Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-34845574-20180429170719/@comment-28092296-20180502005046

This violates the Jailor paradox:

You are not allowed to make another role that can jail people—otherwise issues like these will happen:

- The Jailor & Former Town jail each other. Who's registered as the Jailee and who's the Jailor?

- They both jail the same target. Which one goes through?

- you get the idea.

Regardless, I feel like RubikJohn and TheSheriff1 have said everything that I pretty much wanted to say. But here are some other things:

- This, if anything, should be a Neutral Role. Too powerful for Mafia.

- At least list it as Mafia Killing!

- You could just fire your gun/exeute three people and then never execute anybody else.

- You put you can have infinite alerts.

FOR MAKING FUTURE ROLES: Try not thinking of the most creative idea, or the idea that draws a lot of attention to themself. Introduce new game mechanics, but then balance them out. Kind-of like if you wanted 20$, but you instead got 15. It's almost perfect.