Board Thread:Role Ideas (Mafia)/@comment-43443506-20191001101744/@comment-30739178-20191001190816

Alright.

This is a unique-ish gimmick, where you don't know your own teammates. Does your target know who is jailing them? If not, this would totally break the game. You wouldn't know if you were talking to a town or a mafia member.

Besides that, you need to make it Mafia Killing (which is frowned upon because that's not really how the mafia operates-- they need to be deceptive)

There's no addressing the question: What if the Jailor jails the Kidnapper, and vice versa?

On top of that, it's way too powerful for a Mafia role, or any role. There isn't currently a role that can deal an unstoppable attack every night from the getgo. The only limit is suicide per killing a Mafia member, but remember: the Kidnapper is supposed to be on a team-- strategically jailing confirmed towns and killing them has no defense to it.