Board Thread:Role Ideas/@comment-28112409-20160805100046/@comment-30602244-20161004225619

Ok, let's look at my role idea, 'Forger Staker" and see how it does.

1. Yup, it requires forger

2. yup ,it hardcounters forger

3. yup, it's a neutral version of VH

4. no

5. Not really

6. no

7. no

8. no

9. no

10. NO, it's not a combination of vh and anything else.

11. no

12. no

13. no

14. no

15. no

16. Yes, if you find a forger, but other roles have similar  mechanics  like this. For example,  vh finding vampires and sheriff finding mafia

17. no

18. no

19. no

20. Well, only if you count 'staking' forgers as killing. So I guess yes/

21. It can't win with town, and can win with any neutral, and it can win with mafia IF it doesn't have a forger. You might think this helps town, but once all forgers are staked, you can win with anyone but town. If all forger dies otherwise, then you will turn into a witch, which goes against town. So no

22. no

23. no

24. At the beginning, it hurts mafia more then it helps, BUT mafia isn't technically aits alignment, it can win with neutrals. For the end of the game, see above.

25. no

26. no

I GOT MORE NO'S THEN YESSES IM SOOOOOOOO GOOD