Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20180410024518/@comment-30154040-20180428174051

Nixonix wrote: L O O K O U T

Alright, let's deal with this first argument.

Reason 1: Tracker is VERY inaccurate. You may track a guy to the Mafia's killed target, but when he dies he's an Investigator. Lookout sees ALL targets, meaning that he sees all possibilities to the roles of the visitors.

'''Then, he should claim Investigator. Tracker is better at homing down suspicious individuals, not randomly tracking. Show your will, and Investigator will claim.'''

Reason 2: Lookout can note down people who visit themselves (but so can Tracker) such as Survivor and Bodyguard, and Transporter, but the only thing Tracker is able to confirm is Transporter.

'''Really? So, Bob 1 is Tracker, Bob 2 is Lookout, and Bob 3 is Survivor. Bob 1 watches Bob 3, and sees Bob 3 visit themselves, I believe. This means the target visited themselves. Bob 2 watched Bob 3, and sees the target was visited by themselves. Nothing is confirmed as a role. Bob 3 could be Survivor or Bodyguard. However, if Bob 3 is Transporter, then Lookout still only sees Bob 3 visiting themselves, while Bob 1 sees Bob 3 visiting two people.'''

Reason 3: Let's say the SK and Mafia attacked John Hathorne. Tracker tracks a person and he visited John Hathorne. Lookout says he saw 2 people visiting John Hathorne, meaning both Mafia and SK. Somehow the Lookout makes it more obvious so you can lynch one and shoot the other.

'''If there is 3 Mafia, there is a 1/2352 chance of the Lookout, SK, and Mafia visiting the same person on day 1, with just pure statistics, and other people can visit the same person, too. While I agree, that is an advantage, so what? If you see my above arguments, you would agree that the spread of the Lookout is one of the only advantages.'''

Final Reason: Tracker is a PB claim. That's why it sucks and Lookout, being a common CL claim, is less likely to get lynched as the PB.

'''Umm... No? Coven Leader, in my opinion, is a bigger direct threat than the Plaguebearer. Also, in ranked, there is NO Neutral Chaos, making Lookout claims more suspicious than Tracker claims.'''