this I my option feel free to share yours
S=Amazing one of the best roles to have
A=Great some drawbacks but overall really good
B=Good in most situations some drawbacks
C=Ok this role inset bad but not good
D=Pretty bad role only a few redeeming quality's
F=Horrible role needs to be scrapped or changed now
also if a role has a > next to them they are really close to the next tier up and < for close to one tier down
anyways here's the list
F Tier
Framer & Disguiser
D Tier
Vampire, Hex Master, Crusader<, Medium
C Tier
Vigilante, Mafioso, Forger, Ambusher, Spy>, Consort, Escort, Poisoner, Medusa, Vampire Hunter>, Lookout, Witch>, Executioner, Jester, Guardian Angel, Survivor, Amnesiac>, Arsonist
B Tier
Coven Leader>, Investigator, Sheriff, Pirate<, Doctor, Transporter, Werewolf>, Tracker<
A Tier
Veteran, Bodyguard, Trapper, Plague bearer/Pestilence, Juggernaut, Serial Killer, Janitor>, Blackmailer, Godfather, Potion Master, Necromancer
S Tier
Jailor, Mayor, Retributionist, Psychic<, Consigliere