Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-36331366-20180727013111/@comment-28092296-20180728002445

I'm a bit confused here. Your investigation results seems like a wekaer Consigliere. The weaker consigliere mechanic was supposed to be balanced out with an extra ability (I assume, correct me if I'm wrong).

Hiding your whispers becomes a problem when you need to whisper a role to a confirmed town, or when somebody finds the silencer and keeps them alive to see who doesn't whisper. Besides; mafia has a night chat. Idk how much whispering without other ppl knowing would help u.

Also, the ability to read everybody's whispers doesn't really make much sense to me. The ability to wide whispers, read whispers, and get investigation results doesn't work in any real synergy, it seems like three ideas put into one role, with the theme that this is supposed to operate around whispering mechanics.

Idk if you were thinking for a long time about this role idea, but try and pull your three mechanics together, or remove mechanics so then the role has only one main purpose.

good job with your organization btw. You seem like (at least) a (somewhat) organized person. :P Respect to that.