Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32994909-20171030231558/@comment-35199255-20171101145940

JamJamalWiki wrote: Time to point out all the Logical flaws in Town of Salem although this game relies on mechanics and not logic!


 * The Godfather, Serial Killer and Arsonist do not have supernatural powers, and yet can survive a Vigilante shooting a bullet straight through their heads. true.


 * A full moon night occurs every two nights, when logically a full moon should occur every month. too long makes ww not even possible. i know you said mechanics not logic, but its salem. give it a break


 * A Killing role will promptly kill themselves if a Transporter swaps them with their target, I mean they aren't even controlled, they just find out that they are in their target's house, but than realise that it's their own house, so they are their own target and they need to kill themself.lol.


 * If a Janitor's target is not dead, they will still waste a clean just cleaning nothing. no, they can still clean their house for them


 * The Mafia and Serial Killer can just attack the same person without interacting with each other. maybe mafia comes in first to seriously injure him, walk out, and sk comes in to finish the job.


 * Mafia promotions make no sense. When a Mafioso becomes Godfather, they seem to promptly become stronger (hence, the basic defence) even though all they are supposed to do now is make the new orders, also a Janitor would have to learn how to use a gun in just one night if the Mafioso dies. Janitor, Framer, Forger, Disguiser, Blackmailer, Consigliere, Consort, Ambusher, and all them others might already know how to use a gun.


 * An Investigator cannot distinguish a Doctor from a Serial Killer for some strange reason, besides the fact that they are literally opposites of each other. read the serial killers story. he pretends to be a doctor.


 * The Investigator has absolutely no opinion on the Juggernaut whatsoever, despite having an opinion on every single other role. maybe the investigator already knows who the juggernaut and doesnt care?


 * If the Jailor jails the Mayor for protection, he will still rudely drag the Mayor to jail.


 * The Jailor can drag the Pestilence to jail, despite the Pestilence being invincible at night. dont play coven... yet.


 * The Pestilence can survive fire, a Jester haunting his soul (if he even has one), a Jailor's execution, but just can't handle that rope around his neck. yeah that one doesnt make sense


 * Despite Pestilence reeking of disease and attacking anyone who visits them, they are not at all suspicious to an apparently intelligent Sherrif. wow thats dumb


 * A Serial Killer attacks the Jailor upon release, meaning that the Jailor doesn't bother to take his weapon before throwing him into the cell. maybe jailor doesnt know hes sk.


 * The Werewolf just straight up mauls the Jailor, and the Jailor didn't even see that coming. i mean he might be a ninja. how is ww never detectable unless its a full moon by sheriff?


 * If there's just a Mayor and an evil role left, the Mayor alone can drag that evil onto the noose and lynch him. If he has so much physical strength during the day, why doesn't he do anything during the night? the mayor is an anti-ww so he gets weaker in the night then the day.


 * Not only can an Amnesiac remember who he was, but he can also gather all the neccassary equipement and abilities to perform that role, that includes turning himself into a Werewolf, or learning the foundation of witchcraft in a single night. amne story, he is the person literally and figuratively


 * A Doctor can't heal a poisoned townie during the day, despite the townie knowing he's just been poisoned and needs immediate help. They're probably sitting their coughing and choking, and the Doctor just does nothing. true


 * A Witch or the Coven Leader can control almost anyone, but just can't get the hang of controlling the Transporter, who has no supernatural powers whatsoever. theyre always moving around


 * Escort/Consort just can't get the hang of seducing the Transporter, dammit Transporter, it's always you. transporter might hate women???


 * Escort/Consort can seduce the Medusa, though. I guess Medusa's stone gaze can wait for another night. medusa is homo??? 


 * Escort/Consort forces a Serial Killer or Werewolf to stay home. How the hell do you seduce a Werewolf? And if they are so interested, why do they still kill the Escort/Consort at the end? you seduce a werewolf by complimenting their fur, not that i would know, and also they realize that love is fake and kill her.


 * Both Vampires and Werewolves are not role block immune, it's Twilight all over again. rip


 * There can be multiple Sherrifs in one town, seems legit. this here town is too big for the 5 of us sheriff claims.


 * A Bodyguard will attack an Arsonist who is trying to douse someone, but the Bodyguard dies too, although the Arsonist appears to have no way of killing the Bodyguard. arsonist douses and sets them on fire simutaneously.


 * Vigilantes will commit suicide after killing a townie, whilst the Jailor will only stop executing after killing a townie. Even worse, a Crusader and the Veteran can kill as much Town as they want and feel no guilt at all. some townies are anti-war non christians... who are criminals?


 * Vigilantes or the Jailor won't feel guilty if they execute a Disguiser who disguised as a townie. How the hell did they know that they're not really a townie? because their disguise was really bad.


 * If there's two mafia and the Mayor left, it's a race to see who can vote for the other person quicker. true


 * A Vampire Hunter can hunt Vampires who visit whilst in jail. he asks the jailor politely to let him fight the vampires and then goes back into the jail.


 * A Townie turns into a Vampire upon being bitten, but a member of the Mafia will just die. Too loyal too their faction to able to switch sides. kinda logical?

7/10 would debunk again
 * A Blackmailer threatens to reveal your secrets which is way too embarrassing to reveal, even if you're on trial just about to get killed. Death over dishonour? ye