Board Thread:Role Ideas (Other)/@comment-72.201.29.68-20170225153220/@comment-27398195-20170226222535

Wait, so you created a role that buffs the SK... even though it has the highest win rate out of the 3 NKs?

-If a Vigilante targets you, neither of you die

​The SK is immune, so it can't die in the first place

-You can target people in the night like a serial killer (but it always fails)

​So, other then making it seem like SK is doctor, nothing else happens.

-You have private chat with the Serial Killer at night

​Oh gee, I expect not much talking to happen >_>

-When you die, you are labeled as the Serial Killer

​So basically your a disg that's useless because most likely you won't die from lynching and jailor and instead be attacked.

-If a Serial Killer is lynched, you become a Serial Killer

'''​No. Just no.'''

​-Helps the Serial Killer survive longer and for someone to be able to cooperate with it

'''​BUT WHAT ABOUT THE WW AND ARSO, YOU KNOW, THE TWO ROLES THAT HAVE THE LOWEST WIN RATES? WHY DON'T WE GIVE THOSE ROLES SOME LOVE.'''

​(Yes, I know arso is being buffed, but for now it's still the weakest role)

-Ability to have failed Serial Killer attacks helps the Serial Killer pretend to be the doctor

'''​So basically messing with results. And basically you get confirmed out when the TP is a BG.'''

-Provides a tone of random into the game

​Not like we don't have enough already >_>

-Great support strategy

​It doesn't really "support" SK, mostly the support is either useless or gives the SK away

-New faction introduced

​NEW FRACTIONS GET REJECTED.

-Especially when in large numbers, fanatics ward the town off from killing a confirmed Serial Killer

'''​Wait, so their can be MORE then one of these roles? NO.'''

-Puts greater stress on characters that break night immunity to attack the Serial Killer

​The only 4 night breaking immunity roles are Arso, WW, Jailor and Veteran

​Veteran can't attack the SK directly

​WW and Arso are unlikely to appear if there is an SK

​There's always a jailor, but most likely he'll be jailing the mayor.

​Overall, this "support role" doesn't really help the SK, not to mention that it REQUIRES SK to be in, so it's basically a Reverse VH that helps SK, and it's a new fraction.

​So REJECTED