Board Thread:Debate of The Week/@comment-28112409-20181230235210/@comment-33307613-20190103155643

RASENGAN6 wrote: I would actually nerf the visit-seeing ability to only see Mafia Killing visits (or other visits if no MK attacking), so it can still find immune targets, but can still be tricked by Mafia laying low, and buff the bug ability to find all actions target against the opponent, not just messages your target sees, such as:

"Your target was investigated!" All TI except Spy, and Consig.

"Your target was protected!" All TP and PM'er healing.

etc. Seeing Mafia Killing visits counters roles with basic defense, which are typically Neutral Killings. Neutral Killings do not need nerfs.

Seeing Mafia Deception visits is either completely pointless (Janitor, normally Disguiser) or completely broken (Framer, Forger, normally Hypnotist).

Seeing Mafia Support visits is normally not as effective (Consigliere, Blackmailer), but it still counters the Consort. Escorts become confirmed and Consorts cannot claim Escort, screwing them when they are investigated.

--

I dislike the idea of seeing roles (or a group of roles) that visit a target. A Lookout/Spy combo can instantly confirm Town members and reveal evils with this ability (similarly to how well they can combo currently).