is a little bit refreshing I say.

In-depth Analyse: This is a buddy role. I'm not against any rule-breaking role if the role can give better impact to the game just like. Although it fits the purpose of, the role's ability doesn't seems to fit in the alignment.

Trivia: This is a speaker who can't speak.
 * 1) You talk to someone at night but you can't talk? Is it like watching the someone ALIVE or DEAD talking to you but you can't reply? How is this ability helpful? This reminds me of of ToS BETA version. Once upon a time, the  can only seance with ONE dead and that person doesn't even want to talk. TRIGGERED!
 * 2) Why this role isn't allowed to whisper? Why do you want to see whispers? How is this helpful? Or you're just setting up a challenge for yourself?
 * 3) Your name is revealed after 5 nights to everyone ALIVE or DEAD? Why do you want to reveal your name? This sounds like announcing that you fail to lynch a . Announcer: Attention! XYZ is a Speaker! He fails to lynch a !
 * 4) You can talk for precisely 1 min if you're called out? This is pretty hard to program. It requires certain alphabet to allow this role to speak, so if people with name of common word like "is/are/am", "You/He/She","Doc/bg/gf/Mafia" can talk all the time. Btw, can you talk during voting phase and defense?
 * 5) Why it is unable to vote if there are 5 or more people alive? Does the number makes any difference? Or you simply want to buff this role late game out of desperate? Can this role vote Guilty or Innocent?
 * 6) Do you know who are the ? How these abilities can help you to find them?
 * 7) What if there are multiple ? You can only have one specific as your target or you need to lynch all or you just need to lynch any one of them?

Final thought:

This role is easily exposed as an evil as it can't do anything normal like everyone does. As you can see, I asked a lot of questions, which means that I don't even get any idea of what this role serves? Not enough to stir up some mess like and  as it can hardly communicate with the others. Presence of  and could cause some outburst of chaos, making them fear of lynching and voting, meanwhile the other evils can take such advantage for their own good. That's the purpose of who supposedly ruin the. Finally, the abilities and attributes are mostly just messing with chatting system and do nothing good but only serving balance of the role. I gotta say this role is indeed unique with some kind of role-exclusive ability. Interesting! You can check out this page Making New Roles as a guideline of making role.

Thanks for posting your role idea here! Feel free to drop another role idea. BUT WHY MEDIUM? 1)ahhh... good point and the reason it can do that is so it can maybe find the evils if they wanna admit since the role sort of sides with the bad.

2)Its sort of a challenge since if they can whisper and med reveals not knowing there role and the speaker could get an easy win.

3)It doesnt reveal to the whole town, its like "Speaker:Blah Blah" after 5 nights "XYZ:Blah Blah"

4)Again this is a challenge it probs will be taken out if this is accepted (its 99.99% not gonna be tho :D)

5)^^^^

6)Ya gotta find them yourself

7)Just need to hang 2

The reason medium is because he use to be a medium but was banished.