Board Thread:Fun and Games/@comment-30154040-20161012205020/@comment-25876622-20161015155521

I guess I have two theories again...

Theory 1
 * The Framer really framed the real Medium (7).
 * The second Sheriff (4) interrogated the Medium and saw they were "Mafia" (framed).
 * The Medium already knows that 4 is the Sheriff or someone among the dead told the Medium that 4 is obviously Sheriff.
 * The Medium says that both cleaned are Sheriffs.
 * The Janitor (8) knows that 4 is the Sheriff, but only mentions that 5 was a Sheriff.

Theory 2 I think it's Theory 2. Less speculation involved!
 * The Framer put up a fake will; 7 is actually the Janitor.
 * The second Sheriff (4) interrogated the Janitor and found they were Mafia.
 * The real Medium (8) spoke with the dead. They (or the cleaned guy himself) said that 5 was the first Sheriff.
 * The second Sheriff (4) isn't dead yet, so the Medium can't talk to them.
 * Mafia attacks. The Janitor (7) knows that 4 is a Sheriff because they cleaned them.
 * The next day, the Medium (8) says only what the dead said. The Janitor (7) says what he knows from cleaning.